정치 윤리학으로서의 민족주의: 민족과 개인의 욕망

@article{ART001474543},
author={ 조규형 },
title={정치 윤리학으로서의 민족주의: 민족과 개인의 욕망},
journal={영미문화},
issn={1598-5431},
year={2010},
volume={10},
number={2},
pages={267-289},
doi={10.15839/eacs.10.2.201008.267},
url={http://dx.doi.org/10.15839/eacs.10.2.201008.267}

TY - JOUR
AU - 조규형
TI - 정치 윤리학으로서의 민족주의: 민족과 개인의 욕망
T2 - 영미문화
PY - 2010
VL - 10
IS - 2
PB - 한국영미문화학회
SP - 267-289
SN - 1598-5431
AB - Nationalism endorses a collective movement to establish an authentic position in the international cultural and political arena. Arguably the dialectic of nationalism and geopolitics bears a reassuring similarity to the philosophical lineage going back, at least, to Hegelian dialectic of universality and particularity. This dialectic platform has been concerned with sustaining, among other things, the dynamics between the universal and the particular. In practical terms, nationalism prompts increased sensitivity to socio-political pressures coming from abroad to cancel the national particularity into geopolitical, so-called universal, anonymity. Drawing suggestively from psychoanalysis, Lacanian ethics in particular, this discussion articulates the ethics of nationalism. Recounting Kantian self-determination as a reference point for responsible morality, Lacan suggests the problematics of desire as an alternative index for ethics. As individual desire flows from the unfathomable abyss of misrecognition, Lacanian ethics dissuade individuals to unlearn the fantasy that their own real desire, a residue produced by the Symbolic process, can be satisfied with that very socio-cultural Symbolic. Subjecting nationalism to Lacanian implications, Zizek illuminates nationalism as a small screening object which obscures as much as displays the circuits to the individual desire. Psychoanalytic ethics addresses that the ethical base should be found upon the particular, individual, real desire. As far as the nationalist cause also puts emphasis upon particularity rather than universality, nationalism is logically positioned to exert reflective efforts on empowering its constitutive individuals. Lacanian ethics persuades us to challenge the universal claim and to work through to regenerate nationalism in presenting its final contribution towards individual particularities.
KW - ethics, nationalism, geopolitics, desire, Lacan, psychoanalysis. universality, particularity, individual
DO - 10.15839/eacs.10.2.201008.267
UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.15839/eacs.10.2.201008.267
ER -

조규형 (2010). 정치 윤리학으로서의 민족주의: 민족과 개인의 욕망. 영미문화, 10( 2), 267- 289.

조규형 . 2010, “정치 윤리학으로서의 민족주의: 민족과 개인의 욕망”, 영미문화, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 267-289. Available from: doi:10.15839/eacs.10.2.201008.267

조규형 “정치 윤리학으로서의 민족주의: 민족과 개인의 욕망” 영미문화 10.2 pp. 267-289 (2010): 267.

조규형 . 정치 윤리학으로서의 민족주의: 민족과 개인의 욕망 영미문화 [Internet]. 2010; 10( 2), : 267-289. Available from: doi:10.15839/eacs.10.2.201008.267

조규형 . “정치 윤리학으로서의 민족주의: 민족과 개인의 욕망” 영미문화 10, no.2 (2010): 267-289. doi: 10.15839/eacs.10.2.201008.267

홈 권호 목록 논문 목록 논문 상세

정치 윤리학으로서의 민족주의: 민족과 개인의 욕망

영미문화

약어 : EACS

2010, vol.10, no.2, pp.267 - 289

DOI : 10.15839/eacs.10.2.201008.267

발행기관 : 한국영미문화학회

연구분야 : 영어와문학

조규형¹

¹고려대학교

인용한 논문 수 : - 서지 간략 보기

초록

Nationalism endorses a collective movement to establish an authentic position in the international cultural and political arena. Arguably the dialectic of nationalism and geopolitics bears a reassuring similarity to the philosophical lineage going back, at least, to Hegelian dialectic of universality and particularity. This dialectic platform has been concerned with sustaining, among other things, the dynamics between the universal and the particular. In practical terms, nationalism prompts increased sensitivity to socio-political pressures coming from abroad to cancel the national particularity into geopolitical, so-called universal, anonymity. Drawing suggestively from psychoanalysis, Lacanian ethics in particular, this discussion articulates the ethics of nationalism. Recounting Kantian self-determination as a reference point for responsible morality, Lacan suggests the problematics of desire as an alternative index for ethics. As individual desire flows from the unfathomable abyss of misrecognition, Lacanian ethics dissuade individuals to unlearn the fantasy that their own real desire, a residue produced by the Symbolic process, can be satisfied with that very socio-cultural Symbolic. Subjecting nationalism to Lacanian implications, Zizek illuminates nationalism as a small screening object which obscures as much as displays the circuits to the individual desire. Psychoanalytic ethics addresses that the ethical base should be found upon the particular, individual, real desire. As far as the nationalist cause also puts emphasis upon particularity rather than universality, nationalism is logically positioned to exert reflective efforts on empowering its constitutive individuals. Lacanian ethics persuades us to challenge the universal claim and to work through to regenerate nationalism in presenting its final contribution towards individual particularities.

키워드

ethics, nationalism, geopolitics, desire, Lacan, psychoanalysis. universality, particularity, individual

참고문헌(39)

[단행본] 가라타니 고진 / 2001 / 윤리 21 / 사회평론
[단행본] 가라타니 고진 / 2005 / 트랜스크리틱: 칸트와 마르크스 넘어서기 / 한길사
[단행본] 강영안 / 2000 / 도덕은 무엇으로부터 오는가: 칸트Kant의 도덕 철학 / 소나무
[단행본] 김상봉 / 2005 / 도덕교육의 파시즘: 노예도덕을 넘어서 / 길
[단행본] 들뢰즈, 질 / 2004 / 차이와 반복 / 민음사
[단행본] 레비나스, 엠마누엘 / 2000 / 윤리와 무한: 필립 네모와의 대화 / 다산글방
[단행본] 무페, 상탈 / 2006 / 민주주의의 역설 / 인간사랑
[단행본] 슬로터다이크, 페터 / 2006 / 냉소적 이성 비판 / 에코리브르
[단행본] 애링턴, 로버트 L / 2003 / 서양 윤리학사 / 서광사
[학술지] 오영주 / 2007 / 육체, 욕망, 쾌락 - 소돔 120일 연구 / 한국프랑스학논집 57 : 149 ~ 178
[학술지] 임홍빈 / 1990 / 칸트의 도덕성 개념에 대한 헤겔의 비판은 과연 정당한가? / 철학 35 : 163 ~ 188
[학술지] 정진만 / 2002 / 윤리와 충동 / Journal of Lacan & Contemporary Psychoanalysis 4 (1) : 199 ~ 222
[단행본] 지젝. 슬라보예 / 2002 / 향락의 전이 / 인간사랑
[단행본] 지젝. 슬라보예 / 2009 / 시차적 관점 / 마티
[단행본] 지젝. 슬라보예 / 2003 / 실재계의 사막으로의 환대 / 인간사랑
[단행본] 칸트, 임마누엘 / 2002 / 도덕형이상학을 위한 기초 놓기 / 책세상
[단행본] 칸트, 임마누엘 / 2009 / 실천이성비판 / 아카넷
[단행본] 한단석 / 1981 / 헤겔 철학사상의 이해. in: 오늘의 사상신서 / 한길사 : 34
[단행본] Critchley, Simon / 1999 / Ethics-Politics-Subjectivity: Essays on Derrida, Levinas and Contemporary French Thought / Verson
[단행본] Derrida, Jacques / 1994 / Specters of Marx: The State of the Debt, the Work of Mourning, and the New International / Routledge
[단행본] Eagleton, Terry / 2010 / On Evil / Yale UP
[단행본] Eagleton, Terry / 2009 / Trouble with Strangers: A Study of Ethics / Wiley-Blackwell
[단행본] Freud, Sigmund / 1955 / Beyond the Pleasure Principle. in: The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud / Hogarth P : 7 ~ 64
[학술지] Freud, Sigmund / The Economic Problem of Masochism / Standard Edition 19 : 12 ~ 66
[학술지] Freud, Sigmund / The Ego and the Id / Standard Edition 19 : 159 ~ 170
[단행본] Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich / 1892 / The Logic of Hegel: Translated from The Encyclopedia of the Philosophical Sciences / Oxford UP
[단행본] Lacan, Jacques / 1981 / The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis. in: The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XI / Norton
[학술지] Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty / 2002 / Ethics and Politics in Tagore, Coetzee, and Certain Scenes of Teaching / Diacritics 32 (3) : 17 ~ 31
[단행본] Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty / 1993 / The Post-Colonial Critic: Interviews, Strategies, Dialogues / Routledge
[단행본] Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty / 1985 / Subaltern Studies: Deconstructing Historiography. in: Subaltern Studies IV: Writings on South Asian History and Society / Oxford UP : 330 ~ 363
[단행본] Stavrakakis, Yannis / 1999 / Lacan and the Political / Routledge
[인터넷자료] Žižek, Salvoj / Against the Double Blackmail / Lacan Dot Com
[단행본] Žižek, Salvoj / Badiou and the Real. in: Think Again: Alain Badiou and the Future of Philosophy / Continuum : 165 ~ 181
[단행본] Žižek, Salvoj / 1993 / Enjoy Your Nation as Yourself! Tarrying with the Negative: Kant, Hegel, and the Critique of Ideology / Duke UP : 200 ~ 237
[단행본] Žižek, Salvoj / 1999 / Kant with (or against) Sade. in: The Žižek Reader / Blackwell : 283 ~ 301
[단행본] Žižek, Salvoj / 1991 / Looking Awry: An Introduction to Jacques Lacan through Popular Culture / MIT P
[학술지] Žižek, Salvoj / 2000 / Melancholy and the Act / Critical Inquiry 26 : 657 ~ 681
[단행본] Žižek, Salvoj / 1989 / The Sublime Object of Ideology / Verso
[단행본] Žižek, Salvoj / 1999 / Ticklish Subject / Verso