Abstract
Since 1991, Measurement Science and Technology has awarded a Best Paper prize. The Editorial Board of this journal believes that such a prize is an opportunity to thank authors for submitting their work, and serves as an integral part of the on-going quality review of the journal.
The current breadth of topical areas that are covered by MST has made it advisable to expand the recognition of excellent publications. Hence, since 2005 the Editorial Board have presented 'Outstanding Paper Awards'. This year awards were presented in the areas of 'Measurement Science' and 'Fluid Mechanics'. Although the categories mirror subject sections in the journal, the Editorial Board consider articles from all categories in the selection process.
2012 Award Winners—Measurement Science
Physical characterization and performance evaluation of an x-ray micro-computed tomography system for dimensional metrology applications J Hiller1, M Maisl2 and L M Reindl31 Department of Mechanical Engineering, Technical University of Denmark (DTU), Produktionstorvet, Building 425, 2800 Kgs Lyngby, Denmark 2 Development Center for X-Ray Technology (EZRT), Fraunhofer Institute for Non-Destructive Testing (IZFP), Campus E3 1, 66123 Saarbrücken, Germany 3 Laboratory for Electrical Instrumentation, Institute for Microsystem Technology (IMTEK), University of Freiburg, Georges-Köhler-Allee 103, 79110 Freiburg, Germany
This year's award goes to another paper [1] dealing with micro-measurements, using a scientific measurement technique that is both old and traditional. However, it is the advent of modern technology with computational techniques that have offered new insights into the capability of the measurement method. The paper describes an x-ray computed tomography (CT) system. Such systems are increasingly used in production engineering, where non-destructive measurements of the internal geometries of workpieces can be made with high information density. CT offers important alternatives to tactile or optical measurement systems which sometimes cannot reach internal features.
The subject discussed is very important for measurement science. It is concerned with the many factors that affect precision and accuracy in CT metrology. These include issues in the scanning and reconstruction process, the image processing, and the 3D data evaluation. They all influence the dimensional measurement properties of the system as a whole. Therefore, as the authors point out, it is important to know what leads to, and what are the consequences of, such things as experimental geometrical misalignment of the scanner system, or image unsharpness (blurring), or noise or image artefacts. This paper is therefore directed at the implementation of a modern CT system, identifying what is important with implementation of the technique, and what are the likely sources of systematic and random error.
After a useful introduction, the paper carefully describes a 3D micro-CT system developed at the Fraunhofer Institute for Non-Destructive Testing in Saarbrücken, Germany, to carry out dimensional measurements on small plastic and metal parts. Considerable emphasis is placed on the characterization of the x-ray tube, with discussion about the effective focal spot size and focus drift. Likewise, there is a detailed account of the flat-panel detector, before examining the contrast and noise transfer properties in the measuring volume. These features are important for achieving short term accuracy, whilst a later section discusses temperature measurements that affect long term accuracy. As a consequence, the image sharpness, noise or image artefacts, are evaluated. In a simple example, the length measurement property of the scanner for a given set of scanning parameters was obtained by using a calibrated ball-bar with a reference length of 8.7678 mm. Two different approaches for systematic error compensation were applied. They obtained an expanded measurement uncertainty of 6.9 µm down to 1.0 µm, which confirms the excellent dimensional measurement that can be achieved with a micro-CT scanner.
The paper concludes with a useful summary of their characterization and performance studies. It also sets down possible future research activities in CT metrology. In particular, it identifies the need for development of CT scanning planning strategies to reduce measurement uncertainties in general and to minimize user influence in particular.
This paper is excellent in its presentation and scientific description. Issues have been clearly described, and the paper should help establish x-ray micro-computed CT as a fully accepted measuring system in manufacturing engineering. Its contents were supported by 66 references. This helps to put the contribution into context with contributions from previous research papers. The nomination for this paper was supported by seven panel members, higher than any other paper, and it was rated as excellent during the refereeing process.
2012 Award Winners—Fluid Mechanics
Polynomial element velocimetry (PEV): a technique for continuous in-plane velocity and velocity gradient measurements for low Reynolds number flows C R Samarage1,2, J Carberry2, G J Sheard2 and A Fouras1,21 Laboratory for Dynamic Imaging, Monash University, Melbourne, VIC 3800, Australia 2 Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Monash University, Melbourne, VIC 3800, Australia
The technique proposed in this article [2] is highly relevant to the wide community of experimentalists that make use of particle image velocimetry. The authors have addressed the issue of how to accurately measure the velocity field and the velocity gradient distribution.
The method proposed is elegant and innovative in that it introduces polynomial base functions to represent the spatially varying velocity field within an 'element'. The working principle is clearly described and illustrated. It is noted that the authors have taken a modest position by limiting their conclusions to the case of low Reynolds number flows. It is expected that further developments of this work could lead to successful applications at higher Reynolds numbers and turbulent flows.
For the cases analyzed in this work, the authors have achieved a significant improvement in describing the velocity and the vorticity in proximity of the wall. Lastly, the authors have discussed with an open attitude the possible shortcomings of the method. They have indicated the points that will deserve attention when further research efforts are dedicated to the topic.
Given the above considerations, the MST outstanding paper selection committee for measurements in fluids, chaired by Professor John Foss, has nominated this article for the MST 2012 outstanding paper award.
The chairmen would like to thank the authors for choosing to publish their work in Measurement Science and Technology, and hope that other researchers enjoy reading these works and feel encouraged to submit their own best work to the journal.
References
[1] Hiller J, Maisl M and Reindl L M 2012 Physical characterization and performance evaluation of an x-ray micro-computed tomography system for dimensional metrology applications Meas. Sci. Technol. 23 085404 (18pp)
[2] Samarage C R, Carberry J, Sheard G J and Fouras A 2012 Polynomial element velocimetry (PEV): a technique for continuous in-plane velocity and velocity gradient measurements for low Reynolds number flows Meas. Sci. Technol. 23 105304 (16pp)