Abstract
The West and Russia have been bitterly divided over the conflict in Syria. Whereas Western powers and their Arab allies have backed the opposition and sought the toppling of the Assad regime, Russia has been seen to support the Syrian leader and thwart diplomatic initiatives at the United Nations. In order to better understand what underpins these diametrically opposed positions, this article presents the findings of a detailed analysis of Russian media coverage of the conflict. Focusing on three prominent Russian newspapers and comparing them with three Western counterparts, particular emphasis is placed on their reporting of regime violence, the nature and actions of the opposition, and Russia’s own role in the conflict. In so doing, a clear picture emerges of how starkly different the Syrian conflict appears to a Russian audience.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abrams, E. (2011) Ridding Syria of a despot. Washington Post 25 March.
Adler, A. (2011) Le rôle clé du régime syrien [The key role of the Syrian regime]. Le Figaro 31 March.
Adler, A. (2012) La Russie dans l'imbroglio syrien [Russia in the Syrian imbroglio]. Le Figaro 10 February.
Ajami, F. (2012) The last battle of the Cold War. Wall Street Journal 31 January.
Allison, R. (2013) Russia and Syria: Explaining alignment with a regime in crisis. International Affairs 89 (4): 795–823.
Bahrampour, T. (2011a) In Syria, protesters push to end decades of isolation. Washington Post 17 April.
Bahrampour, T. (2011b) Syrian security forces kill dozens of protesters. Washington Post 22 April.
Barry, E. (2012) For Putin, principle versus practicality on Syria. The New York Times 4 July.
Blomfield, A. (2011a) Syria: Feared militia kills up to 21 people as protests continue. Daily Telegraph 27 March.
Blomfield, A. (2011b) Syria: Power struggle behind failure to end emergency rule. Daily Telegraph 28 March.
Blomfield, A. (2011c) Syria experiences ‘Good Friday’ massacre. Daily Telegraph 22 April.
Blomfield, A. (2011d) Syrian troops open fire on protesters trying to break Deraa blockade. Daily Telegraph 29 April.
Burrett, T. (2013) Television and Presidential Power in Putin’s Russia. Oxon: Routledge.
Daily Telegraph. (2011a) Syria: Thousands of women and children protest. 13 April.
Daily Telegraph. (2011b) International war crimes court should investigate Syria, UN rights chief to say. 18 August.
Daily Telegraph. (2012a) ‘Deadly blasts’ hit security building in Damascus. 17 March.
Daily Telegraph. (2012b) Syrian army blamed for most rights abuses in latest violence. 24 May.
Daily Telegraph. (2012c) Assad’s endgame. 18 July.
Daily Telegraph. (2012d) Syria: 50 dead in Damascus car bomb attacks. 28 November.
Daily Telegraph. (2013a) The army establishes a fragile peace in Egypt. 3 July.
Daily Telegraph. (2013b) Egypt: Bashar al-Assad says coup is defeat for political Islam. 4 July.
Dannreuther, R. (2012) Russia and the Middle East: A cold war paradigm? Europe-Asia Studies 64 (3): 543–560.
Dehghanpisheh, B. (2012) Car bombs kill at least 45, injure scores, in Damascus neighborhood. Washington Post 28 November.
Diehl, J. (2012) Three good reasons to heed the US hawks. Washington Post 20 March.
Economist. (2013) Al-Qaeda returns: The new face of terror. 27 September.
Eggert, K. (2011) Sorok let zakonservirovannykh emotsii, Kommersant FM 24 March.
Fel’gengauer, P. (2012) Siriiskii primer: Zashchishchaya rezhim Asada, rossiiskaya korrumpirovannaya elita zashchishchaet prezhde vsego sebya [Syrian example: In protecting Assad’s regime, Russia’s corrupt elite is above all protecting itself]. Novaya Gazeta 13 February.
Feshchenko, V. (2011a) Asad vsegda byl primernym musul’maninom [Assad was always an exemplary Muslim]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 1 April.
Feshchenko, V. (2011b) MENNtorskii ton [A mentoring tone]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 27 April.
Figaro. (2012a) Syrie: Alep rattrapée par la violence, au moins 28 morts. 2 February.
Figaro. (2012b) Syrie: Plus de 25 morts après des explosions à Damas [Syria: More than 25 dead following explosions in Damascus]. 17 March.
Figaro. (2012c) Syrie: l'armée viole les droits de l'homme [Syria: Army violates human rights]. 24 May.
Figaro. (2012d) Assaut meurtrier de l'armée syrienne à Houla [Deadly Syrian army assault in Houla]. 25 May.
Fildis, A.T. (2012) Roots of Alawite-Sunni rivalry in Syria. Middle East Policy 19 (2): 148–156.
Fishere, C.E. (2013) Authoritarians have no place in Egypt, Financial Times 21 August.
Fomichev, O. (2013) Russian analysts differ on the future of Syria: Russian experts disagree on whether or not a political solution in Syria is still possible. Russia Beyond the Headlines 5 April.
Fordham, A. and Warrick, J. (2011) Attacks on Syrian government buildings seem to strike the heart of state security apparatus. Washington Post 23 December.
Freeman, C. and Sherlock, R. (2012) United Nations ceasefire in tatters after 92 killed in Syrian violence. Daily Telegraph 26 May.
Gardner, D. (2013) The West is failing the Syrian people. Financial Times 11 September.
Gearan, A. (2013) Untangling the fate of US aid to Egypt. Washington Post 21 August.
Gehlbach, S. (2010) Reflections on Putin and the media. Post-Soviet Affairs 26 (1): 77–87.
Gelie, P. (2012) Syrie: La France soupçonne une «manipulation». Le Figaro 12 January.
Gerson, M. (2011) Obama’s serial indecision on the Middle East. Washington Post 25 April.
Girard, R. (2011) Les Syriens défient à nouveau Assad [The Syrians defy Assad again]. Le Figaro 15 April.
Hadley, S. (2011) Our chance to shape change in North Africa and the Mideast. Washington Post 18 August.
Hill, F. (2013) The real reason Putin supports Assad: Mistaking Syria for Chechnya. Foreign Affairs March 25.
Inozemtsev, V. (2012) Zachem nam Siriya? [Why do we need Syria?] Vedomosti 24 December.
Ishiyama, J.T. and Kennedy, R. (2001) Superpresidentialism and political party development in Russia, Ukraine, Armenia and Kyrgyzstan. Europe-Asia Studies 53 (8): 1177–1191.
Izyumov, A. (2011) V Damaske spryatalis’ [Concealed in Damascus]. Kommersant Vlast’ 13917, http://www.kommersant.ru/doc/1611224.
Jaffe, G. and Miller, G. (2012) Syrian rebellion at critical moment. Washington Post 18 July.
Katz, M.N. (2006) Putin’s foreign policy toward Syria. Middle East Review of International Affairs 10 (1): 53–62.
Khatuntsev, S. (2013) Novoe topornoe zverstvo [A new clumsy brutality]. Izvestiya 23 August.
Kommersant. (2011a) Online-interv’yu s Nikolaem Zlobinym i Lionidom Ivashovym [Online interview with Nikolai Zlobin and Leonid Ivashov]. 4 April.
Kommersant. (2011b) Luchshe imet’ odnogo tigra, chem desyat’ tysyach beshenykh krys [Better to have one tiger than ten thousand rabid rats]. 22 August.
Kommersant. (2012a) Rossiyane ne postradali pri terakte v Sirii [No Russian victims of terrorist attack in Syria]. 10 February.
Kommersant. (2012c) Boinya v Sirii [Massacre in Syria]. 27 May.
Kommersant. (2012d) Siriiskaya oppozitsiya vzyalas’ za ministrov [Syrian opposition take out ministers]. 18 July.
Kommersant. (2012e) Izvestnyi islamskii propovednik vozglavil siriiskuyu oppozitsiyu [Well-known Islamic preacher heads Syrian opposition]. 12 November.
Kommersant. (2013) Sily NATO gotovy k voennoi operatsii v Sirii v sluchae prikaza [NATO forces ready for military operation in Syria when ordered]. 20 March.
Krauthammer, C. (2011) Syria’s ‘reformer’. Washington Post 31 March.
Krauthammer, C. (2012) While Syria burns. Washington Post 26 April.
Kunkle, F. and Mansour, M. (2011) Syrian forces attack two villages near Baniyas. Washington Post 12 April.
Lipman, M. (2009) Media Manipulation and Political Control in Russia. Moscow, Russia: Carnegie Moscow Center.
Lynch, C. and Fordham, A. (2012) Russia, China veto U.N. resolution on Syria. Washington Post 4 February.
McElroy, D. (2013) Muslim Brotherhood must be removed like Nazis, Egypt’s ambassador to Britain says. Daily Telegraph 19 August.
MacFarquhar, N. (2011) With rare double U.N. veto on Syria, Russia and China try to shield friend. New York Times 5 October.
Makarychev, M. (2011) Damask minuet ‘chasha sanktsii’ [Damascus bypasses the ‘cup of sanctions’]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 28 April.
Makarychev, M. (2012) Bomba pod mirnyi plan [A bomb under the peace plan], Rossiiskaya Gazeta 28 May.
Makutina, M. (2011) V Sirii rastet chislo pogibshikh v stolknoveniyakh s vlast’yu [In Syria the number of those killed in clashes with the authorities rises]. Kommersant-Online 23 April.
Malbrunot, G. (2011) Damas frappé par un double attentat suicide [Damascus struck by a double suicide attack]. Le Figaro 23 December.
Marlow, C. and Spencer, R. (2011) Analysis: Was Syrian government behind attacks? Daily Telegraph 23 December.
McCartney, J. (2013) Lost in the muddle of the Middle East. Daily Telegraph 6 July.
Miller, A.D. (2012) Why Syria’s rebels can’t have it all. Foreign Policy 1 August.
Minoui, D. (2013) Comment le «Moubarak barbu» s’est coupé du people [How the ‘bearded Moubarak’ became disconnected from the people]. Le Figaro 3 July.
Morozov, O. (2011) Okhlorevolyutsiya. Vozmozhna li ona v Rossii? [Mob revolution. Could it happen in Russia?] Rossiiskaya Gazeta 25 March.
Morris, L. (2013) Video purporting to show Syrian rebel atrocity highlights challenges facing West on aid. Washington Post 14 May.
Nezavisimaya Gazeta. (2013) MID RF: Raketu s otravlyayuschim veschestvom vypustili boeviki [Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs: The rocket with toxic substances was launched by militants]. 21 August.
Novaya Gazeta. (2011a) Siriiskii kataklizm [Syrian cataclysm]. 20 April.
Novaya Gazeta. (2011b) Barak Obama obratitsya k prezidentu Sirii s trebovaniem uiti v otstavku [Barak Obama addresses to the Syrian president a demand for his resignation]. 18 August.
Novaya Gazeta. (2012a) Dva terakta v siriiskom gorode Aleppo unesli zhizni 25 chelovek [Two terror attacks in the Syria city of Aleppo kill 25]. 10 February.
Novaya Gazeta. (2012b) Pravozashchitniki zayavlyayut o gibeli 90 chelovek pod obstrelom armii Sirii [Rights activists claim 90 killed in Syrian army bombardment]. 26 May.
O’Bagy, E. (2012) Jihad in Syria. Middle East Security Report 6 (September). Institute for the Study of War.
Pirogov, I. (2012) Sirii predlozheno sformirovat’ perekhodnoe pravitel’stvo [Proposed that Syria form a transitional government]. Kommersant 30 June.
Reutov, A. (2011a) Siriya styagivaet volneniya v stolitsu [Unrest brought to the Syrian capital]. Kommersant 13 April.
Reutov, A. (2011b) Siriiskii bunt: Damask razvyazyvaet sebe ruki dlya podavleniya oppozitsii [Syrian revolt: Damascus frees its hands for the suppression of the opposition]. Kommersant-Online 19 April.
Reutov, A. (2011c) Raskol islama proshel cherez Siriyu [The split in Islam passes through Syria]. Kommersant 20 April.
Reutov, A. (2011d) Siriya poshla vsled za Egiptom [Syria follows Egypt]. Kommersant 25 April.
Reutov, A. (2012) Pod rezhim Bashara Asada podlozhili kanistry [Canisters planted under the regime of Bashar Assad]. Kommersant 26 December.
RIA Novosti. (2012) Syrian militants free to target russians – Opposition leader. 19 December.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2011a) ES trebuet osvobodit’ arestovannykh demonstrantov v Sirii. 19 March.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2011b) Siriiskaya politsiya primenila slezotochivyi gaz dlya razgona tolpy [Syrian police used teargas to disperse crowd]. 21 March.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2011c) Siriiskaya politsiya otkryla ogon’ po uchastnikam pokhoronnoi protsessii v prigorode Damaska [Syrian police open fire on funeral procession on outskirts of Damascus]. 23 April.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2011d) Barak Obama potreboval otstavki Asada [Barak Obama demands the resignation of Assad]. 18 August.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2011e) Chislo zhertv dvoinogo terakta v Damaske dostiglo 54 chelovek [Number of victims of double terror attack in Damascus reaches 54]. 27 December.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2012a) OON: Prava cheloveka v Sirii narushayut obe storony konflikta [UN: Both sides of the conflict in Syria are violating human rights]. 24 May.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2012b) Pravozashchitniki zayavlyayut o gibeli 90 chelovek pod obstrelom armii Sirii [Rights activists claim 90 killed in Syrian army bombardment]. 26 May.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2012c) V Zheneve predlozhili sozdat’ v Sirii perekhodnoe pravitel’stvo [The creation of a transitional government in Syria is proposed in Geneva]. 30 June.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2012d) Siriiskie oppozitsionery otkazalis’ ot priezda v Moskvu [Syrian opposition rejects a visit to Moscow]. December 29.
Rossiiskaya Gazeta. (2013) MID RF osudil primenenie siriiskoi oppozitsiei khimoruzhiya v Aleppo [Russian foreign ministry condemns use of chemical weapons by Syrian opposition in Aleppo]. 19 March.
Shestakov, E. (2011a) Umytye demokratiei [Washed with democracy]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 1 April.
Shestakov, E. (2011b) Nado li Rossii dogonyat’ takuyu Ameriku? Vashington zabyl o normakh mezhdunarodnogo prava [Does Russia have to run after such an America? Washington has forgotten the rules of international law]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 19 August.
Shestakov, E. (2011c) Damask okruzhili s Vostoka i Zapada: Rossiya ne dopustit inostrannogo voennogo vtorzheniya v Siriyu [Damascus surrounded from East and West: Russia will not allow foreign military intervention in Syria]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 17 November.
Shestakov, E. (2012a) Rossiya zashchitila svoi interesy [Russia defended its interests]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 10 February.
Shestakov, E. (2012b) Rossiya dolzhna pokinut’ “bal litsmerov” [Russia should leave the ‘ball of hypocrites’]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 6 July.
Shestakov, E. (2012c) Damasku pripisali khimiyu: Siriitsev otravili radi togo, chtoby NATO moglo svergnut’ Bashara Asada [Chemistry attributed to Damascus: Syrians poisoned so that NATO can topple Bashar Assad]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 26 December.
Sherlock, R. and Greenwood, P. (2012) Mutilated bodies of mother and four children found in latest Syrian atrocity, Daily Telegraph 25 May.
Shitov, A. (2011) Khata, chto ne s krayu: Opasnaya doktrina poryadochnogo cheloveka [It is our business: The dangerous doctrine of the honest man]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 18 April.
Sly, L. and Cody, E. (2011) Global condemnation, but no action, against bloody Syria crackdown. Washington Post 26 April.
Sly, L. and Eglash, R. (2013) Arab leaders happy to see Morsi gone. Washington Post 5 July.
Sly, L. and Lynch, C. (2012) U.N. Security Council blames Syrian government for civilian massacre. Washington Post 27 May.
Snegirev, V. (2011) Tysyacha i odna noch’ [A thousand and one nights]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 8 April.
Spencer, R. (2011) Syria uprising: ‘We will continue until the fall of the regime’. Daily Telegraph 23 April.
Spencer, R. (2012a) Free Syrian Army is all that stands between civilians and tanks. Daily Telegraph 11 February.
Spencer, R. (2012b) Syria: The carefully planned killings presage more bloodshed to come. Daily Telegraph 18 July.
Spencer, R. (2012c) Syria regime ‘mixing chemicals to make sarin gas’: Report. Daily Telegraph 3 December.
Spencer, R. and Marlow, C. (2011) Syria: Sides point finger of blame at each other for Damascus bombs. Daily Telegraph 23 December.
Strange, H. (2013) 15-year-old boy executed for blasphemy by Syria jihadists. Daily Telegraph 10 June.
Tarasenko, P. (2013) NATO reshit problem Sirii po-liviiski [NATO will resolve the Syrian problem in way of Libya]. Kommersant 21 March.
Thedrel, A. (2012) Syrie: l'ONU confrontée à la tuerie de Houla [UN confronted by the Houla massacre]. Le Figaro 28 May.
Trenin, D. (2013) The Mythical Alliance: Russia’s Syria Policy. Moscow, Russia: Carnegie Moscow Center.
Tsygankov, A. (2012) Why Russia still backs Assad. Moscow Times 29 October.
UN. (2012a) Secretary-General condemns terrorist bombing in Damascus, reiterates all violence in Syria must stop. United Nations press release, 6 January, http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2012/sgsm14046.doc.htm, accessed 8 April 2013.
UN. (2012b) United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Independent International Commission of Inquiry established pursuant to resolution A/HRC/S-17/1 and extended through resolution A/HRC/Res/19/22, periodic update, 24 May, http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/HRBodies/HRCouncil/SpecialSession/CISyria/PeriodicUpdateCISyria.pdf, accessed 10 April 2013.
US Embassy. (2012) Ambassador Rice’s remarks on Syria to U.N. Security Council. 4 February. http://london.usembassy.gov/midest134.html, accessed 9 February 2013.
Vorob’ev, V. (2012) Rossiya v Sirii spasaet mir [Russia is saving the world in Syria]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 18 July.
Vorob’ev, V. (2013) Nakhimichili: SSHA ishchut povod realizovat’ v Sirii liviiskii stsenarii [Wrong chemistry: USA seeks excuse to carry out Libyan scenario in Syria]. Rossiiskaya Gazeta 22 March.
Wannous, D. (2012) Syrian uprising: A victory over fear. Washington Post 11 November.
Warrick, J. and Sly, L. (2011) Senators press Obama to take strong action against Syria. Washington Post 28 April.
Washington Post. (2011a) Opposing Syria. 23 March.
Washington Post. (2011b) Shameful US inaction on Syria’s massacres. 22 April.
Zimmerman, W. (2002) The Russian People and Foreign Policy: Russian Elite and Mass Perspectives, 1993–2000. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brown, J. ‘Better one tiger than ten thousand rabid rats’: Russian media coverage of the Syrian conflict. Int Polit 51, 45–66 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1057/ip.2013.45
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/ip.2013.45