Cooler tile-roofed buildings with near-infrared-reflective non-white coatings
Introduction
Owners of homes with pitched roofs visible from ground level often prefer non-white roofing products for aesthetic considerations. American Rooftile Coatings (Fullerton, CA) has developed non-white, near-infrared (NIR)-reflective architectural coatings that can be applied in situ to pitched concrete or clay tile roofs. These coatings can reduce tile temperature, building heat gain, and cooling power demand, while simultaneously improving the roof's appearance. Such NIR-reflective roof coatings can cool tiles while allowing choice of color by reflecting a significant fraction of the 52% of solar energy that arrives as invisible, NIR radiation1 [1], [2].
Widespread use of cool roofs can lower urban air temperatures, slowing the formation of smog and mitigating urban heat islands. This effect has been investigated in North America [3], [20], [21] as well as in Europe, Asia, and the Mediterranean [4].
Previous studies have measured and/or simulated reductions in cooling energy use and/or peak cooling power demand achieved by retrofitting dark-roofed homes with white roofs. For example, Parker et al. [5] measured energy savings averaging 19% for 11 Florida homes, while Akbari et al. [6] measured cool-roof energy savings exceeding 80% at a house in Sacramento. (The Sacramento house was unusual in that its walls were well-shaded by trees, making its roof the primary source of solar heat gain.) Konopacki and Akbari [7], Konopacki et al. [8] and Akbari and Konopacki [9] have simulated residential cooling energy and peak demand savings in many North American cities and estimate savings of about 10–20%, depending on the house construction and roof insulation. Cool-roof simulations have been used to develop the US Environmental Protection Agency ENERGY Roofing Comparison Calculator [10] and the US Department of Energy Cool Roof Calculator [11]. These online tools estimate cool-roof savings as a function of solar reflectance increase, building characteristics, cooling equipment, and climate.
Since cooling-power and energy savings are proportional to the increase in a roof's solar reflectance [8], white cool-roof savings can be scaled down to estimate savings achievable by (typically less reflective) non-white cool roofs. However, these savings are not directly applicable to tile-roofed homes, because the flow of heat from roof to building can be decreased by the (possibly ventilated) gap between the tile and the roof deck, and delayed by heat storage in the thermally manive tile [12], [13], [14].
The current study uses measurements from scale-model buildings to quantify the reductions in roof surface temperature, attic air temperature, and ceiling heat flux that are achieved by finishing roof tiles with NIR-reflective coatings. These data are then used to predict the energy savings that would accrue in various climates to full-scale homes roofed with NIR-reflective tiles.
We have monitored the interior and exterior temperatures of four adjacent, 1:10 scale, air-conditioned model houses sited in the hot, inland Southern California city of Riverside. The four buildings were roofed with concrete tiles finished with black, white, cool color (NIR reflecting), and standard color (NIR absorbing) coatings, respectively. The thermal performances of the buildings with matching cool and standard color roofs were compared to each other and to those of the black- and white-roofed reference buildings. From this comparison we characterized the thermal performance of the cool-roof tile coating, and extrapolated the results to estimate potential reductions in the peak cooling power demand and annual cooling energy consumption of homes in various California climates.
Section snippets
Reductions in roof surface temperature, attic air temperature, and ceiling heat flux
Neglecting thermal storage and linearizing the exchange of thermal radiation between the roof and its environment, reductions in roof surface temperature (K), attic air temperature (K), and ceiling heat flux q are proportional to the reduction in the solar absorptance of the roof, . That is,where I is insolation ; x is a thermal building property (, or q); and the property-specific sensitivity (coefficient) depends on the thermal resistances (hereafter,
Construction, installation, and instrumentation of the scale models
We tested four identical, 1:10 scale, single-room wooden houses modeled after desert homes. Each building had
a concrete tile roof mounted on a pitched deck;
a naturally ventilated attic;
R-11 foam-board insulation constituting the room's ceiling and lining the inside of the room's floor and walls;
an aluminum-foil facing on the top of the ceiling;
white exterior walls;
a thermoelectric air conditioner with a cooling output of 120 W , controlled by an electronic thermostat
Measured reductions in temperature and heat flux
The performance of each cool-roof tile coating was gauged by measured reductions (standard color value—matching cool color value) in the daily peak values of roof surface temperature , attic air temperature , interior air temperature of an unconditioned building, and heat flux q into the ceiling of an air-conditioned building (Table 2). The coatings reduced roof surface temperature by 5–14 K and ceiling heat flux by 13–21%.
The ceiling heat flux was computed assuming a ceiling undersurface
Discussion
Power savings (per unit ceiling area) were about half those reported for Florida houses with R-11 attic insulation [5]. This may result from
the high thermal resistance between the roof tiles and the roof deck, which adds about R-2 to the roof-to-interior thermal resistance (Appendix);
convective cooling of the roof deck by air flowing between tile and deck; and/or
natural attic ventilation in the model houses.
Conclusions
Application of NIR-reflective roof tile coatings yielded measurable reductions in roof surface temperature, attic air temperature, unconditioned interior air temperature, and ceiling heat flux. The coatings reduced peak roof surface temperature by 5–14 K and peak ceiling heat flux by 13–21%.
The coatings are predicted to save about 230 W in peak cooling power and in cooling energy for a Fresno house with R-11 attic insulation. The economic value
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the California Energy Commission (CEC) through its Public Interest Energy Research Program (PIER)/Energy Innovation Small Grant Program (EISG), and by the Assistant Secretary for Renewable Energy under Contract no. DE-AC03-76SF00098.
We would like to acknowledge the valuable assistance of David Wright, Atoya Mendez, Steven Lafund and especially Klaus Meister of Riverside Public Utilities; Dennis DeBartolomeo and Paul Berdahl of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory;
References (21)
- et al.
Solar spectral optical properties of pigments—Part I: model for deriving scattering and absorption coefficients from transmittance and reflectance measurements
Solar Energy Materials & Solar Cells
(2005) - et al.
Solar spectral optical properties of pigments—Part II: survey of common colorants
Solar Energy Materials & Solar Cells
(2005) - et al.
Cool surfaces and shade trees to reduce energy use and improve air quality in urban areas
Solar Energy
(2001) - et al.
Peak power and cooling energy savings of high-albedo roofs
Energy and Buildings
(1997) - et al.
Energy impacts of heat island reduction strategies in Toronto
Canada, Energy
(2004) - Santamouris M. Heat-island effect. In: Santamouris M, editor. Energy and climate in the urban built environment, James...
- et al.
Measured and simulated performance of reflective roofing systems in residential buildings
ASHRAE Transactions
(1998) - Konopacki S, Akbari H. Energy savings calculations for heat island reduction strategies in Baton Rouge, Sacramento and...
- Konopacki S, Akbari H, Pomerantz M, Gabersek S, Gartland L. Cooling energy savings potential of light-colored roofs for...
- EPA. ENERGY STAR® Roofing Comparison Calculator. 2004. Online at...
Cited by (201)
Building envelopes with radiative cooling materials: A model for indoor thermal environment assessment based on climate adaptation
2023, Journal of Building EngineeringDevelopment of composite-phase change microcapsule coating and numerical investigation on its effect in ballastless track slabs
2023, Construction and Building Materials