ReviewComorbidity of personality disorders in anxiety disorders: A meta-analysis of 30 years of research
Introduction
Anxiety disorders (ADs) are one of the most common mental disorders with a 12-month prevalence of 18% and a lifetime prevalence of about 30% (Kessler et al., 2005a, Kessler et al., 2005b). Depending on the nature and severity of an AD, the concurrent debilitation of daily functioning and quality of life may become substantial (Ghaedi et al., 2010, Lochner et al., 2003). As avoidance of situations and/or other people are the cardinal behavioural symptoms of ADs, the immobilisation and isolation tend to increase over time. This eventually impedes the quality of social relationships and support (Hickey et al., 2005, Stein and Kean, 2000), which in combination with the primary AD symptoms contribute to the chronic course of the disorder (Beard et al., 2010, Perkonigg et al., 2005, Rubio and Lopez-Ibor, 2007, Wittchen, 2002), particularly if left untreated.
The comorbidity of other mental disorders appears to be the rule rather than an exception (Barlow et al., 1986), which partly derives from the secondary functional problems arising over time. In a study by Sanderson et al. (1990), up to 70% of the patients had at least one additional axis I diagnosis. The high comorbidity is striking. However, such estimates may be inflated as the current diagnostic system (i.e., DSM-IV or ICD-10) largely neglects communality in symptom clusters across diagnostic groups. Nevertheless, mental disorder comorbidity is considered negative for the natural course of illness by implying additional kinds of dysfunction (Coryell et al., 1988) depending on whether it is a disorder of mood, substance abuse or personality (Ansell et al., 2011, Brown and Barlow, 1992). These three are the most common comorbid disorders.
Comorbid depression mainly involves anhedonia and reduced motivation. Such clinical features may strongly temper the effects of treatment (Spijker et al., 2001), and in particular psychotherapy treatments requiring own efforts, such as behavioural homework tasks commonly used in for instance cognitive-behavioural therapy. A substance abuse disorder may represent a coping behaviour strategy and a negative reinforcement factor counteracting change in automated avoidance behaviour. This paper focuses however on the proportions of comorbidity of axis II personality disorders (PD). Such comorbidity may more profoundly affect the prognosis and outcome of an AD compared to any other axis I comorbid diagnoses (Reich, 2003, Telch et al., 2011).
One distinction between axis I and II comorbid disorders seems to be in terms of severity and complexity. First, the degree of fear and phobic avoidance (Dreessen et al., 1994, Kose et al., 2009) is usually more pronounced in patients with axis II compared with axis I comorbidity, as well as the level of general psychopathology (Dreessen et al., 1994, Ozkan and Altindag, 2005). This is also reflected in analyses of health care costs showing that axis II PD patients represent a markedly higher economic burden to the health care system than for example depression and anxiety patients (Soeteman et al., 2008). Moreover, having a PD represents a strong vulnerability factor for developing other axis I disorders (Stein et al., 1993). Second, treatment of comorbid PDs are normally more complex and less optimistic than treatment of axis I comorbidities due to less favourable outcomes (Reich, 2003, Slaap and den Boer, 2001, Telch et al., 2011), higher drop-out rates (Sanderson et al., 2002), less positive patient expectations (Martino et al., 2012) and more challenges with establishing a durable and flexible therapeutic alliance (Bienenfeld, 2007, Martino et al., 2012). Furthermore, the degree of comorbid psychosocial impairment depends on the type of PD. For example in a study of 668 PD patients, Skodol et al. (2002) reported a higher degree of impairment among schizotypal and borderline patients than among obsessive-compulsive or avoidant PD patients.
Several reviews of general associations between PDs and ADs have been published (Bienvenu and Stein, 2003a, Brandes and Bienvenu, 2009, Brooks et al., 1989, Stein et al., 1993, Van Velzen and Emmelkamp, 1999). The general conclusions from these reviews are that the comorbid frequency of PDs among patients with an AD diagnosis vary considerably, but that the proportions are highest in the avoidant, dependent and compulsive PDs (cluster C), and smaller in the schizoid, schizotypal and paranoid PDs (cluster A) and the dramatic, borderline and anti-social PDs (cluster B). Patients with cluster A or cluster B PDs also appear to have a poorer treatment response than cluster C PD patients (Hansen et al., 2007, Noyes et al., 1990).
Very few meta-analyses on the same comorbidity have been published. To the best of our knowledge there is only one previous meta-analysis by Ng and Bornstein (2005). They specifically examined the comorbidity of a dependent PD (mean r=11). However, the ratio varied considerably between AD diagnostic groups, with panic disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), agora- and social phobia showing a higher prevalence of PDs, while generalised anxiety disorder (GAD) and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) showed no relationship with PDs. The study was also criticised (Holmbeck and Durlak, 2005) for using a PD rather than an AD as the main inclusion criteria. The lack of previous meta-analyses using AD as the prime inclusion criteria, as well as studies that summarises the comorbidity of a PD across all AD diagnostic groups was therefore the main impetus for the present study. Additionally, we present data as proportions (equal to percentages), which represents a more user-friendly and intuitive effect size statistic.
The patterns of dysfunction and severity of a comorbid PD depend of the type of PD (Ansell et al., 2011). Panic disorder patients with or without agoraphobia are usually strongly confined to their home due to rigid avoidance of public, enclosed or open spaces (Rodriguez et al., 2007), hence constricting mobility and social participation. As avoidance is one of the core symptoms of a panic disorder, the avoidant PD is also one of the most frequent comorbid PDs (Brooks et al., 1989). An avoidant personality preference easily intensifies the primary anxiety problems due to the loss of exposure to potentially corrective experiences. A dependent PD is less common, but if present, the patient may develop an undue reliance on another person, hence representing a safety behaviour strategy. The undue reliance also affects reciprocity in the relationships with other people, which over time constricts the social network. Patients with a borderline PD have more intense panic attacks, and they also attract a lot more attention and concern from other people. It is also regarded as the single PD with the poorest prognosis for a successful treatment of a panic disorder (Nurnberg et al., 1989).
Patients with social phobia are overly afraid of negative evaluations and social embarrassments. Hence, they avoid or at least endure with great pain any situations that involve visibility or responsibility. The protracted avoidance and social withdrawal is also presumed as the prime reason for the lower socioeconomic status often characterising this group (Stein and Kean, 2000, Vorcaro et al., 2004). The avoidant PD is the most frequently occurring comorbid condition (Tillfors and Ekselius, 2009), which is expected considering the strong phenomenological overlap between these two diagnoses (Brooks et al., 1989, Reich, 2000, Rettew, 2000). However, in a review by Rettew (2000) the comorbidity estimates varied extremely, from 25% to nearly 100%. Clearly, this variation must be due to other factors than sampling error alone. Hence, we expected the avoidant PD to be the most prevalent comorbid PD in social phobia. Moreover, this PD is particularly related to a poor treatment outcome (Turner, 1987).
Patients with GAD experience constant worry and tension as their prime symptoms. Procrastination, avoidance behaviour and frequent reassurance seeking from others are typical compensatory strategies (Clark and Beck, 2010). Patients with social phobia and GAD appears to have higher rates of comorbidity than patients with panic disorders (Blashfield et al., 1994, Jansen et al., 1994). Cluster C PDs appears to be the most prevalent in GAD, particularly the avoidant and the OCD PD subtypes (Garyfallos et al., 1999). We therefore expected these to have the highest comorbid estimates. Like for social phobia, the avoidant PD also appear to be the most relevant PD predicting a poorer treatment outcome (Massion et al., 2002).
PTSD-patients are particularly prone to lapse into unhealthy behaviours by overusing alcohol or drugs to alleviate traumatic memories (Hidalgo and Davidson, 2000, Leeies et al., 2010), which over time leads to a poorer physical health and an overuse of health care services (Greenberg et al., 1999). A connection between PTSD and the axis II disorders avoidant (Ansell et al., 2011), obsessive-compulsive (Pietrzak et al., 2011) and borderline PDs have been established (Bienvenu and Stein, 2003b, Pagura et al., 2010, Shea et al., 1999), but also with paranoid and schizotypal PDs (Crepulja and Franciskovic, 2010, Pietrzak et al., 2011). Paranoid traits are understandable as PTSD patients often feel a constant need to be vigilant and on guard. However, the reported proportions vary across studies, to which the present meta-analysis may provide more reliable estimates.
OCD-patients are chronic sufferers who experience major impairment especially related to physical/occupational and emotional functioning (Hollander et al., 1996, Hollander et al., 2010). The degree of any PD has varied from 66% (Stein et al., 1993) to as low as 4% (Joffe et al., 1988), with the OCD PD as the most frequent comorbid condition (Alnaes and Torgersen, 1988, Samuels et al., 2000, Skodol et al., 1995). Obviously, a comorbid OCD PD may introduce a “double burden” in terms of intensified needs for order and perfection when performing OCD related checking or rituals in order to reduce anxiety.
From this brief outline of the literature, it is evident that a concurrent PD may impede both treatment and outcome of an AD, as well as possibly raising health care costs. The lack of previous meta-analyses covering all ADs, call for an empirical review to summarise and evaluate the current standing in the literature. It is also evident that the large between-study variation in the comorbid proportions of PDs across the various ADs, invite for a search for moderators that may explain this variability.
In the current study we examined the impact of diagnostic system (DSM-III-R versus DSM-IV), diagnostic methods (interview versus questionnaire), sample characteristics (patients receiving inpatient versus outpatient treatment), mean age of onset of AD and duration of AD. We expected higher comorbidity estimates from studies based on questionnaire data compared to structured interviews as that has been reported from PD comorbidity studies on for example eating disorders (Ramklint et al., 2010, Rosenvinge et al., 2000). Literature comparing the PD comorbidity between in- and outpatient samples is very scarce, except some findings indicating a higher degree of cluster B comorbidity in inpatients (Melartin et al., 2002). Hence, a clear-cut prediction could not be made, but the degree of comorbidity was expected higher among inpatients based on the psychiatric worse condition that an inpatient admission implies, particularly among patients with cluster B PDs. An early age of onset of an AD appears negative as it is associated with a longer duration of illness and a higher general symptom load in OCD (Wang et al., 2012), a history of childhood abuse and worse clinical outcome in GAD (Goncalves and Byrne, 2012), as well as generally higher comorbidity with other ADs (Klein Hofmeijer-Sevink et al., 2012). Moreover, early onset has also been related to higher comorbidity estimates between OCD and OCD-PD (Coles et al., 2008), between GAD and any PD (Garyfallos et al., 1999), and between social phobia and avoidant PD (Holt et al., 1992). Since the duration of an AD is partly related to the age of onset, we expected that an early age of onset and a longer duration of AD would imply a higher degree of comorbid PDs.
Hence, the paper had two primary aims: First, to compute mean weighted proportions of comorbidity between the major axis I ADs and all axis II PDs. Second, to examine whether any of the moderators described above could explain the variability reported in the literature.
Section snippets
Literature search
The current study was part of a larger meta-analytic project on the comorbidity between axis-I symptom disorders (depression, anxiety and eating disorders) and axis-II PDs. The databases PsychINFO, Embase and Medline were searched for scientific papers on the comorbidity between anxiety and personality disorders published in the period between 1980 and 2010. The following keywords were used: “anxiety disorder” OR “anxiety disorders” OR phobia OR “panic disorder” OR “obsessive-compulsive
Sample characteristics
Most studies were conducted in America (62 studies) and Europe (58 studies). Only seven studies came from other parts of the world. The five year publication rate was relatively steady with 19, 37, 22, 18 and 29 studies appearing within each period. The total number of patients in the 125 studies was 14 612. The study details are provided in Table 1. Most studies were conducted on outpatient samples (49%), while inpatient, a combination of inpatient/outpatient samples and recruited/community
Discussion
This present meta-analysis on the comorbidity of personality disorders (PD) in the major subtypes of anxiety disorders (AD), i.e., agoraphobia/panic disorder, generalised anxiety disorder (GAD), social phobia, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), obsessive-compulsive (OCD) and unspecified AD was based on 125 studies. Most data were collected from outpatient samples. Overall, the risk of having at least one comorbid PD (any PD) was high across all subtypes, ranging from 35% in PTSD to 52% in
Conclusions
Do we need more studies on the comorbidity of axis-II PDs? Probably not due to rather small confidence intervals for panic disorder with agoraphobia, social phobia, GAD and OCD. However, the number of studies on pure panic disorders and PTSD are low. As PTSD also stand out as a very heterogeneous condition, future studies on comorbidity should focus on PTSD and the possible reasons for the considerable heterogeneity observed. On the other hand, future PD-comorbidity studies may be needed in
Role of funding source
The work with the paper has not been externally funded. Funding has been provided internally by the Department of Psychology at the Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Tromsø, Norway.
Conflict of interest
None of the authors have any conflict of interests to declare.
Acknowledgements
None.
References1 (107)
- et al.
Personality disorder traits in generalized anxiety and panic disorder patients
Comprehensive Psychiatry
(1994) - et al.
Co-occurrence of personality disorders with panic disorder, social phobia, and generalized anxiety disorder: a review of the literature
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
(1989) - et al.
OCD with comorbid OCPD: A subtype of OCD?
Journal of Psychiatric Research
(2008) - et al.
Relationship between obsessive-compulsive personality disorder and obsessive-compulsive disorder
Comprehensive Psychiatry
(1997) - et al.
The impact of personality disorders on treatment outcome of anxiety disorders: best-evidence synthesis
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1998) - et al.
Personality disorders do not influence the results of cognitive behavior therapies for anxiety disorders
Comprehensive Psychiatry
(1994) - et al.
Clinical predictors of response to cognitive-behavioral therapy for obsessive-compulsive disorder
Clinical Psychology Review
(2008) - et al.
Clinical relevance of comorbidity in anxiety disorders: a report from the Netherlands Study of Depression and Anxiety (NESDA)
Journal of Affective Disorders
(2012) The relationship between panic disorder agoraphobia and personality-disorders
Psychiatric Clinics of North America
(1990)- et al.
The impact of comorbid mood and personality disorders in the cognitive-behavioral treatment of panic disorder
Clinical Psychology Review
(2000)
Comorbidity in generalized anxiety disorder
Psychiatric Clinics of North America
Comorbid personality disorders in subjects with panic disorder: Do personality disorders increase clinical severity?
Comprehensive Psychiatry
Comorbidity of borderline personality disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder in the U.S. population
Journal of Psychiatric Research
Personality disorders associated with full and partial posttraumatic stress disorder in the U.S. population: results from Wave 2 of the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions
Journal of Psychiatric Research
Anxiety disorders in women
Psychiatric Clinics of North America
Assessing personality disorders in eating disordered patients using the SCID-II: influence of measures and timing on prevalence rate
Personality and Individual Differences
The relationship of social phobia to avoidant personality disorder: a proposal to reclassify avoidant personality disorder based on clinical empirical findings
European Psychiatry
Psychometric characteristics of the Mobility Inventory in a longitudinal study of anxiety disorders: replicating and exploring a three component solution
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
What can be learnt from the natural history of anxiety disorders?
European Psychiatry
Hoarding in obsessive-compulsive disorder: results from the OCD Collaborative Genetics Study
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Patterns of anxiety and personality disorder comorbidity
Journal of Psychiatric Research
The effects of comorbid personality disorders on cognitive behavioral treatment for panic disorder
Journal of Psychiatric Research
The relationship between DSM-III symptom disorders (Axis I) and personality disorders (Axis II) in an outpatient population
Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica
The association of personality disorders with the prospective 7-year course of anxiety disorders
Psychological Medicine
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
Effect of axis II diagnoses on treatment outcome with clomipramine in 55 patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder
Archives of General Psychiatry
Co-morbidity and depression among the anxiety disorders: issues in diagnosis and classification
Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease
Characteristics and predictors of social phobia course in a longitudinal study of primary-care patients
Depression and Anxiety
An autistic dimension: a proposed subtype of obsessive-compulsive disorder
Autism
Cognitive therapy of patients with personality disorders
Psychiatric Annals
Personality and anxiety disorders: a review
Journal of Personality Disorders
Personality and anxiety disorders: a review
Journal of Personality Disorders
Comprehensive meta-analysis: Version 2.0
Comprehensive Meta-analysis (Version 2.) [Computer Software]
Anxiety disorders and personality disorders comorbidity
Reformulating PTSD for DSM-V: life after criterion A
Journal of Traumatic Stress
Comorbidity among anxiety disorders: implications for treatment and DSM-IV
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
Cognitive Therapy of Anxiety Disorders: Science and Practice
Depression and panic attacks: the significance of overlap as reflected in follow-up and family study data
American Journal of Psychiatry
Personality disorder in veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder—‘Ignored’ comorbidity
Socijalna Psihijatrija
Pre-treatment patient variables as predictors of drop-out and treatment outcome in cognitive behavioural therapy for social phobia: a systematic review
Nordic Journal of Psychiatry
The problems in using fixed-effects models of meta-analysis on real-world data
Understanding Statistics
Evidence-based guidelines for interpretation of the Panic Disorder Severity Scale
Depression and Anxiety
Psychiatric comorbidity in Greek patients with generalized anxiety disorder
Psychopathology
Quality of life in college students with and without social phobia
Social Indicators Research
Sooner or later: age at onset of generalized anxiety disorder in older adults
Depression and Anxiety
The economic burden of anxiety disorders in the 1990s
Journal of Clinical Psychiatry
Influence of co-morbid generalized anxiety disorder, panic disorder and personality disorders on the outcome of cognitive behavioural treatment of obsessive-compulsive disorder
Cognitive Behaviour Therapy
Cited by (129)
Factor structure of the Chinese version of the Screen for Adult Anxiety Related Disorders (SCARRED)
2022, Asian Journal of Psychiatry
- 1
Articles marked with an asterisk (⁎) are included in the meta-analysis only.