Scaling of planar dielectric elastomer actuators in an agonist-antagonist configuration

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sna.2010.05.015Get rights and content

Abstract

One of the great advantages of dielectric elastomers (DE) is their scalability. This study investigates the influence of size on their performance and the applicability of theory and established models on large-scale actuators. The testing is based on an active hinge configuration made with planar dielectric elastomer actuators as described by Lochmatter in 2007 [16]. The actuators are scaled to five times the size of the small hinge which results in planar membrane actuators of 0.95 × 0.25 m. Theoretical aspects of the up-scaling are discussed. The issue of scaling in design and manufacturing of actuators is addressed. A planar test rig for agonist-antagonist activation, comparable to the hinge-configuration, was set up and the actuators were experimentally characterised in terms of strain (deflection angle), blocking force (moment) and input energy. The behaviour of the large actuators could be predicted accurately with an Arruda-Boyce model and they scale according to theory.

Introduction

As a subgroup of the electro-active polymers, the soft dielectric elastomers have generated much interest because of their high potential for active deformation [1]. Dielectric elastomer (DE) actuators are basically compliant capacitors, consisting of a thin elastomeric film as dielectric, coated on both sides with compliant electrodes. Some of the benefits of this type of actuator include high energy density, low cost, ease of handling and manufacturing [2]. Their simple working principle allows a wide variety of possible designs and applications. Planar membrane actuators especially have been studied in a variety of publications [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8]. On many occasions the easy scalability is mentioned as an advantage of these membrane actuators, but has not been proved. Possible applications for large planar actuators are mentioned in [9], [10], [11], [12], [13], [14] including e.g. energy harvesting devices, pumps and space applications. So far, with a few exceptions [12], [14], only small to medium-sized objects have been fabricated and thoroughly characterised. In this paper the issue of scaling is addressed not only in terms of performance, but also in terms of design, manufacturing and modelling. One of the major challenges encountered from the scale-up has been maintaining the mechanical pre-stretch whilst avoiding impairment of the deformation. A different (slower) time-dependent behaviour is expected due to the larger area of the capacitor. The Arruda-Boyce model with material parameters adapted for VHB by Wissler et al. [15] was applied to verify the validity for large-scale actuators.

Large-scale and multi-layered actuators are necessary when large displacements and forces are required. The presented work is embedded in a project with the goal of transferring the method of propulsion of a fish into air to an airship, propelled by moving its body in an undulating way and by flapping a caudal fin. The fish is a very efficient swimmer, being manoeuvrable even at slow speeds whilst moving almost completely noiselessly. DE actuators are ideal for this application because the soft, flexible, light-weight membranes can easily be integrated onto the airship hull. In order to have enough buoyancy the lighter-than-air vehicle must be of a certain size, and in order to create thrust given deformations and forces are required. These were part of the motivation and boundary conditions for the up-scaling of the DE actuators.

The present study is based on the active hinge as published in [16]. The actuators on the small hinge measured 0.19 m in height (H) and 0.05 m in length (L). These actuators are scaled in the planar dimensions by a factor of five to 0.95 x 0.25 m. The thickness of the dielectric membrane or the electrodes is not scaled in order to ensure that the electric field remains unchanged. The total thickness of the actuator is scaled by the number of layers with a factor 3.

In this paper an overview over the theoretical scaling of different parameters is given. The scaling factors S and n are introduced for planar dimensions and number of layers respectively. The actuators are experimentally characterised on a planar test-rig that can be compared to the hinge configuration. Since most applications of agonist-antagonist actuators work with a hinge configuration and for easier comparison with [16], the deflection angle and blocking moment of an equivalent hinge are calculated with simple trigonometry from the evaluated strain and blocking force. Furthermore the input voltage and current is monitored and some electro-mechanical properties (e.g. the efficiency) are listed.

Section snippets

Theoretical considerations on scaling of DE

This section discusses how various parameters depend on the actuator size (with a scaling factor expressed in S for planar dimensions and n for the number of layers). The scaling factors are summarised in Table 1. For more clarity, the parameters of an active hinge are shown in Fig. 1.

Actuator design

Just as in [16], the actuators were made of pre-stretched VHB 4910 (λx = 3, λy = 5). Lochmatter scaled the actuators in the thickness direction by increasing the number of layers from one to three. An essential difference of the deflection angle and blocking moment of the hinge was measured between the single- and multilayered actuator, which was not predicted theoretically. Lochmatter reasoned that the difference in the performance of the one- and three-layered actuators resulted from a

Planar agonist-antagonist test-stand

In order to determine the electro-mechanical properties of the hinge more easily, a simplified testing configuration was introduced (Fig. 4a). In the planar test rig two actuators were placed next to each other, attached to each other in a movable centre-line, and fixed on both ends. Whilst one actuator expands, the other contracts and the centre-line moves to one side. The principle has been presented before [9] as a double push-pull actuator. The force of the contracting actuator is similar

Comparison of planar test rig to hinge configuration

The similarity of the two test rigs – the hinge and the planar one - was verified on small actuators. In Fig. 6a the maximum deflection angle after 5 s activation is plotted versus the initial electrical field, which is the applied voltage divided by the initial membrane thickness. The results from the hinge are compared with the equivalent angles calculated from the measured strain in a planar test-stand, both for one- and three-layered actuators. For higher electrical fields and several

Conclusion and Outlook

Applications with a need for large energy capacitance require DE with large surfaces. Targetting these applications we have studied the influence of size on the performance of the actuators. The parameters for established models in this field have naturally been identified with lab-scale objects. We have now validated the applicability for large-scale actuators. The experimental programme shows that the large actuators behave in an expected manner and according to theory. In this context we

Acknowledgements

This work is funded by the board of directors of Empa. The valuable discussions with Lukas Düring and Arne Schmidt are greatly acknowledged. The experimental work was supported by Marco Jakob and Emanuele Fazio.

Christa Jordi was born in Zurich, Switzerland in 1982. After graduating in mechanical engineering at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH) in 2007, she started her PhD in mechanical engineering at Empa, Dubendorf. The research goal of the dissertation is the development and characterisation of a biomimetic airship driven by dielectric elastomers.

References (20)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (31)

  • Closed loop control of force operation in a novel self-sensing dielectric elastomer actuator

    2017, Sensors and Actuators, A: Physical
    Citation Excerpt :

    The outstanding material properties in the electro-mechanical coupling make the DE ideal for displacement/strain sensing [9,10], energy harvesting [11–13], as well as actuation [14–17]. A dielectric elastomer actuator (DEA) has demonstrable muscle-like capability in bio-inspired robots [18–21], tuneable optics [22–26], flexible robotic legs [27], and lighter-than-air vehicles [28]. However, the advancement in other applications is hindered by the viscoelasticity of the DE.

  • Electrostatic-viscoelastic finite element model of dielectric actuators

    2016, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering
    Citation Excerpt :

    The resulting electrical capacities are very small and electrodynamic effects like the time needed for charging the actuators are negligible. If actuators become larger [6], the distribution of charge with respect to time due to applied voltage can become dominating. In this case, electrodynamic effects have to be considered.

  • Sensing frequency design for capacitance feedback of dielectric elastomers

    2015, Sensors and Actuators, A: Physical
    Citation Excerpt :

    If the frequency of the input is unknown, a Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) can be used determine the highest frequency component of interest. While the viscoelastic effects of the DE under high voltage electrostatic actuation can have an effect on its frequency response [28], the experiments carried out in this paper were all conducted at low voltage (5 V) which did not cause any mechanical deformation. Thus the DEs were all measured under static conditions and the capacitance frequency behavior was entirely due to electrical properties.

View all citing articles on Scopus

Christa Jordi was born in Zurich, Switzerland in 1982. After graduating in mechanical engineering at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH) in 2007, she started her PhD in mechanical engineering at Empa, Dubendorf. The research goal of the dissertation is the development and characterisation of a biomimetic airship driven by dielectric elastomers.

Silvain Michel graduated in mechanical engineering at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH) in 1989. After 10 years as a fatigue and damage tolerant specialist in the aerospace industry he joined the Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Testing and Research (Empa) in 2000. Between 2003 and 2008 he was Head of the research group for electroactive polymers within the Laboratory for Mechanical Systems Engineering. Since 2009 he has been a senior scientist, responsible for various projects on dielectric elastomer actuators and devices.

Gabor Kovacs received his Dr.sc.techn. degree at ETH Zurich. Following his PhD he worked at the Institute of Lightweight Structures and Ropeway Technology at ETH as a senior scientist. From 1996 to 2001 he was Head of the competence centre Aerial Cableway Technology at Empa, Dubendorf. Between 2001 and 2003 he was Head of the research group for electroactive polymers. Between 2003 and 2005 he was Head of the Laboratory for Mechanical Engineering Systems at Empa. Since 2006 he has been senior scientist for novel actuator technologies in the field of electroactive polymers.

Paolo Ermanni received his Dr.sc.techn. degree at ETH Zurich in 1990. After working more than five years at DaimlerChrysler Aerospace Airbus GmbH in Hamburg as a senior engineer and as a project manager, he took on a new challenge in 1997 as a manager in the consulting firm A.T. Kearney in Milan. He was appointed associate professor at ETH Zurich in 1998. Since April 1, 2003 Paolo Ermanni has been full Professor of structure technologies at ETH Zurich.

View full text