The Terramare and the surrounding hydraulic structures: a geophysical survey of the Santa Rosa site at Poviglio (Bronze Age, northern Italy)
Introduction
The Terramare are the archaeological remains of banked and moated villages of the Middle and Recent Bronze Ages (1600–1150 BC), located in the central alluvial plain of the Po River. They are evidence of a complex society, whose subsistence was based on intensive agriculture, pastoralism, and long-range trade (Mutti, 1993, Barfield, 1994, Bernabò Brea and Cardarelli, 1997, Cardarelli, 1988). It reached its apogee at the beginning of the Recent Bronze Age and, at the end of this period, it suffered a societal collapse that led to the abandonment of the villages in a few generations (Cardarelli, 2010).
The shape and the structure of the villages have been a main topic of the archaeological research focused on this civilisation, since the first seminal studies (Strobel and Pigorini, 1864, Chierici, 1881) and also in recent research projects (Bernabò Brea and Cardarelli, 1997, Pearce, 1998). The villages were supposed to have been built following sophisticated urban planning, as they are square in shape, with houses on posts that are distributed in regular rows, and enclosed inside earthen ramparts. They were supposed to be surrounded by a moat connected to an adjoining river through a canal network (Strobel and Pigorini, 1864, Chierici, 1881). This scheme is still under discussion (Pearce, 1998), but is supported by recent research on aerial photographs (Fig. 1) which show the existence of moats around most of the sites (e.g., Terramara Gaione – Mutti, 1993) and, in several cases, a direct connection with a neighbouring water course (e.g., Terramara La Falconara – Calzolari, 1997; Terramara Fabbrica dei Soci – Cremaschi, 1997; Terramara Castello del Tartaro – Balista and De Guio, 1997). At present, it is hypothesised that the moats were designed not only with a defensive goal, but also to collect water from the local fluvial network and distribute it to cultivated fields around the site (Balista, 1997, Balista, 2002, Cremaschi and Pizzi, 2007, Cremaschi and Pizzi, 2011, Ferri, 1989, Ferri, 1996), to sustain the irrigated agriculture on which the subsistence of the Terramare was based. The availability of water played a vital role for this culture, and it has been proposed that a dry climatic crisis is a possible cause of the disappearance of the Terramare (Cardarelli, 2010, Cremaschi, 2010, Cremaschi et al., 2006). Consequently, exploring the shapes of the villages and their relation to the moats and the fluvial network is of paramount importance to understanding the level of land exploitation performed by the Terramara culture on the surrounding landscape. Up to now, the knowledge about the shape of the sites and the presence of moats and ditches was manly based on aerial photographs, because subsurface surveys and archaeological digs extended at the site scale was lacking.
An archaeological project focused on these problems has been on-going since 1984 at the Santa Rosa site (Poviglio, Reggio Emilia, Italy; Fig. 2). At present, it is one of the largest archaeological excavations of European prehistory (Bernabò Brea and Cremaschi, 1996, Bernabò Brea and Cremaschi, 2004a, Bernabò Brea and Cremaschi, 2004b, Cremaschi, 2004, Cremaschi, 2013). An area of nearly 1 ha has been unearthed from a larger 7 ha site, and a detailed geophysical survey was carried out over the site and in its closest surroundings to extend the information on the archaeological structures that have been directly investigated (rampart, moat, general shape of the settlement) to the entire site.
Ground-based archaeogeophysical surveys have been successfully applied in archaeological exploration (Scollar et al., 1990, Kvamme, 2003). They provide a time- and cost-effective tool to delimit promising excavation areas and reduce the costs of excavation campaigns. Active and passive methods, such as direct current (Arlsan et al., 1999, Cardarelli and Di Filippo, 2009, Cardarelli et al., 2008, De Domenico et al., 2006), electromagnetic (Carrozzo et al., 2003, Conyers et al., 2008, Piro et al., 2003, Thiesson et al., 2009) and magnetic (Drahor, 2006, Gondet and Castel, 2004, Maillol et al., 2004) methods, can be applied in a wide range of geological environments and permit the non-destructive mapping of archaeological features. The effective identification of geophysical anomalies produced by buried man-made structures relies on vertical and lateral contrasts in the physical properties (such as electrical resistivity, magnetic susceptibility and dielectric constant) of the archaeological target and of the hosting medium (Kvamme, 2003, Reynolds, 2011). In other words, detecting archaeological features is most likely when the physical property contrasts are large.
The Santa Rosa site is located in an environment of fine-textured sediments, which can be considered a highly electrically conductive environment (McNeill, 1980a, Reynolds, 2011). Only slight lithological differences occur between sandy-loamy sediments, which characterise most of the investigated archaeological structures and the substrate sediments of the site, and the widespread flood plain cover (silt and clays). Thus, the main geophysical challenge is to identify small variations in electrical conductivity related to slight changes of sand content between the archaeological features, the substrate sediments and the flood plain cover. To achieve this goal, frequency domain electro-magnetic (FDEM) and earth resistivity imaging (ERI) methods were applied for two reasons: the use of time-varying and stationary fields could yield complementary information for the characterisation of heterogeneities in electrical conductivity and their application could yield different horizontal and vertical resolutions. The FDEM method was adopted to map the lateral transitions between the settlements, the hydraulic structures and the surrounding areas at the site scale. The ERI method was used to validate the electrical response of the site at a finer scale and to integrate additional information about the depth of the archaeological features, which cannot be directly evaluated by the FDEM method.
A description of the archaeological site is given in the following section. The third section is devoted to data acquisition and processing, and the results are discussed in the fourth section. The discussion of the results obtained from the integration of the geophysical interpretation with the archaeological and geoarchaeological data are presented in the fifth section.
Section snippets
Geomorphological context and structure of the site
The Terramara Santa Rosa is located in the Po alluvial plain, approximately 3 km south of the present-day course of the Po River and its alluvial ridges and inside a poorly drained area (Fig. 2) that was occupied by a swamp until the 15th century (Castiglioni and Pellegrini, 2001, Cremaschi, 2004). Geomorphological evidence suggests that this site was located near a palaeo-channel of the Po River that was active during the Bronze Age (Cremaschi et al., 1980, Cremaschi, 2004, Ravazzi et al., 2011
Methods
The application of ground-based geophysical methods at the Santa Rosa site was challenging due to the small variations in the physical properties that were expected in and between the archaeological strata and the deposits covering the site.
The area is characterised by the widespread presence of alluvial sediments with high clay content and the resulting surface electrical conductivity produced at shale–grain surfaces due to the excess negative charges typical of clay particles (Keller and
FDEM results
The FDEM survey provides large-scale mapping of the electrical structure of the Santa Rosa site and its surroundings. Although the measurements are characterised by some scatter at short distances along individual profiles (Fig. 6), plausibly produced by the very severe surface cracking typical of vertisols during arid seasons, the FDEM detected reasonable variations in apparent electrical resistivity at the length scales relevant for the archaeological investigation.
The map of apparent
The alluvial substrate of the Terramara
The vertical electrostratigraphic sequence of the site, obtained from the ERI transects (Fig. 11), allows the identification of the nature of the alluvial substrate on which the site has been built. The sequence consists of an alternation of metres-thick low- and high-resistivity units, which may be interpreted in terms of varying, although slightly contrasting, lithology. The electrically conductive fine-textured sediments are overbank deposits of the flood plain, and the intercalated,
Conclusions
In the case study presented in this paper, the electrical and electromagnetic surveys proved to be quite powerful tools. The FDEM and ERI data were able to recover subtle lithological differences in the sedimentary context of an alluvial plain. This allowed the reconstruction of the architecture of the alluvial deposits and of the archaeological structures of the Terramara, as well as its surrounding hydraulic network, which could not be observed at the surface due to being buried beneath
Acknowledgements
The excavation of the Santa Rosa site started as a rescue excavation and continued as a long-term multidisciplinary archaeological project directed by Maria Bernabò Brea and Mauro Cremaschi, promoted and funded by the Soprintedenza ai Beni Archeologici dell'Emilia Romagna, the Università degli Studi di Milano, Coopsette and the Municipality of Poviglio. In this paper archaeological and geoarchaeological parts are due to M. Cremaschi and C. Pizzi, geophysical parts to M. Mele, M. Giudici, A.
References (68)
- et al.
Geophysical investigations of the Olonium Roman site (Northern Como Lake)
Journal of Applied Geophysics
(1999) - et al.
Combining sedimentological and geophysical data for high-resolution 3-D mapping of fluvial architectural elements in the Quaternary Po plain (Italy)
Sedimentary Geology
(2007) - et al.
Integrated geophysical methods for the characterisation of an archaeological site (Massenzio Basilica – Roman forum, Rome, Italy)
Journal of Applied Geophysics
(2009) - et al.
Water management and land use in the Terramare and a possible climatic co-factor in their collapse. The case study of the Terramara S. Rosa (Northern Italy)
Quaternary International
(2006) - et al.
Integrated geophysical surveys at the archaeological site of Tindari (Sicily, Italy)
Journal of Archaeological Science
(2006) Integrated geophysical studies in the upper part of Sardis archaeological site, Turkey
Journal of Applied Geophysics
(2006)Heartland of Cities. Surveys of Ancient Settlement and Land Use on the Central Flood-plain of the Euphrates
(1981)Fossati, canali e paleoalvei: connessioni nevralgiche per l'impianto e la sopravvivenza dei grandi siti terramaricoli di bassa pianura
La paleoidrografia dell'area terramaricola centro-padana verso la fine dell'età del bronzo inquadramento stratigrafico, cronologico e paleoclimatico
Quaderni della bassa modenese
(2002)- et al.
Ambiente ed insediamenti dell'età del Bronzo nelle Valli Grandi Veronesi
The Bronze Age of Northern Italy: recent works and social interpretations in Mediterranean cultures during the Bronze Age
Le indagini 1983–1984 nella Terramara S. Rosa a Fodico di Poviglio (RE)
Padusa
Tredici anni di ricerche nella Terramara Santa Rosa a Fodico di Poviglio (RE)
Pagine di Archeologia
Le Terramare nel tempo
La Terramara di Santa Rosa di Poviglio nel corso del Bronzo Recente
Il Villaggio Piccolo della Terramara Santa Rosa a Poviglio. Scavi 1987–1992, Firenze
Le strutture abitative del Villaggio Grande – fase su palafitta – della Terramara di Santa Rosa di Poviglio (RE)
Capanne e spazi domestici del Bronzo Recente avanzato nel Villaggio grande della Terramara di S. Rosa di Poviglio
Rivista di Scienze Preistoriche
Carta Archeologica del comune di Poviglio (1986–1989)
L'ambiente e gli insediamenti dell'età del Bronzo nella bassa pianura modenese
L'età del Bronzo: organizzazione del territorio, forme economiche, strutture sociali, in Modena, dalle origini all'anno Mille
Studi di archeologia e storia
The collapse of the Terramare culture and growth of new economic and social systems during the late Bronze Age in Italy
Scienze dell'Antichità
Integrated geophysical survey to detect buried structures for archaeological prospecting. A case-history at Sabine Necropolis (Rome, Italy)
Near Surface Geophysics
GPR survey to understand the stratigraphy of the roman ships archaeological site (Pisa, Italy)
Archaeological Prospection
Note illustrative della Carta Geomorfologica della Pianura Padana
La Paletnologia italiana nel 3° Congresso Geografico Internazionale: Idrografia e Palenografia nella Provincia di Reggio Emilia
Bollettino di Paletnologia Italiana
Electromagnetic conductivity mapping for site prediction in meandering river floodplains
Archaeological Prospection
L'evoluzione di un tratto della pianura emiliana durante l'età del Bronzo, l'età romana e l'alto Medioevo: geomorfologia ed insediamenti
Padusa
Terramare e paesaggio padano
La Terramara di Santa Rosa e il suo territorio: aspetti geomorfologici
Qatna's lake: a geoarchaeological study of the Bronze Age capital
Foreste, terre coltivate ed acque, l'originalità del progetto terramaricolo
Ambiente, clima ed uso del suolo nella crisi della cultura delle Terramare
Scienze dell'Antichità
Terramara Santa Rosa di Poviglio Alluvial Site
Cited by (19)
Geoelectric, magnetic susceptibility, and geochemical survey as a tool to clarify the origin of Bronze Age water reservoirs at the Štěpánov hillfort, Czechia
2022, CatenaCitation Excerpt :Geophysical methods are widely used today as noninvasive tools for imaging of archeological objects (e.g., Leopold et al., 2011; Martínez et al., 2015; Urban et al., 2019). They also can be used for detecting former hydraulic network or natural water reservoirs (e.g., McLachlan et al., 2017; Mele et al., 2013; Uhlemann et al., 2016). The investigated Štěpánov hillfort is unique due to the presence of water at the acropolis and the bailey, but the origin of these three water reservoirs (WRs) is not clear (Šteffl, 2021).
Discovering ‘buried’ channels of the Palaeo-Yamuna river in NW India using geophysical evidence: Implications for major drainage reorganization and linkage to the Harappan Civilization
2019, Journal of Applied GeophysicsCitation Excerpt :Ancient civilizations mostly flourished on the floodplains of major river channels in different parts of the world (Heyvaert and Baeteman, 2008; Gangal et al., 2010; Mele et al., 2013a; Sanjurjo-Sánchez and Montero Fenollós, 2014; Macklin and Lewin, 2015; Ginau et al., 2018).
Lagoonal settlements and relative sea level during Bronze Age in Northern Adriatic: Geoarchaeological evidence and paleogeographic constraints
2017, Quaternary InternationalCitation Excerpt :Between MBE and the transition to FBA, in the central and eastern sector of the Po Plain, a prominent role was held by the Culture of Terramare (Fig. 1). The main villages of this cultural group were characterized by a sub-round or sub-quadrangular earthwork rampart, encircled by a large ditch (Bernabò Brea et al., 1997; Mele et al., 2013). In many cases the rectification and channeling of minor streams for feeding the perimeter ditch are documented (Cremaschi et al., 2006; Mercuri et al., 2006; Vanzetti, 2013).
Climate change versus land management in the Po Plain (Northern Italy) during the Bronze Age: New insights from the VP/VG sequence of the Terramara Santa Rosa di Poviglio
2016, Quaternary Science ReviewsCitation Excerpt :The interdisciplinary study has been carried out in order to obtain palaeoclimatic and environmental inferences from sediments and pollen assemblage. The moat and its fill played an outstanding role in the local hydraulic system of water collection and re-distribution at this Terramara (Mele et al., 2013). But its importance goes beyond this interest.
Palaeoenvironments and palaeotopography of a multilayered city during the Etruscan and Roman periods: Early interaction of fluvial processes and urban growth at Pisa (Tuscany, Italy)
2015, Journal of Archaeological ScienceCitation Excerpt :In that timeframe, the backswamps almost disappeared and widespread well-drained floodplain conditions developed across the urban and suburban areas in response to deforestation, pasturing, agriculture and waterworks (Roman Centuriatio). The geoarchaeological analysis of the Pisa landscape not only confirmed the strong inclination of past human communities to settle on topographically elevated areas close to river courses, as recorded in other Mediterranean alluvial and coastal plains (Arnaud-Fassetta et al., 2000; Bini et al., 2009, 2012; Bruno et al., 2013; Castaldini et al., 2009; Cremaschi et al., 2006; Cremonini et al., 2013; Maselli and Trincardi, 2013; Mele et al., 2013; Mozzi et al., 2010; Ninfo et al., 2011; Russo Ermolli et al., 2014), but also clearly documented the mutual reliance between palaeotopography and urban tissue evolution (Fig. 11). A large number of subsurface and surface geological and archaeological data processed through an interdisciplinary approach, including stratigraphy, geomorphology and archaeology, allowed for a high-resolution reconstruction of the Pisa natural–human landscapes during the Etruscan and Roman times.