Price-based demand side management: Assessing the impacts of time-of-use tariffs on residential electricity demand and peak shifting in Northern Italy
Highlights
► 1,099,839,168 quarter hour readings were downloaded from 1446 smart meters in the Trentino Province, Northern Italy. ► Following the introduction of TOU tariffs consumption increased by 13.69%. ► Consumers' electricity bills decreased by 2.21%. ► Peak load shifting took place for morning peaks and created a split in two peaks for evening periods. ► The majority of substations (75.6%) experienced an increase in electricity demand during peak periods.
Introduction
The recent diffusion of smart metering devices for residential consumers calls for research on how these can be integrated with price-based demand side management (DSM) programs. Price-based DSM programs, which are alternatives to flat tariffs, include critical peak pricing, extreme day pricing, real time pricing and time-of-use (TOU) tariffs [1]. The latter provide consumers with certainty about the price of consumption at different periods of the day, unlike other price-based DSM programs where the price fluctuates following the real time cost of electricity [2], [3]. This is a significant advantage, considering the risk-averse attitude to uncertainty on prices of most residential electricity users [4], [5]. Several studies investigated the relationship between TOU tariffs and energy consumption [6], [7], [8], [9], [10], [11]. Fewer studies have analyzed the relationship between electricity demand and load shifting impacts in connection with price-based DSM programs for residential users [12], [13].
This study assesses the electricity demand and load shifting impacts related to TOU tariffs. The specificity of this approach lies in the assessment of the impacts of TOU tariffs on electricity demand, price savings, peak load shifting and changes in electricity demand at sub-station level. The assessment is based on the comparison of time-related electricity consumption, prices and peak loads before and after the introduction of TOU tariffs from a dataset of residential consumers in the Province of Trento in Northern Italy. The comparability of the TOU and non-TOU (i.e. flat tariffs) samples is ensured by taking into account only data from the same seasons and controlling for weather temperatures.
The paper describes the main features of the TOU database from the Province of Trento (Section 2). It presents findings on impacts of TOU in terms of changes in electricity demand and price savings (Section 3), as well as changes in peak load shedding and demand for electricity substations (Section 4). It discusses findings (Section 5). It concludes by explaining some of the main policy implications of this research (Section 6).
Section snippets
Dataset on the Province of Trento
In Italy, TOU tariffs have gradually been applied to residential electricity users since the year 2010. The first pilot of TOU (tariffa bioraria) involved 4 million end-users. Lower tariffs are applied to weekends and to weekdays from 7.00 PM to 8.00 AM. The two tariffs (0.09982 cent/kWh and 0.07078 cent/kWh for peak and off-peak respectively) are designed to yield savings for end-users whose consumption is concentrated for more than 66% in correspondence with the lower tariff periods. The fact
Electricity demand
Average daily variations in electricity demand associated with consumers moving from flat tariffs to TOU can be calculated as the total sum of the area bounded between the TOU and flat tariffs demand curves. In principle, this could be determined as the integral of the two functions. However, since representing mathematical functions for these two curves is beyond the scope of this paper, the approach of linear interpolation is followed here for all available values. Interpolation would not be
Load shedding
The morning peak, which in year one typically occurred between 8.00 AM and 8.30 AM, is displaced under TOU by a new morning peak taking place between 6.45 AM and 7.15 AM. Hence, the introduction of differentiated tariffs triggers a significant load shed. What is more, both height and spikiness of the peak are mitigated thanks to TOU tariffs. Although this study does not feature qualitative data which might explain some of the causal relations between timing and use of appliances in the
Discussion of findings
Findings from 1,099,839,168 quarter hour readings downloaded from 1446 smart meters over two distinct years show that following the introduction of TOU tariffs (i) consumption increased by 13.69%; (ii) consumers' electricity bills decreased by 2.21%; (iii) peak load shedding occurred for morning peaks and created a split in two peaks for evening periods; and (iv) 75.6% of substations experienced an increase in electricity demand during peak periods.
There are atleast four implications to the
Conclusion
The non-voluntary participation to tariffa bioraria makes the results of this study particularly significant from a policy perspective as these provide evidence about the consequences of deploying large scale TOU as default tariffs. At the same time, the format of how the new tariff system was communicated to end-users through previous paper bills may not be sufficient to prevent problems with information. Other sources of information included a program in the local TV news, advertisements on
References (51)
- et al.
A summary of demand response in electricity markets
Electric Power Systems Research
(2008) - et al.
The effect of utility time-varying pricing and load control strategies on residential summer peak electricity use: a review
Energy Policy
(2010) - et al.
A review of intervention studies aimed at household energy conservation
Journal of Environmental Psychology
(2005) Effects of utility demand-side management programs on uncertainty
Resource and Energy Economics
(1994)- et al.
Energy efficiency actions related to the rollout of smart meters for small consumers, application to the Austrian system
Energy
(2011) Swiss residential demand for electricity by time-of-use
Resource and Energy Economics
(1995)- et al.
Evolution and current status of demand response (DR) in electricity markets: insights from PJM and NYISO
Energy
(2010) - et al.
The demand for residential, industrial and total electricity, 1973–1998
Energy Economics
(2004) - et al.
The value of reducing distribution losses by domestic load-shifting: a network perspective
Energy Policy
(2009) - et al.
Demand response in U.S. electricity markets: empirical evidence
Energy
(2010)
Demand side management for the European supergrid: occupancy variances of European single-person households
Energy Policy
A comparative analysis of time-of-use electricity rate effects: the Arizona experiment
Energy
Smart meter, customer choice and profitable time-of-use rate option
Energy
Dynamic structural analysis and forecasting of residential electricity consumption
International Journal of Forecasting
Environmental impact of building-related and user-related energy consumption in dwellings
Building and Environment
Consumer lifestyle approach to US energy use and the related CO2 emissions
Energy Policy
More efficient household electricity-use: an international perspective
Energy Policy
Analytical comparison between electricity consumption and behavioral characteristics of Swedish households in rented apartments
Applied Energy
Comfort theory and practice: barriers to the conservation of energy by building occupants
Applied Energy
The dark side of occupants’ behaviour on building energy use
Energy and Buildings
A high-resolution stochastic model of domestic activity patterns and electricity demand
Applied Energy
Identifying trends in the use of domestic appliances from household electricity consumption measurements
Energy and Buildings
Appliance energy standards in Europe
Energy and Buildings
Dynamic energy-consumption indicators for domestic appliances: environment, behaviour and design
Energy and Buildings
Decision-making in electrical appliance use in the home
Energy Policy
Cited by (279)
User's perspective in smart meter research: State-of-the-art and future trends
2024, Energy and BuildingsBidding strategy and economic evaluation of energy storage systems under the time-of-use pricing mechanism
2024, Journal of Energy StorageDynamic pricing in consumer-centric electricity markets: A systematic review and thematic analysis
2024, Energy Strategy ReviewsGetting beyond Net Zero dashboards in the information technology sector
2024, Energy Research and Social Science