Male and female health problems in general practice: The differential impact of social position and social roles

doi:10.1016/0277-9536(95)80004-4

Social Science & Medicine

Volume 40, Issue 5, March 1995, Pages 597-611

https://doi.org/10.1016/0277-9536(95)80004-4 Get rights and content

Abstract

Sex, social position and social roles have been identified as important health predictors. Moreover, various social variables have been found to bear differently upon female as compared to male health.

This study analyses data from a large-scale registration project in general practice (the Continuous Morbidity Registration), pertaining to the medical diagnoses of nearly 10,000 patients over a five year period. The effects of sex, social class, marital and parental status on a number of distinct categories of health problems were established, and a possible differential impact of social position and social roles on male and female health was explored. Categories of health problems studied were ‘overall health problems’, ‘sex specific conditions’, ‘symptoms without disease’, ‘prevention and diagnostics’ and ‘trauma’.

Sex and, above all, social class were identified as important predictors of most categories of health problems, especially during the reproductive period of life. Marital status and parental status did not contribute substantially to most types of health problems. Rates of prevention and diagnostics, sex specific conditions and total number of health problems could to a certain extent be predicted by the four sociodemographic variables, as opposed to trauma rates and symptoms without disease rates. Social class appeared the only variable with a substantially different effect on male vs female rates of sex specific conditions, prevention and diagnostics and trauma, but not so for overall health problems and symptoms without disease. Marital status and parental status did not differ significantly in their effect on male vs female health. Results illustrate that differentiation of the health variable into categories of health problems elucidates the relationship between sex, social variables and health.

References (80)

C.A. Nathanson
Illness and the feminine role: a theoretical review
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1975)
C.A. Nathanson
Sex, illness and medical care: a review of data, theory and method
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1977)
D. Mechanic
Sex, illness, illness behavior and the use of health services
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1978)
I. Waldron
Sex differences in illness incidence, prognosis and mortality: issues and evidence
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1983)
E. Roskies
Sex, culture and illness—an overview
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1978)
M. Stacey et al.
Women, men and health: introduction
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1993)
W.R. Gove
Gender differences in mental and physical illness: the effect of fixed roles and nurturant roles
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1984)
J.H. Hibbard et al.
Gender roles, illness orientation and the use of medical services
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1983)
L.M. Verbrugge
Triggers of symptoms and health care
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1985)
O. Lundberg
Causal explanations for class inequality in health: an empirical analysis
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1991)

S. Macintyre et al.

Lack of class variation in health in adolescence: an artefact of an occupational measure of social class?

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1991)

C. Power

Social and economic background and class inequalities in health among young adults

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1991)

D. Vågero

Inequality in health—some theoretical empirical problems

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1991)

R. Illsley et al.

Contextual variation in the meaning of health inequality

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1991)

S. Arber

Class, paid employment and family roles: making sense of structural disadvantage, gender and health status

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1991)

S. Jennings et al.

Women and work: an investigation of the association between health and employment status in middle-aged women

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1984)

O. Anson et al.

Women's health and labour force status: An enquiry using a multi-point measure of labour force participation

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1987)

M.H. Brenner et al.

Unemployment and health in the context of economic change

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1983)

W.J.H.M.van den Bosch

Epidemiologische aspecten van morbiditeit bij kinderen

S. Macintyre

Gender differences in the perceptions of common cold symptoms

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1993)

S. Arber et al.

Gender and inequalities in health in later life

Soc. Sci. Med.

(1993)

L.M. Verbrugge

Females and illness: recent trends in sex differences in the United States

J. Hlth soc. Behav.

(1976)

P.D. Clearly et al.

Sex differences in medical care utilization: an empirical investigation

J. Hlth soc. Behav.

(1982)

L.M. Verbrugge

Sex differentials in health

Publ. Hlth Rep.

(1982)

S.M. Hunt et al.

Perceived health: age and sex comparisons in a community

J. Epidem. Comm. Hlth

(1984)

L.M. Verbrugge et al.

Sex differentials in health and mortality

Wom. Hlth

(1987)

L.M. Verbrugge

The twain meet: empirical explanations of sex differences in health and mortality

J. Hlth soc. Behav.

(1989)

R.M. Kaplan et al.

Gender differences in health-related quality of life

Hlth. Psychol.

(1991)

L.S. Fidell

Sex role stereotypes and the American physician

Psychol. Wom. Q.

(1979–1980)

J.N. Clarke

Sexism, feminism and medicalism: a decade review of literature on gender and illness

Sociol. Hlth. Illness

(1983)

Waddell C. and Floate P. Research note: gender and the utilization of health carte services in Perth, Australia....

H. Lamberts

(1984)

E.J.G.van den Brekel

Sekseverschillen in gezondheid en medische consumptie

Maandbericht Gezondheidsstatistiek

(1987)

C.M.T. Gijsbers van Wijk et al.

Symptom sensitivity and sex differences in physical morbidity

Wom. Hlth.

(1991)

D.H.de Bakker et al.

Man-vrouw verschillen in gezondheid en medische consumptie

NIVEL report

(1992)

A. Baum et al.

Gender, stress, and health

Hlth. Psychol.

(1991)

W.R. Gove et al.

Possible causes of the apparent sex differences in physical health: an empirical investigation

Am. sociol. Rev.

(1979)

L.M. Verbrugge

Comment on Walter R. Gove and Michael Hughes. Possible causes of the apparent sex differences in physical health

Am. Sociol. Rev.

(1980)

Mechanic D. Comment on Walter R. Gove and Michael Hughes. Am. Sociol. Rev.45,...

A.C. Marcus et al.

Sex differences in reports of illness and disability: a preliminary test of the “fixed role obligations” hypothesis

J. Hlth soc. Behav.

(1981)

Cited by (59)

Explaining gender differences in ill-health in South Korea: The roles of socio-structural, psychosocial, and behavioral factors
2008, Social Science and Medicine
Citation Excerpt :
Additionally, women are more likely to encounter undesirable life events and probably concurrent stress and strain (Mcleod & Kessler, 1990), which could account for higher female morbidity. While issues of higher female susceptibility to symptoms are not disregarded in the gender and health literature, there is substantial evidence to refute the “reporting artifact” explanation (Gijsbers van Wijk, Kolk, van den Bosch, & van den Hoogen, 1995; Macintyre, Ford, & Hunt, 1999). We have argued that socially produced gender inequality could be a strong casual factor in women's health in South Korea with its distinctive patriarchal system, namely the gender imbalance in economic power and political authority.
This study examines and explains the gender disparity in health despite rapid modernization in South Korea where the social structure is still based on traditional gender relations. A nationally representative sample of 2897 men and 3286 women aged 25–64 from the 2001 Korean National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey was analyzed. Health indicators included self rated health and chronic disease. Age-adjusted prevalence was computed according to a gender and odds ratios (OR) derived from logistic regression. Percentage changes in OR by inclusion of determinant variables (socio-structural, psychosocial, and behavioral) into the base logistic regression model were used to estimate the contributions to the gender gap in two morbidity measures. Results showed a substantial female excess in ill-health in both measures, revealing an increasing disparity in the older age group. Group-specific age-adjusted prevalence of ill-health showed an inverse relationship to socioeconomic position. When adjusting for each determinant, employment status, education, and depression contributed the greatest to the gender gap. After adjusting for all suggested determinants, 78% for self rated health and 86% for chronic disease in excess OR could be explained. After stratifying for age, the full model provided a complete explanation for the female excess in chronic illness, but for self rated health a female excess was still evident for the younger age group. Socio-structural factors played a crucial role in accounting for female excess in ill-health. This result calls for greater attention to gender-based health inequality stemming from socio-structural determinants in South Korea. Cross-cultural validation studies are suggested for further discussion of the link between changing gender relations and the gender health gap in morbidity in diverse settings.
Gender and use of health care among older adults in Egypt and Tunisia
2004, Social Science and Medicine
In Western industrialized countries, women report using health services more often than do men. We explore the applicability of existing theory to explain gender differences in use of health care among older adults in Egypt and Tunisia, where females have received less health care than males in early life. Findings show that women report visiting providers and using medications more often than do men; however, adjusted odds of visiting doctors are comparable for women and men in Tunisia and lower for women than men in Egypt. Odds of using health care are higher for women than men among those reporting no morbidity or functional impairment, but these relative odds diminish or reverse among those reporting multiple morbidities or severe impairments. The contributions of subjective and objective illness, quality of social support, and availability of services on gender differences in care in later life should be assessed in these and other settings where girls’ excess mortality persists.
A symptom perception approach to common physical symptoms
2003, Social Science and Medicine
This study investigated variables assumed to influence the symptom perception process, as well as the sociodemographic variables of age, gender and socioeconomic status, regarding their relation to common physical symptoms. In addition, it ascertained the predictors of two symptom measurement methods (prospective and retrospective). A group of 152 men and women completed a standardized interview as well as several questionnaires and kept a diary for 4 weeks. Path analyses showed an adequate data fit irrespective of symptom measure. Two main routes to both prospectively and retrospectively measured physical symptoms were found: one from more negative affectivity via a stronger tendency to selective attention and the other from unemployment or a higher number of chronic diseases via a lower quantity of external information. The effect of age on physical symptoms was mediated by the number of chronic diseases and the tendency to selectively attend to bodily sensations. The effects on physical symptoms proved to depend partly on the method of symptom measurement and varied according to the mediating role of negative mood and the tendency to make psychological attributions. Overall, this study highlights the importance of estimating the independent contribution of variables to the experience of common physical symptoms in a comprehensive model while taking into account the method of symptom measurement. In addition, it demonstrates the usefulness of a symptom perception approach for further study.
Social role occupancy, gender, income adequacy, life stage and health: A longitudinal study of employed Canadian men and women
2003, Social Science and Medicine
Social role researchers are increasingly going beyond simply asking whether role occupancy is associated with health status to clarifying the context in which particular social role–health relationships emerge. Building on this perspective, the present study investigates the relationship between social role occupancy and health status over time in a sample of employed Canadian men and women who vary by family role occupancy, life stage, and income adequacy. Results indicated that compared to triple role women (defined as those who are married, have children living at home and are in the workforce), single and double role occupants in 1994/95 were significantly more likely to report poorer self-rated health and the presence of a chronic health condition in 1996/97. This relationship held true for women in varying life stage and economic circumstances. While family role occupancies were not as strongly related to the health status of men as women, one exception emerged: for older men, single and double role occupants reported significantly poorer self-rated health status than triple role men. Methodological limitations of the study are discussed, and the need for added specificity in the study of social roles and health status emphasized.
Premigration social adversity and autism spectrum disorder
2020, BJPsych Open
The value of carer involvement has been extensively researched and promoted. However, the field lacks exploration of conceptual issues, which might help to explain why there are widespread difficulties in putting policy into practice in this area, as implementation rates remain low internationally.
This qualitative study explored patients’, carers’ and clinicians’ perspectives on the role of carers in mental healthcare, particularly with regards to in-patient settings.
Sixteen focus groups were conducted with patients, carers and clinicians who have current or previous experience of in-patient settings. A thematic analysis was conducted on the transcripts, exploring two key domains: (a) what a ‘carer’ is, and (b) how the ‘carer’ role is described within the context of the hospital environment.
Participants diverged in their opinions of what the ‘carer’ role entails, and the perceived helpfulness of it. Issues unique to the in-patient setting were identified, such as the role of the hospital environment in enabling or being a barrier to carer involvement. These differing perspectives and contextual factors had an impact on the position of carers in the hospital setting, as they could be viewed as helpful, a hindrance or as passive visitors, depending on the perspectives of clinicians.
More clarity and agreement is needed between patients, carers and clinicians in terms of how the ‘carer’ role is defined. This has the potential to improve carers’ experience of involvement in hospital settings.
A biosocial model of medication use among older women and men in Ismailia, Egypt
2006, Journal of Biosocial Science

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text