An energetic analysis of a multifunctional façade system for energy efficient retrofitting of residential buildings in cold climates of Finland and Russia

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2014.12.005Get rights and content

Highlights

  • Study on MEEFS multifunctional energy efficient façade system for retrofitting.

  • System is suitable for retrofitting apartment buildings in Finland and Russia.

  • The studied building stock is advantageous for the Meefs industrialization.

  • Field testing are needed in Nordic climates, before actual implementations.

Abstract

Retrofitting of external walls and building facades of residential buildings is often considered as the most energy efficient renovation measure. This paper presents a multifunctional energy efficient façade system for multi-family apartment building retrofitting, the “Meefs” system which is still under development in a concept phase, and analyses its energetic features based on building typologies to cold climate apartment buildings in Finland and in Russia.

Both in Finland and in Russia, the majorities of the apartment building stocks were built after the II World War. Major capital repairs are needed in both building stocks in the coming years. At the same time, energy efficiency of buildings could be improved which would make them more sustainable. The apartment building stocks in both countries consist of typical buildings of this construction period. Therefore prefabricated facade products, such as the “Meefs” system, could beneficially be adapted to retrofit them. In addition, as shown in this paper, the Meefs system would provide considerable energy savings. However, adapting the system to Russian buildings would require changes to building energy systems as well.

Introduction

In view of climate change, aging housing stocks and heavy energy consumption, it is important to promote integrated retrofit of residential areas, and to understand the importance of efficient modernization, deployment of new technology and use of renewable energy resources (Raslanas, Alchimovienė, & Banaitienė, 2011). Energy retrofit of buildings represents an important sector for mobilizing investments to address carbon mitigation of cities (Mastrucci, Baume, Stazi, & Leopold, 2014). For developed countries, such as EU-15, the technical greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction potential for the building stock in 2020 ranges between 21 and 54% of the national baseline. For economies in transition, such as Russia, this value ranges between 26 and 47% of the national baseline, for the building stock in 2030 (Ürge-Vorsatz & Novikova, 2008). For both markets, building envelop retrofits, including insulation, are estimated as measures with the largest potential. The integration of new technologies for renewable-based energy production, into building envelop retrofitting measures, can significantly reduce GHG emissions.

Most national building regulations that mandate thermal insulation of building envelopes were introduced after the 1970s following the energy crisis (Balaras, Droutsa, Dascalaki, & Kontoyiannidis, 2005). In addition, compared to current regulations the first thermal insulation requirements were quite moderate. So, the energy saving potential is the largest in the oldest non-retrofitted buildings.

About 60% of Russia's total multi-family apartment buildings are in need of extensive capital repair, rising to 93–95% in those apartment blocks with an average age of less than 25 years (IFC & EBRD, 2012). The need for renovation and modernization of housing properties in Finland mainly concerns apartment buildings built in 1960s and 1970s (Lindstedt, Kärki, Palmu, & Junnonen, 2011). A major issue in renovation projects is to minimize living interferences and the duration of renovation works cost-effectively.

There is an urgent need for development of efficient and low cost (prefabricated) solutions that are modular, customizable, prefabricated and industrially marketable. These will allow systemic retrofitting that can easily be applied in buildings and affordably maintained with minimum disturbances to end-users (Meno, Chica, Tapia, & Del Portillo, 2012). Industrialization does not necessarily imply the use of new materials, but new forms of application or combination of materials, and manufacturing construction components in facilities outside the place of the final assembly.

This paper introduces a multifunctional energy efficient façade system for multi-family apartment building retrofitting under development in a EC FP7 project Meefs: Multifunctional Energy Efficient Facade System for Building Retrofitting hereafter referred as the “Meefs” system. The Meefs system is still in the concept phase. We analyze the energetic aspect of the system to energy renovations in cold climate apartment buildings, classified by a building typology, and could it improve energy efficiency in these buildings. The analyses are based on case studies in two cold climate locations, namely Helsinki, Finland and Moscow, Russia. We also estimate the potential use of the solution as a part of holistic district renovations relevant in Russia.

Section snippets

Literature review

There are many aspects relevant to the scope of this paper. These include the climatic indicators used in energy calculations, methods to classify existing apartment buildings stock, and potentials and solutions for improving its energy-efficiency especially by means of façade retrofitting. This section will briefly review relevant information, on these themes, available on literature, to provide support and background for the further analysis.

The most widely used general climate classification

The multifunctional energy efficient façade system for building retrofitting (the Meefs system)

Fig. 1 shows the core idea of the Meefs system, i.e. it is an energy efficient non-intrusive façade concept based on multi-module technology components that will allow integrating both active and passive technologies in the façade. The retrofitting facade will be based on a combination of advanced active solutions with efficient passive design and materials as well as efficient energy management system. Every module will represent different energy efficient innovative solutions, and packaged

Building typologies applied

It is of vital importance to analyze which kinds of buildings and façade configurations exist in the targeted market areas. These form the bases on which the product development leans. In the following, we describe the properties of typical apartment buildings in Finland and Russia based on literature.

Energetic assessment of the Meefs system

For Helsinki, the energy load calculations were made during the initial stages of the Meefs project to allow the development planning. In this paper additional energy consumption analysis were made for easier comparison between Helsinki and Moscow, and for conclusions. For Moscow, the authors utilized the energy consumption results by Paiho et al. (2013) with complementary calculations. The energy consumptions of the buildings were calculated with WinEtana, which is a building energy analysis

Discussion and conclusions

This study focused on the building typological and energetic issues of the multifunctional façade systems in two Northern locations, namely Helsinki and Moscow. There are also other important aspects, such as mechanical resistance and stability, safety in case of fire and in use, hygiene, health and local requirements, as well as legal issues which were not considered. The analysis, for the cold climates, of the structural design and applied system materials will be the focus of another study.

Acknowledgements

The results of this study are based on work done in two projects: (1) the ModernMoscow project funded by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Finland. (2) MEEFS project (www.meefsretrofitting.eu) co-financed by the European Commission in 7th FP, NMP2-LA-2011-285411” and developed together with the following partners: Acciona Infrastructures, Tecnalia, AST ingenieria, Gobierno de Extremadura (Spain), E&L Architects, Greenovate Europe, CQFD Composites, TBC générateurs d’innovation, Antworks,

References (58)

  • Y. Matrosov et al.

    Standards for heating energy use in Russian buildings: A review and a report of recent progress

    Energy and Buildings

    (1997)
  • M.I. Nizovtsev et al.

    The facade system with ventilated channels for thermal insulation of newly constructed and renovated buildings

    Energy and Buildings

    (2014)
  • M.W. Opitz et al.

    Energy consumption and conservation in the Russian apartment building stock

    Energy and Buildings

    (1997)
  • S. Paiho et al.

    Energy saving potentials of Moscow apartment buildings in residential districts

    Energy and Buildings

    (2013)
  • S. Paiho et al.

    Energy and emission analyses of renovation scenarios of a Moscow residential district

    Energy and Buildings

    (2014)
  • S. Paiho et al.

    Cost analyses of energy-efficient renovations of a Moscow residential district

    Sustainable Cities and Society

    (2015)
  • N.S. Trumbull

    St. Petersburg, Russian Federation

    Cities

    (2013)
  • D. Ürge-Vorsatz et al.

    Potentials and costs of carbon dioxide mitigation in the world's buildings

    Energy Policy

    (2008)
  • B. Amaro et al.

    Statistical survey of the pathology, diagnosis and rehabilitation of ETICS in walls

    Journal of Civil Engineering and Management

    (2014)
  • Bank of Finland

    Interest rates on new housing loans decreased in June in line with the fall in Euribors

    Statistics

    (2014)
  • I.I. Bobrovitskiy et al.

    Hybrid ventilation in multistory apartment buildings

    ABOK Journal

    (2010)
  • L. Bosselaar

    Calculating the contribution of solar thermal towards the world energy supply

    We Should Harmonize the Methodology

    (2011)
  • I.G. Capeluto et al.

    On the determination of climate strategies for a multifunctional energy retrofit façade system

  • Y. Cronhjort

    Improving the energy efficiency of our built environment through retrofitting and urban infill: TES EnergyFacade in the Finnish context

  • R.G. Dascalaki et al.

    Building typologies as a tool for assessing the energy performance of residential buildings – A case study for the Hellenic building stock

    Energy and Buildings

    (2011)
  • EAE (European Association for External Thermal Insulation Composite Systems). (2014). About ETICS....
  • K. Eliseev

    District heating systems in Finland and Russia

  • European Commission. (2012). Joint Research centre, Institute of Energy and Transport, Photovoltaic Geographical...
  • Finland

    Energiatehokkuutta koskevien vähimmäisvaatimusten kustannusoptimaalisten tasojen laskenta. 20.5.2012. Rakennusten energiatehokkuusdirektiivin (2010/31/EU) 5 artiklan mukainen ilmoitus

    Euroopan komissiolle

    (2012)
  • Cited by (53)

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text