Rapid fraud detection of cocoa powder with carob flour using near infrared spectroscopy
Introduction
Cocoa powder, thanks to its characteristic and pleasant flavor and aroma, is one of the most valued commodities around the world (Bonvehí, 2005). Among its applications in the food industry, the formulation of beverages, confectionery, bakery and pastry products stands out (Shankar, Levitan, Prescott, & Spence, 2009). Apart from flavor and aroma, cocoa is highly appreciated as a natural coloring agent, partly because of the current tendency to restrict the use of artificial colors.
During cocoa processing, it is possible to modify cocoa color and aroma through roasting and/or alkalization processes. Roasting consists of exposing cocoa beans to temperatures of 130–150 °C for 15–45 min. It is used to inactivate microorganisms and to develop the characteristic brown color, mild aroma and texture of commercial natural beans (Afoakwa, Budu, Mensah-Brown, Felix & Ofosu-Snsah, 2014; Bonvehí, 2005; Krysiak, 2006). Alkalization is an optional operation to reduce acidity, bitterness and astringency, and to darken cocoa's color. This procedure involves using an alkali (generally potassium carbonate) in combination with oxygen, water and high temperatures. These extreme conditions provoke, among others, Maillard reactions and polyphenol oxidations and polymerizations, which end up with flavor and color modifications from light brown (natural) to red, dark brown or extremely black (Li et al., 2012; Miller et al., 2008).
In recent years, the demand for cocoa powder has increased and its supplies have tightened, thus its price has steadily grown (Fadel, Mageed, Samad, & Lotfy, 2006). Consequently, there is a demand to develop cocoa substitutes. Some studies suggest that cocoa-like aromas can be found in roasted carobs (Arrighi, Hartman, & Ho, 1997). Carob pods are characterized by a high sugar content (around 50%), composed essentially of sucrose. This high sugar content favors the same chemical reactions that occur during the roasting and alkalization of cocoa: caramelization of high sugar content and Maillard reactions between amino acids and sugars (Fadel et al., 2006). In this way, toasted carob can provide similar aromas to cocoa.
Bearing in mind this striking aromatic and visual similarity between carob flour (natural or toasted) and cocoa (natural or alkalized), some traders have seen that selling carob (average price of 940 US$/tonne) as cocoa (1945 US$/tonne), by omitting this substitution, is a profitable option to increase their benefits (ICCO, 2017). However, this deliberate, intentional and undeclared substitution of one product for another with a lower price is food fraud that not only affects producers and consumers, but also the physico-chemical properties of the manufactured product. Some studied examples comprise milk chocolates and chocolate cakes, in which some percentages of cocoa powder have been substituted for carob flour (Rosa, Tessele, Prestes, Silveira, & Franco, 2015; Salem & Ohaad Fahad, 2012).
To detect food adulteration, the three most widespread technologies are liquid chromatography, infrared spectroscopy and gas chromatography (Moore, Spink, & Lipp, 2012). Liquid and gas chromatography analyses need long sample preparation times, method optimization, and high-cost materials and reagents, while infrared spectroscopy is fast, reliable, less expensive and a chemical-free alternative (Ellis et al., 2012). Near infrared spectroscopy (NIR) is an infrared spectroscopy type characterized by recording reflectance or transmittance spectra within the region from 750 nm to 2500 nm. These spectra act as a ‘fingerprint’ that is characteristic of a particular sample molecule and allows its identification. Some examples of using NIR and multivariate analyses in the cocoa sector include the prediction of basic food components, such as moisture, carbohydrate, fat, protein, theobromine and catechin and total polyphenol content (Huang et al., 2014; Veselá et al., 2007; Álvarez et al., 2012). In other sectors, NIR in combination with a multivariate analysis has been employed to detect starch in onion powders, acid whey, starch, maltodextrin in skim powder milk, sudan dyes in chili powders, and talcum powder in teas (Lohumi, Lee, Lee, & Cho, 2015; Capuano, Boerrigter-Eenling, Koot, & van Ruth, 2015; Haughey, Galvin-King, Ho, Bell, & Elliott, 2015; Li, Zhang, & He, 2016).
In this context, the aim of this work was the rapid detection of the adulteration of cocoa powders, regardless of their alkalization level, with carob flours by applying NIR and a multivariate analysis.
Section snippets
Raw materials
In order to analyze a good representative set of samples of the variability in commercial cocoa and carob flour, cocoa powders with different alkalization levels (n = 12), as well as carob flour powders with three different roasting degrees (n = 6) were used in this study. The samples used were natural cocoa (NC), lightly alkalized cocoa (LAC), medium alkalized cocoa (MAC), strong alkalized cocoa (SAC), light carob flour (LCF), medium carob flour (MCF) and dark carob flour (DCF).
OLAM Food
Raw materials characterization
Table 1 contains the color parameters and pH values of the different raw materials. As observed, the obtained pH values ranged from 5.3 (NC1) to 7.9 (SAC3). According to these values and following the Miller Classification, twelve samples were considered natural cocoas (NC; 5 < pH < 6), three samples light alkalized cocoas (LAC; 5 < pH < 6.2), tree samples medium alkalized cocoas (MAC; 7.2 < pH < 7.6) and three samples strong alkalized cocoas (SAC; PH > 7.6). pH can be used as an indicator of
Conclusions
Near infrared spectroscopy (NIR) combined with PLS-DA and PLS statistical models has been shown to be a rapid effective method to identify adulterations of cocoa powder with Carob flour, regardless of the alkalization or roasting level. In contrast, these adulterations would not be readily detectable by routine techniques such as determination of pH analysis and color measurement.
With the PLS-DA analysis, all (100%) the samples were correctly classified into three groups: cocoa, carob flour and
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to acknowledge the financial assistance provided by the Spanish Government and European Regional Development Fund (Project RTC-2016-5241-2). Maribel Quelal Vásconez thanks the Ministry of Higher Education, Science, Technology and Innovation (SENESCYT) of the Republic of Ecuador for her PhD grant. The Olam Food Ingredients Company is acknowledged for proving part of the cocoa samples used herein.
References (45)
- et al.
Supervised pattern recognition in food analysis
Journal of Chromatography a
(2007) - et al.
Multivariate data analysis applied to spectroscopy: Potential application to juice and fruit quality
Food Research International
(2011) - et al.
Differentiation of Chinese robusta coffees according to species, using a combined electronic nose and tongue, with the aid of chemometrics
Food Chemistry
(2017) - et al.
The feasibility of using near infrared and Raman spectroscopic techniques to detect fraudulent adulteration of chili powders with Sudan dye
Food Control
(2015) - et al.
Latin hypercube sampling and the propagation of uncertainty in analyses of complex systems
Reliability Engineering & System Safety
(2003) Influence of roasting conditions on coloration of roasted cocoa beans
Journal of Food Engineering
(2006)- et al.
The effect of alkalization on the bioactive and flavor related components in commercial cocoa powder
Journal of Food Composition and Analysis
(2012) - et al.
A review of vibrational spectroscopic techniques for the detection of food authenticity and adulteration
Trends in Food Science & Technology
(2015) - et al.
Influence of data pre-processing on the quantitative determination of the ash content and lipids in roasted coffee by near infrared spectroscopy
Analytica Chimica Acta
(2004) - et al.
Chemometric models for the quantitative descriptive sensory analysis of Arabica coffee beverages using near infrared spectroscopy
Talanta
(2011)