Consistency of patient- and doctor-assessed cosmetic outcome after conservative treatment of breast cancer

Abstract

The cosmetic results of the breast (144 patients)were analysed after segmental resection and axillary dissectionwith or without postoperative radiotherapy for early low-riskbreast cancers. Cosmetic results were assessed over time(3, 9, 18, 36, 48 months respectively) bythe patient and by the physician. Patients ratedthe overall cosmetic result good or excellent in92% of cases after 3 months. The proportionof good or excellent cosmetic results decreased overtime and after four years 89% of patientsclassified themselves in this category, whereas the physicianassessed the outcome as good or excellent in91% of cases after 3 months and 75%after 4 years. The inter-observer consistency between physicianand patient in assessing the cosmetic outcome wasκ=0.42 at the beginning and decreasedover time (κ=0.07 after 4 years).The intra-observer variation over time was κ =0.53 for the patient and κ=0.32for the physician.Inter-observer consistency between patient and physician was moderateimmediately following treatment but decreased over time. Thefeeling of satisfaction of the patient was relativelystable whereas the opinion of the physician becamesomewhat more critical over time. Therefore the intra-observerconsistency over time was somewhat better for thepatient than for the physician.