Elsevier

Science of The Total Environment

Volume 478, 15 April 2014, Pages 36-47
Science of The Total Environment

Does road salting confound the recovery of the microcrustacean community in an acidified lake?

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2014.01.076Get rights and content

Highlights

  • We examine if road salting modifies the biological recovery of an acidified lake.

  • The main driver of changes in microcrustacean community was reduced acidification.

  • Biological recovery of the study lake lacked behind an acidified “reference lake”.

  • Lower pH, Al and Ca did not explain the shift between the two dominating species.

  • We suggest that Cl may affect the community indirectly maybe in combination with TOC.

Abstract

Numerous boreal lakes across the Northern Hemisphere recovering from acidification are experiencing a simultaneous increase in chloride (Cl) concentrations from road salting. Increasing Cl may have profound effects on the lake ecosystem. We examine if an increase in Cl from road salting has modified the recovery of the microcrustacean community in an acidified boreal lake undergoing chemical recovery (study lake). Results from the study lake were compared with an acidified “reference lake”. The community changed during the study period in the study lake mainly driven by the reduction in acidification pressure. Despite the community changes and an increase in species richness, the absence of several acid sensitive species, previously occurring in the lake, indicates a delayed biological recovery relative to the chemical recovery. Moreover, changes in occurrence of acid sensitive and acid tolerant species indicated that the biological recovery was slower in the study lake compared to the “reference”. Although recurrent episodes of high aluminum and low pH and decreasing Ca are likely important factors for the delay, these do not explain, for instance, the shift from Cyclops scutifer to Bosmina longispina in the study lake. Although the contribution of Cl was not significant, the correlation between Cl and the variation in microcrustacean community was twice as high in the study lake compared to the “reference”. We argue that small, sheltered forest lakes may be especially sensitive to increased Cl levels, through changes in pattern of stratification, thus providing a mechanism for the shift from C. scutifer to B. longispina. The reduction of the acidification pressure seems to override the Cl effects on microcrustaceans at low Cl levels in salt-affected lakes recovering from acidification. However, prognoses for growing traffic and increasing road salting raise concern for many recovering lakes located in proximity to roads and urbanized areas.

Introduction

The structure and function of freshwater ecosystems are affected by a multitude of anthropogenic stressors (e.g. Palmer and Yan, 2013). One such stressor is acidification of rivers and lakes, which has been a major environmental problem in North America and Europe for more than 50 years (Schindler et al., 1989, Skjelkvåle et al., 2005). Atmospheric deposition of acid components has significantly impacted water quality, resulting in marked decreases in pH and alkalinity and increases in concentrations of sulfate (SO4) and a subsequent mobilization of toxic aluminum (Al). Impoverished water quality has been followed by reduced diversity of aquatic organisms, e.g. a general shift in invertebrate assemblages (Larsen et al., 1996, Sandin et al., 2004, Schartau et al., 2008) and the loss of a vast number of fish populations (Gjedrem and Rosseland, 2012). As a result of international agreements and actions, the emission of sulfur (S) has been reduced by more than two-thirds since 1980 in Europe (EMEP, 2011) followed by improvements in surface water quality (Monteith et al., 2014, Skjelkvåle et al., 2005, Stoddard et al., 1999). Although recent studies have attributed recovery of lake biology to decreased deposition of acidifying compounds (Hesthagen et al., 2011, Raddum et al., 2004), evidence of widespread biotic recovery is generally lacking (Gray and Arnott, 2009, Gunn and Sandoy, 2003, Skjelkvale et al., 2001). Studies performed in Europe and North America have demonstrated a delay in zooplankton recovery of 3–10 years, even after water quality has reached acceptable levels (see Gray and Arnott, 2009). Thus, acidification is still considered a serious threat to the biodiversity and ecosystem functioning of inland surface waters in northern Europe (e.g. Brodin, 1995, EMEP The European Monitoring Evaluation Programme, 2005, EMEP The European Monitoring Evaluation Programme, 2011).

Biological recovery from acidification is a complex process. A number of biotic and abiotic factors may delay the restitution of the biological communities. Species interactions may prevent or delay the biological response to improved water quality (see Lundberg et al., 2000). For example, acid sensitive grazers may be excluded from their former niche by acid-tolerant generalists that have occupied this role during the period of acidification. Suppression by invertebrate predators may cause failure of herbivorous zooplankton to respond to the improved chemistry of acidified fishless lakes (Arnott et al., 2006). In other lakes, the return of and the predation by fish may impact on biological recovery (e.g. Valois et al., 2010). Dispersal limitation may also constrain or delay the recovery of biological communities (Gray and Arnott, 2011). An example of an abiotic factor that can delay biological recovery is the mobilization and leaching of dissolved organic carbon (DOC, Korosi and Smol, 2012), observed in many lakes of the Northern Hemisphere during the last decades and which may reduce the water clarity. Another example is the declining level of base cations as a consequence of long term acidification, which might affect certain crustacean zooplankton species (Alstad et al., 1999, Hessen and Rukke, 2000).

Increasing salt concentrations may also affect biological recovery from acidification. Higher salt concentrations of surface waters can be caused by deposits from the sea or from runoff of de-icing chemicals from roads. Here we will focus on the latter. The by far most applied de-icing chemical is sodium chloride (hereafter termed road salt). In the Northern Hemisphere sodium (Na) and chloride (Cl) concentrations of surface waters have increased over the last decades due to increasing use of road salt (e.g. Evans and Frick, 2001, Molot and Dillon, 2008). Also, in Norway there has been a significant increase in the amount of applied road salt, and since year 2000 the annual amount has more than tripled (Kronvall, 2013) leading to increasing Cl concentrations in lakes (Bækken and Haugen, 2012).

Increasing salt concentration in lakes affects the ecological structure and functioning of the aquatic ecosystem both directly and indirectly. At high enough concentrations, Cl can increase the acidity of water, causing some of the same negative effects as acid rain (Löfgren, 2001). Higher salt concentrations may also favor more salt tolerant taxa (Blinn et al., 2004, Evans and Frick, 2001, Sarma et al., 2006). However, one of the most evident impacts of road salt on the aquatic environment is increased density stratification followed by altered circulation patterns and oxygen depletion in lakes (Kjensmo, 1997, Koretsky et al., 2012, Novotny et al., 2008, Novotny and Stefan, 2012). A recent survey conducted in Norway revealed that almost 30% of the investigated lakes had developed salt gradients and altered circulation patterns (Bækken and Haugen, 2012). Oxygen depletion of the deep water may in turn lead to mobilization of toxic metals and phosphorus from the sediments (Bækken and Haugen, 2012, Lewis, 1999). Increased salt concentrations may therefore indirectly lead to algal blooms because of increasing nutrient availability. So far most of the literature dealing with the effects of increasing salt concentrations on aquatic freshwater ecosystems has focused on relatively high concentration ranges (e.g. Van Meter et al., 2011). However, Evans and Frick (2001) noted that very small increases in Cl of 2–10 mg L 1 can affect phytoplankton community structure in low salinity lakes. In Norwegian calcium poor lakes effects on the phytoplankton community may appear at chloride concentrations of 23–30 mg L 1 (Haugen et al., 2011). Growth reductions of individual sensitive phytoplankton species occur at even lower concentrations (10–15 mg L 1, Haugen et al., 2011). A recent study of multiple anthropogenic stressors on Canadian freshwater zooplankton demonstrated effects of rising Cl concentrations on important zooplankton metrics at concentrations below 5 mg L 1 (Palmer and Yan, 2013). The effect of Cl at low concentrations may be exacerbated in a multiple stressor environment, e.g. recovering from acidification.

Numerous lakes across the temperate and subarctic zones in North America and Northern Europe undergoing chemical recovery from acidification are also experiencing a simultaneous increase in Cl concentrations due to deicing of roads during winter (e.g. Palmer and Yan, 2013). No studies have investigated if the biological recovery from acidification is affected by the increasing Cl concentrations in these lakes. The Lake Øvre Jerpetjern in Southeastern Norway (Fig. 1) undergoing chemical recovery from acidification is also influenced by road salts. Using monitoring data on water chemistry and microcrustaceans from this lake, we test whether the change in water quality (decreasing acidification and increasing Cl concentrations) over a 17 year period has affected the structure of the microcrustacean community. A comparable lake recovering from acidification but without influence from road salts was used as a reference. We hypothesize that increasing Cl concentration in the lake modifies the recovery of the microcrustacean community from acidification.

Section snippets

Study site

Lake Øvre Jerpetjern is located in Southeastern Norway in the county of Telemark about 48 km from the sea (N 59.60692°, E 9.42168°). The lake is situated at an altitude of 457 m.a.s.l. It has a surface area of 0.12 km2, and the maximum depth is 17 m (Fig. 1). The catchment area is 1.85 km2, mainly covered by forest consisting of spruce (Picea abies) and pine (Pinus sylvestris). The bedrock of the catchment consists of granite. One of the main roads between Southeastern and Western Norway, the E134,

Water chemistry

Chemical monitoring of Lake Øvre Jerpetjern from 1986 showed that the increase in the concentration of nmSO4 was followed by a decrease since 1991 with a subsequent increasing trend in pH and decreasing trend in LAl. Also the concentration of TOC increased. Moreover, the concentration of Ca has decreased from 1995 (Fig. 2). The changes in the acidification related parameters indicate that the lake has undergone a period of chemical recovery. Concurrent with the improvement of the acidification

Discussion

Lake Øvre Jerpetjern has been going through a period of acidification followed by chemical recovery from the early 1990s onwards. Wright et al. (unpublished results) calculated the original water chemistry (pH and acid neutralizing capacity (ANC)) in the lake before acidification started (1800) using the F-factor method (Henriksen and Posch, 2001). Their results demonstrate that with regard to these parameters, the lake shows only a minor departure from pre-industrial conditions from 2004

Conclusions

In Lake Øvre Jerpetjern, experiencing an increase in chloride, the microcrustacean community is recovering from acidification. Our analysis shows that the reduced acidification pressure was the main driver of the changes of the community. However, it is evident that the recovery of the community was lagging behind the chemical recovery, and was slower than in an acidified “reference lake”, not subject to road salt. Recurrent episodes of low pH and high LAl and a decreasing Ca concentration are

Conflict of interest

The authors of this manuscript declare to have no conflict of interests.

Acknowledgments

The study was supported by the Norwegian Institute for Nature Research and the Norwegian Public Roads Administration. “Monitoring of long-range transboundary air pollution” was financed respectively by the Norwegian Climate and Pollution Agency (Klif) and the Norwegian Directorate for Nature Management (DN) (now Norwegian Environment Agency). Erik Framstad and three anonymous reviewers provided valuable suggestions and comments on the manuscript.

References (90)

  • J. Bertilsson et al.

    Occurrence of limnic microcrustaceans in relation to temperature and oxygen

    Hydrobiologia

    (1995)
  • D.W. Blinn et al.

    Diatom and micro-invertebrate communities and environmental determinants in the western Australian wheatbelt: a response to salinization

    Hydrobiologia

    (2004)
  • D. Borcard et al.

    Partialling out the spatial component of ecological variation

    Ecology

    (1992)
  • Z. Brandl et al.

    The impact of predation by the copepod Mesocyclops edax (Forbes) on zooplankton in three lakes in Ontario, Canada

    Can J Zool

    (1979)
  • Y.-W. Brodin

    Acidification of lakes and watercourses in a global perspective

  • C.E. Campbell

    Prey selectivities of threespine sticklebacks (Gasterosteus aculeatus) and phantom midge larvae (Chaoborus spp.) in Newfoundland lakes

    Freshw Biol

    (1991)
  • R. Caroni et al.

    The potential of zooplankton communities for ecological assessment of lakes: redundant concept or political oversight?

    Biolv Environ Proc R Ir Acad

    (2010)
  • J.A. Downing et al.

    A manual of methods for the assessment of secondary productivity in fresh waters

    (1984)
  • K. Elgmork

    On the distribution and ecology of Cyclops scutifer Sars in New England (Copepoda, Crustacea)

    Ecology

    (1967)
  • K. Elgmork

    A monograph of life history strategies of the freshwater, planktonic copepod Cyclops scutifer G. O. Sars 1863

    Arch Hydrobiol Suppl

    (2006)
  • EMEP The European Monitoring Evaluation Programme

    Transboundary acidification, eutrophication and ground level ozone in Europe in 2003

    (2005)
  • EMEP The European Monitoring Evaluation Programme

    Transboundary acidification, eutrophication and ground level ozone in Europe in 2009

    (2011)
  • EN15110

    Water quality — guidance standard for the sampling of zooplankton from standing waters

    (2006)
  • M. Evans et al.

    The effects of road salts on aquatic ecosystems

    02–308: Saskatoon, Environment Canada — Water Science and Technology Directorate

    (2001)
  • D. Flössner

    Die Haplopoda und Cladocera (ohne Bosminidae) Mitteleuropas

    (2000)
  • T. Gjedrem et al.

    Genetic variation for tolerance to acidic water in salmonids

    J Fish Biol

    (2012)
  • D.K. Gray et al.

    Recovery of acid damaged zooplankton communities: measurement, extent, and limiting factors

    Environ Rev

    (2009)
  • D.K. Gray et al.

    Does dispersal limitation impact the recovery of zooplankton communities damaged by a regional stressor?

    Ecol Appl

    (2011)
  • J.M. Gunn et al.

    Introduction to the Ambio special issue on biological recovery from acidification: northern lakes recovery study

    Ambio

    (2003)
  • Haugen TO et al.
    (2011)
  • A. Henriksen et al.

    Steady state models for calculating critical loads of acidity for surface waters

    Water Air Soil Pollut

    (2001)
  • H.V. Herbst

    Blattfusskrebse (Phyllopoden: Echte Blattfüsser und Wasserflöhe)

    (1976)
  • D.O. Hessen et al.

    The costs of moulting in Daphnia; mineral regulation of carbon budgets

    Freshw Biol

    (2000)
  • D.O. Hessen et al.

    Calcium limitation in Daphnia magna

    J Plankton Res

    (2000)
  • M.O. Hill et al.

    Detrended correspondence analysis: an improved ordination technique

    Plant Ecol

    (1980)
  • F. Kiefer

    Copepoda non-parasitica

  • J. Kjensmo

    The influence of road salts on the salinity and the meromictic stability of Lake Svinsjoen, southeastern Norway

    Hydrobiologia

    (1997)
  • C.M. Koretsky et al.

    Redox stratification and salinization of Three Kettle Lakes in Southwest Michigan, USA

    Water Air Soil Pollut

    (2012)
  • J.B. Korosi et al.

    Contrasts between dystrophic and clearwater lakes in the long-term effects of acidification on cladoceran assemblages

    Freshw Biol

    (2012)
  • K.W. Kronvall

    Road salt and environmental hazards — identification of vulnerable water resources

  • J. Larsen et al.

    Quantitative relationships of invertebrates to pH in Norwegian river systems

    Hydrobiologia

    (1996)
  • W.M. Lewis

    Studies of environmental effects of magnesium chloride deicer in Colorado: Denver

    (1999)
  • S. Löfgren

    The chemical effects of deicing salt on soil and stream water of five catchments in Southeast Sweden

    Water Air Soil Pollut

    (2001)
  • P. Lundberg et al.

    Species loss leads to community closure

    Ecol Lett

    (2000)
  • J. LuningKrizan

    Selective feeding of third- and fourth-instar larvae Chaoborus flavicans in the field

    Arch Hydrobiol

    (1997)
  • Cited by (8)

    • Road effects on benthic macroinvertebrate assemblages in boreal headwater streams

      2023, Science of the Total Environment
      Citation Excerpt :

      Yet, chloride concentrations were more than four times higher at reaches downstream than upstream from road crossings (6.9 mg l−1 and 1.6 mg l−1, respectively; maximum: 20.8 mg l−1), and sodium concentrations were three times higher downstream than upstream (4.3 mg l−1 and 1.4 mg l−1, respectively; maximum: 12.1 mg l−1) reflecting salting of the roads by the Norwegian Public Roads Administration during winter. Sodium chloride accounts for >99.5 % of the used chemicals for winter maintenance of roads in Norway (Holen, 2010), and increased Cl concentrations due to road salting comprise a widespread and increasing environmental problem in Norwegian freshwaters in the vicinity of roads (Haugen and Bækken, 2012; Jensen et al., 2014). The differences in salt concentrations hence hinted at the possible existence of systematic variation in the degree of pollution between the study reaches, although it remained unclear whether the differences in the concentrations of the pollutants were large enough to cause measurable ecological effects.

    • Aquatic biodiversity in sedimentation ponds receiving road runoff – What are the key drivers?

      2018, Science of the Total Environment
      Citation Excerpt :

      For example, habitat quality can be altered through sediment loading (Angermeier et al., 2004) and pollutants released from transportation (Le Viol et al., 2009; Scher and Thièry, 2005). Runoff from roads contains a plethora of pollutants and is considered a major source of diffuse pollution (Bohemen and Janssen Van De Laak, 2003), causing negative impacts on the receiving water bodies (Meland et al., 2010a; Jensen et al., 2014). Therefore, the national road administrations as well as the environmental authorities consider pollution reduction to be important.

    • Current water quality guidelines across North America and Europe do not protect lakes from salinization

      2022, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text