Abstract
Bioethics, and indeed much ethicalwriting generally, makes its point throughnarratives. The religious parable no less thanthe medical teaching case uses a simple storyto describe appropriate action or theapplication of a critical principle. Whilepowerful, the telling story has limits. In thispaper the authors describe a simple teachingcase on ``end-of-life'' decision making that wasill received by its audience. The authors ill-receivedexample, involving the disconnection ofventilation in a patient with ALS (Lou Gherig'sDisease) was critiqued by audience members withlong-term experience as ventilation users. Inthis case, the supposedly simple narrative ofthe presenters conflicted with the lifehistories of the audience. The lessons of thisstory, and the conflict that resulted, speakcritically to the limits of simple teachingcases as well as the strengths of narrativeanalysis as a tool for the exploration ofbioethical case histories.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
REFERENCES
Bindman, Stephen. “Judge Stays on Bench to Fight His Disease's ‘Death Sentence.'” Toronto Star (January 11, 1993): A1, A11.
Chambers, Tod. “The Fiction of Bioethics: A Précis.” American Journal of Bioethics 1(1) (2001): 40.
Chambers, Tod. “From the Ethicist's Point of View: The Literary Nature of Ethical Inquiry.” Hastings Center Report 26(1) (1996): 25–32.
Duncan, Barbara and Diane Woods, eds. Ethical Issues in Disability and Rehabilitation. Edited by New York: World Institute on Disability, Rehabilitation International, World Rehabilitation Fund, New York, 1989.
Elliot, Carl. A Philosophical Disease: Bioethics, Culture, and Identity. New York: Routledge, 1998.
Ethical Issues in Disability and Rehabilitation. Annual Meeting of the Society for Disabilities, Pre-Conference Workshop. Denver, Colorado (May 9- 11, 1989).
Frank, Arthur. “Social Bioethics and the Critique of Autonomy.” Health 4(3) (2000): 378–397.
Frank, Arthur. “Rhetoric, Moral Relativism, and Power.” American Journal of Bioethics 1(1) (2000): 51–52.
Geertz, Clifford. The Interpretation of Cultures. New York: Basic Books, 1973.
Hardwig, John. “What About Family?” Hastings Center Report 20(2) (1990): 5–10.
Koch, Tom. Scarce Goods: Justice, Fairness, and Organ Transplantation.NewYorkand London: Praeger Books, 2001.
Koch, Tom. “Disability and Difference: Balancing Social and Physical Constructions.” Journal of Medical Ethics 27 (2001): 370–376.
Koch, Tom. “End-of-Life Issues: A Disabilities Perspective.” In Cultural Issues in End of Life Decision Making. Edited by Kathryn Braun, James H. Pietsch, and P.L. Blanchette. pp. 285–301. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications, 2000.
Koch, Tom. “Stillborn Bioethics.” In Ethics, Law, and Aging Review, Vol. 6. Edited by Marshall Kapp. 223–238. New York: Springer Publishing, 2000.
Koch, Tom. “Life Quality vs. the ‘Quality of Life’ Assumptions Underlying Prospective Quality of Life Instruments in Health Care Planning.” Social Science & Medicine 51 (2000): 419–427.
Kuczewski, G. Mark. “In Search of an Honest Case.” American Journal of Bioethics 1(1) (2001): 44–45.
Kuczewski, G. Mark. Fragmentation and Consensus: Communitarian and Casuist Bioethics. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 1997.
Miller, L. Bruce. “Autonomy and the Refusal of Lifesaving Treatment.” Hastings Center Report 11(4) (1981): 22–28.
Nelson, L. James. “Taking Families Seriously.” Hastings Center Report 22(4) (1992): 6–12.
Rodriguez v. British Columbia. S. C. J. 94 (September 30, 1993).
Singer, Peter. “Response to Mark Kuczewski.” American Journal of Bioethics 1(3) (2001): 55.
Thomasma, D. “Commentary: Guidelines for Rationing Resemble Process of Family Decision Making.” British Medical Journal 312 (1996): 1531–1532.
Wackers, Gerardus L. Constructivist Medicine. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. University of Maastricht, NL, 1994.
Young, M. Jenny, McNicoll, P.P. “Against All Odds: Positive Life Experiences of People with Advanced Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis.” Health and Social Work 23(1) (1998): 253–260.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kaufert, J., Koch, T. Disability or end-of-life? Competing narratives in bioethics. Theor Med Bioeth 24, 459–469 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:META.0000006922.00289.a9
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:META.0000006922.00289.a9