Scoring system to predict the success rate of external cephalic versions and determine the timing of the procedure

L.-G. Zheng, H.-L. Zhang, R.-X. Chen, Z.-D. Liu, Q.-P. Liao, Y.-Y. Ma, J.-Y. Yan

Fujian Maternity and Child Health Hospital, Affiliated Hospital of Fujian Medical University, Fuzhou, China. yanjy2019@fjmu.edu.cn

---

• Obstetrics

OBJECTIVE: We aimed to examine the prenatal clinical characteristics of women with single pregnancies undergoing external cephalic version (ECV) without anesthesia, develop a novel scoring system for predicting the ECV success rate, and demonstrate that this scoring system can be used to individualize the timing of ECV attempts.

PATIENTS AND METHODS: We enrolled 270 women who underwent ECV without anesthesia at 37-40 weeks of gestation in the Fujian Maternity and Child Health Hospital from 2016 to 2019 and divided them into two ECV outcome groups (success vs. failure). We identified five clinical features (the fetal buttocks’ station, the sum of the fundal height and station, the fetal head location, and whether the fetal head or buttocks could be grasped) as independent factors affecting the ECV success rate, and we scored them using a regression coefficient.

RESULTS: Women with scores of 0-3 points had ECV success rates, vaginal delivery rates, and delivery gestational ages at 16.67%, 16.67%, and 38.88 weeks, respectively; those with scores of 4-6 points had ECV success rates, vaginal delivery rates, and delivery gestational ages at 65.75%, 58.90%, and 39.62 weeks, respectively; and those with scores of 7-9 points had ECV success rates, vaginal delivery rates, and delivery gestational ages at 93.71%,74.83%, and 40.00 weeks, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS: The ECV success and vaginal delivery rates increased with the score, and the delivery gestational age showed an initial increase. To optimize the ECV procedure and reduce the hospital burden, this scoring system should be used routinely to predict the ECV success rate and determine the timing of ECV attempts.

Free PDF Download