Goodbye Cinema, Hello Cinephilia Film Culture in Transition
by Jonathan Rosenbaum
University of Chicago Press, 2010
Cloth: 978-0-226-72664-9 | Paper: 978-0-226-72665-6 | Electronic: 978-0-226-72666-3
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226726663.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

The esteemed film critic Jonathan Rosenbaum has brought global cinema to American audiences for the last four decades. His incisive writings on individual filmmakers define film culture as a diverse and ever-evolving practice, unpredictable yet subject to analyses just as diversified as his own discriminating tastes. For Rosenbaum, there is no high or low cinema, only more interesting or less interesting films, and the pieces collected here, from an appreciation of Marilyn Monroe’s intelligence to a classic discussion on and with Jean-Luc Godard, amply testify to his broad intellect and multi-faceted talent. Goodbye Cinema, Hello Cinephilia gathers together over fifty examples of Rosenbaum’s criticism from the past four decades, each of which demonstrates his passion for the way we view movies, as well as how we write about them. Charting our changing concerns with the interconnected issues that surround video, DVDs, the Internet, and new media, the writings collected here also highlight Rosenbaum’s polemics concerning the digital age. From the rediscovery and recirculation of classic films, to the social and aesthetic impact of technological changes, Rosenbaum doesn’t disappoint in assembling a magisterial cast of little-known filmmakers as well as the familiar faces and iconic names that have helped to define our era.

As we move into this new decade of moviegoing—one in which Hollywood will continue to feel the shockwaves of the digital age—Jonathan Rosenbaum remains a valuable guide. Goodbye Cinema, Hello Cinephilia is a consummate collection of his work, not simply for fans of this seminal critic, but for all those open to the wide variety of films he embraces and helps us to elucidate.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Jonathan Rosenbaum wrote for many periodicals (including the Village Voice, Sight and Sound, Film Quarterly, and Film Comment) before becoming principal film critic for the Chicago Reader from 1987 until his retirement in 2008. He is the author of many books, most recently including Discovering Orson Welles and the major collection of essays Essential Cinema. He continues to write for both print and online publications and maintains a blog at www.jonathanrosenbaum.com.

REVIEWS

“Jonathan Rosenbaum is a great film critic and I’ve learned so much over the years from his wise writing.”

— Roger Ebert

“This is a major new collection of essays from a preeminent American film critic who has evolved a unique voice over decades of writing that is extraordinarily well-informed, full of insights and unforeseen connections, and deeply, profoundly international. Jonathan Rosenbaum’s intellectual and political engagement, his insistence in going beyond the US-centrism of most American critics, and his extraordinarily wide-ranging cinephilia represent near-heroic work by an invaluable critic, and are all fully on display here. This excellent collection, much like its author, crosses many boundaries with conviction.”
— Janet Bergstrom, University of California, Los Angeles

“One of the finest film critics currently active.”
— Times (UK)

 “Among the best is Rosenbaum.”
— Booklist

"One of the bellwether critics in film reviewing. . . . Rosenbaum offers arguments to make you to think again."
— Globe and Mail

"An important contribution to the discussion not just of film, but of all of film culture."
— Front Table

"Rosenbaum's argument is simpler and more convincing: when you're looking at a film that has survived decades, has many substantive admirers and nothing in it speaks to you, you should probably do some reading on it, or at least watch the extras. You may learn how quickly your gut reaction can change."

— GreenCine Daily

"Ceaselessly prolific, frighteningly well-informed on seemingly every detail of film history, and well ahead of the technological curve. . . . The handsomely curated Goodbye Cinema is a dense collection of Rosenbaum’s most fervent causes."

— The Onion's A/V Club

“Jonathan Rosenbaum has long been known for forging a path for cinephilia in a changing landscape, and for cautioning against hand-wringing and nay-saying about new technologies among older generations of movie lovers. Goodbye Cinema Hello Cinephilia, Rosenbaum’s invaluable new collection of writing about film, takes those positions as one of its organizing principles—in keeping with which it includes blog posts as well as more conventionally published pieces, all bringing to bear his vast store of knowledge and dexterity in deploying it, as well as his customary social and political engagement.”

— Criterion Collection, The Critierion Collection’s Book Notes

“There’s plenty of evidence on display of what has made Rosenbaum an essential critic for generations of readers.”

— Film Comment

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction

I. Position Papers

Goodbye Cinema, Hello Cinephilia

In Defense of Spoilers

Potential Perils of the Director’s Cut

Southern Movies, Actual and Fanciful: A Personal Survey

À la recherche de Luc Moullet: 25 Propositions

Bushwhacked Cinema

What Dope Does to Movies

Fever Dreams in Bologna: Il Cinema Ritrovato

From Playtime to The World: The Expansion and Depletion of Space within Global Economies

II. Actors, Actors-Writers-Directors, Filmmakers

Kim Novak as Midwestern Independent

Marilyn Monroe’s Brains

A Free Man: White Hunter, Black Heart

Bit Actors

Rediscovering Charlie Chaplin

Second Thoughts on Stroheim

Sweet and Sour: Lubitsch and Wilder in Old Hollywood

Ritwik Ghatak: Reinventing the Cinema

Introducing Pere Portabella

Portabella and Continuity

Two Neglected Filmmakers: Eduardo de Gregorio and Sara Driver

Vietnam in Fragments: William Klein in 1967–68: A Radical Reevaluation

Movie Heaven: Defending Your Life

The World as a Circus: Tati’s Parade

The Sun Also Sets: The Films of Nagisa Oshima

III. Films

Inside the Vault [on Spione]

Family Plot

"The Doddering Relics of a Lost Cause": John Ford’s The Sun Shines Bright

Prisoners of War: Bitter Victory

Art of Darkenss: Wichita

Cinema of the Future: Still Lives: The Films of Pedro Costa

A Few Eruptions in the House of Lava

Unsatisfied Men: Beau travail

Viridiana on DVD

Doing the California Split

Mise en Scène as Miracle in Dreyer’s Ordet

David Holzman’s Diary/My Girlfriend’s Wedding: Historical Artifacts of the Past and Present

Two Early Long-Take Climaxes: The Magnifi cent Ambersons and A Star Is Born

Wrinkles in Time: Alone. Life Wastes Andy Hardy

Martha: Fassbinder’s Uneasy Testament

India Matri Buhmi

Radical Humanism and the Coexistence of Film and Poetry in The House Is Black

WR, Sex, and the Art of Radical Juxtaposition

Revisiting The Godfather

IV. Criticism

Film Writing on the Web: Some Personal Reflections

Goodbye, Susan, Goodbye: Sontag and Movies

Daney in English: A Letter to Trafic

Trailer for Godard’s Histoire(s) du cinéma

Moullet retrouvé (2006/2009)

The Farber Mystery

The American Cinema Revisited

Raymond Durgnat

Surviving the Sixties

L.A. Existential

Index