Don't you say it that way! Experimental evidence that controlling voices elicit defiance
Section snippets
Controlling versus autonomy-supportive motivating styles and defiance
Central within Self-Determination Theory (SDT; Ryan & Deci, 2017) is the claim that human beings have the natural desire to experience a sense of choice and psychological freedom in their thinking, feeling, and acting. When people have this inherent psychological need for autonomy met, they report a myriad of positive outcomes, including improved well-being (Yu, Levesque-Bristol, & Maeda, 2018), greater engagement (Jang, Kim, & Reeve, 2016), and more flexibility and openness (Hodgins & Knee,
Autonomy-supportive and controlling communication styles
Autonomy-supportive and controlling motivating styles do not solely differ in the type of practices being used (e.g. choice, giving a rationale), but also through the way socializing agents communicate with those that need to be motivated. Yet, only a minority of studies has zoomed in on the role of motivating language per se, thereby identifying and examining the effect of the words used to convey the same message in more inviting, informational, and autonomy-supportive or more threatening,
Different tones of voice
Apart from this shortcoming, past research sheds little light on the role that tone of voice may play in the effects that these motivational messages have. As far as motivating language is manipulated through written instructions, it suggests that semantics suffice to elicit different reactions and outcomes among those reading the message. If instructions are orally provided, both the semantics and tone of voice may be driving observed effects (e.g., De Meyer et al., 2016; De Muynck et al., 2017
Present research
While many speakers may be considerate of the words they use to stimulate others to act, they might underestimate the effect of tone of voice, and this oversight is echoed by a research body that has largely focused on listeners' reactions to semantics rather than prosody in controlling versus autonomy-supportive motivational speech (see Voße & Wagner, 2018; Weinstein et al., 2018 for exceptions). One meaningful way to explore listener reactions to these motivational styles of communicating is
Participants
Ninety-five native English speakers (50 males; 45 females) were recruited on Prolific Academic (Peer, Brandimarte, Samat, & Acquisti, 2017) for an Internet survey.1 Previous studies show that survey respondents from online platforms such as this provide similar data to students and evidence higher intrinsic enjoyment of
Preliminary analyses
Age correlated negatively with defiance, r = −0.22, p = .04, while being unrelated to perceptions of speakers. Gender did not relate to either defiance or perceptions, ps > 0.40.
Primary analyses
A multiple analysis of covariance (MANCOVA) was conducted simultaneously predicting both outcomes, while entering gender and age as covariates.2 Overall, condition
Participants and procedure
One hundred native English speakers (58% female, mean age = 34.9 years; SD = 11.2 years) rated their perception of warmth, power and defiance on Prolific Academic. New to this study, along with preparing participants for listening to audio files as in Study 1, we also asked participants at the end of the study “Did you listen to all the sentences in the link provided earlier in the study?” to account for the possibility that participants had access to the audio file but selected to leave their
Preliminary analyses
An independent t-test indicated that women perceived speakers to be more pressuring, t(98) = −2.38, p = .02, while age related negatively to defiance, r = −0.22, p = .03. No other associations were present with gender and age, ps > 0.09.
Primary analyses
A multiple analysis of covariance (MANCOVA) was conducted simultaneously predicting all four outcomes, and controlling for gender and age as covariates.5
Participants and procedure
Two-hundred and eighty-five native English speakers were recruited on Prolific Academic. Of these 158 (55.4%) were female and ages of participants averaged, M = 36.2 years (SD = 19.2 years), comparable to sample compositions for the previous study and well-representative of the adult population in terms of these two characteristics.
Participants were once again asked whether they had listened to all sentences serving as experimental stimuli. We recruited 45 participants per condition for a
Analytic strategy
As in previous studies, primary analyses were conducted using ANOVAs, but this time models examined the main and interacting effects of motivational quality (Autonomy-Supportive vs. Controlling) and mode of communication (Semantics vs. Prosody vs. Both) since the study used a 2 (motivational quality) × 3 (mode of communication) design. PROCESS models examined direct effects predicting perceptions of speakers and defiance from motivational qualities, separately for each mode of communication.
Discussion
SDT and reactance theory (Brehm, 1966; Deci & Ryan, 1985) suggest that controlling motivational climates elicit defiance – a tense desire to resist influence, yet we have little understanding about whether and how this happens through the spoken qualities of motivating communications. Here, we tested the possibility that merely by using controlling tone of voice, motivating speakers could produce defiance, suggesting that speakers' use of tone may in some cases backfire.
Consistent with our
Conclusions
Despite these findings, the experiments conducted in this paper were only the second to test the extent motivational prosody characterized by either control or autonomy support impacts listeners' experiences (following Weinstein et al., 2018) and the first of which we are aware to study its intriguing influence on defiance, an outcome which directly speaks to the effectiveness of these two motivational approaches. Further, our findings that controlling tone of voice elicited defiance were
References (90)
- et al.
Nonconscious relationship reactance: When significant others prime opposing goals
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
(2007) - et al.
Do students with different motives for physical education respond differently to autonomy-supportive and controlling teaching?
Psychology of Sport and Exercise
(2016) - et al.
The general causality orientations scale: Self-determination in personality
Journal of Research in Personality
(1985) - et al.
Need satisfaction and the self-regulation of learning
Learning and Individual Differences
(1996) - et al.
Power and overconfident decision-making
Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes
(2012) - et al.
Influence of coaches’ autonomy support on athletes’ motivation and sport performance: A test of the hierarchical model of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation
Psychology of Sport and Exercise
(2010) - et al.
Impacts of autonomy-supportive versus controlling instructional language on motor learning
Human Movement Science
(2014) - et al.
Why students become more engaged or more disengaged during the semester: A self-determination theory dual-process model
Learning and Instruction
(2016) - et al.
When emotional prosody and semantics dance cheek to cheek: ERP evidence
Brain Research
(2007) - et al.
Coercive and supportive teacher behaviour: Within-and across-lesson associations with the classroom social climate
Learning and Instruction
(2011)
An ERP investigation on the temporal dynamics of emotional prosody and emotional semantics in pseudo-and lexical-sentence context
Brain and Language
Now listen to this! Evidence from a cross-spliced experimental design contrasting pressuring and supportive communications
Neuropsychologia
Beyond the Turk: Alternative platforms for crowdsourcing behavioral research
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
Preferential decoding of emotion from human non-linguistic vocalizations versus speech prosody
Biological Psychology
Beyond the right hemisphere: Brain mechanisms mediating vocal emotional processing
Trends in Cognitive Sciences
A theoretical upgrade of the concept of parental psychological control: Proposing new insights on the basis of self-determination theory
Developmental Review
The impacts of motivational framing of technology restrictions on adolescent concealment: Evidence from a preregistered experimental study
Computers in Human Behavior
The role of observed autonomy support, reciprocity, and need satisfaction in adolescent disclosure about friends
Journal of Adolescence
The personal sense of power
Journal of Personality
The impact of automatically activated motivation on exercise-related outcomes
Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology
Behavioral cues of interpersonal warmth
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
From external regulation to self-regulation: Early parenting precursors of young children’s executive functioning
Child Development
A theory of psychological reactance
Psychological reactance: Theory and applications
I won’t obey! Psychologically controlling parenting and nonclinical adolescents’ responses to rule-setting
Journal of Clinical Psychology
Attributional antecedents of verbal and vocal assertiveness
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Nonassertive expression of parental approval and disapproval and its relationship to child disturbance
Child Development
Nonverbal communication: The unspoken dialogue
Basic psychological need satisfaction, need frustration, and need strength across four cultures
Motivation and emotion
Untangling the links of parental responsiveness to distress and warmth to child outcomes
Child Development
Does observed controlling teaching behavior relate to students’ motivation in physical education?
Journal of Educational Psychology
The effects of feedback valence and style on need satisfaction, self-talk, and perseverance among tennis players: An experimental study
Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology
Facilitating internalization: The self-determination theory perspective
Journal of Personality
On the nature of reactance and its role in persuasive health communication
Communication Monographs
Scoundrels or stars? Theory and evidence on the quality of workers in online labor markets
The Accounting Review
A model of (often mixed) stereotype content: Competence and warmth respectively follow from perceived status and competition
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Ideals, perceptions, and evaluations in early relationship development
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Autonomy in children’s learning: An experimental and individual difference investigation
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Observing physical education teachers’ need-supportive interactions in classroom settings
Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology
Emotional versus neutral expressions and perceptions of social dominance and submissiveness
Emotion
Attentive Turkers: MTurk participants perform better on online attention checks than do subject pool participants
Behavior Research Methods
Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach
Guilford publications
The integrating self and conscious experience
Handbook of self-determination research
Autonomy and control motivation and self-esteem
Self and Identity
Cited by (18)
Unity in diversity: Exploring the effect of oneness with humanity on the willingness to donate to Syrian and Ukrainian refugees
2024, Personality and Individual DifferencesHow (de)motivating teaching styles shape message framing outcomes on students’ self-efficacy, emotions, and grades
2024, Learning and Individual DifferencesTeachers’ engaging messages, students’ motivation to learn and academic performance: The moderating role of emotional intensity in speech
2023, Teaching and Teacher EducationPredicting students' basic psychological need profiles through motivational appeals: Relations with grit and well-being
2022, Learning and Individual DifferencesCitation Excerpt :Therefore, if we want to reduce possible bias, data on the present study could be complemented with observational data on teacher motivational appeals. For instance, teachers' speech during classes could be audio-recorded and then analysed for target messages and, in line with previous findings, it could also incorporate analysis on teachers' voice tone (Weinstein et al., 2020). Third, our sample correspond to students that belonged to the secondary educational stage.
When body positivity falls flat: Divergent effects of body acceptance messages that support vs. undermine basic psychological needs
2022, Body ImageCitation Excerpt :That is, messages can empower people to be autonomous and authentic actors by emphasizing decision-making agency, choice, and cultivating inner resources, or they can coerce people toward a prescribed ideal using forceful tactics and pressuring language (Legault, Gutsell, & Inzlicht, 2011; Vansteenkiste, Ryan, & Soenens, 2020). We further suggest that, because the autonomy-support versus control framework underlies a broad subset of communication styles (Legate, Nguyen, Weinstein, Moller, & Legault, 2021; Legault, Gutsell, & Inzlicht, 2011; Vansteenkiste, Simons, Lens, Soenens & Matos, 2005; Weinstein, Vansteenkiste, & Paulmann, 2020), they are a useful platform from which to also understand body positive education more broadly. When targeting body acceptance, the other relevant psychological need is relatedness/acceptance – that is, the need to feel cared for and to be understood and accepted authentically and unconditionally (Deci & Ryan, 2000; Ryan, 1995).
The Psychological Science Accelerator’s COVID-19 rapid-response dataset
2023, Scientific Data