Elsevier

Clinical Nutrition ESPEN

Volume 38, August 2020, Pages 280-282
Clinical Nutrition ESPEN

Short Communication
Tipping point: When patients stop eating and drinking in the last phase of their life

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clnesp.2020.04.012Get rights and content

Summary

Background

Eating and drinking are essential also in social life. Nutrition and hydration (N&H) at end of life are often a source of discussion and distress. Stopping eating and drinking is a defining element of the dying phase, however, this time point is not well defined. The aim of this retrospective analysis was to investigate whether such a time point can be detected, whether there are specific characteristics associated.

Methods

The time point when patients stopped oral intake was analyzed in relation to time until death on a specialist palliative care ward (sPCW) of a tertiary comprehensive cancer center. This “tipping point” (TP) was defined as the time point when total food intake fell below 25% of normal solid intake (TP-S) and “tipping point fluid” (TP-F) when fluid intake fell below 500 ml/day (oral/intravenous/subcutaneous). Demographic and medical data, the N&H-module in the electronic patient management system and the daily multiprofessional treatment notes at TP (±3 days) were analyzed in all patients cared on the sPCW between 1/15 and 9/17.

Results

In these 32 months, of 1194 treated patients 683 (57%) died on the ward. A TP-S was identified in 291 patients prior to dying on the ward (43%) with a median time of six days from to TP-S death. In 75% of these patients, TP-S occurred within two weeks prior to death (range: 0–5 weeks). A TP-F was detected in 202 patients (30%) with a median TP-F-time of two days prior to death. In 75% of these patients, the TP-F was within three days prior to death (range: 0–14 days). The cancer entities in patients in whom TPs could be detected were heterogeneous. No specific disease-related or sociodemographic characteristics for patients with TPs could be determined. In the daily treatment notes, oral and swallowing problems, taste alterations and discussions about stopping artificial nutrition were mentioned.

Conclusion

In less than half of dying patients a definitive TP could be detected. In these patients, TP-S occurred within two weeks and TP-F within few days before death. No specific characteristics of patients with TPs could be observed. This indicates the individual nature of the trajectory at end of life.

Section snippets

Background

Eating and drinking are preconditions for survival and essential elements of cultural and social life. Shared meals are connecting families and social groups.

Malnutrition is common in cancer disease and in treating cancer nutritional support is often needed. Patients are often reminded by families and health care professionals to eat and drink enough and if the patients are unable to do so, artificial nutrition is prescribed [1].

In end of life care, appetite and thirst diminish and it

Methods

This retrospective analysis was performed on a specialist palliative care ward (sPCW) of a tertiary comprehensive cancer center. All deceased patients, oncological or non-oncological, hospitalized on this ward between January 2015 and September 2017 were included. Patients that were discharged were excluded.

Demographic and medical data as well as the specific nutrition and hydration module in the daily nursing assessment system (ePA-AC©, result oriented nurse assessment for acute care) were

Results

From 2015 to 2017, 1194 patients were treated on the specialist palliative care ward.

A total of 683 patients (57%) died on the ward and were included for tipping point analysis. Median length of stay was 17 days for the deceased.

Characteristics of the included patients are displayed in Table 2.

A “tipping-point-solid” was identified in 291 of these 683 patients (43%) with a mean of 7.8 days (SD 7.6; CI 7.5–6.2) with a median of six days from tipping-point-solid to death.

A tipping-point-fluid was

Discussion

In the present report, a definitive tipping point solid/fluid could be detected in less than half of dying patients. In these patients, the tipping-point-solid lay within two weeks and the tipping-point-fluid within few days before death.

In recent years voluntarily stopping eating and drinking is an intensely debated way to hasten death and median time to death lays at around 7 days as reported by nurses and physicians in two surveys [6,7]. However, if patients still take little fluids survival

Conclusion

In less than half of dying patients a definitive tipping point, solid/fluid could be detected. Tipping-point-solid lay within two weeks and tipping-point-fluid within few days before death. No specific characteristics for patients displaying a tipping point could be detected. This underlines dying as an individual process and explains daily challenges in detecting the best time to change care strategy.

Funding and Acknowledgments

This study has been conducted without grants or funding.

David Blum and Karin Oechsle are responsible for design study, practical performance, data analysis, and preparation of the manuscript, all others were involved in the critical review of the manuscript, and none of the authors has a conflict of interest concerning this study.

References (10)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (0)

View full text