Ecological traffic management: A review of the modeling and control strategies for improving environmental sustainability of road transportation
Introduction
While energy-related air pollution is considered today one of the primary premature death causes (World Health Organization, 2016), the global carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions are on a rising trend destined to grow well above the levels imposed by the international climate goals (International Energy Agency, 2018). Population surge and economic growth of the developing countries have been identified as the main causes of the drastic increase of energy demand and pollutant emissions in all sectors (International Energy Agency, 2018).
The worldwide transportation sector alone accounts for 55% of the total liquid fuels consumption and, with the increasing travel demand, this share is not expected to decrease for the next two decades (U.S. Energy Information Administration, 2017a). In the member countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), projections show that the improved energy efficiency in transportation may lead to a net decline of about 2% in energy use until 2040, thus outpacing the predicted increase of vehicle-miles traveled (VMT). However, in OECD-Europe, transportation still represents the biggest source of carbon emissions (Transport & Environment, 2018), contributing about 25% of the total CO2 emissions, with cars and vans representing more than two thirds of this share (Mandl & Pinterits, 2018). The situation is even more alarming in non-OECD countries, where the transportation energy demand is expected to rise by 64% until 2040, implying an increase of about 15% of energy-related CO2 emissions (U.S. Energy Information Administration, 2017a).
Therefore, a lot of attention has been drawn worldwide to finding the most effective measures to help reduce the current contribution to greenhouse gas emissions from transportation. Governments, practitioners and researchers seem to agree on the fact that a combination of short-term and long-term strategies must be adopted. In the short-term, policies and regulations encouraging changes in behavior and travel habits represent a key lever. Attractiveness of alternative means of transportation should be enhanced, a shift to less polluting transport modes should be promoted, and a change in purchasing habits favoring smaller and more energy-efficient cars should be encouraged (Chapman, 2007). In the long-term, the widespread adoption of innovative technological solutions such as electrification, connectivity and automation are expected to enable a significant shift in the future of personal transportation and mobility. The way for such a technological transformation of mobility is already being paved thanks to the diffusion of connected and automated vehicles (CAVs), multi-vehicle (V2V) and vehicle-infrastructure (V2I) cooperation and communication networks, in- and over-roadway sensors, cloud-computing capabilities, etc. (Guanetti, Kim, & Borrelli, 2018).
However, the potential energy benefits of these technologies remain uncertain, mostly because of the high level of non-linear dependence between different aspects of an automated transportation system operating with conventional vehicles, as well as possible side-effects of automation (U.S. Energy Information Administration, 2017b). Among the features enabled by the aforementioned technologies that promise to increase energy efficiency and reduce pollutant emissions of transportation, it is worth mentioning eco-driving, eco-routing, platooning, roadway throughput optimization, powertrain electrification, vehicle down-sizing, parking search time reduction, ride-sharing. On the other hand, as for the side-effects that may endanger energy efficiency and emission reduction, it is likely that technology may increase traffic congestion as a consequence of an increased access to mobility, increase travel speeds as a consequence of enhanced safety, increase commute distances as an effect of increased comfort and reduced travel costs, etc. (U.S. Energy Information Administration, 2017b).
From a single-vehicle efficiency perspective, research suggests that lightweight, low-speed, autonomous vehicles have the potential to achieve fuel economies an order of magnitude higher than current cars (U.S. Energy Information Administration, 2017b). However, at system-wide level, current estimates suggest that the total energy consumption impacts can range from a 90% decrease to a 200% increase in fuel consumption as compared to a projected 2050 baseline energy (Brown, Gonder, & Repac, 2014).
Such a large variability in the possible outcome of the adoption of the new vehicular and traffic technologies makes it somewhat difficult to focus and prioritize the research efforts to increase energy efficiency of mobility. Nowadays, the general trend in research and policy seems to aim to reduce CO2 emissions by pushing for more efficient vehicles and reducing VMT. This is based on a generally accepted paradigm that congestion mitigation programs should reduce CO2 emissions. However, it is difficult to prove a clear direct proportionality between congestion and CO2 emissions (Fiori et al., 2018). The most reliable approach to improve energy efficiency and reduce pollutant emissions in the design of a traffic regulation measure consists in directly considering these aspects as decision and optimization criteria. Therefore, interest in transportation regulation problems with explicit environmental considerations is growing (Vreeswijk, Mahmod, van Arem, 2013, Wang, Szeto, Han, Friesz, 2018).
This paper surveys the existing scientific literature on energy consumption and emission models, as well as road transportation problems directly addressing the issue of energy consumption and pollutant emissions reduction. Such problems can be tackled at different levels depending on the granularity and the object of the control action. At vehicle level, the energy-efficient control strategies typically act on single vehicles or groups of cooperating vehicles by modifying their individual speed profiles or route choices. At traffic level, the control strategies aim to influence the vehicular flow as a whole by acting on the typical flow regulation actuators, such as traffic lights, speed limits, etc. The adopted categorization in terms of modeling and control approaches both at vehicle and traffic level for the general problem of reducing environmental impact of road transportation is illustrated in Fig. 1.
The contributions of this paper are summarized as follows:
- •
A comprehensive literature review of the existing energy consumption and pollutant emissions models is provided. The review distinguishes between data and physics-based models and discusses their adaptation for usage with both single-vehicles and traffic flow.
- •
An overview of the existing vehicle and traffic control strategies to improve energy and environmental efficiency of transportation is given. The review focuses on the control techniques that explicitly address energy consumption and emissions. The connection and interaction between traffic congestion and energy efficiency is also discussed.
- •
As an outcome of this review, research gaps in the current state of the art have been identified and discussed in order to inspire future works in this field.
The body of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the energy consumption and emission models for the single vehicle with a brief discussion of how the vehicle kinematics can be obtained. Analogously, Section 3 introduces the modeling approaches to describe traffic kinematics, with a particular focus on the most popular fluid-dynamics traffic models, as well as the energy consumption and emission models for vehicular flow. The energy-optimal control strategies for single vehicles are presented in Section 4, while the transportation problems dealing with traffic energy efficiency are reviewed in Section 5. Finally, Section 6 contains concluding remarks and discussion on the current research gaps and future outlooks.
Section snippets
Emission and energy consumption models for single vehicles
Different models estimating emissions and energy consumption rate (Jy) of a vehicle as a function of its parameters and operation variables (u) have been investigated in the past. This section presents the data-driven and the physical modeling approaches employed to estimate Jy.
In the proposed formalization, Jy refers to the prediction of the rate of y, which can be calculated per distance traveled by the vehicle () or per time unit (), depending on the modeling method. y
Emission and energy consumption models for traffic vehicular flows
The emission and energy consumption models presented in Section 2 are microscopic. They estimate emissions and energy consumption based on the instantaneous operating variables of individual vehicles, that can be obtained through microscopic traffic models. But on a network scale, they have the known disadvantage of high computational load, as their computation time increases sharply with the number of vehicles. The instantaneous operating variables can also be measured, but the data for so
Single vehicles control design for emission and energy consumption reduction
In Sections 2 and 3, emission and energy consumption models have been presented for single vehicles and for traffic flows. In this section, we review some control strategies for single vehicles aiming at limiting emissions and energy consumption. They can be mostly categorized into eco-driving, i.e. computing a vehicle speed trajectory that minimizes the emissions or energy consumption along a given route, and eco-routing, i.e. planning a minimum energy or emissions route. An excellent overview
Traffic flow control design for emission and energy consumption reduction
In Section 4, we presented vehicle-based control designs aiming at reducing the emissions and energy consumption of a single vehicle. In this section, we review some road-based control strategies to reduce the environmental impact on a large spatial scale and for a large number of vehicles. These strategies consist in regulating vehicular flow by controlling speed limits, traffic-light duty cycles or offsets, split ratios at intersections or bifurcations, or mobile actuators (e.g. autonomous
Conclusion and outlook
The current situation regarding pollutant emissions and energy consumption of road transportation is alarming both for environmental and health reasons. Ecological traffic management appears to be a promising lever in the long-term to reduce the environmental impact of transportation.
This paper surveys the existing emission and energy consumption models, as well as the traffic control strategies to reduce them, either by considering vehicles independently, or by considering traffic flows. The
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors certify that they have NO affiliations with or involvement in any organization or entity with any financial interest (such as honoraria; educational grants; participation in speakers’ bureaus; membership, employment, consultancies, stock ownership, or other equity interest; and expert testimony or patent-licensing arrangements), or non-financial interest (such as personal or professional relationships, affiliations, knowledge or beliefs) in the subject matter or materials discussed
Acknowledgment
This project has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (grant agreement 694209).
References (152)
- et al.
Store-and-forward based methods for the signal control problem in large-scale congested urban road networks
Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies
(2009) - et al.
The effects of route choice decisions on vehicle energy consumption and emissions
Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment
(2008) - et al.
A variable-length cell transmission model for road traffic systems
Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies
(2018) Transport and climate change: A review
Journal of Transport Geography
(2007)- et al.
Modeling and optimal control of travel times and traffic emission on freeways
IFAC Proceedings Volumes
(2011) Requiem for second-order fluid approximations of traffic flow
Transportation Research Part B: Methodological
(1995)- et al.
Urban traffic eco-driving: A macroscopic steady-state analysis
European Control Conference (ECC), 2014
(2014) - et al.
Optimizing route choice for lowest fuel consumption’ potential effects of a new driver support tool
Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies
(2006) - et al.
First-order macroscopic traffic models
Freeway traffic modelling and control, chapter 3
(2018) - Hausberger, S. (2009). Emission factors from the model PHEM for the HBEFAversion...
Improved fluid-dynamic model for vehicular traffic
Physical Review E
Coupling conditions for a class of second-order models for traffic flow
SIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis
Sustainable model-predictive control in urban traffic networks: Efficient solution based on general smoothening methods
IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology
Energy optimal real-time navigation system
IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems Magazine
Variable speed limit: an overview
Transportation Letters
Performance of current eco-routing methods
Intelligent vehicles symposium (IV), 2016 IEEE
Eco-platooning of autonomous electrical vehicles using distributed model predictive control
Parameters
Integrated urban traffic control for the reduction of travel delays and emissions
IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems
Can autonomous vehicle reduce greenhouse gas emissions? a country-level evaluation
Energy Policy
Network effects of intelligent speed adaptation systems
Transportation
Reducing idling at red lights based on probabilistic prediction of traffic signal timings
American control conference (ACC), 2012
Theoretical study on eco-driving technique for an electric vehicle considering traffic signals
Power electronics and drive systems (PEDS), 2011 IEEE ninth international conference on
A simplified theory of kinematic waves in highway traffic, part i: General theory
Transportation Research Part B: Methodological
Modelling instantaneous traffic emission and the influence of traffic speed limits
Science of the Total Environment
Microscopic fuel consumption and emission modeling
Microframework for modeling of high-emitting vehicles
Transportation Research Record
Applying vehicular networks for reduced vehicle fuel consumption and co2 emissions
Intelligent transportation systems
Development of comprehensive modal emissions model: Operating under hot-stabilized conditions
Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
Ecotour: Reducing the environmental footprint of vehicles using eco-routes
Mobile data management (MDM), 2013 IEEE 14th international conference on
Relative influence of acceleration and speed on emissions under actual driving conditions
International Journal of Vehicle Design
Resurrection of second order models of traffic flow
SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics
Modal emissions modeling: A physical approach
Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
Real-world carbon dioxide impacts of traffic congestion
Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
Integrated traffic control for mixed urban and freeway networks: A model predictive control approach
European Journal of Transport and Infrastructure Research EJTIR
Dynamic programming and optimal control
Application of an optimal control problem to a trip-based energy management for electric vehicles
SAE International Journal of Alternative Powertrains
Public policy of urban mobility: Impact of the history and practices on young drivers’ social representation of 30 km/h
Journal of Nonprofit & Public Sector Marketing
Eco-routing navigation system based on multisource historical and real-time traffic information
IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems
An analysis of possible energy impacts of automated vehicles
Hybrid microscopic-mesoscopic traffic simulation
Best-effort highway traffic congestion control via variable speed limits
Decision and control and European control conference (CDC-ECC), 2011 50th IEEE conference on
Hyperbolic phase transitions in traffic flow
SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics
The cell transmission model: A dynamic representation of highway traffic consistent with the hydrodynamic theory
Transportation Research Part B: Methodological
Eco-driving in urban traffic networks using traffic signals information
International Journal of Robust and Nonlinear Control
Arterial bandwidth maximization via signal offsets and variable speed limits control
54th Annual Conference on Decision and Control (CDC)
An application of shock wave theory to urban traffic control via dynamic speed advisory
heart 2017: 6th symposium of the European association for research in transportation
Bi-objective eco-routing in large urban road networks
2017 IEEE 20th international conference on intelligent transportation systems (ITSC)
Evaluation of the energy efficiency of a fleet of electric vehicle for eco-driving application
Oil & Gas Science and Technology–Revue d’IFP Energies nouvelles
Intelligent transportation systems
IEEE Vehicular Technology Magazine
Cited by (37)
Tackling urban freight distribution: A public-private perspective
2024, Research in Transportation Business and ManagementPowering up urban mobility: A comparative study of energy efficiency in electric and diesel buses across various lane configurations
2024, Sustainable Cities and SocietyAdoption of energy consumption in urban mobility considering digital carbon footprint: A two-phase interval-valued Fermatean fuzzy dominance methodology
2023, Engineering Applications of Artificial IntelligenceBenchmarking the driver acceleration impact on vehicle energy consumption and CO<inf>2</inf> emissions
2022, Transportation Research Part D: Transport and EnvironmentAssessment and key factors of urban liveability in underdeveloped regions: A case study of the Loess Plateau, China
2022, Sustainable Cities and SocietyControl for smart systems: Challenges and trends in smart cities
2022, Annual Reviews in Control