Co-development of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems during early childhood among child welfare-involved children
Introduction
Although prior research suggests that internalizing and externalizing behavior problems commonly co-occur, both concurrently and consecutively (Gilliom & Shaw, 2004), this has not been studied with child welfare–involved children who are at elevated risk for developing internalizing and externalizing behavior problems (McCrae, 2009). Internalizing and externalizing behavior problems in early childhood are of serious concern as early behavior problems tend to persist throughout childhood and adolescence (Ashford, Smit, Van Lier, Cuijpers, & Koot, 2008), serving as a marker for later psychopathology (Pihlakoski et al., 2006). Furthermore, children exhibiting continuous co-occurring internalizing and externalizing behavior problems are at heightened risk for experiencing subsequent negative outcomes, including peer rejection, association with deviant peers, engagement in risky behaviors, and substance use during adolescence (Colder et al., 2013, Fanti and Henrich, 2010). Examining cross-domain associations and early risk factors of internalizing and externalizing behavior trajectories during early childhood, defined here as the period from birth to 5 years (Votruba-Drzal, 2006), among children in the child welfare system is important to develop effective early intervention strategies that can promote positive development for these vulnerable children. Using parallel-process growth curve modeling, the current study aimed to extend the current knowledge base by investigating the developmental course of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems in early childhood and identifying risk factors among children involved in the child welfare system.
Children involved in the child welfare system are at a heightened risk for experiencing internalizing and externalizing behavior problems (Burns et al., 2004, McCrae, 2009). Internalizing behavior problems are characterized by inward-directed feelings and include symptoms of depression, anxiety, withdrawal, and somatic complaints, whereas externalizing behavior problems refer to acting-out behaviors directed toward others, such as aggressive and rule-breaking behaviors (Achenbach & Edelbrock, 1978). Despite a high volume of research indicating elevated levels of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems among children involved in the child welfare system (Aarons et al., 2010, McCrae, 2009), studies examining the developmental trajectories of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems in maltreated children are scarce, and the few existing studies have yielded inconsistent findings (e.g., Godinet et al., 2014, Kim et al., 2009, Thompson and Tabone, 2010). Furthermore, no research has examined trajectories during toddlerhood despite empirical evidence suggesting that most persistent and serious behavior problems develop as early as the toddlerhood/preschool period (Moffitt & Caspi, 2001). For internalizing behavior problems, two studies reported a similar trajectory pattern (a curvilinear, smooth inverse U-shaped trajectory), in which internalizing behavior problems peaked around ages 8 and 9 and slightly decreased afterward, following children from age 6 to age 14 (Kim et al., 2009) and age 4 to age 10 (Thompson & Tabone, 2010). In contrast to these studies, one study found a flat trajectory of internalizing behavior problems (i.e., no significant increase or decrease over time) from age 4 to age 12 (Godinet et al., 2014). Findings related to externalizing behavior problems have been more mixed, with Kim et al. (2009) reporting a smooth inverse U-shaped trajectory, Thompson and Tabone (2010) reporting a flat trajectory, and Godinet et al. (2014) reporting a declining trajectory. While these studies offer valuable information regarding internalizing trajectories during childhood, the samples used in the studies were geographically limited (Kim et al., 2009: a Northeastern city; Thompson & Tabone, 2010: 5 study sites in the U.S.). The current study addresses such limitations and extends the existing literature by using a nationally representative sample of children involved in the child welfare system.
Identifying early predictors of internalizing and externalizing trajectories is critical to preventing and reducing the development of serious internalizing and externalizing behavior problems over time. Previous studies have identified several early risk factors, including child maltreatment, intimate partner violence, caregivers' mental health problems, caregivers' substance use problems, out-of-home placement, and caregiver-child attachment (Dance et al., 2002, Godinet et al., 2014, Mian et al., 1996).
Early childhood maltreatment, including physical abuse (Egeland et al., 2002, Lansford et al., 2007), sexual abuse (Mian et al., 1996), emotional abuse (Dance et al., 2002), and neglect (Kotch et al., 2008) occurring in the first 5 years of life has been found to have a strong association with children's internalizing and externalizing behavior problems. However, longitudinal studies examining the influence of early childhood maltreatment on the growth factors (intercept, slope) of trajectories of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems have produced inconsistent findings. Thompson and Tabone (2010) found that early maltreatment (birth–age 4) predicted only the slope of the internalizing trajectory, but not the intercept, meaning there were no baseline differences of internalizing problem rates among maltreated and non-maltreated children, though maltreated children exhibited significantly greater increases in internalizing problems over time. On the contrary, Godinet et al. (2014) found that early maltreatment (birth–age 4) was significantly related to the intercept but not the slope of behavior trajectories in boys. Maltreated boys exhibited higher levels of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems at the initial assessment (i.e., age 4), but the rate of change in their behavior problems did not differ from those without early maltreatment experience.
Exposure to intimate partner violence (IPV) has also been related to elevated internalizing and externalizing behavior problems among young children (Evans, Davies, & DiLillo, 2008). Children younger than age 6 are particularly vulnerable for exposure to IPV, because they are more likely to be present in the home when violence occurs (Fantuzzo & Fusco, 2007). Using a sample of child welfare–involved children, Holmes, Yoon, and Berg (2017) found that exposure to IPV during toddlerhood was significantly related to increased aggression in toddlerhood and the preschool/kindergarten period.
Caregivers' mental health problems, including depression and anxiety disorders, are another well-known risk factor for children's behavior problems in early childhood (Avan et al., 2010, Edwards and Hans, 2015). A review of studies regarding the association between caregiver’ mental health and child's behavior problems suggested that parenting disruption was the central mechanism through which parental mental disorders transmitted to child's behavior problems. Caregivers' substance use also tends to increase the risk of children's behavior problems, partly due to compromised parenting capacity (Child Welfare Information Gateway, 2014). Parental substance use has been linked to children's internalizing (Fusco & Cahalane, 2013) and externalizing (Osborne & Berger, 2009) behavior problems during early childhood. Additionally, caregiver substance use was found to be predictive of children's worsening externalizing behavioral trajectory in a sample of 827 maltreated children (Tabone et al., 2011).
Early behavior problems among children in the child welfare system may be largely influenced by the arrangement of placement (Halfon, Mendonca, & Berkowitz, 1995). Studies have suggested higher levels of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems for children younger than 6 in out-of-home care (Simms, Dubowitz, & Szilagyi, 2000), with approximately 56% of children aged 2 and 40% of children aged 3–5 showing clinical levels of behavior problems in a nationally representative child welfare sample (Leslie et al., 2005).
Finally, caregiver-child attachment may exert strong influence on early childhood internalizing and externalizing behavior problems. Meta-analysis studies indicated a relatively large effect size for the association between insecure attachment and externalizing behavior problems, especially among high-risk boys (Fearon, Bakermans-Kranenburg, van IJzendoorn, Lapsley, & Roisman, 2010), and a significant association between insecure attachment and internalizing behavior problems, with small to medium effect size (Madigan, Atkinson, Laurin, & Benoit, 2013).
Prior studies enhanced the understanding of risk factors for early childhood internalizing and externalizing behavior problems, but these studies have usually used cross-sectional design, and rarely considered co-development of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems. Longitudinal cross-domain trajectory research focusing on young children in the child welfare system is needed to gain a better understanding of the course of behavioral development among these high-risk children and to provide them with most effective interventions to ensure their healthy and positive behavioral functioning.
A substantial body of research has indicated that internalizing and externalizing behavior problems commonly co-develop (Gilliom and Shaw, 2004, Keiley et al., 2000, Lee and Bukowski, 2012, Oland and Shaw, 2005), yet directional explanations of these relationships have been mixed. A robust body of literature supports a mutually reinforcing relationship, suggesting that the increase or decrease in one domain leads to the same trend of symptoms in the other domain (Gilliom and Shaw, 2004, Keiley et al., 2000). In these studies, as symptoms in one domain increase or decrease, so do symptoms in the other domain (Gilliom and Shaw, 2004, Keiley et al., 2000, Lee and Bukowski, 2012, Lee and Stone, 2012). A number of studies, in contrast, suggest a unidirectional relationship, with externalizing behavior problems leading to the development of internalizing problems (Boylan et al., 2007, Patterson and Capaldi, 1990). For example, Capaldi (1991) reported that early conduct problems predicted later depressed mood symptoms, but early depressed mood symptoms did not predict later conduct problems in an at-risk sample of 203 preadolescent boys. Conversely, others have indicated that internalizing behavior problems precede externalizing behavior problems (Bornstein et al., 2010, Ritakallio et al., 2008). A study of 117 children from an East Coast metropolitan area found that internalizing behavior problems at age 4 predicted greater externalizing behavior problems at age 14 (Bornstein et al., 2010). To date, the co-development and cross-domain relations of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems have not been studied with a child welfare–involved population, during early childhood in particular, which is a research gap worth future investigation.
In summary, little research has examined the co-development and cross-domain relations of internalizing and externalizing behavior trajectories among child welfare-involved children, despite the high prevalence of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems in this population (Burns et al., 2004, McCrae, 2009). Previous findings from general population studies on cross-domain relationships of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems have been mixed, with some studies reporting mutually reinforcing bi-directional relationship (Gilliom & Shaw, 2004) and others reporting one domain preceding the other domain (externalizing as an antecedent: Boylan et al., 2007; internalizing as an antecedent: Bornstein et al., 2010). While child maltreatment, child exposure to IPV, out-of-home placement, caregiver mental health, substance use, and caregiver-child insecure attachment have been identified as early risk factors for internalizing and externalizing behavior problems, the longitudinal impact of such early risk factors on the co-development of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems over time remains unclear. To fill the gaps in the literature, we sought to examine the cross-domain associations and early risk factors of internalizing and externalizing behavior trajectories in young children involved in the child welfare system.
We applied the developmental psychopathology perspective, which concerns the origins, course, and outcomes of an individual's functioning (Sroufe & Rutter, 1984). This perspective seeks to understand how children's early life experiences and subsequent environmental challenges affect their later developmental outcomes by emphasizing the concept of ‘developmental pathways,’ underscoring the importance of a process-level investigation of developmental outcomes (e.g., longitudinal trajectories) (Cicchetti, 1993). Drawing from developmental psychopathology, this study seeks to answer the following research questions: (a) What are the initial levels and growth rates of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems in early childhood among children who have been involved in the child welfare system? (b) How are the trajectories of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems associated across domains? (c) How are early risk factors related to the developmental trajectories of internalizing and externalizing behavior problems? The conceptual model is depicted in Fig. 1.
Section snippets
Sample
This study is a secondary data analysis using data from the National Survey of Child and Adolescent Well-Being (NSCAW-II), which is a nationally representative longitudinal study of children and families involved in the child welfare system. The NSCAW-II baseline sample includes 5872 children, ages birth to 17.5 years at the time of sampling, who were subjects of child abuse or neglect investigations conducted by child protective services (CPS) closed between February 2008 and April 2009.
Sample characteristics
A little less than half of the children were girls. Children were 2 years old at W1, 3.5 years old at W2, and 5 years old at W3. About 42% of the sample were White/non-Hispanic, 28% were Black/non-Hispanic, 27% were Hispanic, and 5% were other race. Approximately one quarter of the caregivers had less than a high school education. Descriptive statistics of study variables are presented in Table 1.
Unconditional parallel-process model
Fig. 2 presents the unconditional parallel-process model of internalizing and externalizing behavior
Discussion
Guided by the developmental psychopathology perspective, the present study examined the developmental trajectories of behavior problems (both internalizing and externalizing) and assessed early risk factors for those trajectories among child welfare-involved children from ages 2 to 5. It contributes to the field of child psychopathology by expanding our knowledge on co-development and cross-domain relations of internalizing and externalizing behavior trajectories in early childhood among
Conclusion
We found a positive correlation between internalizing and externalizing behavior problems in toddlerhood as well as positively correlated rates of change in symptoms throughout the early childhood period, with a group of early risk factors predicting these problem behavior trajectories. Taken together, the results of this study highlight the importance of comprehensive screening, assessment and treatment for young children, as they are likely to have co-occurring internalizing and externalizing
Acknowledgments
This document includes data from the National Survey on Child and Adolescent Well-Being, which was developed under contract with the Administration on Children, Youth, and Families, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (ACYF/DHHS). The data were provided by the National Data Archive on Child Abuse and Neglect.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
References (85)
- et al.
Behavior problems and placement change in a national child welfare sample: A prospective study
Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
(2010) Reliability and validity of temperament scales of the NLSY child assessments
Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology
(1995)- et al.
Mental health need and access to mental health services by youths involved with child welfare: A national survey
Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
(2004) Developmental psychopathology: Reactions, reflections, projections
Developmental Review
(1993)- et al.
Exposure to domestic violence: A meta-analysis of child and adolescent outcomes
Aggression and Violent Behavior
(2008) Prenatal depression effects on early development: A review
Infant Behavior and Development
(2011)- et al.
Primary care clinicians' use of standardized tools to assess child psychosocial problems
Ambulatory Pediatrics
(2003) - et al.
Early childhood maltreatment and trajectories of behavioral problems: Exploring gender and racial differences
Child Abuse & Neglect
(2014) Depressive disorders in maltreated children
Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
(1991)- et al.
Co-development of internalizing and externalizing problem behaviors: Causal direction and common vulnerability
Journal of Adolescence
(2012)
The clinical picture of depression in preschool children
Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
The effects of sexual abuse on 3- to 5-year-old girls
Child Abuse & Neglect
Continuity, comorbidity and longitudinal associations between depression and antisocial behaviour in middle adolescence: A 2-year prospective follow-up study
Journal of Adolescence
The impact of early alleged maltreatment on behavioral trajectories
Child Abuse & Neglect
Manual for child behavior checklist/ 4–18 and 1991 profile
The classification of child psychopathology: A review and analysis of empirical efforts
Psychological Bulletin
The early childhood aggression curve: Development of physical aggression in 10- to 50-month-old children
Child Development
Early risk indicators of internalizing problems in late childhood: A 9-year longitudinal study
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
Maternal postnatal depression and children's growth and behaviour during the early years of life: Exploring the interaction between physical and mental health
Archives of Disease in Childhood
The normative development of child and adolescent problem behavior
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
Social competence, externalizing, and internalizing behavioral adjustment from early childhood through early adolescence: Developmental cascades
Development and Psychopathology
Attachment and loss
Comorbidity of internalizing disorders in children with oppositional defiant disorder
European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
Parental anxiety and child symptomatology: An examination of additive and interactive effects of parent psychopathology
Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology
Co-occurrence of conduct problems and depressive symptoms in early adolescent boys: I. Familial factors and general adjustment at Grade 6
Development and Psychopathology
Extending parent–child interaction therapy for early childhood internalizing problems: New advances for an overlooked population
Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review
The insecure/ambivalent pattern of attachment: Theory and research
Child Development
Prospective associations of internalizing and externalizing problems and their co-occurrence with early adolescent substance use
Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology
Emotional abuse in early childhood: Relationships with progress in subsequent family placement
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
Tracing the cascade of children's insecurity in the interparental relationship: The role of stage-salient tasks
Child Development
Maternal depression, paternal psychopathology, and toddlers' behavior problems
Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology
Infant risk factors associated with internalizing, externalizing, and co-occurring behavior problems in young children
Developmental Psychology
The long-term consequences of maltreatment in the early years: A developmental pathway model to antisocial behavior
Children's Services: Social Policy, Research, and Practice
The relative performance of full information maximum likelihood estimation for missing data in structural equation models
Structural Equation Modeling
Trajectories of pure and co-occurring internalizing and externalizing problems from age 2 to age 12: Findings from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Study of Early Child Care
Development and Psychopathology
Children's direct exposure to types of domestic violence crime: A population-based investigation
Journal of Family Violence
The significance of insecure attachment and disorganization in the development of children's externalizing behavior: A meta-analytic study
Child Development
Learning to trust: Trust and attachment in early psychosis
Psychological Medicine
Child maltreatment and children's developmental trajectories in early to middle childhood
Child Development
Developmental and social-emotional screening in child welfare: Implications for young children in rural settings
Journal of Public Child Welfare
Parental substance use and the child welfare system
Codevelopment of externalizing and internalizing problems in early childhood
Development and Psychopathology
Cited by (23)
Academic achievement and relations to externalizing behavior: Much ado about nothing?
2022, Journal of School PsychologyCitation Excerpt :For example, Kjellstrand et al. (2018) used a sample of children with incarcerated parents and found four distinct trajectories, whereas Figge et al. (2018) used a sample from the Longitudinal Studies in Child Abuse and Neglect and found five distinct trajectories. Other studies, utilizing similar samples, have found three trajectories (e.g., Yoon et al., 2017). Although the number of trajectories has varied, studies have consistently found that the majority of children show low frequencies of externalizing behavior, and a smaller percentage of children belong to a high externalizing behavior trajectory.
Neighborhood influences on early childhood behavioral problems: Child maltreatment as a mediator
2022, Child Abuse and NeglectCitation Excerpt :Thus, a deep understanding of how the two types of neighborhood factors affect early childhood internalizing and externalizing symptoms will provide a solid foundation for future prevention and intervention efforts. Additionally, neighborhood factors were shown to be a strong predictor of child maltreatment experiences, which in turn, affect child behavior problems (e.g., Freisthler & Maguire-Jack, 2015; Pei et al., 2019; Yoon, Yoon, Wang, Tebben, Lee, & Pei, 2017). A literature review of 25 studies (Coulton et al., 2007) confirmed that neighborhood structures affected parental child maltreatment behaviors, which is consistent with various empirical studies (e.g., Maguire-Jack & Showalter, 2016; Molnar et al., 2016).
Longitudinal trajectories of behavioral problems among children in out-of-home care: A systematic review
2021, Children and Youth Services ReviewCitation Excerpt :In this paper, caregiver characteristics refer to out-of-home care caregivers (rather than birth parents). Characteristics associated with decreased problem behaviors included caregiver monitoring and supervision (Grogan-Kaylor et al., 2008; Stoner et al., 2015; Vis, Handegard, Holtan, Fossum, & Thornblad, 2016), while caregiver substance use and mental health problems were associated with increased problem behaviors (Seay & Kohl, 2015; Yoon et al., 2017). Interestingly, while it was hypothesized that caregiver resources and socioeconomic status would be an important factor for behavioral change, studies consistently found that caregiver resources did not make a significant difference to later delinquency, or that only extreme levels of economic differences resulted in statistically significance differences (e.g., family income exceeds 200% the poverty line compared to children whose family income fell under the poverty line) (Williams-Butler, 2018; Yoon, 2017).
Mental health services receipt among caregivers in the child welfare system: A longitudinal analysis
2020, Children and Youth Services ReviewCitation Excerpt :Among caregivers being served by the child welfare system, 16.8%–41.6% reportedly have a mental health problem such as depression (Garcia et al., 2015; Horwitz et al., 2013; Mowbray et al., 2017; Simon & Brooks, 2016; Staudt & Cherry, 2009). A caregiver’s mental health problem, including depression, has been associated positively with behavioral problems exhibited by that caregiver’s child (Garcia et al., 2015; Horwitz et al., 2013; Mowbray, Jennings, Littleton, Grinnell-Davis, & O'Shields, 2018; Yoon et al., 2017). A caregiver’s diagnosed mental health disorder has been associated negatively with likelihood of family reunification (Marshall, Huang, & Ryan, 2011).
Foster children are at risk for developing problems in social-emotional functioning: A follow-up study at 8 years of age
2020, Children and Youth Services ReviewCitation Excerpt :There are some empirical findings that support this claim. Yoon et al. (2017) found that initial higher levels of internalizing behavior were associated with higher levels of externalizing behavior among children aged 2–5 years. Further, in a study by Bornstein, Hahn, and Haynes (2010) children with more internalizing behavior at age 4 years showed more externalizing behavior when they were 14 years old.