Abstract
Background/objectives
The growing interest of medical community about sarcopenia resulted in the production of several clinical practice guidelines (CPGs), with an unavoidable variability in terms of the overall quality of those publications. Our aim is to evaluate the quality of CPGs on sarcopenia using the AGREE II instrument.
Subjects/methods
We performed an online literature search for sarcopenia CPGs using different databases. Four independent reviewers evaluated the quality of CPGs using the AGREE II instrument. To classify the quality of each guideline, we defined specific thresholds of final score: high-quality if five or more domains scored >60%; average-quality if three or four domains scored >60%; low-quality if ≤2 domains scored >60%.
Results
Our literature search yielded 315 articles, and after applying exclusion criteria our final analysis included 19 CPGs. The overall quality of CPGs was remarkable, as 13/19 (68.4%) were considered of “high-quality” CPGs, with more than four domains reached a score higher than 60%. “Scope and Purpose” and “Clarity of Presentations” had the best domain results (78.4% and 73.8%, respectively), while the two domains with the lowest scores were “Rigor of Development” and “Applicability” (61.5% and 58.7%, respectively). Interobserver variability ranged between moderate (0.624) and fair (0.275).
Conclusions
Our study showed that the overall quality of CPGs about sarcopenia was noteworthy, as more than two-third of paper obtained a “high-quality” score. The domain “applicability” had the lowest score, suggesting that emphasis should be put on possible strategies for helping other doctors to implement guideline recommendations in clinical practice.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution
Access options
Subscribe to this journal
Receive 12 print issues and online access
$259.00 per year
only $21.58 per issue
Rent or buy this article
Prices vary by article type
from$1.95
to$39.95
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Rosenberg IH. Summary comments. Am J Clin Nutr. 1989;50(Nov 1):1231–3.
Beaudart C, McCloskey E, Bruyère O, Cesari M, Rolland Y, Rizzoli R, et al. Sarcopenia in daily practice: assessment and management. BMC Geriatr. 2016;16(Dec 5):170.
Cruz-Jentoft AJ, Bahat G, Bauer J, Boirie Y, Bruyère O, Cederholm T, et al. Sarcopenia: revised European consensus on definition and diagnosis. Age Ageing. 2019;48(Jan 1):16–31.
Morley JE, Argiles JM, Evans WJ, Bhasin S, Cella D, Deutz NEP, et al. Nutritional recommendations for the management of sarcopenia. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2010;11(Jul):391–6.
Iolascon G, Di Pietro G, Gimigliano F, Mauro GL, Moretti A, Giamattei MT, et al. Physical exercise and sarcopenia in older people: position paper of the Italian Society of Orthopaedics and Medicine (OrtoMed). Clin Cases Min Bone Metab. 2014;11(Sep):215–21.
De Spiegeleer A, Beckwée D, Bautmans I, Petrovic M, Sarcopenia Guidelines Development group of the Belgian Society of Gerontology and Geriatrics (BSGG). Pharmacological interventions to improve muscle mass, muscle strength and physical performance in older people: an umbrella review of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Drugs Aging. 2018;35(Aug 25):719–34.
Cesari M, Fielding RA, Pahor M, Goodpaster B, Hellerstein M, Van Kan GA, et al. Biomarkers of sarcopenia in clinical trials-recommendations from the International Working Group on Sarcopenia. J Cachexia Sarcopenia Muscle. 2012;3(Sep):181–90.
Petak S, Barbu CG, Yu EW, Fielding R, Mulligan K, Sabowitz B, et al. The Official Positions of the International Society for Clinical Densitometry: body composition analysis reporting. J Clin Densitom. 2013;16(Oct):508–19.
Kung J, Miller RR, Mackowiak PA. Failure of clinical practice guidelines to meet institute of medicine standards: two more decades of little, if any, progress. Arch Intern Med. 2012;172(Nov 26):1628–33.
Grilli R, Magrini N, Penna A, Mura G, Liberati A. Practice guidelines developed by specialty societies: the need for a critical appraisal. Lancet. 2000;355(Jan 8):103–6.
Kredo T, Bernhardsson S, Machingaidze S, Young T, Louw Q, Ochodo E, et al. Guide to clinical practice guidelines: the current state of play. Int J Qual Heal Care. 2016;28(Feb):122–8.
Hoffmann-Eßer W, Siering U, Neugebauer EAM, Brockhaus AC, Lampert U, Eikermann M. Guideline appraisal with AGREE II: systematic review of the current evidence on how users handle the 2 overall assessments. Zhang H-L, editor. PLoS One. 2017;12(Mar 30):e0174831.
Sardanelli F, Bashir H, Berzaczy D, Cannella G, Espeland A, Flor N, et al. The role of imaging specialists as authors of systematic reviews on diagnostic and interventional imaging and its impact on scientific quality: report from the EuroAIM Evidence-based Radiology Working Group. Radiology 2014;272(Aug):533–40.
EIBIR. European network for the assessment of imaging in medicine [Internet]. [cited 27 Dec 2016]. http://www.eibir.org/scientific-activities/joint-initiatives/euroaim/
Sconfienza LM. Sarcopenia: ultrasound today, smartphones tomorrow? Eur Radiol. 2019;29(Jan 12):1–2.
Bramer WM, Rethlefsen ML, Kleijnen J, Franco OH. Optimal database combinations for literature searches in systematic reviews: a prospective exploratory study. Syst Rev. 2017;6(Dec 6):245.
AGREE Enterprise website [Internet]. [cited 5 Jun 2019]. https://www.agreetrust.org/
Brouwers MC, Kho ME, Browman GP, Burgers JS, Cluzeau F, Feder G, et al. AGREE II: advancing guideline development, reporting and evaluation in health care. CMAJ 2010;182(Dec 14):E839–42.
Ou Y, Goldberg I, Migdal C, Lee PP. A critical appraisal and comparison of the quality and recommendations of glaucoma clinical practice guidelines. Ophthalmology 2011;118(Jun):1017–23.
Armstrong JJ, Rodrigues IB, Wasiuta T, MacDermid JC. Quality assessment of osteoporosis clinical practice guidelines for physical activity and safe movement: an AGREE II appraisal. Arch Osteoporos. 2016;11(Dec 13):6.
Messina C, Bignotti B, Tagliafico A, Orlandi D, Corazza A, Sardanelli F, et al. A critical appraisal of the quality of adult musculoskeletal ultrasound guidelines using the AGREE II tool: an EuroAIM initiative. Insights Imaging 2017;8(Oct 28):491–7.
Messina C, Bignotti B, Bazzocchi A, Phan CM, Tagliafico A, Guglielmi G, et al. A critical appraisal of the quality of adult dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry guidelines in osteoporosis using the AGREE II tool: an EuroAIM initiative. Insights Imaging 2017;8(Jun 21):311–7.
Sekercioglu N, Al-Khalifah R, Ewusie JE, Elias RM, Thabane L, Busse JW, et al. A critical appraisal of chronic kidney disease mineral and bone disorders clinical practice guidelines using the AGREE II instrument. Int Urol Nephrol. 2017;49(Feb 1):273–84.
Cruz-Jentoft AJ, Baeyens JP, Bauer JM, Boirie Y, Cederholm T, Landi F, et al. Sarcopenia: European consensus on definition and diagnosis: Report of the European Working Group on Sarcopenia in Older People. Age Ageing 2010;39(Jul 1):412–23.
Nishikawa H, Shiraki M, Hiramatsu A, Moriya K, Hino K, Nishiguchi S. Japan Society of Hepatology guidelines for sarcopenia in liver disease (1st edition): recommendation from the working group for creation of sarcopenia assessment criteria. Hepatol Res. 2016;46(Sep):951–63.
Reginster J-Y, Cooper C, Rizzoli R, Kanis JA, Appelboom G, Bautmans I, et al. Recommendations for the conduct of clinical trials for drugs to treat or prevent sarcopenia. Aging Clin Exp Res. 2016;28(Feb):47–58.
Kendler DL, Borges JLC, Fielding RA, Itabashi A, Krueger D, Mulligan K, et al. The Official Positions of the International Society for clinical densitometry: indications of use and reporting of DXA for body composition. J Clin Densitom. Jan;16:496–507.
Vellas B, Pahor M, Manini T, Rooks D, Guralnik JM, Morley J, et al. Designing pharmaceutical trials for sarcopenia in frail older adults: EU/US task force recommendations. J Nutr Health Aging. 2013;17(Aug 6):612–8.
Suominen MH, Jyvakorpi SK, Pitkala KH, Finne-Soveri H, Hakala P, Mannisto S, et al. Nutritional guidelines for older people in Finland. J Nutr Health Aging. 2014;18(Dec 23):861–7.
Abellan van Kan G, André E, Bischoff Ferrari HA, Boirie Y, Onder G, Pahor M, et al. Carla Task Force on Sarcopenia: propositions for clinical trials. J Nutr Health Aging. 2009;13(Oct):700–7.
Studenski SA, Peters KW, Alley DE, Cawthon PM, McLean RR, Harris TB, et al. The FNIH sarcopenia project: rationale, study description, conference recommendations, and final estimates. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2014;69(May):547–58.
Chen L-K, Liu L-K, Woo J, Assantachai P, Auyeung T-W, Bahyah KS, et al. Sarcopenia in Asia: consensus report of the Asian Working Group for Sarcopenia. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2014;15(Feb):95–101.
Arends J, Bachmann P, Baracos V, Barthelemy N, Bertz H, Bozzetti F, et al. ESPEN guidelines on nutrition in cancer patients. Clin Nutr. 2017;36(Feb):11–48.
Dent E, Morley JE, Cruz-Jentoft AJ, Arai H, Kritchevsky SB, Guralnik J, et al. International Clinical Practice Guidelines for Sarcopenia (ICFSR): screening, diagnosis and management. J Nutr Health Aging. 2018;22:1148–61.
Cederholm T, Barazzoni R, Austin P, Ballmer P, Biolo G, Bischoff SC, et al. ESPEN guidelines on definitions and terminology of clinical nutrition. Clin Nutr. 2017;36(Feb):49–64.
Arends J, Baracos V, Bertz H, Bozzetti F, Calder PC, Deutz NEP, et al. ESPEN expert group recommendations for action against cancer-related malnutrition. Clin Nutr. 2017;36(Oct):1187–96.
van den Berg T, Engelhardt EG, Haanstra TM, Langius JAE, van Tulder MW. Methodology of clinical nutrition guidelines for adult cancer patients. J Parenter Enter Nutr. 2012;36(May 13):316–22.
Zeng L, Zhang L, Hu Z, Ehle EA, Chen Y, Liu L, et al. Systematic review of evidence-based guidelines on medication therapy for upper respiratory tract infection in children with AGREE instrument. Schildgen O, editor. PLoS One. 2014;9 (Feb 20):e87711.
Gitto S, Bisdas S, Emili I, Nicosia L, Pescatori LC, Bhatia K. Clinical practice guidelines on ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration biopsy of thyroid nodules: a critical appraisal using AGREE II. Endocrine. 2019;65(2):371–78.
Doniselli FM, Zanardo M, Manfrè L, Papini GDE, Rovira A, Sardanelli F, et al. A critical appraisal of the quality of low back pain practice guidelines using the AGREE II tool and comparison with previous evaluations: a EuroAIM initiative. Eur Spine J. 2018;27(Nov 15):2781–90.
Lawrenson JG, Evans JR, Downie LE. A critical appraisal of national and international clinical practice guidelines reporting nutritional recommendations for age-related macular degeneration: are recommendations evidence-based? Nutrients 2019;11(Apr 11):823.
Sabharwal S, Patel NK, Gauher S, Holloway I, Athanasiou T, Athansiou T. High methodologic quality but poor applicability: assessment of the AAOS guidelines using the AGREE II instrument. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2014;472(Jun 25):1982–8.
Sabharwal S, Patel V, Nijjer SS, Kirresh A, Darzi A, Chambers JC, et al. Guidelines in cardiac clinical practice: evaluation of their methodological quality using the AGREE II instrument. J R Soc Med. 2013;106(Aug 28):315–22.
Anker SD, Morley JE, von Haehling S. Welcome to the ICD-10 code for sarcopenia. J Cachexia Sarcopenia Muscle. 2016;7(Dec):512–4.
Norris SL, Holmer HK, Ogden LA, Burda BU. Conflict of interest in clinical practice guideline development: a systematic review. Mintzes B, editor. PLoS One. 2011;6 (Oct 19):e25153.
Norris SL, Holmer HK, Ogden LA, Selph SS, Fu R. Conflict of interest disclosures for clinical practice guidelines in the national guideline clearinghouse. Ross JS, editor. PLoS One. 2012;7 (Nov 7):e47343.
Neuman J, Korenstein D, Ross JS, Keyhani S. Prevalence of financial conflicts of interest among panel members producing clinical practice guidelines in Canada and United States: cross sectional study. BMJ 2011;343(Oct 11):d5621–d5621.
Acknowledgements
This work has been conducted within the framework of the EuroAIM, research platform of the European Institute for Biomedical Research (http://www.eibir.org/scientific-activities/joint-initiatives/euroaim/). This study was supported by the Italian Ministry of Health (Ricerca Corrente).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
All authors contributed to meet the ICMJE Recommendations for authorship, having provided: 1. Substantial contributions to the conception and design (CM, DA), acquisition (IV), or analysis and interpretation of data (LP, SG, JV, VC). 2. Drafting the paper (CM, DA) or revising it critically for important intellectual content (CM, LMS). 3. Final approval of the version to be published (all authors). 4. All authors agreed to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Messina, C., Vitale, J.A., Pedone, L. et al. Critical appraisal of papers reporting recommendation on sarcopenia using the AGREE II tool: a EuroAIM initiative. Eur J Clin Nutr 74, 1164–1172 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41430-020-0638-z
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41430-020-0638-z
This article is cited by
-
Comparison between magnetic resonance imaging and electrical impedance myography for evaluating lumbar skeletal muscle composition
BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders (2022)
-
Clinical indications for image-guided interventional procedures in the musculoskeletal system: a Delphi-based consensus paper from the European Society of Musculoskeletal Radiology (ESSR)—part VII, nerves of the lower limb
European Radiology (2022)
-
Clinical indications for image-guided interventional procedures in the musculoskeletal system: a Delphi-based consensus paper from the European Society of Musculoskeletal Radiology (ESSR)—part V, knee
European Radiology (2022)
-
Clinical indications for image-guided interventional procedures in the musculoskeletal system: a Delphi-based consensus paper from the European Society of Musculoskeletal Radiology (ESSR)—part IV, hip
European Radiology (2022)
-
Clinical indications for image-guided interventional procedures in the musculoskeletal system: a Delphi-based consensus paper from the European Society of Musculoskeletal Radiology (ESSR)—part VI, foot and ankle
European Radiology (2022)