Effects of different reproduction techniques: AI, moet or IVP, on health and welfare of bovine offspring

doi:10.1016/S0093-691X(99)00259-9

Theriogenology

Volume 53, Issue 2, 15 January 2000, Pages 575-597

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0093-691X(99)00259-9 Get rights and content

Abstract

Since the introduction of in vitro production (IVP) of bovine and sheep pre-implantation embryos, increased birth weights and other deviations of IVP calves and lambs compared with AI or MOET offspring have been reported. Study 1 of the present paper, a comparison between AI, MOET and IVP (co-culture/serum) calves with respect to calf and calving characteristics in large-scale field conditions, confirms these reports. In addition, it is shown that MOET calves tend towards higher birth weights and have significantly longer gestations and more difficult calvings than AI calves. It is presently unknown if the effect of IVP is also observed later in life. In this paper, data on reproduction characteristics of bovine IVP co-culture/serum offspring are presented. Semen production — and non return data of one year old IVP bulls and superovulation-, AI- and OPU/IVP results of one year old IVP heifers are compared with those of one year old AI and MOET animals producing semen or embryos in the same time period. So far, there are no indications that the use of IVP is reflected in deviate reproduction characteristics of bovine IVP offspring.

It has been suggested that use of co-culture cells and serum during in vitro culture of bovine (and sheep) embryos may partially explain the increased birth weights and other deviations of bovine and sheep IVP offspring. Deletion of these factors in semi-defined culture media, e.g. Synthetic Oviductal Fluid (SOF), could result in more normal offspring. Study 2 investigates this hypothesis in both field conditions (Study 2a, comparing AI, IVP co-culture/serum and IVP SOF calves) and in semi-standardized conditions (Study 2b, comparing MOET, IVP co-culture/serum and IVP SOF calves at one herd). In Study 2a, although IVP SOF calves showed (non-significant) shorter gestations, easier calvings and lower percentages of perinatal mortality and congenital malformations than IVP co-culture calves, birth weights were not decreased. In Study 2b however, the difference between IVP co-culture and IVP SOF calves in birth weight and ease of calving was significant (P<0.05), IVP SOF calves resembling MOET calves more. IVP calves differed significantly from MOET calves with respect to several physiological parameters, such as blood oxygen saturation level, heart beat frequency and some measures of the heart. In addition, in Study 2b, recipients receiving an IVP SOF embryo showed a more regular return to estrus than those receiving an IVP co-culture embryo. From Study 2 it can be concluded that using a semi-defined medium for in vitro culture (SOF) may improve characteristics of IVP calves born.

References (41)

E Behboodi et al.
Birth of large calves that developed from in vitro-derived embryos
Theriogenology
(1995)
FB Garry et al.
Postnatal characteristics of calves produced by nuclear transfer cloning
Theriogenology
(1996)
JF Hasler et al.
Production, freezing and transfer of bovine IVF embryos and subsequent calving results
Theriogenology
(1995)
H Jacobsen et al.
In vitro embryo production versus artificial insemination: Delivery type, birth weight and blood chemistry of the newborn calf
Theriogenology
(1999)
TG McEvoy et al.
Ovine fetal development following embryo culture in synthetic oviductal fluid with added ammonium
Theriogenology
(1999)
WH McMillan et al.
Development during mid to late pregnancy following either in vitro embryo transfer or artificial insemination in cattle
Theriogenology
(1999)
JS Merton et al.
Factors affecting birth weight of IVP calves
Theriogenology
(1998)
AC Ravelli et al.
Glucose tolerance in adults after prenatal exposure to famine
Lancet
(1998)
M Schmidt et al.
Pregnancies, calves and calf viability after transfer of in vitro produced bovine embryos
Theriogenology
(1996)
KD Sinclair et al.
Culture of sheep zygotes can alter fetal growth and development
Theriogenology
(1997)

KD Sinclair et al.

Conceptus growth and development following in vitro culture of ovine embryos in media supplemented with bovine sera

Theriogenology

(1998)

JG Thompson

Defining the requirements for bovine embryo culture

Theriogenology

(1996)

H Tricoire et al.

Effect of fetal calf serum on the quality of in vitro produced cattle embryos

Theriogenology

(1999)

SK Walker et al.

The production of unusually large offspring following embryo manipulation: Concepts and challenges

Theriogenology

(1996)

JM Wilson et al.

Comparison of birth weight and growth characteristics of bovine calves produced by nuclear transfer (cloning), embryo transfer and natural mating

Anim Reprod Sci

(1995)

RG Edwards et al.

Birth after the preimplantation of a human embryo

Lancet

(1978)

GT Erbach et al.

Differential growth of the mouse preimplantation embryo in chemically defined media

Biol Reprod

(1994)

PW Farm et al.

Transfer of bovin embryos produced in vivo or in vitro: Survival and fetal development

Biol Reprod

(1995)

YM Fukada et al.

Birth of normal calves resulting from bovine oocytes matured, fertilized and cultured with cumulus cells in vitro up to the blastocyst stage

Biol Reprod

(1990)

F Gandolfi et al.

Stimulation of early embryonic development in the sheep by co-culture with oviduct epithelial cells

J Reprod Fertil

(1987)

Cited by (209)

Could assisted reproductive techniques affect equine fetal membranes and neonatal outcome?
2024, Theriogenology
Embryo transfer (ET) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) are widely used in equine species, but their effects on fetal adnexa and neonates have not been investigated yet. The aim of this study was to retrospectively evaluate whether pregnancies obtained by ET or ICSI could be associated with the presence of macroscopic alterations of fetal membranes (FM) and umbilical cord (UC) and if the use of these techniques could influence neonatal outcome. Sixty-six light breed mares hospitalized at the Veterinary Teaching Hospital, University of Bologna, for attending delivery were included in the study. Mares were divided into Artificial Insemination (AI; 32/66 mares, 48 %), Embryo Transfer (ET; 12/66 mares, 18.2 %) and Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI; 22/66 mares, 33 %) groups. All the medical reports of mares and their foals were reviewed and data about mare, pregnancy, foaling, fetal membranes, umbilical cord and foal were recorded. The occurrence of dystocia resulted statistically different between AI group and ICSI group (p = 0.0066), and between AI group and ET group (p = 0.044). Macroscopic examination of FM revealed alterations in 30/66 mares (46 %): 8/32 in AI (25 %), 7/12 in ET (58 %) and 15/22 in ICSI (68 %) with significant lower incidence in AI compared to ET (p = 0.04) and ICSI (p = 0.002) groups. Alterations reported were chorionic villi hypoplasia, chorioallantois edema, allantois cysts, necrotic areas and greenish-grey concretions. Total length of UC resulted significantly shorter in ICSI group (49 ± 9 cm; p < 0.03) compared to AI (60 ± 17 cm) and ET (59 ± 15 cm). However, there were no differences in the incidence of foals' diseases at birth and in foals’ survival among groups (p > 0.05). The results demonstrate that transfer of in vivo or in vitro produced embryos may lead to alterations of placental development, as observed in other species, without being associated with a higher incidence of neonatal morbidity and mortality. Further studies about trophoblast development, FM histological evaluation, and placental gene expression should be carried out to clarify the mechanisms underlying the placental alterations.
The mammalian preimplantation embryo: Its role in the environmental programming of postnatal health and performance
2023, Animal Reproduction Science
During formation of the preimplantation embryo several cellular and molecular milestones take place, making the few cells forming the early embryo vulnerable to environmental stressors than can impair epigenetic reprogramming and controls of gene expression. Although these molecular alterations can result in embryonic death, a significant developmental plasticity is present in the preimplantation embryo that promotes full-term pregnancy. Prenatal epigenetic modifications are inherited during mitosis and can perpetuate specific phenotypes during early postnatal development and adulthood. As such, the preimplantation phase is a developmental window where developmental programming can take place in response to the embryonic microenvironment present in vivo or in vitro. In this review, the relevance of the preimplantation embryo as a developmental stage where offspring health and performance can be programmed is discussed, with emphasis on malnutrition and assisted reproductive technologies; two major environmental insults with important implications for livestock production and human reproductive medicine.
Genetic analysis of in-vitro embryo production traits in Dairy Gir cattle
2020, Theriogenology
Citation Excerpt :
From that it is possible to assume that there is higher environmental pressure inside the uterus than within the in vitro process. This fact may impose stronger challenges to the spermatozoon and could be the crucial factor for the reduced genetic effect observed for the sire in results from in vivo embryo production [17,39]. Was reported a higher heritability for percentage traits in Holstein Friesian cows, varying from 0.05 to 0.12 for PGI and PEMB respectively [16].
The potential of dams as oocyte donors can be a selection criterion for animal breeding programs, but also an involuntary driver of the process. In both cases, it is important to determine genetic components influencing the outcome of in vitro embryo production (IVEP). The objective of the present study was to perform a detailed genetic analysis for in vitro embryo production traits in Dairy Gir cows. A dataset containing 11,450 records of ovum pick-up (OPU) and in vitro fertilization (IVF) procedures from 2684 Dairy Gir donors was evaluated. Analyzed traits were number (N_OV) and percentage (P_OV) of viable oocytes; number (N_GI) and percentage (P_GI) of grade I oocytes; number (N_EMB) and percentage (P_EMB) of viable embryos. All analyzes were performed using animal models by a Bayesian framework. Heritability estimates varied from 0.16 to 0.32 for count traits and from 0.01 to 0.06 for percentage traits. The proportion of the total variation represented by the additive genetic effect of sire (semen used in IVF) for N_EMB and P_EMB was 7% and 5% respectively. Associations between estimated breeding values from progeny tested bulls for IVEP traits, milk production, age at first calving and conformation traits were mainly low or close to zero. Results indicate that selection for IVEP traits is possible in Dairy Gir cattle and would not impair genetic progress for traits already considered as selection criteria. The N_OV seems to be a promising target trait. However, a selection index could help to avoid the use of sires with negative genetic merit for percentage traits, minimizing possible deterioration in the long term.
Efficient one-step direct transfer to recipients of thawed bovine embryos cultured in vitro and frozen in chemically defined medium
2020, Theriogenology
Citation Excerpt :
Experiments of embryo transfer in cattle can be preceded by an analysis of embryonic viability in vitro because of the high costs of recipient pregnancy management to term. Predicting pregnancy from in vitro platforms is particularly interesting within IVP embryos, which typically show lower pregnancy rates –mainly after cryopreservation-, higher gestational losses in the early pregnancy and in the late fetal and perinatal periods, and more cases of morbidity and dystocia than in vivo produced embryos [14,34–38]. In this study, we analyzed the performance of a new system of embryo culture combined with F/T under chemically defined conditions for IVP embryos.
Direct transfer (DT) of cryopreserved embryos to recipients facilitates on-farm application. We analyzed a new freezing/thawing (F/T) procedure for in vitro produced (IVP) embryos, integrating: 1) an ethylene-glycol based system; 2) a culture step without protein; and 3) a synthetic protein substitute (CRYO3) in cryopreservation medium. IVP embryos from abattoir ovaries were cultured in groups in BSA-containing synthetic oviduct fluid with or without 0.1% fetal calf serum (FCS) until Day-6. Morulae and early blastocysts were subsequently cultured without protein from Day-6 onwards. Day 7 and Day 8 expanded blastocysts (EXB) were subjected to F/T or vitrification/warming (V/W). Thawed and warmed EXB were cultured in vitro, and development rates, cell counts and dead cells were analyzed in surviving embryos. V/W improved survival over F/T (live and hatching rates at 2 h, 24 h and 48 h) (P < 0.0001), and FCS before Day 6 did not affect in vitro survival. After F/T, embryos had lower cell counts in the ICM, TE and total cells than after V/W. Day-7 embryos after F/T showed % apoptotic, % pycnotic and % total dead cells higher (p < 0.05) than their Day-8 counterparts, probably because F/T reduced the numbers of ICM cells within Day-8 embryos. Thereafter, Day-7 blastocysts were transferred to heifers in an experimental herd. There were no differences in birth rates with frozen (-FCS [n = 40]: 45%; +FCS [n = 14]: 28%), vitrified (-FCS [n = 47]: 53%; +FCS [n = 11]: 36%) and fresh (-FCS [n = 30]: 47%; +FCS [n = 17]: 53%) embryos. However, frozen embryos produced with FCS showed 5/9 miscarriages after Day-40. Calves born from frozen (n = 22), vitrified (n = 29) and fresh (n = 22) transfers did not differ in birth weight, gestation length and daily gain weight (P > 0.10). Subsequently, transfer of frozen embryos (n = 29) derived from oocytes collected from live, hormonally stimulated cows in experimental herd, led to pregnancy rates of 57% (heifers) and 40% (dry cows). with EXB on Day-62 Finally, embryos produced with BSA were transferred to cows in an on-field trial (frozen [n = 80]; fresh [n = 58]), with no differences in pregnancy rates (days 30–40). Pregnancy and birth rates could not be predicted from in vitro approaches. The new F/T system yields pregnancy and birth rates comparable to vitrified and fresh embryos without birth overweight. The absence of products of animal origin, defined chemical composition, and direct transfer entail sanitary, manufacturing and application advantages.
Reproductive technologies and animal welfare
2020, Reproductive Technologies in Animals
The present chapter aims at identifying the most common practices and assessing the impact, either positive or negative, of reproductive technologies on animal welfare. The application of any reproductive technology to farm animals implies handling and often sorting and restraining. These practices should be conducted quietly in order to prevent excitement and fright and keep the animals calm. In addition, the removal of the animal from the herd (generally temporary for females and permanent for males) and the consequent social isolation may also impair animal welfare. Most of the reproductive technologies (e.g., estrus detection) show a mild effect on the animals and in several cases, habituation may occur. Conversely, other technologies may have marked direct detrimental effects (e.g., pain induced by electroejaculation) and/or indirectly induce negative emotional states (e.g., through restraining and isolation). However, some technologies have been developed with the primary aim of increasing animal welfare, as directly linked to farm profits. In particular, uterus and fetal monitoring by allowing the prediction of calving may also allow a prompt intervention in case of dystocia. Nevertheless, also in these cases preventive measures, such as the application of appropriate breeding programs including calving ease to reduce the incidence of dystocia and cesarean sections, should be preferred for an effective improvement of animal welfare.
Magnesium is a critical element for competent development of bovine embryos
2019, Theriogenology
The study was designed to determine the impact of magnesium (Mg²⁺) on bovine embryo development. We found that two commercially available sources of bovine serum albumin (BSA) and fetal bovine serum (FBS) contained different amounts of Mg²⁺ residue: 4 ppm in ICPbio BSA, 114 ppm in Sigma BSA, and 44 ppm in FBS. When CR1 was used as basal medium, PVA and ICPbio BSA produced the lowest blastocyst yield (2.2–2.3%), whereas Sigma BSA increased blastocyst yield to 18.9% (P < 0.05). Supplementation of 1.4 mM MgCl₂ into the medium increased the blastocyst rate in the ICPbio BSA group (29.4%) but not in the PVA group (5.4%; P < 0.05) to a level comparable to that of the FBS group (33.7%; P > 0.05). We next found that increasing concentrations of MgCl₂ in the culture medium (ICPbio BSA) elevated blastocyst rate from 2.6% (0 mM), 38.4% (0.35 mM) to 50.2% (1.4 mM; P < 0.05), further maintained at 44.9% (2.1 mM) and 43.4% (2.8 mM) (P > 0.05). However, blastocyst rate was reduced to 31.4% (4.2 mM) and 29.4% (5.6 mM) when MgCl₂ supplement was increased (P < 0.05). Comparable blastocyst development was achieved in both ICPbio BSA (30.0–33.1%) and Sigma BSA (37.4–38.7%) groups when 1.4 mM Mg²⁺ was supplemented regardless of its source (MgCl₂ vs. MgSO₄; P > 0.05). In embryo transfer experiments, higher rates of pregnancy (54.3 vs. 41.5%) and calving (44.3 vs. 32.5%) were achieved in the CR1-Mg²⁺-supplemented BSA group compared with the FBS group with co-culture, respectively (P < 0.05). These results demonstrate that Mg²⁺ is a key ion that promotes competent blastocyst and term development. Therefore, a simple and efficient defined medium (CR1-Mg²⁺-BSA) can successfully replace complex serum and somatic cell co-culture.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text