초록

This paper examines the ambiguity that arises from the Left-Node Raising (LNR) construction in Korean. I argue that the ambiguity is induced by the scopal relation between a coordinate phrase and a quantifier-type pivot: the quantificational meaning of a pivot can scope over the coordinate phrase, or it can take a narrow scope within each conjunct. I show that previous proposals such as the ATB-scrambling analysis (Nakao 2010) and the multi-dominance analysis (Chung 2010) have not addressed the ambiguity or have some empirical problems. I develop a compositional analysis of the scopal ambiguity within the framework of Combinatory Categorial Grammar (e.g. Steedman 1996; Steedman 2000; Baldridge 2002; Steedman and Baldridge 2011; Steedman 2012), and propose that it can be extended to the English and Korean RNR sentences with a quantificational pivot.

키워드

Left-Node Raising, scope ambiguity, (non-)distributive scope, coordinate phrase, Right-Node Raising, Combinatory Categorial Grammar, Korean

참고문헌(35)open

  1. [학위논문] Baldridge, Jason. / 2002 / Lexically specified derivational control in Combinatory Categorial Grammar

  2. [학술지] Bošković, Zeljko / 1998 / Scrambling and last resort / Linguistic Inquiry 29 : 347 ~ 366

  3. [학술지] 정대호 / 2010 / Left Node Raising as a Shared Node Raising / 생성문법연구 20 (1) : 51 ~ 72

  4. [학술지] Fukui, Naoki / 1993 / Parameters and optionality / Linguistic Inquiry 24 : 399 ~ 420

  5. [단행본] Hartmann, Katharina. / 2000 / Right node raising and gapping: Interface Conditions on Prosodic Deletion / John Benjamins

  6. [단행본] Hartmann, Katharina. / 2003 / The interfaces: Deriving and interpreting (omitted) structures / John Benjamins : 121 ~ 151

  7. [단행본] Heim, Irene / 1998 / Semantics in generative grammar / Blackwell

  8. [학위논문] Hendriks, Herman. / 1993 / Studied flexibility: Categories and types in syntax and semantics

  9. [학술지] Hudson, Richard / 1976 / Conjunction reduction, gapping, and right-node-raising / Language 52 : 535 ~ 562

  10. [단행본] Kayne, Richard / 1994 / The Antisymmetry of syntax / MIT Press

  11. [학술지] Kubota, Yusuke / 2015 / Against ellipsis : Arguments for the direct licensing of ‘noncanonical’ coordinations / Linguistics and Philosophy 38 : 521 ~ 576

  12. [학술지] Kuroda, Shige-Yuki / 1988 / Whether we agree or not : A comparative syntax of English and Japanese / Linguisticae Investigationes 12 : 1 ~ 47

  13. [학술지] Lee, Jungmee / 2010 / Temporal interpretation without tense : Korean and Japanese coordination constructions / Journal of Semantics 27 : 307 ~ 341

  14. [기타] Lee, Jungmee / 2018 / Ambiguity with summative and symmetrical predicates in Korean Left-Node Raising constructions. Unpublished manuscript

  15. [학술지] Maling, Joan / 1972 / On gapping and the order of constituents / Linguistic Inquiry 1 : 101 ~ 108

  16. [학위논문] May, Robert. / 1977 / The Grammar of quantification

  17. [학술지] Miyagawa, Shigeru / 1997 / Against optional scrambling / Linguistic Inquiry 28 : 1 ~ 26

  18. [인터넷자료] Nakao, Chizuru / Japanese left node raising as ATB-scrambling. University of Pennsylvania Working Papers in Linguistics 16: 156-165

  19. [학술지] 박명관 / 2009 / A 'RNR' Analysis of 'Left Node Raising' Constructions in Korean / 생성문법연구 19 (4) : 505 ~ 528

  20. [단행본] Partee, Barbara / 1983 / Meaning, use, and interpretation of language / Walter de Gruyter : 361 ~ 383

  21. [단행본] Postal, Paul M. / 1974 / On raising / MIT Press

  22. [단행본] Postal, Paul M. / 1998 / Three investigations of extraction / MIT Press

  23. [학술지] Sabbagh, Joseph / 2007 / Ordering and linearizing rightward movement / Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 25 : 349 ~ 401

  24. [단행본] Saito, Mamoru. / 1989 / Alternative conceptions of phrase structure / University of Chicago Press : 182 ~ 200

  25. [학술지] Saito, Mamoru / 1992 / Long distance scrambling in Japanese / Journal of East Asian Linguistics 1 : 69 ~ 118

  26. [단행본] Saito, Mamoru. / 2004 / Peripheries: Syntactic edges and their effects / Kluwer Academic Publishers : 143 ~ 163

  27. [단행본] Saito, Mamoru. / 2005 / The free word order phenomenon / Mouton de Gruyter : 335 ~ 376

  28. [단행본] Steedman, Mark. / 1996 / Surface structure and interpretation / MIT Press

  29. [학술지] Steedman, Mark / 2000 / Information structure and the syntax-phonology interface / Linguistic Inquiry 31 : 649 ~ 689

  30. [단행본] Steedman, Mark. / 2012 / Taking scope / MIT Press

  31. [단행본] Steedman, Mark. / 2011 / Non-transformational syntax / Wiley-Blackwell : 181 ~ 224

  32. [단행본] Wexler, Ken / 1980 / Formal principles of language acquisition / MIT Press

  33. [단행본] Wilder, Chris. / 1999 / Proceedings of West Coast Conference in Formal Linguistics / Cascadilla Press : 586 ~ 598

  34. [단행본] Wilder, Chris / 2008 / Topics in ellipsis / Cambridge University Press : 229 ~ 258

  35. [학술대회] Yatabe, Shûichi / 2001 / The syntax and semantics of left-node raising in Japanese / The Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar : 325 ~ 344