Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-cfpbc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T13:56:48.164Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

An Unknown Nigerian Export: Tiv Benniseed Production, 1900–1960

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

D. C. Dorward
D. C. Dorward
Affiliation:
C.W.A.S., University of Birmingham
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The article examines the factors which influenced Tiv initiative and response in the development of the Nigerian export production of benniseed or sesamum indicum. A trade hitherto largely ignored, it has been overshadowed by the Bohannans' classic account, with its emphasis on the subsistence aspect of Tiv economy. It is therefore presented both as a case study of the development of an African export commodity and as a contribution to the broader field of socio-economic history of the colonial era.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 16 , Issue 3 , July 1975 , pp. 431 - 459
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1975

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Hopkins, A. G., An Economic History of West Africa (London, 1973).Google ScholarHill, P., The Migrant Cocoa-Farmers of Southern Ghana (Cambridge, 1963).Google ScholarHelleiner, G. K., Peasant Agriculture, Government and Economic Growth in Nigeria (Homewood, 1966).Google Scholar

2 ‘Going up in smoke’, West Africa, no. 3002 (6 01 1975), 9.Google Scholar

3 Bohannan, P., Tiv Farm and Settlement (London, 1954).Google Scholar, P. and Bohannan, L., Tiv Economy (London, 1968).Google ScholarBohannan, P., ‘The Impact of Money on an African Subsistence Economy’, J. Econ. Hist., XIX (1959), 491–503.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

4 Personal communications from Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, 42 July 1969, D. 2395/M69. Hutchinson, J. and Dalziel, J. M., Flora of West Tropical Africa, 11 (London, 1963), 389–91.Google Scholar There is a savanna variety, Sesamum alatum, which is adapted to drier conditions and is used domestically, though not exported, as well as two other West African species, Sesamum augustifolium and Sesamum radiatum, neither of which is of commercial value. In addition, there is another plant, Polygala butyracea, similar in appearance to Sesamum indicum but which yields a dark seed easily distinguished from the light coloured sesame seed, hence its common name ‘black benniseed’. It has an oil content of only about 36 per cent and is of no commercial value. Smith, E. H. G., ‘A Note on Benniseed and Adulterantes’, 11th Annual Bulletin of the Agricultural Department (Lagos, 1936), 17–21.Google Scholar

5 International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, The Economic Development of Nigeria (Baltimore, 1955), 221–2.Google Scholar Imperial Institute, Selected Reports from Scientific and Technical Department, No. V: Oil Seeds, Oils, Fats and Waxes, Cd. 7260 (1914).Google Scholar

6 ‘Annual Report, Yandev Plantation, Benue Province, 1929’, 9th Annual Bulletin of Agricultural Department (Lagos, 1930), 205.Google Scholar‘Annual Report, Yandev Plantation, Benue Province, 1930’, 10th Annual Bulletin of the Agricultural Department (Lagos, 1931), 205.Google Scholar

7 Weiss, E. A., Castor, Sesame and Safflower (London, 1971), 345.Google Scholar Nigeria, Annual Report of Agricultural Department, 1943, SP no. 12/1944. Nigeria, Annual Report of the Agricultural Department, 1944, SP no. 13/1946.

8 Imperial Economic Committee, Vegetable Oils and Oilseeds; A Summary of Figures of Production and Trade relating to (London, 1936), 35.Google Scholar In the mid-1930s the five leading producers, as distinct from exporters, were India, China, Turkey, Mexico and the Soviet Union.

9 Colonial Office, An Economic Survey of the Colonial Empire, 1932 (Colonial no. 95)Google Scholar; 1935 (Colonial no. 126); 1937 (Colonial no. 179).

10 Helleiner, , Peasant Agriculture, Table IV-A-16.Google Scholar

11 East, R., ed., Akiga's Story (London, 1939), 67–8, 89–90.Google Scholar

12 Gordon, C. F., Notes on the Munshi Tribe, 1907, NAK, SNP 5313/1907.Google Scholar

13 Bohannan, , Tiv Farm and Settlement, 19.Google Scholar

14 Royal Niger Company letterbook, 1886–8; Royal Niger Company letterbook, 1885–90, United Africa Company, London. Hewby, W. P., ‘Notes on the Munshi’, 1 01 1909, MSS no. 116, H. R. Palmer Papers, Jos.Google Scholar

15 Alexander, Boyd, From the Niger to the Nile, 1 (London, 1907), 31.Google Scholar

16 Akiga, , ‘History of the Tiv’, 268–9, MSS, Africana Library, Ibadan.Google Scholar

17 Northern Nigeria; Annual Report for 1902, Cd. 1768–14. Trigge, Joseph E., Produce Purchase Report, 30 04 1906Google Scholar, MSS Afr. s85, Rhodes House, Oxford.

18 Niger Company Produce Purchases, 1905, MSS, Afr. s85, Rhodes House.

19 Elphinstone, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, Mar. 1908, NAK, SNP 2126/1908. Ruxton, Some notes on the Munshi, 3 Mar. 1910, MSS Afr. s230, Rhodes House.

20 Walter Watts, Diary, 1907–8, passim, MSS Afr. s88, Rhodes House. Ruxton, Annual Report, Muri Province, 1907, NAK, SNP 786/1908.

21 Ruxton, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, June 1908, NAK, SNP 3826/1908. Trigge, Joseph E. to Scarborough, Lord, 9 07 1908Google Scholar, MSS Afr. s85, Rhodes House. Pressure from the Niger Company for the pacification of the presumed rubber-rich area of southern Tivland was a factor behind Lugard's abortive 1906 Munshi Campaign.

22 Ruxton, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, June 1908, NAK, SNP 3826/1908. Ruxton, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, Dec. 1909, NAK, SNP 405/1910.

23 Rowe, Assessment Report, Batiava, 30 Oct. 1912, NAK, SNP 530p/1913.

24 This is one side of what has been referred to as the ‘double profit’ of the European traders, the other being the difference between the purchase price and the selling price in Europe. Prices tended to fluctuate during each buying season, but as a rule of thumb the purchase price was roughly one third the c.i.f. price. Based on commodity prices listed by Messrs William Porter & Co., Rumford Street, Liverpool, as reported in West Africa, and available data on seasonal purchase prices.

25 Niger Company Produce Purchases, 1905, MSS Afr. s85; Niger Company Produce Purchases, 1908, MSS Afr. 896; Niger Company Produce Purchases 1911, MSS Afr. 585, Rhodes House.

26 , P. and Bohannan, L., Tiv Economy.Google Scholar

27 Ruxton, Report on Cotton Production and Industry, Muri Province, 1910, BCGA Papers, Birmingham University.

28 Gordon, Notes on the Munshi Tribe, 1907, NAK, SNP 5313/1907.

29 Ruxton, Report on Cotton Production and Industry, Muri Province, 1910.

30 Ruxton, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, Sept. 1910, NAK, SNP 5056/1910. For an interesting Hausa parallel, see Hogendorn, J. S., ‘The Origins of the Groundnut Trade in Northern Nigeria’ in Growth and Development of the Nigerian Economy, Eicher, C. K. and Liedholm, C., eds. (Michigan, 1970), 30–51.Google Scholar

31 List of BCGA buying stations and pounds of seed cotton purchased 1912, C.O. 446/111/12553.

32 Ruxton, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, June 1913, NAK, SNP 583p/1913.

33 Rowe, Assessment Report, Batiava, 30 Oct. 1912, NAK, SNP 530p/1913. Eastwood to BCGA, June 1913, C.O. 446/114/27501. Northern Nigeria, Annual Report of Customs Department, 1913.

34 Faulkner, O. T. and Mackie, J. R., West African Agriculture (Cambridge, 1933), 128.Google Scholar

35 ‘Annual Report, Yandev Plantation, Benue Province, 1929’, 9th Annual Bulletin of the Agricultural Department, 207.Google Scholar

36 Ibid.

37 Ibid.

38 Waters, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, Sept. 1912, NAK, SNP 6259/1912. Eastwood of the BCGA also commented on the increased cultivation with the introduction of taxation. Eastwood to BCGA, June 1913, C.O. 446/114/2750.

39 Ruxton, Annual Report, Muri Province, 1913, NAK, SNP 15P/1914.

40 Gordon, Assessment Report, Haraba East, Mar. 1913, C.O. 446/112/22378. Chapman, Assessment Report, Ukan, 25 May 1917, NAK, SNP 367p/1917.

41 Dupigny, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, June 1912, NAK, SNP 4378/1912. Waters, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, Sept. 1912, NAK, SNP 6259/1912.

42 Rowe, , Assessment Report, Batiava, 30 10 1912, NAK, SNP 530P/1913.Google Scholar

43 Ruxton, , Quarterly Report, Muri Province, 09 1913, NAK, SNP 717p/1913.Google Scholar

44 Francis, , Quarterly Report, Muri Province, 09 1915, NAK, SNP 683p/1915.Google Scholar

45 Rowe, , Assessment Report, Abinsi Urban, 2 04 1913, NAK, SNP 401p/1913.Google Scholar

46 Ruxton, , Quarterly Report, Muri Province, 09 1913, NAK, SNP 717p/1913.Google Scholar

47 Niger Company Produce Purchases, 1911–12, MSS Afr. s85; Niger Company Produce Purchases, 1913–14, MSS Afr. s86, Rhodes House.

48 Trigge, Joseph E. to Scarborough, Lord, 16 07 1914, MSS Afr. s85, Rhodes House.Google Scholar

49 Fremantle, Annual Report, Muri Province, 1914, NAK, SNP 171p/1915.

50 Fremantle, Annual Report, Muri Province, 1917, NAK, SNP 198p/1918. Rowe, Half Yearly Report, Muri Province, June 1918, NAK, SNP 516p/1918.

51 Fremantle, Half Yearly Report, Muri Province, June 1915, NAK, SNP 484p/1915.

52 Trigge to Agent i/c Nassarawa District, 26 Jan. 1915, MSS Afr. s99, Rhodes House.

53 Trigge to Agent i/c Lower Benue, 12 Jan. 1915, MSS Afr. s99, Rhodes House.

54 Fremantle, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, Sept. 1916, NAK, SNP 671p/1916. Trigge to Scarborough, 31 Dec. 1915, MSS Afr. s99, Rhodes House.

55 Holt, Agent i/c Ibi, to Niger Company, 1 Mar. 1915, MSS Afr. s99 Rhodes House, Fremantle, Annual Report, Muri Province, 1917, NAK, SNP 198p/1918.

56 Chapman, quoted in Fremantle, Quarterly Report, Muri Province, Sept. 1916, NAK, SNP 671p/1916.

57 Blair, Yellow Fever Report, 7 Nov. 1917, C.O. 583/61/1890. Northern Provinces, Annual Medical Report, 1918, C.O. 583/77/57905.

58 See Appendix, ‘Statistical Data’.

59 Francis, , Annual Report, Muri Province, 1919, NAK, SNP 6p/1920.Google Scholar

60 Francis, , Half Yearly Report, Muri Province, 06 1920, NAK, SNP 271p/1920.Google Scholar

61 Seton, , Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1923, NAK, SNP 94/1924.Google Scholar

62 Bohannan, , Tiv Economy, 62.Google Scholar

63 Gordon, Report for the fifteen months ending 31 Mar. 1921, Munshi Province, NAK, SNP 122P/1921.

64 Gordon, , Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1922, NAK, SNP 67/1923.Google Scholar

65 Seton, , Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1923, NAK, SNP 94/1924. Sciortino, Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1925, NAK, SNP K 106, vol. 1.Google Scholar

66 Gordon, , Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1922, NAK, SNP 67/1923. Akiga, ‘History of the Tiv’, MSS, 303–4.Google Scholar

67 Seton, , Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1923, NAK, SNP 94/1924.Google Scholar

68 Sciortino, Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1924, NAK, SNP 543/1925.

69 Gordon, Report for the fifteen months ending 31 Mar. 1921, Munshi Province, NAK, SNP 122P/1921.

70 Seton, , Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1923, NAK, SNP 94/1924.Google Scholar

71 Nigerian Gazetteer, Trade Supplement, V, 11, 24 11 1921Google Scholar; VII, 12, 27 Dec. 1923, et al.

72 Sciortino, , Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1924, NAK, SNP 543/1925.Google Scholar

73 Sciortino, , Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1925, NAK, SNP K 106, vol. 1.Google Scholar

74 Nigeria, Annual Reports of the Customs Departments, 1923–37.

75 Seton, , Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1923, NAK, SNP 94/1924.Google Scholar

76 Feasey, Re-assessment Report, Munshi Province, [1924], NAK, SNP 864/1924.

77 Bohannan, , Tiv Economy, 247–8.Google Scholar Akiga also referred to the problem created by the export of foodstuffs. East, Akiga's Story, 347.Google Scholar

78 Monk, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1926, NAK, SNP K 106, vol. 111. Monk, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1927, NAK, SNP K 6836, vol. 1.

79 Sciortino, Annual Report, Munshi Province, 1924, NAK, SNP 543/1925.

80 Commodity prices listed by Messrs William Porter & Co., Liverpool in West Africa.

81 Pembleton, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1931, NAK, SNP 16701. Pembleton, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1929, NAK, SNP 12332, vol. 1.

82 Commodity prices listed by Messrs William Porter & Co., Liverpool in West Africa.

83 Pembleton, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1931, NAK, SNP 16071.

84 Northern Provinces, Native Administration Estimates for 1932–33. Morgan, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1930, NAK, SNP 14639.Google Scholar

85 Pembleton, Annual Report, Benue Provinces, 1931, NAK, SNP 16701.

86 Pembleton, Annual Report, Benue Provinces, 1932, NAK, SNP 18473, vol. I; Pembleton, Annual Report, Benue Provinces, 1933, NAK, SNP 21302, vol. I; Pembleton, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1934, NAK, SNP 23593, vol. I.

87 Northern Provinces, Native Treasury Estimates for 1936–37, SP no. 22/1936.

88 Annual Report on the Northern Provinces of Nigeria, 1934, 15.Google Scholar

89 Emberton, , Annual Report, Benue Province, 1935, NAK, SNP 25720.Google Scholar

90 Nigeria, Annual Report of the Agricultural Department, 1937.Google Scholar

91 Annual Report on the Northern Provinces of Nigeria, 1936, SP no. 22/1937.Google Scholar

92 Wilkinson, , Annual Report, Benue Province, 1937Google Scholar, NAK, SNP 29626. Beck, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1938, NAK, SNP 30844. Beck, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1939, NAK, SNP 32056.

93 Briggs, G. W. G., ‘Crop Yields and Food Requirements in Tiv Division Benue Province, Nigeria’, Farm and Forest, V (1944), 17–23.Google Scholar

94 Beck, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1942, NAK, SNP 35341. Beck, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1943, NAK, SNP 37026.

95 Colonial Office, An Economic Survey of the Colonial Territories, 1951, vol. IIIGoogle Scholar; The West African Territories (H.M.S.O., 1952), 60.Google Scholar

96 Cullen, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1945, NAK, SNP 40250.

97 Nigeria, Annual Report of the Agricultural Department 1944, SP no. 13/1946.

98 Helleiner, , Peasant Agriculture, Table II-B-4.Google Scholar

99 Macdonald, Annual Report, Benue Province, 1946, NAK, SNP 41868.

100 Nigeria, Annual Report of the Agricultural Department, 1947, SP no. 12/1949.

101 Nigeria, Annual Report of the Agricultural Department, 1948, SP no. 29/1949. Nigeria, Annual Report of the Agricultural Department, 1949–50, SP no. 2/1951.

102 Bohannan, , Tiv Economy, 62.Google Scholar

103 Donald Vermeer has described a similar change in the ‘traditional’ system of crop rotation, the introduction of the bugh bu System, necessitated in part by population pressure and by the export trade in foodstuffs. Vermeer, D. E., ‘Population Pressure and Crop Rotational Changes among the Tiv of Nigeria’, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, LX, 2 (06 1970), 299–314.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

104 Agricultural Officer, Yandev, to Resident Benue, 11 Oct. 1951, NAK, MAKPROF 480, vol. IV.

105 D.O. i/c Tiv Division to Resident Benue, 12 Oct. 1951, NAK MAKPROF 480, vol. IV.

106 Nigeria, 3rd Annual Report of the Groundnut Marketing Board, 1951–52 season.

107 Nigeria, 4th Annual Report of the Groundnut Marketing Board, 1952–53.

108 Nigeria, 5th Annual Report of the Groundnut Marketing Board, 1953–54. Nigeria, Sale of Produce (Taxation) Ordinance, 1953, no. 12 of 1953.

109 Northern Region, 2nd Annual Report of the Northern Region Marketing Board, 1955–56. Northern Region, 3rd Annual Report of the Northern Region Marketing Board, 1956–57.

110 Northern Region, 4th Annual Report of the Northern Region Marketing Board, 1957–58. Northern Region, 5th Annual Report of the Northern Region Marketing Board, 1958–59. Northern Region, 6th Annual Report of the Northern Region Marketing Board, 1959–60.

111 Vermeer, , ‘Population pressure’, 308.Google Scholar

112 Northern Nigeria; Annual Report for 1902, Cd. 1768–14. Trigge, Joseph E., Produce Purchase Report, 30 04 1906, MSS Afr. s85, Rhodes House.Google Scholar

113 ‘Annual Report, Yandev Plantation, Benue Province, 1930’, 10th Annual Bulletin of Agricultural Department (Lagos, 1931), 198.Google ScholarCobley, L. S., An Introduction to the Botany of Tropical Crops (London, 1956), 106.Google Scholar

114 Colonial Office, An Economic Survey of the Colonial Territories, 1951, 111, 60.Google Scholar

115 In 1949 changes were made in the export valuation for bananas, cocoa, raw cotton, groundnuts, palm kernels, and palm oil, as well as for benniseed. The magnitude of these statistical adjustments can be ascertained by comparing earlier reports with the Trade Report for the Year 1949, produced by the Nigerian Department of Statistics, which contains revised values for all the above items for 1948, for all except cocoa for 1947, and for raw cotton only for 1946. These altered export values for selected commodities appear to have passed largely unnoticed by Helleiner, who used the upward revised calculations in his classic study of the Nigerian economy. He mentions in note 3 to Table IV-A-7 that the 1947 value of cocoa was ‘… estimated to have been underdeclared by approximately £6 million …’, but failed to mention that the 1946 cocoa export was estimated to have been underdeclared by £1 7 million, 1945 by £0 5 million, 1944 by £0 9 million, 1943 by £0 7 million, and 1941 by £0 5 million, or that the 1948 export value was revised upward in the 1949 Statistics which he used from £7,458,580 to £17,878,736. Similar alterations of other commodities export values were likewise not insignificant. As a result of the 1949 revision of the 1948 export values, the declared value of Nigerian exports for 1948 were increased by £25,097,364:

Original 1948 Revised 1948

Commodity export values export values Export duty

£ £ £

Bananas 309.593 146,460 34.497

Raw cotton 400,918 34.75.785

Groundnuts 6.785,330 9,806,200 405.554

Palm kernel 6,262,253 11,451.097 520,938

Palm oil 3,880,653 9,048,260 329,605

Benniseed 113.538 301,680

Cocoa 7.459,580 17,878,736 408,509

116 Agricultural Officer, Yandev, to Resident Benue, 11 Oct. 1951, NAK, MAKPROF 480, vol. IV.

117 This is the only instance of a major discrepancy between the customs returns in the Blue Books, which list 1,196 tons of benniseed valued at £16,918, with a unit value of £14 15 per ton, exported in 1921 and the sum of the monthly entries for 1921 in the Nigerian Gazette, Trade Supplement, which come to 2,102 tons valued at £30,347, with a unit value of £14 44 Per ton The Annual Summary in the Trade Supplement of 26 Jan. 1922 liste 1,195 tons at £16,917. One suspects an error in the unusually high entry for benniseed exports for June 1921 in Trade Supplement of 25 Aug. 1921.