Original researchIs the pink ball still under review? Cricket umpires’ perceptions of the pink ball for day/night matches
Section snippets
Practical implications
- •
This systematic investigation of elite cricket umpires’ opinions suggests that the visibility of the pink cricket ball is equal to or better than the red ball in traditional conditions.
- •
The results of this study suggest that the visibility of the pink ball is significantly better at night under floodlights from both bowler’s end and square-leg positions, and significantly better at night than at dusk from the square-leg position.
- •
The results indicate that the pink ball is suitable for day/night
Method
A cross-sectional survey study design was used to establish umpire perceptions of the visibility of the pink cricket ball in day/night matches. The white ball used in limited (50 and 20) over matches cannot currently be used in Test match cricket. The surface integrity and colour of the ball degrades significantly prior to the 80 over life span required for use in Test cricket. The white ball offers little to no contrast against the white clothing worn by Test cricketers. For these reasons, the
Results
Section A — Umpire characteristics
Participants (n = 27; age 50.9, SD = 8.1yrs; range 32−57yrs) had all officiated in first-class or International pink-ball matches (mean matches = 3.7, SD = 3.3, range 1–15) and so had experience of umpiring under the full variety of lighting conditions. When asked if they had previously undertaken any specific training in preparation for pink-ball matches, 11 umpires (41%) reported no specific training and 16 umpires (59%) reported that they had attended practice
Discussion
Anecdotally, some cricket umpires have reported that they find it difficult to see the pink cricket ball during dusk.1 This study sought to empirically investigate these reports using a cross-sectional survey with a purposeful sample of elite cricket umpires. Findings fail to support the anecdotal observations, with the visibility of the pink ball at dusk (and in the daytime) rated as being no different to that of a red cricket ball during natural daylight. In fact, elite umpires considered the
Conclusion
Elite cricket umpires reported no difference in the visibility of the pink ball and the red ball when umpiring from both the bowler’s end and square leg positions under natural light and at dusk under floodlights. The pink ball was reported to be more visible at night than the red ball under regular daylight conditions when umpiring from both the bowler’s end and square leg, with a significant increase in visibility compared to dusk when positioned at square leg. These findings differ from
Confirmation of ethical compliance
Ethical approval was granted by a Departmental Research Ethics Panel at Anglia Ruskin University in Cambridge, UK. The study adhered to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki.
Funding
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank Cricket Australia, The International Cricket Council, and The England and Wales Cricket Board for facilitating distribution of the survey. Thanks also go to all the professional umpires’ who kindly gave their time to complete the survey.
References (26)
- et al.
Is optimal vision required for the successful execution of an interceptive task?
Hum Mov Sci
(2007) - et al.
The resilience of natural interceptive actions to refractive blur
Hum Mov Sci
(2010) - et al.
When in doubt, it’s not out: match format is associated with differences in elite-level cricket umpires’ leg-before-wicket decisions
Psychol Sport Exerc
(2020) - et al.
Visual pathways to perception and action
Prog Brain Res
(1993) Sensitivity to chromatic and luminance contrast and its neuronal substrates
Curr Opin Behav Sci
(2019)- Ravi S. A pink-ball Test is like officiating five back-to-back ODIs. Available at:...
- Silgardo D. A brief history of pink-ball cricket. Available at:...
Evolution of the Kookaburra Pink Ball for the First Ever Day-Night Cricket Test
(2015)- Lalor P. David Warner the first player to object to second day-night Test. Available at:...
- Smith M. CA respects Rogers’ absence. Available at:...
The pink ball in cricket: a call to investigate the impact of ball-colour on visual-motor behaviour
SportRxiv Preprints
Cricketers are not tickled pink by the new coloured ball
J Sci Med Sport
Cited by (1)
Difficult at dusk? Illuminating the debate on cricket ball visibility
2024, Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport