Paper

Photometric analysis and evolutionary stages of the contact binary V2790 Ori

and

© National Astronomical Observatories, CAS and IOP Publishing Ltd.
, , Citation Wichean Kriwattanawong and Kriangsak Kriwattanawong 2019 Res. Astron. Astrophys. 19 143 DOI 10.1088/1674-4527/19/10/143

1674-4527/19/10/143

Abstract

A photometric analysis and evolutionary stages of the contact binary V2790 Ori are presented. The BVRC observations were carried out at the Thai National Observatory. The photometric light curves were fitted to provide fundamental parameters, required to examine evolutionary stages of the binary. The results indicate that V2790 Ori is a W-type contact system with a mass ratio of q = 2.932. The orbital period increase is found at a rate of dP/dt = 1.03 × 10−7 d yr−1. This implies that a rate of mass transfer from the secondary component to the primary one is dm2/dt = 6.31 × 10−8 M yr−1. Furthermore, we find that from the detached phase to the contact phase, the amount of mass that the evolved secondary component has lost is 1.188±0.110 M, i.e., mass lost by the system is 0.789±0.073 M and mass transfer to the primary is 0.399±0.037 M. Since the time of the first overflow, the angular momentum loss is found to be 72.2% of JFOF, causing the orbit and Roche surface to shrink until the present time.

Export citation and abstract BibTeX RIS

1. Introduction

Contact binaries are believed to have been formed from detached systems by evolutionary expansion of the components or angular momentum loss (AML) due to magnetic breaking (e.g., Vilhu 1981; Rucinski 1986; Jiang et al. 2014). Demircan et al. (2006) provided evidence of decreasing rates in angular momentum, systematic mass and orbital period from a sample of 114 detached systems, derived from their kinematics. However, the evolution is controlled not only by the AML but also bymass loss andmass transfer between the components (e.g., Yakut & Eggleton 2005; Eker et al. 2008). The evolution is driven by a slow expansion of the progenitor of the secondary component (the evolved component near or after the terminal age main sequence), followed by mass transfer to the other component, accompanied by AML due to stellar winds and mass loss. The components of close detached binaries approach each other to form contact binaries. The continuous AML and mass loss can bring the components closer together, yielding a smaller orbit and shrinking the Roche surface (e.g., Vilhu 1981; Iben & Tutukov 1984; Tutukov et al. 2004; Gazeas & Stȩpień 2008; Stȩpień & Gazeas 2012).

V2790 Ori [R.A.(J2000.0) = 06h15m31.40s, Dec.(J2000.0) = + 19° 3522.1] is a contact binary, found in the Northern Sky Variability Survey (NSVS). Its orbital period was firstly reported by Otero et al. (2004) to be 0.287842 d with a primary minimum at HJD 2451521.695. Two years later, Ammons et al. (2006) contributed the effective temperature of V2790 Ori to be 5643K. Furthermore, two recent values of the effective temperature of 5713K and 5576K were cataloged by McDonald et al. (2017) and Oelkers et al. (2018), respectively. The average value was calculated to be about 5644K.

This work presents a photometric analysis and evolutionary stages of the contact binary V2790 Ori. The BVRC photometric observations are described in Section 2. Section 3 presents an analysis of a period change. Section 4 explains the results of the light curve fit. Section 5 describes the evolutionary stages, includingmass change throughout its evolution from the detached phase to the contact phase and orbital evolution by AML from the time of the first overflow(FOF) to the present time. Finally, the main results are summarized in Section 6.

2. Observations

V2790 Ori was observed with the 0.5 m reflecting telescope, operated by Thai National Observatory, Chiang Mai, during three nights in 2015 (January 21–23). An Andor iKon-L-936 CCD camera was equipped on the telescope. Total integration times were 120 s for B band and 60 s for V and RC bands. We obtained a total of 699 individual observations for the three filter bands. The BVRC differential magnitudes of the binary were measured using TYC 1322-1399-1 [R.A.(J2000.0) = 06h15m19.52s, Dec.(J2000.0) = +19°37'07.6''] and TYC 1322–1411–1 [ R.A.(J2000.0) = 06h15m05.39s, Dec.(J2000.0) = +19°40'43.3''] as comparison and check stars, respectively. The observed magnitudes cover light curves with five minimum light times as shown in Table 1. The tricolor light curves vary about 0.64, 0.59 and 0.56 mag, for the B, V and RC bands, respectively. Max II is found to be slightly brighter than Max I.

Table 1. Times of Minimum Light for V2790 Ori

HJD (1) Min (2) Ref. (3) Epoch (4) (OC) (5)
2451521.6950 I [1]    
2453327.7560 II [2]    
2455520.8205 II [3] –5291.5 0.0005
2455532.9103 II [2] –5249.5 0.0009
2455604.2950 II [4] –5001.5 0.0009
2455632.3597 I [4] –4904.0 0.0010
2455644.3050 II [4] –4862.5 0.0009
2455896.8827 I [5] –3985.0 –0.0026
2455902.7850 II [6] –3964.5 –0.0011
2455959.3466 I [7] –3768.0 –0.0004
2456288.0610 I [8] –2626.0 –0.0013
2456288.2045 II [8] –2625.5 –0.0018
2456623.1092 I [9] –1462.0 –0.0010
2456623.2547 II [9] –1461.5 0.0006
2457041.6326 I [10] –8.0 0.0004
2457041.7767 II [10] –7.5 0.0006
2457042.6403 II [10] –4.5 0.0007
2457042.7836 I [10] –4.0 0.0000
2457044.0792 II [11] 0.5 0.0004
2457045.0865 I [11] 4.0 0.0002
2457045.2306 II [11] 4.5 0.0004
2457046.0942 II [11] 7.5 0.0005
2457046.2377 I [11] 8.0 0.0000
2457048.6848 II [10] 16.5 0.0005
2457048.8286 I [10] 17.0 0.0004
2457049.6919 I [10] 20.0 0.0001
2457049.8362 II [10] 20.5 0.0005
2457050.6995 II [10] 23.5 0.0003
2457050.8432 I [10] 24.0 0.0001
2457064.3746 I [12] 71.0 0.0029
2457345.7361 II [10] 1048.5 –0.0010
2457345.8798 I [10] 1049.0 –0.0012
2457346.7434 I [10] 1052.0 –0.0011
2457346.8876 II [10] 1052.5 –0.0008
2457384.0202 II [13] 1181.5 0.0002
2457384.1636 I [13] 1182.0 –0.0003

Notes: Column (1): HJD at light minimum. Col. (2): types of minimum. Col. (3): references for the sources are as follows:

[1]Otero et al. (2004); [2]Diethelm (2011); [3]Nelson (2011); [4]Nagai (2012); [5]Diethelm (2012); [6]Nelson (2012); [7]Hubscher (2013); [8]Nagai (2013); [9]Nagai (2014); [10]Michaels (2016); [11]This study; [12]Juryšek et al. (2017); [13]Nagai (2016). Col. (4): epoch. Col. (5): (OC).

3. Period Analysis

The first estimate of orbital period for the contact binary V2790 Ori was provided by Otero et al. (2004). Until the present day, 36 eclipse timings, including this work, are available as listed in Table 1. Since the first two times are too far from the others, the last 34 times were used to calculate the orbital period as shown in Equation (1). The revised period is found to be 0.2878418d.

Equation (1)

Equation (2)

With the above ephemeris, a least squares method was used to fit the (OC) residuals as shown in Equation (2). The (OC) fit yields an upward quadratic curve as displayed in Figure 1. This can be interpreted as the orbital period increase at a rate of dP/dt = 1.03 × 10−7 d yr−1.

Fig. 1

Fig. 1 (OC) curve (upper) and the corresponding residuals (lower) for V2790 Ori.

Standard image

4. Light Curve Fit

An analysis of the tricolor light curves for V2790 Ori was done by using the 2013 version of the Wilson-Devinney (W-D) code (Wilson & Devinney 1971; Wilson 1979, 2012; Wilson et al. 2010). According to three available published values of effective temperature, as mentioned in Section 1, the average value of 5644K was assigned to fix the temperature of star 2, T2. The adjustable parameters (the mass ratio, q; the effective temperature of star 1, T1; the surface potential of the components, Ω1 = Ω2; the orbital inclination, i; and the monochromatic luminosities of star 1, L1) were applied to the W-D fit. A spot was added on star 1. A q-search procedure was iterated over a wide range of mass ratio to minimize sum of squared residuals ΣW(OC)2. A good fit is found at about q ∼ 3 as illustrated in Figure 2. With more precise iterations, the minimum value of ΣW(OC)2 is obtained at q = 2.932±0.002. The results show that V2790 Ori is a W-type contact binary. Contact configuration of the system is not very deep with a fill-out factor of 20.89±1.03%. A total eclipse is confirmed by the orbital inclination of 85.1°. The derived temperature ratio of T2/T1 is 0.964. A cool spot on star 1 can explain the asymmetric light maxima, well-known as the O'Connell effect. This effect was also similarly found to be evidence of star-spot activities on one component or both components in many W-type contact systems such as V789 Her (Li et al. 2018), V474 Cam (Guo et al. 2018), RW Dor (Sarotsakulchai et al. 2019) and TY UMa (Li et al. 2015). The fitted light curves are depicted in Figure 3. The main parameters are listed in Table 2, and compared with those from a previous work (Michaels 2016). The mass ratio and fill-out factor in this study are not very different from those in the previous work. The other parameters are nearly the same, except the effective temperatures, due to the value of T2 being fixed with different assumptions and source data. However, the temperature ratio is still the same.

Fig. 2

Fig. 2 q-search values for V2790 Ori.

Standard image
Fig. 3

Fig. 3 Observed light curves in B (circles), V (squares) and RC (triangles) filter bands and theoretical light curves (solid lines) versus orbital phase of V2790 Ori.

Standard image

Table 2. Photometric Parameters for V2790 Ori

Parameters MICH16 This study
q 3.157(±0.008) 2.932(±0.002)
T1(K) 5620(±3) 5856(±9)
T2(K) 5471 5644
i (°) 84.15(±0.20) 85.1(±0.2)
Ω1 = Ω2 6.732(±0.010) 6.397(±0.007)
L1B/(L1B + L2B) - 0.3229(±0.0010)
L1V/(L1V + L2V) - 0.3106(±0.0007)
L1Rc/(L1R + L2Rc) - 0.3048(±0.0006)
L1g'/(L1g' + L2g' 0.2966(±0.0007) -
L1r'/(L1r' + L2r' 0.2867(±0.0005) -
L1i'/(L1i' + L2i') 0.2830(±0.0005) -
r1 (pole) - 0.2798(±0.0009)
r1 (side) - 0.2929(±0.0011)
r1 (back) - 0.3330(±0.0021)
r2 (pole) - 0.4544(±0.0007)
r2 (side) - 0.4891(±0.0010)
r2 (back) - 0.5182(±0.0013)
f(%) 15 20.89(±1.03)
ΣW(OC)2 0.0056 0.0035
Spot 1 on star 1 Hot spot Cool spot
Spot Colatitude (°) 105(±5) 37(±3)
Spot Longitude (°) 10(±3) 264(±4)
Spot Radius (°) 14(±4) 26(±2)
Temperature Factor 1.16(±0.05) 0.90(±0.03)
Spot 2 on star 2 Cool spot  
Spot Colatitude (°) 78(±4) -
Spot Longitude (°) 2(±1) -
Spot Radius (°) 12(±4) -
Temperature Factor 0.90(±0.05) -

5. Evolutionary Stages

5.1. Mass Change

To understand the evolutionary status of this contact binary, we first calculated masses of both components using correlations between mass, orbital period and mass ratio (Gazeas 2009). We find that M1 = 0.348±0.038 M and M2 = 1.020±0.112 M for the secondary and primary components, respectively. According to the orbital period increase with a rate of dP/dt = 1.03 × 10−7 d yr−1, described in Section 3, a mass transfer rate from the less massive hotter component to the other one can be estimated using Equation (3) (Singh & Chaubey 1986; Pribulla 1998). The mass transfer rate is obtained to be dM2/dt = 6.31 × 10−8 M yr−1.

Equation (3)

Some W-type contact systems with increasing orbital period were collected to compare the value of dP/dt as listed in Table 3. The period increasing rate for V2790 Ori is found to be a typical value with respect to other W-type systems.

Table 3. W-type Contact Systems with Increasing Orbital Period

Contact Systems P (d) q i (°) f(%) T1(K) T2(K) dP/dt (d yr−1) Ref.*
AA UMa 0.4681266 1.819 80.3 14.8 5965 5929 4.70 × 10−8 [1]
AB And 0.3318911 1.786 83.2 25.2 5888 5495 1.46 × 10−7 [2]
AH Vir 0.4075243 3.317 86.5 24.0 5671 5300 2.19 × 10−7 [3]
FI Boo 0.3899980 2.680 38.1 50.2 5746 5420 1.65 × 10−7 [4]
TX Cnc 0.3828832 2.220 62.1 24.8 6537 6250 3.70 × 10−8 [5]
TY Uma 0.3545481 2.523 84.9 13.4 6250 6229 5.18 × 10−7 [6]
UX Eri 0.4452823 2.681 76.9 14.0 6100 6046 7.70 × 10−8 [7]
V728 Her 0.4712901 5.607 69.2 71.0 6787 6622 3.79 × 10−7 [8]
V1191 Cyg 0.3133888 9.360 80.8 57.9 6375 6215 3.13 × 10−6 [9]
V2790 Ori 0.2878418 2.932 85.1 21.6 5856 5644 1.03 × 10−7 [10]

*References for the sources are as follows: [1]Lee et al. (2011); [2]Li et al. (2014); [3]Chen et al. (2015); [4]Christopoulou & Papageorgiou (2013); [5]Zhang et al. (2009); [6]Li et al. (2015); [7]Qian et al. (2007); [8]Yu et al. (2016); [9]Ostadnezhad et al. (2014); [10]This study.

The photometric parameters in Section 4 are used to calculate radii and luminosities of the components, and the semimajor axis of the orbit, which are derived to be R1 = 0.613±0.018 R, R2 = 0.991±0.029 R, L1 = 0.396±0.016 L, L2 = 0.892±0.036 L and a = 2.036±0.059 R, respectively. Masses of both components in the study are slightly greater than values in Michaels (2016)'s work because of the different method of calculations. In this study, we applied the three-dimensional correlations of physical parameters provided by Gazeas (2009), while Michaels (2016) employed the mass-period relation supplied by Qian (2003). Accordingly, our values of R1, R2, L1, L2 and a are slightly greater than values in the previous work as listed in Table 4.

Table 4. Absolute Parameters for V2790 Ori

Parameters Michaels (2016) This study
M1 (M) 0.30 0.348±0.038
M2 (M) 0.96 1.020±0.112
R1 (R) 0.58 0.613±0.018
R2 (R) 0.97 0.991±0.029
L1 (L) 0.28 0.396±0.016
L2 (L) 0.68 0.892±0.036
a (R) 1.98 2.036±0.059
ρ1 (g cm−3) 2.17 2.121±0.259
ρ2 (g cm−3) 1.46 1.474±0.179
log g1 (cm s−2) 4.39 4.406±0.051
log g2 (cm s−2) 4.44 4.456±0.051

The mass–luminosity and mass–radius diagrams in Figure 4 are plotted to compare evolutionary status for both components of V2790 Ori with the zero age main sequence (ZAMS) and terminal age main sequence (TAMS), constructed by the Hurley et al. (2002) binary star evolution code. The other well-known contact systems were obtained from the catalog of Yakut & Eggleton (2005). It is found that the primary component of V2790 Ori is located near the ZAMS, similar to the primary stars of other W-type systems, implying that its evolutionary stage remains in the main sequence phase, while the secondary component of V2790 Ori lies above the TAMS, indicating that the secondary component has evolved to be oversized and overluminous. We calculated the mean densities of the components using the equations taken from Mochnacki (1981)

Equation (4)

Equation (5)

where the relative volumes of the components V1 and V2 are normalized to the semimajor axis, q is the mass ratio and P is the orbital period. We obtained ${\bar{\rho }}_{1}$ = 2.121±0.259 g cm−3 and ${\bar{\rho }}_{2}$ = 1.474±0.179 g cm−3, which are quite close to the values in Michaels (2016)'s work. The mean density of the secondary component, ${\bar{\rho }}_{1}$, is less than the theoretical value of the ZAMS star, confirming that the component has evolved away from the ZAMS to become oversized, while the mean density of the solar-mass primary star, ${\bar{\rho }}_{2}$, is nearly the same value as the Sun, meaning that the primary component is still a main sequence star.

Fig. 4

Fig. 4 Both components of V2790 Ori on the log M − log L (upper) and log M − log R (lower) diagrams: the primary more massive (filled dot) and the secondary less massive (filled triangle) components. The sample of contact binaries, collected from the work of Yakut & Eggleton (2005), is plotted for comparison. The solid and dashed lines are for ZAMS and TAMS, respectively, constructed by the Hurley et al. (2002) binary star evolution code for solar metallicity.

Standard image

With the assumption that mass transfer starts, when the secondary (initially more massive) component has evolved to be near or after the TAMS, the initial masses of both components are computed from Equations (6)–(8) (Yildiz & Doğan 2013):

Equation (6)

Equation (7)

Equation (8)

where MSi and MPi are the initial masses, and MS and MP are the current masses of the secondary and primary stars, respectively. Δ M is the total mass lost by the secondary, Mlost is the mass lost by the binary and γ is the ratio of Mlost to Δ M. LS is the luminosity of the secondary star. The derived value for the initial mass of the secondary star is 1.535±0.148 M and the mass decrease of the secondary is Δ M = 1.188±0.110 M. However, for W-type contact systems, the value of the fitting parameter γ, given by Yildiz & Doğan (2013), must be in the range of 0.500 < γ < 0.664. Consequently, the corresponding initial mass of the primary star must be a value between 0.426 and 0.620 M, depending on the value of γ. The precise value of γ needs to be assigned in Equation (7). We applied the minimum, average and maximum values for γ of 0.500, 0.582 and 0.664 respectively for three cases to estimate some possible values of the initial mass of the primary star and total initial mass of the binary. The values of mass lost by the system and mass transfer between the components were finally obtained. The possible mass parameters for the three cases are listed in Table 5. As shown in Figure 5, the total initial mass of V2790 Ori for the case of γ = 0.664 lies closer to the relation between total present mass (MT) and total initial mass (MTi) for W-type (Yıldız 2014) than the other cases. Thus, the appropriate value of γ for V2790 Ori should be 0.664. The initial mass of the primary component is obtained to be 0.620±0.075 M. From the detached phase until the present time, some 0.789±0.073 M of mass has been lost from the system, while there could be a mass transfer of 0.399±0.037 M from the secondary component to the primary component, after the time of FOF.

Fig. 5

Fig. 5 Total initial mass of V2790 Ori for the three cases of γ on the MTMTi diagram. The dotted and solid lines are the MTMTi relations, fitted by Yıldız (2014) using a sample of 51 A-type (open squares) and 49 W-type (open circles) contact systems, respectively. V2790 Ori with the value of γ = 0.664 (filled triangle) is located closer to the relation than the cases of γ = 0.582 (filled square) and γ = 0.500 (filled star).

Standard image

Table 5. Mass Parameters Corresponding to the Three Cases of γ for V2790 Ori

Mass parameters Values
MS (M) 0.348(±0.038)
MSi (M) 1.535(±0.148)
Δ M (M) 1.188(±0.110)
MP (M) 1.020(±0.112)
  Values for three cases of γ
γ 0.500 0.582 0.664
MPi (M) 0.426(±0.057) 0.523(±0.066) 0.620(±0.075)
MTi (M) 1.961(±0.159) 2.058(±0.162) 2.156(±0.166)
Mlost (M) 0.594(±0.055) 0.691(±0.064) 0.789(±0.073)
Mtransfer (M) 0.594(±0.055) 0.496(±0.046) 0.399(±0.037)

5.2. Orbital and Angular Momentum Change

In general, the orbital angular momentum can be calculated by using the following well known equation

Equation (9)

where Jo is the orbital angular momentum, q is the mass ratio, MT is the total mass of the binary and P is the orbital period. The value of the present angular momentum of the binary is computed to be log Jo = 51.42±0.06 cgs. Figure 6 shows a diagram of the orbital angular momentum versus total mass of contact and detached binaries, separated by the quadratic border line (Eker et al. 2006). The sample of detached systems was collected from the catalogs of Eker et al. (2006), Yildiz & Doğan (2013) and Lee (2015). The sample of contact systems was obtained from the works of Eker et al. (2006) and Ibanoğlu et al. (2006). Location of the binary V2790 Ori at the present time (filled triangle) is found to be below the border line, meaning that the present angular momentum of the binary is less than all detached systems with the same mass. This is consistent with angular momentum and/or mass loss in the past during the detached phase causing the binary to evolve into the contact phase.

Fig. 6

Fig. 6 Locations of V2790 Ori at the FOF (filled square) and the present time (filled triangle) on the log Jo − log MT diagram. The samples representing detached (Eker et al. 2006; Lee 2015; Yildiz & Doğan 2013) and contact (Eker et al. 2006; Ibanoğlu et al. 2006) are separated by the quadratic border line (Eker et al. 2006).

Standard image

During the formation of the contact binary V2790 Ori, the AML must continue from detached to semi-detached and contact phases. The orbital period and semimajor axis decrease lead to the components being close together. The angular momentum at the FOF, JFOF, can be calculated from Equation (9). According to a mass transfer process starting at the FOF and the lifetime in the detached phase for W-type typically being negligibly short (Yıldız 2014), we assumed that masses of both components were not much different from their initial values. Thus, for the beginning of the semi-detached phase, initial mass parameters from Table 5 were implemented in calculating JFOF, while the orbital period and semimajor axis at the FOF were computed using Equations (10)–(11) (Yıldız 2014)

Equation (10)

Equation (11)

where PFOF and aFOF are the orbital period and semimajor axis at the FOF, respectively. RTAMS is the Roche lobe radius filled by the massive component that evolved to reach TAMS. PFOF, aFOF and JFOF are computed to be 1.083±0.049 d, 5.731±0.090 R and 9.39(±0.73) × 1051 cgs respectively. These results demonstrate that the angular momentum has decreased from 9.39 × 1051 cgs at the FOF to 2.62 × 1051 cgs at the present time, concurrently with a mass lost by the system of 0.789 M as depicted in Figure 6. Consequently, the orbital period and semimajor axis have reduced from 1.083 d and 5.731 R to 0.2878420 d and 2.036 R, respectively.

Initially, the binary V2790 Ori in the detached phase consisted of two main sequence stars. The more massive component (the progenitor of the secondary component) has evolved to TAMS, leading to the resulting oversized envelope. In combination with AML, the Roche surface was filled by the evolved secondary component, causing mass transfer to begin. From the FOF until the present time, the orbit has been reduced by AML and mass loss.

6. Conclusions

In summary, the BVRC observations were carried out at the Thai National Observatory, during three nights in 2015. The photometric data covered five eclipse timings. The (OC) curve shows an orbital period increase at a rate of dP/dt = 1.03× 10−7 d yr−1. The observed light curves were fitted with the W-D method to provide fundamental parameters. It is found that V2790 Ori is a contact system with a mass ratio of q = 2.932. The estimated masses of the components are calculated to be MP = 1.020±0.112 M and MS = 0.348±0.038 M for the primary and secondary, respectively. With an orbital period increase, there could be mass transfer from the less massive secondary to the more massive primary with a rate of 6.31 × 10−8 M yr−1.

Locations of V2790 Ori's components on the log M − log L and log M − log R diagrams confirm that the secondary has evolved to be overluminous and oversized, causing the envelope to fill its Roche surface, while the primary is still a main sequence star. Its mass and angular momentum have been lost continuously throughout its evolution from the detached phase to the contact phase. From the detached phase until the present time, there could be mass lost by the secondary of 1.188 M, i.e., mass of 0.789 M lost by the system and mass of 0.399 M transferred to the primary. Also, 72.2% of the angular momentum has been lost from JFOF since the FOF stage to the present time, yielding a smaller orbit.

Acknowledgements

This research work was partially supported by Chiang Mai University. We acknowledge the Thai National Observatory, operated by the National Astronomical Research Institute of Thailand, for use of the 0.5 m telescope. This work has made use of the SIMBAD online database, operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France and NASA's Astrophysics Data System (ADS), operated by the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory (SAO) under a NASA grant.

Please wait… references are loading.