Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-m8qmq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T10:40:39.147Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

How Archaeologists and Artifact Collectors Can—and Should—Collaborate to Comply with Legal and Ethical Antiquities Codes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2017

Bonnie L. Pitblado
Bonnie L. Pitblado*
Affiliation:
Department of Anthropology, University of Oklahoma, 455 West Lindsey, Norman, OK 73019 (bonnie.pitblado@ou.edu)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In a recent American Antiquity forum (Pitblado 2014), I argued that not only is it possible for archaeologists to engage in ethical collaborations with members of the artifact-collecting public, but that the Society for American Archaeology’s “Principles of Archaeological Ethics” stipulates that we should do so. This is not a message, however, that has fully permeated the archaeological community, which has led to a schism between populations who are often natural allies. This paper starts with that premise: that archaeologists should actively pursue collaborations with the artifact-collecting community with the goal of advancing research agendas, public education, and long-term care of collections in private hands. The paper offers guidelines for establishing and nurturing professional-collector relationships in a way that furthers the directives of legal and ethical archaeological codes. I begin with an overview of the changing nature of professional-collector relationships during the twentieth century, exploring reasons for the divisiveness that has characterized recent decades. I next suggest five steps for establishing appropriate relationships with artifact collectors—and avoiding inappropriate ones. Finally, I describe how I followed those steps to establish a network of collector-collaborators to build the foundation for a Paleoamerican research program in southeastern Idaho and northern Utah.

En un reciente foro de American Antiquity (Pitblado 2014), argumenté que no sólo es posible que los arqueólogos se dediquen a colaboraciones éticas con miembros de la colección pública de artefactos sino que “los principios de ética arqueológica” de la Sociedad Americana de Arqueología estipula que lo hagamos. Sin embargo, este no es un mensaje que ha impregnado totalmente a la comunidad arqueológica, ya que ha dado lugar a una división entre la población que a menudo es su aliada natural. Este ensayo comienza con esta premisa: que los arqueólogos deben buscar activamente colaboraciones con la comunidad recolectora de artefactos con la meta de avanzar en los programas de investigación, educación pública y cuidado a largo plazo de las colecciones privadas. El documento ofrece pautas para el establecimiento y apoyo profesional en las relaciones con el coleccionista de una forma que promueve las normas éticas y legales de los códigos arque lógicos. Inicio con una visión general acerca de la natur leza variable de las relaciones de los profesionales y los coleccionistas durante el siglo veinte al explorar las razones de divergencia que las ha caracterizado en las últimas décadas. Posteriormente, sugiero cinco pasos para establecer relaciones adecuadas y evitar las inapropiadas con los coleccionistas de artefactos. Finalmente, describo cómo seguí esos pasos para establecer una red de coleccionistas-colaboradores y construir las bases de un programa Paleoamericano de investigación en el sureste de Idaho y el norte de Utah.

Type
Research Article
Information
Advances in Archaeological Practice , Volume 2 , Issue 4 , November 2014 , pp. 338 - 352
Copyright
Copyright © Society for American Archaeology 2014

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References Cited

Anderson, David G., Miller, D. Shane, Yerka, Stephen J., Gillam, J. Christopher, Johanson, Erik N., Anderson, Derek T., Goodyear, Albert C., and Smallwood, Ashley PIDBA (Paleoindian Database of the Americas) 2010: Current Status and findings.Archaeology of Eastern North Americaatus and Findings. 38:63–90.Google Scholar
Andrew, Holly, Pitblado, Bonnie L., Fowler, Benjamin, and Shipley, Richard 2013 Paleoindian Occupation of Southeastern Idaho and Northern Utah. Poster presented at the Paleoamerican Odyssey Conference, Santa Fe, New Mexico.Google Scholar
Bowman, Kate, and Cannon, Molly Boeka 2011 Water, Water Everywhere: Streams and Springs in Southeastern Idaho and Northern Utah. Poster presented at the 9th Biennial Meeting of the Rocky Mountain Anthropology Conference,Missoula, Montana.Google Scholar
Brodie, Neil. and Gill, David 2003 Looting: An International View. In Ethical Issues in Archaeology, edited by Zimmerman, Larry J., Vitelli, Karen D., and Hollowell-Zimmer, Julie, pp. 31–44. Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Butler, B. Robert 1979 A Folsom Point Multipurpose Tool from the Little Blackfoot River, Southeastern Idaho. Idaho Archaeologist 3(3):10–13.Google Scholar
Chase, Arlen F., Chase, Diane Z., and Topsey, Harriot W. 1996 Archaeology and the Ethics of Collecting. In Archaeological Ethics, edited by Vitelli, Karen D., pp. 30–38. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Chippindale, Christopher 1995 Commercialization: The Role of Archaeological Laboratories and Collectors. In Ethics in American Archaeology: Challenges for the 1990s, edited by Lynott, Mark J. and Wylie, Alison, pp. 80–83. Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Chippindale, Christopher, and Gill, David W.J. 2000 Material Consequences of Contemporary Classical Looting. American Journal of Archaeology 104:463–511.Google Scholar
Coggins, Clemency 1969 Illicit Traffic of Pre-Columbian Antiquities. Art Journal 29(1):94, 96, 98, and 114.Google Scholar
Colwell-Chanthaphonh, Chip 2004 Those Obscure Objects of Desire: Collecting Cultures and the Archaeological Landscape in the San Pedro Valley of Arizona. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 33:571–601.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Colwell-Chanthaphonh, Chip 2005 The Quest for Coronado.Archaeology Southwest 19(1):1–2.Google Scholar
Early, Ann M. 1999 Profiteers and Public Archaeology: Antiquities Trafficking in Arkansas. In The Ethics of Collecting Cultural Property, edited by Messenger, Phyllis Mauch, pp. 39–50. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Elia, Ricardo J. 1996 A Seductive and Troubling Work. In Archaeological Ethics, edited by Vitelli, Karen D., pp. 54–62. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Fagan, Brian 1996 Enlightened Stewardship. In Archaeological Ethics, edited by Vitelli, Karen D., pp. 106–110. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Fagan, Brian 2003 Black Day at Slack Farm. In Archaeological Ethics, edited by Vitelli, Karen D., pp. 39–46. Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Fenneman, Nevin M., and Johnson, Douglas W. 1946 Physical Divisions of the Coterminous United States, 1:7,000,000-Scale Map. U.S. Geological Survey, Reston, VA.Google Scholar
Fowler, Benjamin 2014 Obsidian Toolstone Conveyance: Southern Idaho Forager Mobility. Master’s thesis, Department of Sociology, Social Work, and Anthropology, Utah State University, Logan.Google Scholar
Frison, George C. 1984 Avocational Archaeology: Its Past, Present, and Future. In Ethics and Values in Archaeology, edited by Green, Ernestine L., pp. 184–193. The Free Press, New York City.Google Scholar
Gauthier, Jon, and Dalpra, Cody 2011 What Lies Beneath: The Paleoenvironmental and Archaeological Data Potential of Deep Basalt Crevices in Southeastern Idaho. Poster presented at the 9th Biennial Meeting of the Rocky Mountain Anthropology Conference,Missoula, Montana.Google Scholar
Green, Ernestene L. (editor) 1984 Ethics and Values in Archaeology. The Free Press, New York City.Google Scholar
Griffin, Gillett G. 1986 In Defense of the Collector. National Geographic 169(4):462–465.Google Scholar
Groarke, Leo, and Warrick, Gary 2006 Stewardship Gone Astray? Ethics and the SAA. In The Ethics of Archaeology: Philosophical Perspectives on Archaeological Practice, edited by Scarre, Chris and Scarre, Geoffrey, pp. 163–180. Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, Roberta I., McCarthy, Donna, and Hall, Don Alan 2002 How Were North American Sites of the Pleistocene-Holocene Transition Discovered? North American Archaeologist 23:145–146.Google Scholar
Harrington, Spencer P.M. 1996a Bones and Bureaucrats: New York’s Great Cemetery Imbroglio. In Archaeological Ethics, edited by Vitelli, Karen D., pp. 221–236. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Harrington, Spencer P.M. 1996b The Looting of Arkansas. In Archaeological Ethics, edited bVitelli, y Karen D., pp. 90–105. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Harris, Kathryn A. 2009 Obsidian Sourcing of Southeastern Idaho Paleoindian Projectile Points. Unpublished B.S. Honors thesis, Department of Sociology, Social Work, and Anthropology, Utah State University, Logan.Google Scholar
Harris, Leo J. 1999 From the Collector’s Perspective: The Legality of Importing Pre-Columbian Art and Artifacts. In The Ethics of Collecting Cultural Property, edited by Messenger, Phyllis Mauch, pp. 155–175. University of New Mexico Press,Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Herscher, Ellen and McManamon, Francis P. 1995 Public Education and Outreach: The Obligation to Educate. In Ethics in American Archaeology: Challenges for the 1990s, edited by Lynott, Mark J. and Wylie, Alison, pp. 42–44. Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Hildreth, William Alex, and Pitblado, Bonnie 2010 Ice Caves of Southeastern Idaho: Distribution and Research Potential. Paper presented at the 32nd Biennial Meeting of the Great Basin Anthropological Association, Layton, Utah.Google Scholar
Hinsley, Curtis M. Jr. 2000 Digging for Identity: Reflections on the Cultural Background of Collecting. In Repatriation Reader: Who Owns American Indian Remains, edited by Mihesuah, Devon A., pp. 37–55. University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln.Google Scholar
Hollowell-Zimmer, Julie 2003 Digging in the Dirt—Ethics and Low-End Looting. In Ethical Issues in Archaeology, edited by Zimmerman, Larry J., Vitelli, Karen D., and Hollowell-Zimmer, Julie, pp. 45–56. Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Howell, Carol L. 1996 Daring to Deal with Huaqueros. In Archaeological Ethics, edited by Vitelli, Karen D., pp. 47–53. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Kelly, Robert L., and Thomas, David Hurst 2012 Archaeology, 6th ed. Cengage Learning,Independence, Kentucky.Google Scholar
Krech III, Shepard, and Hail , Barbara A. 1999 Collecting Native America, 1870-1960. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
LaBelle, Jason M. 2003 Coffee Cans and Folsom Points: Why We Cannot Continue to Ignore the Artifact Collectors. In Ethical Issues in Archaeology, edited by Zimmerman, Larry J., Vitelli, Karen D., and Hollowell-Zimmer, Julie, pp. 115–127. Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Lackey, Douglas P. 2006 Ethics and Native American Reburials: A Philosopher’s View of Two Decades of NAGPRA. In The Ethics of Archaeology: Philosophical Perspectives on Archaeological Practice, edited by Scarre, Chris and , pp. 146–162. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Levine, Marc N., and de Luna, Lucha Martinez 2013 Museum Salvage: A Case Study of the Mesoamerican Artifacts in Museum Collections and on the Antiquities Market. Journal of Field Archaeology 38:264–276.Google Scholar
Lynott, Mark J., and Wylie, Alison (editors) 1995 Ethics in American Archaeology: Challenges for the 1990s. Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
>Lynott, Mark J., and Wylie, Alison 1995 Stewardship: The Central Principle of Archaeological Ethics. In Ethics in American Archaeology: Challenges for the 1990s, edited by Lynott, Mark J. and Wylie, Alison, pp. 28–32. Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Meltzer, David J. 2005 The Seventy-Year Itch: Controversies over Human Antiquity and Their Resolution. Journal of Anthropological Research 61:433–468.Google Scholar
Meltzer, David J. 2006 Folsom: New Archaeological Investigations of a Classic Paleoindian Bison Kill. University of California Press, Oakland.Google Scholar
Messenger, Phyllis Mauch 1999 The Ethics of Collecting. Whose Culture? Cultural Property: Whose Property? University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Miss, Christian J. 1974 Final Report on the Archaeology of the Blackfoot Reservoir, Southeastern Idaho. Report on file,Idaho State University, Pocatello.Google Scholar
Muensterberger, Werner 1994 Collecting, An Unruly Passion: Psychological Perspectives. Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Murphy, Larry E., Beaudry, Mary C.,Adams, Richard E.W., and Brown, James A. 1995 Commercialization: Beyond the Law or Above It? Ethics and the Selling of the Archaeological Record. In Ethics in American Archaeology: Challenges for the 1990s, edited by Lynott, Mark J. and Wylie, Alison, pp. 38–41. Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Neary, John 1996 Project Sting. In Archaeological Ethics, edited by Vitelli, Karen D., pp. 64–70. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Pearce, Susan M. 1995 On Collecting: An Investigation into Collecting in the European Tradition. Routledge Press, London.Google Scholar
Plew, Mark G. 1987 An Archaeological Survey of State Lands in Bear Lake and Franklin Counties, Idaho. Report on file, Boise State University, .Idaho.Google Scholar
Pitblado, Bonnie L. 1994 Paleoindian Presence in Southwest Colorado. Southwestern Lore 60(4):1–20.Google Scholar
Pitblado, Bonnie L. 1998 Peak to Peak in Paleoindian Time: Occupation of Southwest Colorado. Plains Anthropologist 43:333–348.Google Scholar
Pitblado, Bonnie L. 2000 Living the High Life in Colorado: Late Paleoindian Occupation of the Caribou Lake Site. In This Land of Shining Mountains: Archeological Studies in Colorado’s Indian Peak Wilderness, edited by Cassells, E. Steve, pp. 124–158.Center for Mountain Archeology Research Report 8,Ward, Colorado.Google Scholar
Pitblado, Bonnie L. 2003 Late Paleoindian Occupation of the Southern Rocky Mountains. University Press of Colorado, Niwot.Google Scholar
Pitblado, Bonnie L. 2009 Utah State University’s Southeastern Idaho & Northern Utah Paleoindian Research Program. SINUPP Short Report Series 1, Logan, Utah. Electronic document, https://ou.academia.edu/BonniePitblado/Publications-for-General-Audience, accessed September 1, 2014.Google Scholar
Pitblado, Bonnie L. 2010 Utah State University’s Southeastern Idaho & Northern Utah Paleoindian Research Program. SINUPP Short Report Series 2, Logan, Utah. Electronic document, https://ou.academia.edu/BonniePitblado/Publications-for-General-Audience, accessed September 1, 2014.Google Scholar
Pitblado, Bonnie L. 2011 Utah State University’s Southeastern Idaho & Northern Utah Paleoindian Research Program. SINUPP Short Report Series 3, Logan, Utah. Electronic document, https://ou.academia.edu/BonniePitblado/Publications-for-General-Audience, accessed September 1, 2014.Google Scholar
Pitblado, Bonnie L. 2014 An Argument for Ethical, Proactive, Archaeologist-Artifact Collector Collaboration. American Antiquity 79:385–400.Google Scholar
Pitblado, Bonnie L., Cannon, Molly Boeka, and Fowler, Ben 2011 Predictive Modeling of the Paleoindian Record in Southeastern Idaho and Northern Utah. Idaho Archaeologist 34(2):21–30.Google Scholar
Poetschat, Cathy, Kornfeld, Marcel, and Keyser, James D. 2012 Avocational Archaeology: A Half-Century of Increasing Contributions. SAA Archaeological Record 12(3):5–11.Google Scholar
Proulx, Blythe Bowman 2013 Archaeological Site Looting in “Glocal” Perspective: Nature, Scope, and Frequency. American Journal of Archaeology 117:111–125.Google Scholar
Renfrew, Colin, and Elia , Ricardo 1993 Collectors are the Real Looters. Archaeology 46(3):16–17.Google Scholar
Robson, Eleanor, Treadwell, Luke, and Gosden, Chris 2006 Who Owns Objects? The Ethics and Politics of Collecting Cultural Artefacts. Oxbow Books, Oxford, England.Google Scholar
Rose, Mark, and Acar , Özgen 1996 Turkey’s War on the Illicit Antiquities Trade. In Archaeological Ethics, edited by Vitelli, Karen D., pp. 71–89. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Sassaman, Kenneth E. 2014 Editor’s Corner. American Antiquity 79:381–384.Google Scholar
Seebach, John D. 2006 Drought or Development? Patterns of Paleoindian Site Discovery on the Great Plains of North America. Plains Anthropologist 51:71–88.Google Scholar
Shott, Michael J. 2008 equal o nll roofht w ded l e vsbr cted: A Proposal for Conservation of Private Collections in American Archaeology. SAA Archaeological Record 8(2):30–35.Google Scholar
Smith, Monica L. 2014 Citizen Science in Archaeology. American Antiquity, in press.Google Scholar
Society for American Archaeology (SAA) 1996 Principles of Archaeological Ethics. Electronic document, http://www.saa.org/-AbouttheSociety/PrinciplesofArchaeologicalEthics/tabid/203/Default.aspx, accessed July 12, 2014.Google Scholar
Stamm, John F., Pitblado, Bonnie L., and Camp , Beth Ann 2004 The Geology and Soils of the Chance Gulch Archaeological Site near Gunnison, Colorado. The Mountain Geologist 41:63–74.Google Scholar
Thompson, Randy A. 2004 Trade or Transport Occurrence of Obsidian from the Malad, Idaho, Source in the Great Plains. Master’s thesis, Anthropology Department, Idaho State University, Pocatello.Google Scholar
Trigger, Bruce G. 2006 A History of Archaeological Thought, 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press, New York City.Google Scholar
Vitelli, Karen D. 1996 Archaeological Ethics. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Watkins, Joe 2003 Archaeological Ethics and American Indians. In Ethical Issues in Archaeology, edited by Zimmerman, Larry J., Vitelli, Karen D., and Hollowell-Zimmer, Julie, pp. 129–141. Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Watkins, Joe,Goldstein, Lynne, Vitelli, Karen, and Jenkins, Leigh 1995 Accountability: Responsibilities of Archaeologists to Other Interest Groups. In Ethics in American Archaeology: Challenges for the 1990s, edited by Lynott, Mark J. andWylie, Alison, pp. 33–37.Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Wildermuth, Todd 2012 Museum Hosting Folsom Man Exhibit. The Raton Range, March 23, 2012, Raton, NM. Electronic document, http://ratonrange.com/museum-hosting-folsom-man-exhibit-p3134-1.htm, accessed May 19, 2014.Google Scholar
Zimmerman, Larry J. 1995 In Ethics in American Archaeology: Challenges for the 1990s, edited by Lynott , Mark J.and Wylie, Alison, pp. 64–67. Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Zimmerman, Larry J., Vitelli, Karen D., and Hollowell-Zimmer, Julie 2003 Ethical Issues in Archaeology. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar