Full length articleEnergy dissipation in mammalian collagen fibrils: Cyclic strain-induced damping, toughening, and strengthening
Graphical abstract
Introduction
Collagen serves as the hierarchical building block of structural mammalian tissues [1]. This hierarchy begins with tropocollagen molecules (1.5 nm in diameter) that assemble into collagen fibrils (10 s to 100 s of nm in diameter) having a D-band structure with 67 nm repeated spacing [2], [3], [4]. The hierarchy continues across the length scales to fascicles (bundles of fibrils with micrometer diameter) and tissues (millimeters in diameter) [5], [6], [7]. Although the bulk mechanical properties of such tissues are well described, the hierarchical underpinnings continue to be the focus of research, especially at the nanoscale [8], [9], [12]. Although molecular dynamics predictions and experimental measurements of the low strain elastic behavior of hydrated collagen fibrils [14], [15] are well established, their low and high strain response to cyclic loading remains unknown. Measurement of the dynamic response of collagen fibrils under cyclical forces, which is the focus of the current study, is important because tissues in our body experience mechanical cycling due, for instance, to cardiovascular outputs and routine movement.
The levels of strain transferred across the different hierarchies to the collagen fibrils are not definitively known, but are typically understood to span a broad distribution within a single tissue [16], [17]. Mature collagen fibrils subjected to tension in fully hydrated environment have been shown to exhibit one, or more, of the following regimes of deformation: (a) An initial, nonlinear, toe regime followed by a nonlinear “heel” regime in which micrometer and nanometer level crimps straighten [7], [13], [15], [18]; (b) an initial loading regime (often referred to as a “linear” regime) in which tropocollagen molecule uncoiling, assisted by a reduction in hydrogen bonds, takes place [19]; (c) an extended reduced stiffness regime in which molecular sliding occurs [10], [13], [20]; (d) a hardening regime in which stretching of the backbones of tropocollagen molecules, promoted by molecular cross-links, stiffens the fibril [21], [22]; and finally, (e) a softening regime in which failure occurs. Having two or more cross-links per tropocollagen molecule substantially increases hardening [21] which becomes pronounced in the presence of mature, trivalent, cross-links. This hardening behavior leads to increased modulus in the aforementioned hardening regime, which is higher than the modulus of the initial loading regime (E1) described above [10], [22]. However, observations have varied significantly, with studies reporting rubber-like [10], linear/multi-linear [23], parabolic [24], or toe/heel/linear stress–strain curves [7], [20], which do not include all five of the aforementioned regimes of the deformation response, depending on the type and density of cross-linking [10], [18], [21], [22], [25], and partially [26], [27] or fully hydrated [10], [18], [28] conditions.
The key property that was investigated in this study is the ability of nanoscale collagen fibrils to absorb and dissipate energy in steady-state mode during cyclic loading, as quantified from mechanical loading–unloading hysteresis curves. Because energy dissipation is critical to the functions of collagenous tissues and their insertions [29], there is a pressing need to understand the hierarchical origins and extent of the hysteretic behavior of collagenous tissues, especially in the context of engineering tissues and prosthetics. At the bulk level, hysteresis can arise in collagenous tissues due to fibril sliding [11], but the contribution of the dissipative material behavior of nanoscale fibrils has not yet been quantified. An important first step in this direction has been atomic force microscope (AFM) assisted testing of hydrated bovine collagen, which showed a stress–strain behavior that is characterized by hysteresis and plastic deformation for strains exceeding 6% [18]. These results suggested the possibility of nanoscale energy absorption in collagenous tissues, and, by comparison to the non-hysteretic behavior of dry collagen tested at the same strain levels [30], indicated that hydration affects the interactions between tropocollagen molecules, possibly by modulating hydrogen bonding [31]. To address this hypothesis, we undertook the first systematic cyclical loading study of reconstituted mammalian collagen fibrils in the absence of unbound water surrounding a collagen fibril in order to quantify the amount of energy dissipation per cycle and the associated changes in key mechanical properties, such as stiffness, strength and toughness. This study was conducted with partially hydrated collagen fibrils at 60% relative humidity (RH). The absence of external water molecules focuses this study in intrafibrillar processes that affect energy dissipation inside individual collagen fibrils, rather than the exchange of water molecules between a collagen fibril and a buffer. The dissipated energy during mechanical cycling is normalized by an elastic term to yield the loss coefficient, a metric that enables a comparison amongst different materials [32], especially in the same modulus range as the collagen fibrils.
Furthermore, we quantified for the first time the effect of unloading on the recovery of the inelastic strain accrued during cyclic loading in different regimes of deformation, and the return to the mechanical behavior prior to mechanical cycling. The new insights presented in this work were made possible because of experiments at the low and the high strain regimes of the deformation of nanoscale collagen fibrils, which are controlled by some of the molecular mechanisms described above.
Section snippets
Synthesis and characterization of collagen fibrils
The collagen used in this study was lyophilized collagen type I from calf skin (Elastin Products Co., No. C857 (1 g) Lot 267), which was prepared according to Gallop and Seifter [33]. In this method, fresh calf skin is extracted with 0.5 M NaOAc to remove non-collagen proteins. The soluble collagen is then extracted with 0.075 M sodium citrate, pH 3.7, and precipitated as fibrils by dialysis against 0.02 M Na2HPO4. Reconstituted collagen was then synthesized at our lab according to [34], [35].
Results
The reconstituted collagen fibrils tested herein assembled from acid-soluble collagen and had the characteristic native D-banding (Fig. 1a). In general, reconstituted collagen approximates in vivo collagen better than fibers formed from enzyme digested collagen [43], [44]. The σ–λ curves of 24 successfully tested fibrils under monotonic and cyclic loading, Table 1, were comprised of three distinct regimes (Fig. 1e,f): (I) an initial linear regime (regime I) with λ values up to 1.05–1.1 and E1
Discussion
The results presented herein suggest previously unforeseen ways in which nanoscale collagen may contribute to the mechanics of collagenous tissues, and that low frequency, high strain, “stretching” may improve their mechanics by resulting in a steady-state response at the lowest levels of the tissue hierarchy. As shown in Table 1, stretching at strains 20% or higher (regime II and beyond) increased the tensile strength and the toughness by 70%, as compared to monotonic or small strain loading.
Conclusions
It was shown that a single cycle of mechanical conditioning of reconstituted mammalian collagen fibrils tested under partially hydrated conditions can lead to steady-state hysteresis with large energy dissipation and inelastic deformation that reaches a plateau after the first few cycles of loading. The loss coefficient associated with this hysteresis was shown to be 5–10 times higher than the values reported for all homogeneous materials in the same elastic modulus range. Cyclic loading at 20%
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the National Science Foundation and National Institutes of Health under award number U01BE016422, and by the National Science Foundation Science and Technology Center for Engineering MechanoBiology (grant CMMI 1548571). Dr. D. Das’ effort was supported by the National Science Foundation grant CMMI 1635681.
References (53)
The molecular and fibrillar structure of collagen and its relationship to the mechanical properties of connective tissue
Biophys. Chem.
(1988)- et al.
Nature’s hierarchical materials
Prog. Mater. Sci.
(2007) - et al.
Tensile properties of human collagen fibrils and fascicles are insensitive to environmental salts
Biophys. J.
(2010) - et al.
Fracture mechanics of collagen fibrils: influence of natural cross-links
Biophys. J.
(2013) - et al.
Elongation mechanism of collagen fibrils and force-strain relations of tendon at each level of structural hierarchy
J. Biomech.
(1996) - et al.
In situ multi-level analysis of viscoelastic deformation mechanisms in tendon collagen
J. Struct. Biol.
(2010) - et al.
Micromechanical analysis of native and cross-linked collagen type I fibrils supports the existence of microfibrils
J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater.
(2012) Nanomechanics of collagen fibrils under varying cross-link densities: atomistic and continuum studies
J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater.
(2008)- et al.
Influence of cross-link structure, density and mechanical properties in the mesoscale deformation mechanisms of collage fibrils
J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater.
(2015) - et al.
In Vitro fracture testing of submicron diameter collagen fibril specimens
Biophys. J.
(2010)
Mechanical properties of native and cross-linked type I collagen fibrils
Biophys. J.
Stress-strain experiments on individual collagen fibrils
Biophys. J.
Stochastic interdigitation as a toughening mechanism at the interface between tendon and bone
Biophys. J.
Preparation and properties of soluble collagens
Methods Enzymol.
Collagen fibril formation: optimal in vitro conditions and preliminary kinetic results
J. Biol. Chem.
Strong and tough mineralized PLGA Nanofibers for tendon-to-bone scaffolds
Acta Biomater.
X-ray diffraction analysis of tendon collagen at ambient and cryogenic temperatures: role of hydration
Int. J. Biol. Macromol.
Mechanical properties of collagen fibres: a comparison of reconstituted and rat tail tendon fibres
Biomaterials
Ultrastructural deformation of reconstituted collagen
BBA
Viscoelastic properties of isolated collagen fibrils
Biophys. J.
In situ multi-level analysis of viscoelastic deformation mechanisms in tendon collagen
J. Struct. Biol.
Investigating load relaxation mechanics in tendon
J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater.
Collagen stability, hydration and native state
J. Mol. Graph. Model.
The mechanical efficiency of natural materials
Phil. Mag.
A subunit model for the tropocollagen macromolecule
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.
Biopolymers
Rep. Prog. Phys.
Cited by (36)
Open-system force-elongation relationship of collagen in chemo-mechanical equilibrium with water
2024, Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical MaterialsMechanics of isolated individual collagen fibrils
2023, Acta BiomaterialiaCitation Excerpt :If this sliding is inhibited by the cross-linking, the stiffness would increase in phase I. Performing creep experiments in phase I while intermolecular sliding is assumed to occur, one would expect a) not to reach a plateau in strain increase and b) failure should occur already in phase I. But recent studies [51,70] have not confirmed this which could suggest that intermolecular sliding does not take place but rather cross-linking inhibits uncoiling and straightening. This hypothesis seems to favor rather AGEs, to enzymatic cross-links, as the theoretical attainable concentration of AGEs per molecule is higher and not confined at the end regions of the collagen molecules.
Understanding the inelastic response of collagen fibrils: A viscoelastic-plastic constitutive model
2023, Acta BiomaterialiaCitation Excerpt :This exercise is performed as a means to provide insights into the interplay between plastic and viscoelastic deformations as fibril loading transitions between physiological cyclic loading to overload. To calibrate the proposed material model we utilized the data from Liu et al. [38] with the adjustments discussed in Section 2. The data that we used in the optimization consists of four distinct experiments - as we discuss in Section 2 -, namely
Nonlinear time-dependent mechanical behavior of mammalian collagen fibrils
2023, Acta BiomaterialiaMicroscale creep and stress relaxation experiments with individual collagen fibrils
2022, Optics and Lasers in EngineeringCitation Excerpt :This is in agreement with preconditioning protocols established before for tissues [42–45]. In this study, the collagen fibrils were preconditioned by cyclic loading for 10 cycles to the maximum target stress or strain, similarly to [13], before performing creep or stress relaxation experiments. After preconditioning, each fibril was completely unloaded and held for 30 min before performing a test.