Idolatry and Representation: The Philosophy of Franz Rosenzweig Reconsidered

Leora Batnitzky

Published by Princeton University Press 2000

Idolatry and Representation

The Philosophy of Franz Rosenzweig Reconsidered

Leora Batnitzky

https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400823581

Overview
Contents

About this book

Although Franz Rosenzweig is arguably the most important Jewish philosopher of the twentieth century, his thought remains little understood. Here, Leora Batnitzky argues that Rosenzweig's redirection of German-Jewish ethical monotheism anticipates and challenges contemporary trends in religious studies, ethics, philosophy, anthropology, theology, and biblical studies.

This text, which captures the hermeneutical movement of Rosenzweig's corpus, is the first to consider the full import of the cultural criticism articulated in his writings on the modern meanings of art, language, ethics, and national identity. In the process, the book solves significant conundrums about Rosenzweig's relation to German idealism, to other major Jewish thinkers, to Jewish political life, and to Christianity, and brings Rosenzweig into conversation with key contemporary thinkers.

Drawing on Rosenzweig's view that Judaism's ban on idolatry is the crucial intellectual and spiritual resource available to respond to the social implications of human finitude, Batnitzky interrogates idolatry as a modern possibility. Her analysis speaks not only to the question of Judaism's relationship to modernity (and vice versa), but also to the generic question of the present's relationship to the past--a subject of great importance to anyone contemplating the modern statuses of religious tradition, reason, science, and historical inquiry. By way of Rosenzweig, Batnitzky argues that contemporary philosophers and ethicists must relearn their approaches to religious traditions and texts to address today's central ethical problems.

Author / Editor information

Leora Batnitzky is Assistant Professor of Religion at Princeton University.

Reviews

"This illuminating study offers new, indeed daringly novel, hermeneutical strategies of reading the often exasperatingly complex writings of Franz Rosenzweig, arguably the most towering figure of twentieth-century Jewish thought. By identifying his critique of idolatry—characterized by an improper relation to God—to be the subtext informing Rosenzweig's religious vision, Batnitzky not only allows us to unravel his arguments, but also offers a rich array of insights into the religious condition of contemporary Judaism."—Paul Mendes-Flohr, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

"Leora Batnitzky is one of the up-and-coming stars in contemporary Jewish philosophy and the philosophy of religion, and this book shows why. The book displays careful, comprehensive scholarship in modern and contemporary Jewish, Christian, and general theology and philosophy. It is a creative, constructive project that displays for our use previously under-seen patterns of hermeneutical and ethical thinking in one of the greatest twentieth-century Jewish figures. It is an urgent book that addresses with academic rigor issues of significant ethical-philosophic import on the border between academe and broader social life."—Peter Ochs, University of Virginia

This is not only a thorough and innovative study of Franz Rosenzweig's often dazzlingly complex philosophy but also a pathbreaking analysis of Rosenzweig's contribution to contemporary Jewish as well as Christian theologies. . . . This book will set the standard for future scholarship on both Rosenzweig and Christian-Jewish dialogue.---Michael Mack, Journal of Religion

This is not only a thorough and innovative study of Franz Rosenzweig's often dazzlingly complex philosophy but also a pathbreaking analysis of Rosenzweig's contribution to contemporary Jewish as well as Christian theologies. This will set the standard for future scholarship on both Rosenzweig and Christian-Jewish dialogue.---Michael Mack, Journal of Religion

"In Idolatry and Representation, Rosenzweig has found a commentator who has fully absorbed the implications of his fundamental insight, that ethics cannot be separated from logic and aesthetics, that our capacities to stand in for our neighbor, to be there for him or her, are deeply connected to our theories of representation, however explicit they may be. This book, written with philosophical lucidity and moral intensity, will orient discussions of German-Jewish thought for years to come."—Eric Santner, University of Chicago

"For a postliberal Christian theologian, reading Batnitzky on Rosenzweig is an unalloyed joy. He is, in her interpretation, the kind of Jewish conversation partner Christians need—a partner who is both more critical of Christianity and also Jewishly self-critical than has been previously supposed. The book contributes greatly to a welcome turn in Jewish-Christian dialogue which is now in progress."—George Lindbeck, Yale University

Topics

Frontmatter Publicly Available Download PDF	i
Contents Publicly Available Download PDF	vii
Acknowledgments Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	ix
Introduction. Reconsidering Rosenzweig and Modern Conceptions of Idolatry Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	1
PA RT I : ETHICS AND MONOTHEISM
One. The Eradication of Alien Worship: Rosenzweig as Ethical Monotheist Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	17
Two. Miracles and Martyrs, Ethics and Hermeneutics: Idolatry from Mendelssohn to Rosenzweig Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	32
Three. The Philosophical Import of Carnal Israel: Hermeneutics and the Structure of Rosenzweig’s The Star of Redemption Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	62
PART II : ART AND LANGUAGE
Four Risky Images: Rosenzweig’s Aesthetic Theory and Jewish Uncanniness Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	83
Five The Problem of Translation: Risking the Present for the Sake of the Past Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	105
PART III: RELIGIONAND POLITICS
Six. Risking Religion: Christian Idolatry Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	145
Seven. Risking Politics: Jewish Idolatry Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	169
Eight. After Israel: Rosenzweig’s Philosophy of Risk Reconsidered Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	188
Conclusion. The Future of Monotheism Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	207
Notes Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	227
Index Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	273

(Deutsch)