Type I pitting of copper tubes from a water distribution system

doi:10.1016/S1350-6307(97)00029-0

Engineering Failure Analysis

Volume 5, Issue 1, March 1998, Pages 35-40

https://doi.org/10.1016/S1350-6307(97)00029-0 Get rights and content

Abstract

Samples of copper tubes from a cold water distribution system which had failed due to pitting whilst in service were subjected to a detailed failure investigation. Analysis of the tubes showed that failure was a result of Type I pitting attack. While the exact cause of pitting was unknown, it was hypothesised that it could have been due to changes in the water quality and/or content. The tubes were found to be made from phosphorus de-oxidised copper and no anomalies were evident in either the chemical that composition or the microstructure which could have caused the pitting observed. It was recommended that the tubes be replaced and that due attention be given that the new tubes are free of internal carbonaceous deposits or other foreign matter.

References (2)

Billau, M., Drapier, C., Materiaux et Techniques, Nos 1 and...

Cited by (23)

Analysis of pitting corrosion failure of copper tubes in an apartment fire sprinkler system
2016, Engineering Failure Analysis
Citation Excerpt :
Both samples were a little alkaline with almost the same pH value of 8.25. This pH value is well in the so called passivation region where the copper oxide protective layer is formed, preventing further oxidation of copper [5] (see Pourbaix diagram of Fig. 14). Na, Cu, Zn, and Fe were analyzed by AAS while Mg, Ca and Al were analyzed by ICP/OES.
Microscopical and structural analyses as well as visual inspection of copper tubes were used to investigate the cause of pitting corrosion failure of copper tubes in the wet pipe sprinkler system. Chemical analysis of the water in the copper tubing and XRF/XRD analysis of its sediments were also used to obtain hints on what was happening in the copper tubing during the progress of the pitting corrosion. It was found from the failed copper tube that a significant amount of pressurized air was present over the water in the copper tubing during operation and a series of corrosion pits were aligned adjacent to the water/air line. The waterline localized corrosion, a type of differential oxygen concentration cell corrosion, induced by pressurized air over the water in the copper tubing was identified as the cause of the pitting corrosion failure. A state of a very low oxygen concentration was maintained under the envelope of a dense layer of malachite, the corrosion byproduct, which was evidenced by the formation of Cu₂O crystalline particles inside the corrosion pit. CuO particles observed on the inside surface of the copper tube do not seem to help prevent local as well as general corrosion. Accelerated pitting corrosion of the copper tube in the wet fire sprinkler system was simulated using a differential aeration cell. Finally, measures for stopping or delaying the pitting corrosion of the copper tube in the wet sprinkler system are suggested.
Hot-water corrosion failure of a hard-drawn copper tube
2013, Engineering Failure Analysis
Citation Excerpt :
High chlorine content likely stimulated the pit initiation and growth. It is considered essential for pitting attack by aiding the breakdown of protective surface layers and inducing to the formation of wide, shallow pits [16]. The composition of flowing medium had likely contributed to the formation of fragile and loosely adherent scale products, primarily mixed (hydroxy)chlorides, such as CuCl2⋅3Cu(OH)2, and secondarily sulfates, phosphates, that they can easily be detached and sustain the corrosion process, see also Ref. [17].
Deoxidized high phosphorus copper (C12200, DHP-Cu) is the principal construction element in piping in water distribution systems and HVAC (Heating Ventilation and Air-Conditioning) installations due to its excellent thermal and electrical conductivity, formability, corrosion resistance and antimicrobial activity. However, design and installation deficiencies or aggressive environmental parameters, such as improper water quality, may lead to unexpected failures causing material losses and many times property damage incurring high costs of repair. A corroded copper water tube caused leakage in a hot water hydraulic installation. The leakage was reported after approximately 6 years in service. Tubes were disconnected from a hydraulic installation and samples were taken for failure investigation. Failure analysis findings suggest strongly that the leakage was caused by tube perforation from the inner waterside due to localized pitting corrosion. The main cause of the accelerated tube pitting corrosion was the improper water chemistry (especially high chlorine content and low pH) inducing chemical attack of copper leading to scale layers of cuprite, chlorides and sulfates.
Investigation of pitting corrosion of a copper tube in a heating system
2010, Engineering Failure Analysis
Electrochemical tests, as well as surface and chemical analyses were used to examine the mechanism of pitting failure of a copper tube. Synthetic tap water simulating the hot water in a heating system and field-used heating water at 60 °C were used as electrolytes in these tests. The results showed that the presence of a Cu(I) oxide layer on the copper surface is essential for pitting corrosion of a copper tube in hot synthetic tap water. Moreover, the pitting corrosion of copper tubes is preferred in heating water containing higher concentrations of Fe species and under stagnant condition.
Effect of flow induced corrosion and erosion on failure of a tubular heat exchanger
2010, Materials and Design
Failure of a tubular heat exchanger made up of copper based alloys in a steam power plant was investigated. Tubes were made initially from yellow brass, and there after replaced by Cu–5Ni alloys. Circulating water from cooling tower was used as coolant, to condense the hot steam inside the steel shell. The velocity of cooling water was found to be very low, causing accumulation of deposits, reduction of diameter and some times complete blockage of tubes. The causes of failure were investigated performing various tests such as chemical analysis, XRD, optical, and SEM examination. Study revealed that tube material suffering from extensive dealloying and impingement attack.
Microstructural Analysis of Corroded Copper Pipes Used in Water Distribution Network
2019, Metallography, Microstructure, and Analysis
Copper corrosion and biocorrosion events in premise plumbing
2017, Materials

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text