ANNEX PUBLISHERS

Journal of Waste Resources and Recycling

ISSN: 2766-5887

Open Access
Research Article
Max Screen >>

A Facil Water Treatment Rendering Cement Kiln Dust Reusable in Clinker Manufacturing

Received Date: July 27, 2019 Accepted Date: December 21, 2020 Published Date: December 23, 2020

Copyright: © 2019 Zaki MI. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Related article at Pubmed, Google Scholar

Abstract

Background:Worldwide, stockpiled cement kiln dust (CKD) has been neither properly disposed, nor profitably utilized. Mostly it contains ≥6 wt % alkali metal salts; therefore, it cannot be reused as a raw material in clinker manufacturing in cement industry. In the present work, a facile water treatment, before and after calcination (at 500-1000 oC) of CKD, was designed and found to help leaching out the salt content that renders CKD reusable in the clinker manufacturing.

Results:Water treatment products, as examined for compositional and morphological consequences by XRD, FTIR, SEM and EDX, were found to reveal that the water treatment applied, via stirring for as short as 15 min under ambient conditions, effectively freed CKD from its salt content (KCL, NaCl and CaSO4) in the form of separable flake-like crystal aggregates.

Conclusion:The proposed water treatment procedure was proved efficient in wavering CKD from its salt content thus paving the way to its reuse in clinker manufacturing, thus evolving an added value to the cement industry.

Keywords:Cement Kiln Dust; Heat Treatment; Water Treatment; Compositional Consequences; Morphological Consequences

Introduction

Cement kiln dust (denoted CKD) is by-produced during the calcination process in the kiln of cement clinker manufacturing plants [1,2]. It is a massive by-product (ca. 30 million tons/year worldwide and 5-20 % of the amount of cement clinker produced [3-5]) that is generally a heterogeneous mixture by chemistry and particulate size. These characteristics are dependent on the raw feed materials, fuels, kiln pyro-processing type (dry or wet), overall equipment layout, and kind of cement being manufactured [4,6]. Chemically speaking, however, it includes oxides, carbonates, chlorides and sulfates of Ca, K, Na, Al, Fe and Si, with CaO/CaCO3 being its major constituent [2]. CKD is separated from the clinker kiln exhaust gas in order to prevent (i) the alkali content of the clinker from exceeding the maximum allowable value (≤0.6 %) [7], and (ii) the buildup of excessive salts (chlorides and sulfates) in the produced clinker [7].

Only a small proportion of the generated CKD is recycled back again with the clinker, but the rest (ca. 80 %) is stockpiled and/or land-filled thus posing significant environmental and health threats [3,7,8]. Hence, it is a chemical waste material that is neither properly disposed, nor profitably utilized. In Egypt, for instance, ca. one million tons of CKD are discharged annually from cement kilns [9], which contain excessive amounts of alkali compounds, thus making them unsuitable for reuse in the cement making process [5,10]. Consequently, an active research has been urged to find out profitable ways and means of using CKD, not only to avoid its environment and health threats, but also to evolve an added value to the global cement industry. This is bearing in mind, that cement is indispensably a strategic material for the ever growing construction economy [7,11]. Research-devised new applications implement CKD in (i) concrete mixes as cement substituent [6,11,12], (ii) soil conditioning and stabilization [13-17], (iii) filler material in asphalt mixes [13,15,18], (iv) the making of lightweight aggregates, blocks and bricks [7], (v) solidification/stabilization of hazardous waste [15], (vi) wastewater treatment [9,19], (vii) heavy metal scavenging [20,21], and (viii) the making of a catalyst for the gasification of biomass [22]. Despite of their obvious diversity, these applications use-up but only a small amount of the on-site piled CKD worldwide. Hence, further research efforts are still urged to optimize utilization of CKD.

The present investigation is an attempt to join the forces with the international research endeavor in tackling this important issue. The thrust has been not only the awareness of the obvious environmental, health and economical necessities of the subject, but also the lack of in-depth knowledge about the influence of two basic treatments, namely the heat and water treatments, on the chemical composition and morphology of CKD particles. It is worth noting, in this regard, that influence of water treatment of CKD was previously examined but was focused on the hydration of the lime content into Ca(OH)2 in order to improve the viability of using it in soil stabilization [14] and wastewater treatment [9,19,20] purposes. In the present investigation, however, water treatment experiments were designed to facilitate long-term (up to 14 days) processing in hopes of going beyond the hydration into the hydrolysis of a patch of a stockpiled CKD in a local cement manufacturing plant. Subsequently, the CKD and its hydrolysis (and thermolysis) products were characterized by means of thermogravimetry, X-ray diffractometry, infrared spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy, and energy dispersive X-ray micro-probing chemical analysis. Results obtained were implemented to reveal influence of the heat and water treatments applied on the salt content of CKD and, hence, its reusability in clinker manufacturing.

Experimental
CKD origin and factory provided information

CKD sample used in the present investigation was a grayish white fine powder provided by ASECMINYA cement plant (Minya Portland/El-Minya/Egypt). It was taken from a freshly homogenized mixture that was exited at 1050 oC, then quenched and cooled by fresh air, separated by means of a bag house filter, and collected in pin without any treatment, throughout a 24-h processing. Information provided for the CKD sample included the chemical composition, mass loss on ignition (LOI) at 975 oC for 1 h, the manufacturing kiln type and processing condition, and raw materials used, are set out in Table 1. Accordingly, the chemical composition is shown to be majored by CaO (50.25 %) and SiO2 (14.66 %), and minored by alkali metal oxides (K2O (6.64 %), Na2O (3.30 %) and MgO (0.99 %)) as well as Al2O3 (4.51 %), Fe2O3 (2.9 %), SO3 (5.89 %) and Cl (7.69 %). These quantitative results are in the order of magnitude of the average of quantitative results reported for variously obtained CKD samples by Peethamparan et al. [14]. On the other hand, it was also provided that the CKD sample consists of 61 % particles below 45 μm diameter and 15 % particles above 90 μm.

CKD heat treatment

Based on thermogravimetry and differential thermal analysis results (vide infra), portions of the CKD sample were calcined at 500, 650 or 1000±2 oC (for 1 h) in a static atmosphere of air. Therefore, ca. 10-g portion of the loose powder was placed in wide-mouth porcelain crucible, admitted into an electronically controlled Naber 2804 muffle furnace (Germany) at room temperature (RT), and, then, the temperature was linearly elevated (at 20 oC/min) to the set value. After the elapse of 1 h, the temperature was leveled off, the calcination product was withdrawn from the furnace (at 200 oC), and kept desiccated over CaCl2 till further use. The calcination products are discerned from the uncalcined CKD by suffixing the calcination temperature applied. For instance, the calcination product at 500 oC is denoted CKD-500 throughout the text.

CKD water treatment

Long- (LT) and short-term (ST) modes of water treatment of CKD and its calcination product at 1000 oC (i.e., CKD-1000) were conducted by soaking the material particles in bi-distilled water (1 g/40 mL) in a glass vessel at RT, magnetically stirring the vessel content for 15 min, and, then, either (i) maintaining the water/solid contact at RT till complete dryness (LT mode), or (ii) separating immediately the solid particles from the aqueous medium by filtration through a filter paper (ST-mode). In the ST-mode, the separated wet solid and filtrate were also maintained under ambient conditions till complete dryness. The complete dryness was accomplished in both modes after 14 days. The dried products of the LT-mode were milky white crystals (aggregated in the form of large, thin flakes) settling on top of a fine powder. The crystals’ flakes were large enough to be successfully manually separated from the powder. Dried crystals and powders produced via the LT- and ST-modes of water treatment were pulverized by mortar and pestle, and kept desiccated over CaCl2 till further use. It is obvious that the crystals are for water-leachable constituents of the soaked material (CKD or CKD-1000), whose growth may had been reminiscent to the slowness of both the water solvent evaporation and the consequent elevation of concentration of the leachate species at room temperature (RT). Whereas the powders are to dwell the residual solid particles. Hence, leachate crystals (L) produced via the LT-mode of water treatment of CKD are designated as CKD(LT/L), whereas the residual powder (R) produced via the ST-mode is denoted CKD(ST/R). It is worth noting, that water treatment parameters were chosen in order to help going beyond CKD hydration [14] into hydrolysis.

Characterization methods

Thermogravimetry (TG) and differential thermal analysis (DTA) were carried out on heating (at 20 oC/min) ca. 25-mg portion of test sample, in a dynamic atmosphere of air (40 mL/min), up to 1000 oC, using a model DTG-60H Shimadzu analyzer (Japan). α-Al2O3 (Shimadzu Corp.) was the thermally inert reference material used with the DTA measurement. X-ray powder difractometry (XRD) was conducted on a model JSX-60PA Jeol diffractometer (Japan) equipped with Ni-filtered CuKα radiation (λ = 0.1542 nm, 40 kV and 30 mA). Diffraction patterns thus obtained were matched with standard diffraction data filed in JCPDS cards [23] for phase composition identification purposes. Fourier-transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy was carried out employing a Genesis II Thermo Mattson FT-IR spectrophotometer (USA) powered with WinFirst Lit software (Mattson Corp.) for data acquisition and handling. The spectra were taken from lightly loaded (< 1 wt %) KBr-supported disks of test samples at 4000-400 cm-1, by averaging 20 scans at the resolution of 4 cm-1. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was performed with Thermo Fischer Quanta FEG250 scanning electron microscope (Switzerland) at 30 kV. Test samples were sputter coated with ca. 2-nm thick gold film before examination, by means of a Balzers sputter coater (Liechtenstein). Energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) analysis was done using an Oxford-Instruments (High Wycombe, United Kingdom) EDX system. It is worth noting, that (i) test samples characterized were pre-ground and passed through a ≤250 mesh Sieve, and (ii) equipment used for TG/DTA, XRD and IR analysis were pre-calibrated versus CaCO3 thermal decomposition, Si single crystal, and polyethylene standard film, respectively.

Results and Discussion
CKD composition and particle morphology

XRD, IR and TGA/DTA results obtained for CKD are exhibited in Figure 1. Matching the diffraction peaks monitored in the XRD diffractogram (Figure 1A) with standard diffraction data [23] revealed that crystalline domains of CKD are majored by CaO (Lime), and minored by SiO2 (Quartz), KCl (Sylvine), CaSO4 (Anhydrite), NaCl (Halite) and Fe2O3 (Hematite). According to Peethamparan et al. [14], such a crystalline phase composition is typical for CKD released during cement clinker manufacturing under the processing conditions set out in Table 1. Consistently, the corresponding IR spectrum (Figure 1B) monitors absorptions of S-O bond vibrations (at 1149, 677, 616 and 597 cm-1) for the CaSO4 [24], and Si-O bond vibrations (at 1119, 1001, 917 and 890 cm-1) for the SiO2 [24]. It monitors, moreover, absorptions at 3638, 3422, 1630, 1446, 1423, 864 and 510 cm-1, which are frequently encountered in IR spectra taken from partially hydrated and carbonated CaO [25]. This is in the sense that the former three absorptions (at 3638, 3422 and 1630 cm-1) are due to ν/δOH vibrations arising from hydrated species of CaO, i.e. Ca(OH)2 [24,25]. Whereas, the absorptions at 1446, 1423 and 864 cm-1 are assignable to ν/δCO3 vibrations arising from carbonated species of CaO, i.e. CaCO3 [24,25]. Partial hydration and carbonation of CaO are influenced by the known strong tendency of CaO towards adsorption/absorption of ambient H2O and CO2 molecules yielding Ca(OH)2 and CaCO3 impurity species in the CKD. The absence of XRD indications (Figure 1A) for these impurity species may be due to their scarce presence and/or non-crystallinity. It is worth noting, that the XRD-observed chlorides of K and Na (Figure 1A) are not accessible to IR spectroscopy over the frequency range scanned [24].

TGA and DTA curves obtained for CKD (Figure 1C) indicate that it is thermally stable to heating up to 560 oC, but at higher temperatures it suffers a minor mass loss (ca. 0.7 %) via an endothermic decomposition process maximized at 610 oC, and a larger mass loss >750 oC, which is shown to extend beyond the highest temperature scanned (1000 oC). On-site LOI determination at 975 oC brought about a value of 4.03 % (Table 1), which may corroborate ascribing the TGA-observed high-temperature mass loss to a minor decomposition process. The fact that Ca(OH)2 has been reportedly found [26] to decompose into CaO and H2O near 600 oC, but CaCO3 decomposes >750 oC [25], may consider the observed mass loss maximized at 610 oC to be due to the decomposition of the Ca(OH)2 minority species, whereas the larger mass loss at >750 oC to undertake that of the CaCO3 species. It is worth noting, however, that contribution of decomposition and/or sublimation of other constituents of CKD (e.g., sulfate and/or chlorides) to the high-temperature mass loss cannot be excluded with certainty. It is worth admitting, that the TGA-observed non-isothermal mass losses were the thrust behind examining consequences of isothermal heat treatments of CKD at 500-1000 oC (vide infra).

SEM image (16 kx) taken from CKD is shown (Figure 2A) to visualize loose globular particles of sizes ≤2 μm, as well as particle aggregates of larger sizes (up to 6 μm). The corresponding EDX spectrum (Figure 2B) is shown to detect most of the elements expected from Table 1. Analytical data derived therefrom (set out in the table inset underneath) convey relative elemental proportions in line with the XRF-determined proportions (Table 1). EDX probing across the sample could identify CaO-rich particles (Figure 1D and the table underneath), whose SEM image (Figure 1C) finds them to assume warm-like shapes of preferential growth direction, but of non-preferential orientation. Furthermore, these CaO-rich particles are shown to be slightly coalescent and to assume varied lengths in the range 336-678 nm (Figure S1, in online Supplementary Material).

Consequences of heat treatment

Compositional consequences of calcining CKD at 500, 650 and 1000 oC (for 1 h) were identified by means of the XRD powder diffractograms compared in Figure S2, and IR spectra stacked in Figure S3. Figure S2 shows that most of the diffraction peaks given rise by CKD are maintained in the diffractograms of the calcination products, except for a gradual weakening of the diagnosing peak (Si-labeled at 2θ = 26.7o) of SiO2 with increasing temperature till complete disappearance in the diffractogram of CKD-1000. In contrast, the diagnosing peak (S-labeled at 2θ = 25.6o) of CaSO4, though is shown to have varied intensities, remained visible in the diffractogram of CKD-1000. On the other hand, three weak, but distinct, peaks emerged (CS-labeled at 2θ = 32.6, 34.3 and 41.3o) in the diffractogram of CKD-1000. According to the standard data filed in JCPDS file No. 77-0409 [23], these are the three strongest peaks of Ca2SiO4 (Larnite). Formation of Larnite is, most likely, due to a solid state reaction between SiO2 and CaO activated at high temperature (ca. 1000 oC). This may be justified by the observed disappearance of the diagnostic diffraction peak of SiO2 as well as the relative weakening of CaO (Lime) diffraction peaks (Ca-labeled, Figure S2) particularly in the diffractogram of CKD-1000. It is worth noting, that peaks due to KCl (Sylvine) and NaCl (Halite) are still clearly observed in the diffractogram of CKD-1000. In order to better resolve and highlight the described ultimate changes in the mineralogical composition as a consequence of heating, close-up diffractograms of CKD and CKD-1000 are compared in Figure 3.

IR spectra taken from CKD and its calcination products, shown in Figure S3, do not only sustain the XRD-observed compositional consequences of heating CKD, but also reveal changes occurred in its non-crystalline species. This is manifested in (i) the significant weakening and sharpening of the SiO2 (Quartz) absorptions at 1119, 1001, 917, 890 and 841 cm-1 due to its conversion into Ca2SiO4 (Larnite) [25], (ii) the almost complete elimination of the absorptions assignable to Ca(OH)2 and CaCO3 (at 3638, 3422, 1630, 1446, 1423 and 864 cm-1) [24,25], and (iii) the weakening of diagnostic absorptions of CaSO4 (Anhydrite) at 1149, 677, 616 and 597 cm-1. The comparison held in Figure S3 reveals, moreover, that the νOH-absorptions (at 3638 and 3422 cm-1), i.e. those diagnostic of the presence of non-crystalline Ca(OH)2 species, are significantly weakened in the spectrum of CKD-650, whereas those of CaCO3 and CaSO4 are shown, respectively, to be eliminated and weakened but only in the spectrum of CKD-1000. These results may support that the TGA-monitored 0.7 % mass loss at 560-650 oC (Figure 1C) is confined to the decomposition of Ca(OH)2 [24,25], whereas the larger mass loss (ca. 4 %, Table 1) observed at > 750 oC involves the complete decomposition of CaCO3 species as well as a partial elimination of CaSO4.

Exploring morphological consequences of heating was sought by SEM examination of CKD-1000. Image obtained and corresponding EDX microanalysis results are given in Figure S4. The SEM image (Figure S4A) visualizes some remarkable morphological modifications: (i) overall particle thickening and size increase, (ii) formation of particle agglomerates with signs of frozen melts, which are more visible in Figure S4B, and (iii) formation of rod-like particles. The particle size increase and agglomeration are due, expectedly, to enhanced mass transfer at such a high temperature of calcination (1000 oC). The melts are most likely of chlorides of K and Na, which are still there as evidenced in the EDX analytical results (Figure S4C and D). On the other hand, the rod-like particles are presumably formed at the expense of the original warm-like CaO-rich particles of CKD (Figure 2C). This modification might have been influenced as a result of the formation of Ca2SiO4. Compatibly, the EDX analysis results (Figure S4C) brought about much higher proportions for Ca (29.75 %) and Si (8.72 %) than for the other metal components probed (≤4.03 %).

Summing up, the test CKD has been found largely stable to heat treatment at 500 oC. Upon increasing the temperature up to 650 oC, it was freed from minority Ca(OH)2 species via thermal decomposition. At 1000 oC, CKD was freed further from minority CaCO3 species via thermal decomposition, and the SiO2 (Quartz) content of CKD was activated for a solid state reaction with CaO (Lime) whereby it was transformed almost quantitatively into Ca2SiO4 (Larnite). Moreover, the CaSO4 (Anhydrite) content was only partially reduced in magnitude, whereas the chlorides of Na and K commenced to melt but without significant mass loss. Hence, the heat treatment applied could not free CKD from the chloride and sulfate contents, whose presence is known to hamper CKD reuse as a raw material in the clinker production [7].

Consequences of water treatment

Irrespective of the water treatment mode applied (i.e., long-term (LT) or short-term (ST)), and whether the treated material is CKD or its calcination product at 1000 oC (CKD-1000), the yield is two-fold: (i) a crystalline leachate (L), and (ii) a pulverized solid residue (R)).

Long-term processing

The solid residues: XRD diffractograms obtained for the solid residues of long-term water-treated CKD (i.e., CKD(LT/R)) and CKD-1000 (i.e., CKD-1000(LT/R)) are compared to those obtained for the untreated materials in Figure 4. The comparison reveals that the diffractogram of CKD (LT/R) is almost completely void of diagnostic peaks of CaO, SiO2, Fe2O3, KCl and NaCl. It declares, moreover, a weakening of the diagnostic (S-labeled) peak of CaSO4, and the emergence of six new (CC-labeled) peaks (at 2θ= 29.4, 36.0, 39.5, 43.2, 47.6 and 48.50) due to formation of CaCO3 (Calcite, JCPDS 88-1812) [23]. On the other hand, the diffractogram obtained for CKD-1000(LT/R) shows not only the disappearance of peaks of Fe2O3, KCl and NaCl, but also weakening of the peaks of Ca2SiO4 due, most likely, to its gelation into calcium silicate hydrate (CSH) and non-crystalline Ca(OH)2 species [27]. It also monitors peaks of CaCO3 at detectably lower intensities than those monitored in CKD (LT/R), and CaSO4. Consistent results are communicated in the corresponding IR spectra compared in Figure S5. These results are in line with the facts that upon hydrolysis (i) CaO is transformed into Ca(OH)2 (Portlandite), which, in turn, absorbs ambient CO2 to convert into CaCO3 (Calcite) [27], (ii) Ca2SiO4 (Larnite) is readily transformed into Ca(OH)2 (and eventually to CaCO3) and CSH gel [14,27], (iii) KCl and NaCl are readily dissolved in the aqueous medium, and (iv) β-CaSO4 (β-Anhydrite), a high-temperature transformation product of CaSO4, is sparingly soluble in water [27], However, the disappearance of the XRD diagnostic peak (at θ = 26.6o) of SiO2 (Quartz) in the diffractogram of CKD(LT/R) (Figure 4) is due, presumably, to its conversion into non-crystalline CSH species [27].

Morphological consequences of the long-term water treatment of CKD were examined by SEM and EDX microanalysis. SEM image obtained for CKD (LT/R) (Figure 5) resolves three discernible particle morphologies; namely, A-labeled rod-like particles, B-labeled sponge-like particles, and C-labeled cubic-like particles. Neither of these particle morphologies is observable in the SEM images (Figure 2) obtained for CKD before exposure to the water treatment, which are shown to be dominated by CaO-rich warm-like particles, plus loose and aggregated globular particles (Figure 2A). Therefore, it is plausible to relate these new particle morphologies to water-treatment influenced changes to the initial CKD composition, i.e. the formation of CaCO3 at the expense of CaO, and the conversion of quartz-SiO2 into non-crystalline CSH species. EDX microanalysis results obtained for the A-labeled rod-like particles, set out in Table S1, reveal that they are Ca (17.46 %) and C (16.87 %) enriched. Hence, the rod-like particles are most probably due to CaCO3. EDX results obtained for the B-labeled sponge-like particles (Table S2) reveal further Ca (23.26 %) and C (21.37 %) enrichment, as well as Si (3.76 %) enrichment, which may help relating the sponge-like morphology to non-crystalline domains dwelling CSH species. In contrast, Table S3 indicates that the C-labeled cubic-like particles are distinct by the highest proportion of Fe (28. 17 %), which may help suggesting that they contain non-crystalline FeO(OH)x species.

The leachate crystals: It is obvious from the XRD diffractogram exhibited in Figure 6, that the CKD leachate (i.e., CKD(LT/L) is composed of crystalline salts of CaCO3 (Calcite), KCl (Sylvine) and NaCl (Hallite). The corresponding IR spectrum is shown (Figure 7) to be dominated by diagnostic absorptions (at 2518, 1800, 1430, 869 and 713 cm-1) of CaCO3 (Calcite) [24], since KCl and NaCl bond vibrations are observable only <400 cm-1 [24]. The broad absorption centered around 3465 cm-1 is indicative of the presence of hydrogen-bonded OH-groups of retained water molecules. Whereas the shoulder at 1163 cm-1 and the tiny, but distinct, peak at 605 cm-1, which are assignable to S-O vibrations [24], may imply the presence of non-crystalline calcium sulfate species. The failure of EDX spectroscopy to detect Na, K and Cl in the solid residue CKD(LT/R) (Tables S1-S3) may evidence their almost complete leaching out under the long-term water treatment conditions applied. The subsequent slow natural evaporation of the water at RT (completed in 14 days) must have furnished the necessary conditions for crystal growth of KCl and NaCl. On the other hand, the presence of Calcite large crystals in the leachate (CKD(LT/L)), and microcrystallites in the solid residue CKD(LT/R) (Figure 4), should have occurred via one-and-the-same formation course: CaO(s) + H2O(l) = Ca(OH)2 + ambient CO2(g) = CaCO3(s) + H2O(l) [27]. Unlike the complete leaching out of the elements of KCl and NaCl from CKD, the much larger proportion of CaO has rendered its leaching out incomplete under the water treatment conditions applied. It is worth mentioning, that subjecting CKD-1000 to the same long-term water treatment resulted in leachate crystals of Calcite only (Figure S6). The corresponding SEM and EDX analysis results (Figure S7) disclose the presence in the leachate (CKD-1000(LT/L) of detectable amounts of non-crystalline KCl and NaCl species. This may imply that their melting in CKD-1000 (Figure S4) may have rendered them sparingly soluble in water, thus rendering their soluble concentrations far less than the necessary saturation level for crystallization.

Short-term processing

Shortening the soaking period of CKD particles in water (1 g/40 mL) to 15 min (instead of 14 days), the dried filtrate (CKD(ST/L)) and soild residue (CKD(ST/R) exhibited the XRD diffractograms compared in Figure S8. The comparison reveals that the leachate crystals formed were of CaCO3 (Calcite), NaCl (Hallite) and KCl (Sylvine), as well as CaSO4.2H2O (Gypsum, JCPDS 06-0047)) [23]. On the other hand, the solid residue is shown to be still majored by microcrystallites of CaO (Lime), but minored by microcrystallites of CaCO3 (Calcite). In contrast, none of the diffraction peaks of NaCl and KCl are monitored in the XRD diffractogram of the solid residue CKD(ST/R) (Figure S8). SEM and EDX analysis results (Figure S9) obtained for CKD(ST/R) resolve, according to Peethmparan et al. [14], the co-existence of non-crystalline aggregates of Ca(OH)2 and CSH species. Accordingly, the short soaking period of CKD particles in water facilitates leaching out most of the KCl, NaCl and CaSO4 contents of CKD, and help leaching but a small proportion of its initially high content of CaO. These results, together with the detection of non-crystalline Ca(OH)2 in the residue, may suggest that the hydration, and subsequent carbonation, of CaO are slow processes; hence, their completion require long CKD/water contact time.

Conclusion

The above presented and discussed results may help drawing the following conclusions, which are further graphically summarized in Figure S10:

1. CKD composition is stable to heating (in air) up to 500 oC. It is freed from minority Ca(OH)2 species via thermal decomposition at 650 oC. At 1000 oC, it is further freed from minority CaCO3 species via thermal decomposition, the SiO2 (Quartz) content is activated for a solid state reaction with CaO (Lime) whereby it is transformed almost quantitatively into Ca2SiO4 (Larnite). Moreover, the CaSO4 (Anhydrite) content was only partially eliminated, whereas the chlorides of Na and K commenced to melt but without significant mass loss. 2. Hence, the heat treatment up to 1000 oC cannot free CKD from the chloride and sulfate contents, whose presence is known to hamper the CKD reuse as a raw material in the clinker production. 3. The chloride and sulfate contents are, however, leached out almost completely while soaking CKD particles in water (1g/40 mL) with stirring for as short as 15 min. Meanwhile, the CaO content is partially hydrated into Ca(OH)2, which is carbonated (via acid-base interaction with ambient CO2 molecules) to yield CaCO3 both in the aqueous and solid residue. Moreover, the Quartz- SiO2 and Hematite-Fe2O3 contents are hydrolyzed into non-crystalline species. 4. The hydration and carbonation processes of the CaO content are slow and, therefore, require a longer CKD/water contact time to be completed. 5. The slow evaporation of water (under ambient conditions) from the aqueous leachate results in the formation of visibly large flake-like aggregates of crystals of CaCO3 (Calcite), CaSO4.2H2O (Gypsum), KCl (Sylvine) and NaCl (Halite). 6. Hence, a 15-min stirring of CKD in water (1g/40 mL) is sufficient to bring down its chloride and sulfate salt content to <6 %, which renders possible the reusing of CKD as a raw material in the clinker manufacturing, thereby minimizing its environmental hazards.

Conflict of interest

We declare that we do not have any commercial or associative conflict of interest in connection with the present work.

Acknowledgment

We acknowledge with appreciation a donation from the Alexander von Humboldt-Foundation (Bonn) that made possible the purchase of the FT-IR spectrophotometer.

Supplementary Material
8Maslehuddin M, Al-Amoudi OSB, Rahman MK, Ali M, Barry M (2009)Properties of cement kiln dust concrete. Constr Build Mater 23: 2357-61.
17Abdel-Gawwad HA, Heikal M, Mohamed MS, Abd El-Aleem S, Hassan HS, et al. (2019)Sustainable disposal of cement kiln dust in the production of cementitious materials. J Cleaner Prod 232: 1218-29.
23International Center for Diffraction Data (2018)Campus Boulevard, Newton Square, PA, USA.
27El-Didamony H, Heikal M, Khalil KhA, El-Sanhory A (2017) Pozzolanic activity of silica fume with lime. J Basic Environ Sci 4: 236-46.

Tables at a glance
Table 1
Table 2
Table 3
Table 4
Table 5
Table 6
Table 7
Table 8
Table 9
Table 10
Figures at a glance
Figure 1
Figure 2
Figure 3
Figure 4
Figure 1: (A) XRD diffractogram; (B) IR spectrum; and (C) TGA/DTA curves obtained for the as-obtained CKD
Figure 2: SEM images (A and C) and EDX spectra (B and D) obtained for CKD. Tables underneath set out analytical results derived from the EDX spectrum above each
Figure 3: XRD diffractograms obtained for CKD and its calcination product at 1000 oC for 1 h (CKD-1000)
Figure 4: XRD diffractograms obtained for long-term water treatment solid residues of CKD (i.e., CKD(LT/R)) and CKD-1000 (i.e., CKD-1000(LT/R)). The diffractograms of the untreated CKD and CKD-1000 are inset for comparison purposes
Figure 5: SEM image obtained for CKD(LT/R). Encircled are the different morphologies observed: (A) rod-like particles; (B) sponge-like particles; and (C) cubic-like particles. Corresponding EDAX analysis results are set out in Tables S1, S2 and S3, respectively
Figure 6: X-ray diffractogram obtained for the leachate of CKD after long-term water treatment, i.e. CKD(LT/L)
Figure 7: IR spectrum obtained for CKD(LT/L)

Parameter

Estimated Value

Source

Labour

1 Plant Manager
1 Maintenance Technician
1 Office Clerk
1 Shredder Operator (× 3 Shifts)
1 Microwave Polymiser Operator (× 3 Shifts)
1 Truck & Front Loader (× 3 Shifts)
2 Labourer (× 3 Shifts)

 

Maintenance

11% of Major Equipment Cost

Levy & Carley, 1989

Taxes/Insurance

2% of Major Equipment Cost

Aden et al. 2002

Table 1: Economic assumptions for fixed operating costs

Parameter

Estimated Value

Source

Financing

100% Equity

 

Discount Rate

10%

Swanson et al. 2010

Internal Rate of Return

10%

Towler & Sinnott, 2013

Plant Lifetime Period

20 years

Edwards, 2016

Plant Availability

310 days per year (85%)

Edwards, 2016

Table 2: Main economic assumptions for feasibility of the plant

Parameter

Estimated     Value

 Source

Major equipment: E4000T Tyre Shredding System

 8,622,900

 Quotation

Minor equipment: Tipper Truck
 Front Loader
 Weighbridge

 520,000
 820,800
 513,000

 “

Installation Costs

 3,143,010

 

Contingency Costs

 1,361,971

 

Fixed Capital Investment

 14,981,681

 

Working Capital

 2,247,252

 

Total Capital Investment

 17,228,933

 

Table 3: Estimated capital investment costs for the shredding phase (ZAR)

Parameter

Estimated Value

Labour 1 Plant Manager
 1 Office Clerk
 1 Maintenance Technician
 1 Shredder Operator/Shift (× 3 Shifts)
 1 Truck/Loader Driver/Shift (× 3 Shifts)
 2 Labourers/Shift (× 3 Shifts)

500,000
 60,000
 60,000
480,000 (@ 160,000 per operator)
180,000 (@ 60,000 per driver)
240,000 (@ 40,000 per labourer)

Maintenance

1,152,437

Taxes/Insurance

 209,534

Total Fixed Operating Cost

2,881,971

Table 4: Estimated fixed operating costs for the shredding phase (ZAR)

Parameter

Estimated Value

Major equipment: EWS Model TR-1500 system

 100,000,000

Installation Costs

 30,000,000

Contingency Costs

 13,000,000

Fixed Capital Investment

 143,000,000

Working Capital

 21,450,000

Total Capital Investment

 164,450,000

Table 5: Estimated capital investment costs for the reverse polymerization phase (ZAR)

Parameter

Estimated Value

Labour 1 Lab Technician
 1 Shredder Operator/Shift (× 3 Shifts)
 2 Labourers/Shift (× 3 Shifts)

 60,000
180,000 (@ 60,000 per driver)
240,000 (@ 40,000 per labourer)

Maintenance

 11,000,000

Taxes/Insurance

 2,000,000

Total Fixed Operating Cost

 13,480,000

Table 6: Estimated fixed operating costs for the reverse polymerization phase (ZAR)

Parameter

Shredding

Microwave Polymerisation

Combined

Total Capital Investment

 17,228,933

 164,450,000

 181,678,933

Fixed Operating Costs

 2,881,971

 13,480,000

 16,361,971

Variable Operating Costs

 1,771,200

 8,114,064

 9,885,264

Investment Cost

 

 

207,926,168

Table 7: Estimated investment costs for the combined units of the tyre recycling plant (ZAR)

Product

Quantity
(Ton/yr)

Unit Price
(ZAR)

Total Amount

Carbon Black

1,023 tons/year

10,664

10,909,272

Oil

4,650,744 gallons/year

7.91

36,787,385

Steel

334.8 tons/year

466.55

156,200

Total

 

 

47,852,857

Table 8: Estimated total revenue per year

Parameter

Estimated Value

Payback Period

 5 years

Net Present Value

 R 225, 714,128

Internal Rate of Return

 12%

Table 9: Economic performance of the tyre recycling plant

Index

Base case value

Investment Cost

 R 207,926,168

Annual Average Revenue

 R 47,852,857

Payback Period

 5 years

Internal Rate of Revenue

 12%

Table 10: Base case values of indices for sensitivity analysis