The Courtiers' Anatomists Animals and Humans in Louis XIV's Paris
by Anita Guerrini
University of Chicago Press, 2015
Cloth: 978-0-226-24766-3 | Electronic: 978-0-226-24833-2
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

The Courtiers' Anatomists is about dead bodies and live animals in Louis XIV's Paris--and the surprising links between them. Examining the practice of seventeenth-century anatomy, Anita Guerrini reveals how anatomy and natural history were connected through animal dissection and vivisection. Driven by an insatiable curiosity, Parisian scientists, with the support of the king, dissected hundreds of animals from the royal menageries and the streets of Paris. Guerrini is the first to tell the story of Joseph-Guichard Duverney, who performed violent, riot-inducing dissections of both animal and human bodies before the king at Versailles and in front of hundreds of spectators at the King's Garden in Paris. At the Paris Academy of Sciences, meanwhile, Claude Perrault, with the help of Duverney’s dissections, edited two folios in the 1670s filled with lavish illustrations by court artists of exotic royal animals.

Through the stories of Duverney and Perrault, as well as those of Marin Cureau de la Chambre, Jean Pecquet, and Louis Gayant, The Courtiers' Anatomists explores the relationships between empiricism and theory, human and animal, as well as the origins of the natural history museum and the relationship between science and other cultural activities, including art, music, and literature.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Anita Guerrini is Horning Professor in the Humanities and professor of history in the School of History, Philosophy, and Religion at Oregon State University. She is the author of Experimenting with Humans and Animals: From Galen to Animal Rights and Obesity and Depression in the Enlightenment: The Life and Times of George Cheyne.

REVIEWS

"Guerrini ably shows how anatomy emerged as a science within the institutional and courtly spaces of Louis XIV's France. Her beautifully illustrated and richly woven account explores the relationship between the emerging fashion for dissection and the mechanical philosophy, showing how and why dead bodies were enrolled into the wider transformation of European learning in the seventeenth century. Navigating between the pan-European Republic of Letters which made and disseminated new anatomical knowledge, and the promise and constraints of courtly patronage, Guerrini displays an assured grasp of her subject."
— E. C. Spary, University of Cambridge

"Guerrini’s research has uncovered a wealth of information on the key figures of the time and their endeavors, from the early contacts among Jean Pecquet, Adrien Auzout, and Blaise Pascal, to the lecturing style of Joseph-Guichard Duverney. The Courtiers’ Anatomists provides by far the most detailed account of the French anatomists’ researches, relying on a subtle and far-reaching analysis of extensive manuscript sources ranging from the reports of the French Académie to Duverney’s handwritten notes."
— Domenico Bertoloni Meli, Indiana University

"The history of seventeenth-century French science has suffered considerable neglect. Both the richness and the complexity of Guerrini’s The Courtiers’ Anatomists suggest why this is so: the context she explores requires both a mastery of the intellectual tradition throughout history and a deep familiarity with the sciences and scientific practices across Europe. Guerrini deftly weaves a complex history of many interconnected traditions, grounded in French professional and familial networks, court practices, and patronage. Thoroughly incorporating the natural sciences into the Scientific Revolution, The Courtiers’ Anatomists offers an important amplification of our understanding of scientific practices in the early modern period."
— Kathleen Wellman, Southern Methodist University

"In Guerrini's hands, the history of science and medicine in early modern Paris was simultaneously a history of fairy tales and opera, dogs and chameleons, artists and knife-makers, labyrinth-making and oratory. It is a fascinating book that is a must-read for historians of anatomy and of early modern science and medicine, and will be accessible and gripping for readers well beyond those fields."
— Carla Nappi, New Books in History

"The early science of living creatures developed along lines quite different from those of astronomy, physics, and chemistry. Guerrini describes how the study of animals grew and developed in 17th-century Paris. According to the author, dissection “has a justifiable claim to be the most widespread and significant scientific activity” of the century, and Paris became the center for the dissection of animals of all sorts—from humans to ostriches and even an elephant.  Focusing principally on the remarkably diverse and numerous dissections performed by Joseph-Guichard Duverney and on the subsequent emergence of Claude Perrault’s lavishly illustrated Histoire des animaux, Guerrini outlines the many ways in which patronage, humanistic scholarship, art, experimentation, and new theories of mechanical science interacted in fruitful ways to advance the study of animal life. The text is clearly written and thoughtfully illustrated and includes over 60 pages of notes and bibliography. Recommended."
— Choice

"This work is original in its documentation as much as in its form and content....Its historical breadth is unprecedented insofar as its topic is that of 'animals and humans' in Grand Siècle Paris. In Guerrini’s book we find...to borrow from Louis-Sebastien Mercier, the Tableau de Paris of the Grand Siècle. Guerrini crosses practices with events, rather than crossing disciplines. Without a doubt, the results exceed her expectations."
— Bulletin of the History of Medicine

“Details from the dissections and anecdotes range from the serious to the fascinating, the comical, and the downright gory….Nearly seven hundred endnotes and a bibliography listing around two hundred primary sources and over four hundred secondary sources will make this book a major resource for years to come for those interested in the histories of anatomy and natural history, menageries, paper zoos, and the intersections of knowledge, collection, and entertainment in the Paris of Louis XIV.”
 
— American Historical Review

“In this engrossing book, the culmination of a succession of innovative articles published over the past 15 years, Anita Guerrini makes a fresh and thought-provoking assessment of human and animal anatomy as it was practised in the Paris of Louis XIV. She describes hurried dissections of decomposing animals from the King’s menageries at Vincennes and Versailles; experimentation, notably in blood-transfusion, upon living dogs; exploration of human and animal cadavers in the style of William Harvey; a grandiose scheme to record and publish (with illustrations) a comprehensive anatomical and physiological history of animals; and attempts to constrain men of intellect to publish their findings anonymously, to become a compagnie existing for the greater glorification of the monarch. The importance of the book, however, lies in the author’s scrutiny of the work of the anatomists of the Paris Academy of Sciences, in particular Claude Perrault, Jean Pecquet, Louis Gayant, and Joseph-Guichard Duverney.”
— Archives of Natural History

“As a cultural historian, Guerrini draws on the practices of dissection performed by Paris anatomists as well as the artistic and printing practices used to record and represent their activities. Her profound and rigorous study is based on original research and a wide range of printed and manuscript sources. Guerrini shows how dissection and comparative anatomy were key to the development of the experimental methods of the new science. But The Courtiers’ Anatomists not only tells the story of the epistemic and moral value of animals and how they became an object of study in their own right. It is also a book about the rise of the new science and how royal and court patronage promoted unique ways of knowing in early modern France.”
 
— Canadian Journal of History

"The Courtiers’ Anatomists is a welcome addition to the history of science and medicine, and to the history of the age of Louis XIV...Guerrini adds a new twist to our understanding of the political culture of Old Regime France by enriching Sharon Kettering’s classic conception of patronage, and by articulating a nuanced role for animals in the broader propaganda process..."
— Early Science and Medicine

TABLE OF CONTENTS

A Note on Names, Dates, and Other Matters

Abbreviations Used in the Notes

List of Illustrations

- Anita Guerrini
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.003.0007
[dissection, experiment, bodies, Louis XIV, Paris, natural history]
The introduction outlines the various key concepts for the remainder of the book. Paris was the center of cultural and scientific pursuits during the seventeenth-century, and science was embedded in the cultural pursuits of the city, as the same people practiced science, architecture, art, music, and literature simultaneously. Other individuals that have resisted disciplinary categories, animals, played an enormous role in the birth of the experimental method, natural history, and the reconfiguration of the human and animal body. The dissection of animals, even of live animals, was neither controversial nor unusual, and resulting doctrines such as the circulation of the blood, were not of concern to the Catholic Church, or to Protestant churches, in the way that astronomy was in this period. Dissection came to play a vital role in the development of the science of natural history, as natural history encompassed collecting, describing, classifying, anddissecting. (pages 1 - 16)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Anita Guerrini
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.003.0001
[anatomy, Marin Cureau de la Chambre, Jean Pecquet, Louis Gayant, Claude Perrault, honnête homme, Republic of Letters, Jean Riolan]
Beginning with a geography of Paris anatomy in the seventeenth century, this chapter then asks who the anatomist was in this period, framed by the experiences of four charter members of the Paris Academy of Sciences: Marin Cureau de la Chambre, Jean Pecquet, Louis Gayant, and Claude Perrault. Their experiences chart diverse paths toward anatomical knowledge, including dissection at multiple sites as well as books. Jean Riolanmodeled the ideal anatomist. The “honnête homme” courted by both Descartes and Molière sought to replace Latin with French as the language of learning and literature, and anatomical works increasingly were published in French. Books and later journals situated human and animal anatomy within the broader cultural framework of the Republic of Letters. (pages 17 - 49)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Anita Guerrini
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.003.0002
[William Harvey, circulation, GaspareAselli, lacteal vessels, natural history, anatomy, experiment, Jean Pecquet, thoracic duct]
This chapter explores the implications in France of William Harvey’s discovery of the circulation of the blood and GaspareAselli’s discovery of the lacteal vessels, published in 1627–28. Harvey reconceived the relationship between natural history and anatomy and between historia and scientia in two important ways: he validated a descriptive methodology that explicitly did not include final causes, and his dissection techniques constituted a method that led to an experimental science based on animals that not only described but also revealed new knowledge. Passionate discussion of these issues accompanied by much more dissection over the next two decades led to a second watershed, Jean Pecquet’s discovery of the thoracic duct, published in 1651. (pages 50 - 91)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Anita Guerrini
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.003.0003
[Paris Academy of Sciences, Claude Perrault, animals, dissection, comparative anatomy, menageries, Vincennes, Versailles, experimenting, mechanism]
In the last third of the seventeenth century, the Paris Academy of Sciences pursued two dissection projects, of exotic animals and of living and dead domestic animals coupled with the dissection of human cadavers. These projects led to a new experimental comparative anatomy that valued animals as models for humans and as legitimate objects of knowledge in themselves. Claude Perrault led the Academy’s anatomical work, establishing a style of experimenting, collaboration, and publication that set it apart from other European academies. New anatomical subjects included exotic animals from the royal menageries at Vincennes and Versailles. The Academy based its Christian vitalism on Perrault’s mechanistic but non-Cartesian theory of animal mechanism. (pages 92 - 127)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Anita Guerrini
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.003.0004
[artists, illustration, engraving, dissection, animals, Histoire des animaux, Paris Academy of Sciences, Claude Perrault, Joseph-Guichard Duverney, Jean-Baptiste Colbert]
Artists and illustrations were part of the Academy’s work from the outset; illustrated accounts of dissections of exotic animals began to appear in 1667. Colbert’s imperative to contribute to the glory of Louis XIV led to the elephant folio Mémoires pour servir à l’histoirenaturelle des animaux (Histoire des animaux) in 1671, augmented in 1676. Full-page engravings revealed the animal in life as well as its dissected parts. But the beauty, size, and expense that made Histoire des animaux an effective tool in promoting Louis, its images echoed in paintings and tapestries, made it less useful to fellow men of science. By 1674, Joseph-GuichardDuverney had joined Claude Perrault in the animal project. (pages 128 - 164)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Anita Guerrini
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.003.0005
[Claude Perrault, Charles Perrault, Joseph-Guichard Duverney, Paris Academy of Sciences, mechanism, Versailles, ear, music, opera]
Known as the “anatomiste des courtisans” (the courtiers’ anatomist) for his instruction of the Dauphin, Duverney, unlike other members of the Academy, only dissected. This chapter examineshis collaboration with Perrault in the 1676 Histoire des animaux and inPerrault’s 1680 essay on animal mechanism, which employed evidence from Academy dissections to elaborate a theory of the animal body based on peristaltic motion and an innate immaterial soul. The 1676 volume also acknowledged the Versailles menagerie, where animal themes dominated, particularly in the Labyrinth designed by André le Nôtre and Charles Perrault. Charles contributed to his brother’s ideas about hearing, the ear, and the value of modern music, particularly opera. Duverney also wrote about the anatomy of the ear. (pages 165 - 200)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Anita Guerrini
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.003.0006
[Joseph- Guichard Duverney, Claude Perrault, Charles Perrault, Jardin du roi, Jean Méry, ancients, moderns, anatomy, Paris Academy of Sciences]
Even before he entered the Academy, Duverney’s anatomical skills had made him well known in the private academies and salons of Paris. In 1679 he was appointed anatomy lecturer at the Jardin du Roi, the King’s Garden, where he taught to large audiences of students and other spectators. Student notes detail the content of his lectures, and his eloquence contributed to the ongoing ancients and moderns debates about language and its uses, discussed by Charles Perrault in several works. After Claude Perrault’s 1688 death the Histoire des animaux project eventually ended, and the post-Colbert Academy turned to other projects. Duverney’s debates with Jean Méry led to his departure from the Academy in 1706, marking the end of an era. (pages 201 - 238)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Anita Guerrini
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.003.0008
[Claude Perrault, Paris Academy of Sciences, salons, Bibliotheca anatomica, honnêtes hommes, comparative anatomy, natural history, mechanism]
The French played a distinctive role in the many comparative anatomies of this era. Perrault and the Academy joined anatomy closely to natural history and did not assume uniformity in nature, unlike most mechanical philosophers. Ideas about animal mechanism were indeed diverse and eclectic, and LeClerc and Manget’s 1685 Bibliotheca anatomica included several variations on this theme. The Academy’s comparative anatomy also contributed to discussions of classification and the definition of species. Anatomy in seventeenth-century Paris formed part of a wider cultural milieu that intertwined intellectual and courtly activities, where ancient and modern ideas coexisted as well as clashed. The honnêtes hommes of the academies and salons of Paris mingled science, art, music, and literature as interdependent forms of knowledge. (pages 239 - 246)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Anita Guerrini
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226248332.003.0009
[Histoire des animaux, Joseph- Guichard Duverney, Fontenelle, Buffon, Louis-Jean-Marie Daubenton, Histoire naturelle, Jardin du roi, comparative anatomy, Paris Academy of Sciences]
Although the Histoire des animaux had limited circulation in its first incarnation, it had a long afterlife. Following Duverney’s death in 1730, a complete revised edition of the project was undertaken under the guidance of the Academy’s secretary Fontenelle, which appeared in three volumes in 1733–34. Five years later, Buffon took control of the Jardin du roi, and his appointment of Daubenton in the 1740s signaled the revival of comparative anatomy in Paris, made evident in the volumes they jointly undertook of Histoire naturelle between 1749 and 1767. Buffon self-consciously took up where Perrault and Duverney left off. (pages 247 - 254)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Acknowledgments

Notes

Bibliography

Index