Abstract
A total of 636 1-day-old male Cobb chicks were randomly assigned to seven treatments. The chicks were offered feed and water ad libitum throughout the experimental period. The first three groups included different stocking densities of broiler birds (low stocking density, LSD: 23 kg/m2; medium stocking density, MSD: 34 kg birds/m2; and high stocking density HSD: 39 kg birds/m2). The LSD group was considered a control group. The other four groups included MSD or HSD broiler birds supplemented with either Vit E (100 mg/kg DM diet; MSDVE and HSDVE) or Zn (100 mg/kg DM diet; MSDZn and HSDZn) in their basal diet. The main findings indicated that HSD and MSD negatively affected (p < 0.05) all variables under investigation compared with LSD. Compared with LSD, broiler birds in the MSD and HSD groups had lower body weights and higher feed conversion ratios, higher concentrations of blood plasma hormones (triiodothyronine thyroxine and corticosterone), and downregulated expression levels of hepatic growth hormone and insulin-like growth factor-l. In addition, broiler birds stocked at medium or high densities resulted in less economic return and profit. Vit E or Zn supplementation to broiler birds stocked at medium or high densities significantly reversed all adverse effects of HSD (> 23 kg/m2) on growth performance, hormones, and gene expression. It could be recommended that adding Zn at a level of 100 mg/kg per DM diet allows increasing the stocking density of broiler birds from 23 kg/m2 to 34 birds/m2 while maintaining the birds, welfare and economic profit.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Worldwide poultry production has a significant economic role and remains at the top of meat production industries. Recently, poultry production has rapidly become more intensive to support the resilience of global food supply chains and meet the increased demand for animal protein sources. Thus, in the modern poultry industry, broilers are usually reared at a high stocking density (HSD) to maximize the number of chickens produced per square meter of space to decrease the cost of production and to achieve sufficient economic returns (Abudabos et al. 2013; Goo et al. 2019; Li et al. 2019). However, HSD of birds is usually related to negative effects on birds’ welfare and health and thus their productivity, which may negate the outputs and profits of intensive production (Simitzis et al. 2012).
Growth hormone (GH), triiodothyronine (T3), thyroxine (T4), and insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) are the main hormones that determine the expected growth in chickens (Scanes 2009). GH directly works on growth, development, and metabolism (Kim 2010). GH activates hepatic IGF-I release indirectly by combining GH receptors on the liver membrane. IGF-1 is a multifunctional polypeptide hormone that significantly affects growth and development and is more like the insulin hormone. An alteration in this gene can affect its expression level and thus affect the developmental characteristics of animals. Therefore, IGF-1 can be a better indicator for growth (Duclos 2005). Among trace minerals, specific importance is given to Zn due to its involvement in several important biological events such as maintaining growth performance, boosting the immune system, and supporting the antioxidant defense system (Shah et al. 2018; Hidayat et al. 2020). It regulates the process of skeletal development, membrane protection, prostaglandin metabolism, and lipid metabolism. Zn is involved in the activity of more enzymes, and the metalloenzymes (Tatiane et al. 2020). Of vital vitamins for growing chicks, Vit E is one of the essential vitamins in poultry nutrition, and it is considered a natural antioxidant usually provided in the form of synthetic alpha-tocopherol (Vieira et al. 2021). It is well known that vitamin E supplementation has a protective function in such stressful conditions (Lohakare et al. 2016). Vitamin E is a fat-soluble vitamin known to be a biological membranous lipid component and natural antioxidant. Fundamentally, vitamin E is located in the membrane lipid bilayer hydrocarbon part towards the membrane interface near to oxidase enzymes, which initiate free radicals production (Khalifa et al. 2021). These free radicals are generated due to normal cell activity and increase due to several stress factors. Thus, vitamin E protects cells and tissues from free radicals that cause oxidative damage to the cells (Part et al. 2004).
Supplementing Vit E to feed could overcome the undesirable effects of overcrowding stress and positively impact broiler chickens’ productive performances (Khalifa et al. 2021; Part et al. 2004). More information is required to understand the mechanisms by which HSD can biologically affect productivity and the birds’ health. Also, previous studies have not adequately addressed the economic efficiency of rearing birds at a HSD. In this study, we focused on studying the effects of different levels of stocking densities (SD) on growth and stress-related hormones to identify how these physiological processes are affected by overcrowding. We also investigated whether organic Vit E or Zn supplementation could alleviate the detrimental effects of HSD on the growth performance, physiological parameters, and gene expression of broiler birds. We chose these two supplementations based on their important biological roles in poultry (Shah et al. 2018; Hidayat et al. 2020). Finally, we evaluated the impacts of HSD and the expected benefits of adding Vit E or Zn economically to consider the profitability of one broiler fattening cycle.
Materials and methods
Birds and diets
This study was performed at the Center of Experimental Animal Research, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Benha University, Egypt, during the period from September 8 to October 20 in 2020. All procedures and the research protocol were carried out following the guidelines of the Local Committee for Experimental Animal Care and were confirmed by the ethics of the Institutional Animals Care and Use committee Research Ethics Board, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Benha University, under ethical number BUFVTM 08–06-21.
A total of 636 male, 1-day-old chick Cobb-500 broilers were obtained from local hatcheries. All chicks were subjected to the same managerial and hygienic housing conditions. The chicks were transported, weighed, wing banded, and then housed in well-ventilated litter floor pens and stocked in an area 50 cm high × 100 cm wide × 100 cm long. The chicks were exposed to a near-continuous photoperiod length of 23 L:1D with rotation. During the experimental period (6 weeks), the chicks received a typical feeding program that covered their nutritional requirements during different growth phases. The chicks were fed corn-soybean meal-based-basal diets and formulated to meet the nutritional specifications of the Cobb-500 broilers management guide (avialable at: https://www.cobb-vantress.com/assets/5a88f2e793/Broiler-Performance-Nutrition-Supplement.pdf). The feeding program included a starter diet (offered during the first and second weeks of age), grower diet (offered during the third and fourth weeks of age), and finisher diet (offered during the fifth and sixth weeks of age) in a pelleted form. The ingredients and calculated chemical composition of each basal diet are presented in Table 1.
The chicks were distributed randomly into seven treatment groups, with six replicate pens each, with different SDs and dietary supplementations, as follows: (1) low SD (LSD: 10 chicks/m2; control), (2) medium SD (MSD: 15 chicks/m2), (3) high SD (HSD: 17 chicks/m2), (4) MSD (15 chicks/m2) supplemented with 100 mg Vit E/kg DM (MSDVE), (5) HSD (17 chicks/m2) supplemented with 100 mg Vit E/kg DM (HSDVE), (6) MSD (15 chicks/m2) supplemented with 100 mg Zn/kg DM (MSDZn), and (7) HSD (17 chicks/m2) supplemented with a 100 mg Zn/kg DM diet (HSDZn).
Dietary supplementations, Vit E or Zn, were added to all three basal diets at a 100 mg/kg DM diet level. Vit E, alpha-tocopherol acetate, was obtained from Sigma Al-drich Co., USA. Zn mineral and the zinc amino acid complex were obtained from Multi vita Co., Egypt, with a commercial name Availa-Zn 120.
Evaluation of growth performance
Bodyweight (BW) and body weight gain (BWG) were calculated according to Mohammed et al. (2021a), \(\mathrm{BWG}=\mathrm{BW}2-\mathrm{BW}1\) Feed intake (FI) was calculated as the difference between the offered feed’s weight and the refused feed’s weight. The feed conversion ratio (FCR) was calculated \(\mathrm{FCR}\:=\:\mathrm{FI}\;(\mathrm g/\mathrm{bird}/\mathrm{week})/\mathrm{BWG}\;(\mathrm g/\mathrm{bird}/\mathrm{week})\) according to Shehata et al. (2021).
Evaluation of economic efficiency
Economic efficiency comprising the costs of production and return parameters was estimated. Costs of production included total costs (TC), which consisted of total variable costs (TVC) and total fixed costs (TFC). TVC involved the cost of feed consumed, veterinary management, labor, price of chicks, water and electricity, and litter (Al-khalaifah et al. 2020). This was estimated as an average value for each bird in each group per LE (1 USD ≈ 15.67 LE) during the experimental period. TFC included depreciation of the building and equipment.
Total feed cost = total FI per single bird × price/kg (Tareen et al. 2017). The return parameters included total return (TR = live BW and net profit (NP = TR-TC)) (CO and KI 2015). Using the previously mentioned cost and return parameters, economic efficiency measures were calculated as follows: benefit cost ratio (BCR) = TR (L.E/chick/group)/TC (L.E/chick/group), TR (L.E/chick/group/TVC (L.E/chick/group), NP/TC, NP/TVC, BW/kg (Final BW/1000), and WG/kg (Final BWG/1000) (Mohammed et al. 2021b).
Analysis of mRNA expression of growth hormone (GH) and insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) genes
At the end of the experiment (week 6), two randomly selected birds of each replicate (n = 12 birds/treatment) were slaughtered. Liver samples were immediately stabilized in an RNA stabilization reagent (RNA Later solution; 10 μL per 1 mg of hepatic tissue, Qiagen-GmbH, Germany), and stored at − 80 °C for subsequent total RNA extraction. A total RNA purification kit (Easy Red TM, Intron Biotechnology, Korea) was used for total RNA extraction following the manufacturer’s protocol; that is, 100-mg hepatic tissue was placed in a microcentrifuge tube with 750 μL Trizol solution and homogenized with Rotor Tissue Ruptor (Qiagen, GmbH, Germany). The quantity and purity of the RNA were examined by determining the absorbance in a Spectro Star Nanodrop spectrophotometer (BMG Lab Tec, GmbH, Germany). An RNA concentration of 40 μg/ml corresponds to an absorbance value of 1.0 at 260 nm. Pure RNA has an A260/A280 ratio of 1.8–2.0. A 2 × Reverse Transcriptase Master Mix (Applied Biosystems, USA) was used to synthesize cDNA following the manufacturer’s directions. Relative quantification of the m-RNA expression for the studied genes was carried out via real-time PCR with SYBR green. In a 20 μL reaction mixture containing 10 μL SYBR Green qPCR Master Mix (TOPreal™ qPCR 2X PreMIX), 1 μL of 1 μg/μL cDNA, 1 μM of each forward and reverse primer, and nuclease free water were added to reach 20 μL. Reactions were then made on an Applied Biosystem 7500 Fast Real-time under the following conditions: initial heating at 95 °C for 10 min, 40 cycles of 95 °C for 15 s then 60 °C for 1 min. The primer sequences of GH, IGF-1, and β-actin (used as a housekeeping gene) were 5’-AAGGGATCCAAGCTCCTGAT-3’ (5’-3’ sequence forward) and 5’-ATAACCACGTCCCTCAGTGC-3’ (5’-3’ sequence reverse); 5’-CACCTAAATCTGCACGCT-3’ (5’-3’ sequence forward) and 5’-CTTGTGGATGGCATGATCT-3’(5’-3’ sequence reverse) and 5’- ACCCCAAAGCCAACAGA-3’ (5’-3’ sequence forward) and 5’-CCAGAGTCCATCACAATACC -3’ (5’-3’ sequence reverse), respectively (Gasparino et al. 2014). The PCR primers were manufactured by Invitrogen (Thermo Fisher Scientific, USA). Changes in gene expression were measured from the cycle threshold (Ct) values obtained relative to those provided by real-time PCR instrumentation using the 2−ΔΔCt calculation, where ΔCt indicates the changes in Ct in target genes compared with those in a reference (housekeeping) gene (Schmittgen and Livak 2008). The Ct is defined as the time when the measured fluorescence rises above the background fluorescence and serves as a tool for calculating the starting template amount in each sample.
Blood samples for determination of the plasma level of growth-related hormones
At weeks 3 and 6 of the experimental period, a blood sample was collected from the jugular vein of two randomly selected birds of each replicate (n = 12 birds/treatment). Samples were retrieved in vacutainer tubes (coated with heparin) and then centrifuged at 3000 rpm for 15–30 min. Plasma was carefully collected and kept frozen at − 20 °C until subsequent analyses.
Concentrations of plasma glucose were determined using an autoanalyzer detector colorimetric procedure according to the instructions provided by the manufacturer (Biodiagnostic Company Giza, Egypt). Concentrations of blood plasma thyroxin (T4), triiodothyronine (T3) (Guangzhou Wondfo Biotech Co., Ltd. No.8 Lizhishan Road, Science City, Luogang District, 510,663, Guangzhou, P.R. China), and corticosterone (corticosterone: ADI-900–097 Enzo Life Sciences, Inc., Madison Avenue New York, NY, 10,022, USA) were measured using commercial kits following the provided analysis instructions. The sensitivity of the methods was 0.39 ng/ml, 0.01 μg/ml, and 0.027 ng/ml for T3, T4, and corticosterone, respectively.
Statistical analysis
The results were statistically analyzed using IBM SPSS version 22. All data were subjected to a one-way ANOVA to detect the differences among the different treatment groups. Contrast analysis was carried out using the control/LSD, MSD, and HSD experimental groups to identify the effects of different SDs on different independent variables regardless of the effect of supplementation. Furthermore, the contrast analysis was carried out to identify the effects of each supplementation (Vit E or Zn) on different independent variables compared with the LSD group. The differences among the means of the experimental groups were detected using Tukey’s test at a 5% probability level. The obtained results are shown as the mean ± pooled standard error of the mean.
Results
Growth performance
Table 2 shows the effects of different SDs and the influence of Vit E or Zn supplementation to MSD or HSD birds on the BW, BWG, FI, and FCR of broiler birds during the experimental period. SDs of broiler birds significantly affected the BW, BWG, FI, and FCR of birds. Birds in the MSD and HSD groups showed significant decreases in all growth parameters than birds in the LDS group. At the grower phase, the addition of either Vit E or Zn to the birds stocked at medium or high density (MSDVE, HSDEV, MSDZn, and HSDZn) resulted in similar BW compared with the LDS (control) group and significantly higher BW compared with the MSD and LSD groups. However, this trend was only observed in the MSDVE and MSDZn groups at the finisher phase (week 6). The highest (p < 0.05) overall means of BWG were observed in the LSD, MSDZn, and MSDVE groups. The addition of either Vit E or Zn to the birds stocked at high density (HSDEV and HSDZn) significantly improved the overall means of BWG compared with those stocked at the same densities but without supplementations.
Adding either Vit E or Zn to the birds stocked at MSD or HSD (MSDVE, HSDEV, MSDZn, and HSDZn) significantly improved FI compared with the MSD and HSD groups during the finisher phase (weeks 4 to 6 of age). However, the highest overall means of FI were observed in the MSDZn and MSDVE groups. Among the different groups, the lowest (better feed efficiency) overall means of FCR were observed in the LSD, MSDZn, and MSDVE groups.
Metabolism and gene expression
Table 3 shows the effect of different SDs and the influence of Vit E or Zn supplementation to medium or high stocked birds on blood plasma glucose, T3, T4, and corticosterone, and liver m-RNA expression of GH and IGF-l genes of broiler birds. The SD of broiler birds had significant effects on the blood plasma glucose, T3, T4, and corticosterone. At week 3 of age, blood plasma glucose was not affected by the SD; however, significant increases in blood plasma glucose concentrations were observed in the MSD and HSD groups compared with the LSD group. The concentrations of blood plasma T3, T4, and corticosterone of broiler birds in the MSD and HSD groups increased significantly compared to those recorded for the LSD group either at week three or week 6 of age.
At week 3 of age, blood plasma glucose was significantly decreased in the MSDZn, HSDZn, MSDVE, and HSDVE groups at the third and sixth weeks of age compared with the LSD, MSD, and HSD groups. This trend changed at week 6 of age, as the differences between Vit E- or Zn-supplemented groups and the LSD group disappeared while remaining lower than that observed in the MSD and HSD groups. The concentrations of T3 did not differ between the LSD group and all groups supplemented with either Vit E or Zn, whereas the highest values were observed in the MSD and HSD groups either at week 3 or week 6 of age. At week 3 of age, the concentrations of blood plasma T4 and corticosterone of all Vit E- or Zn-supplemented groups did not differ from those observed in the LSD group, whereas the highest values were observed in the MSD and HSD groups. At week 6 of age, all Vit E- or Zn-supplemented groups had significantly decreased blood plasma T4 and corticosterone concentrations compared with the LSD group, whereas the highest values were observed in the MSD and HSD groups.
For the relative expression levels of mRNAs of GH and IGF-1 genes, broiler birds stocked at medium or high density had significantly decreased expression levels of both genes in the liver tissues compared with those stocked at low stocking density. Comparing the MSD and HSD groups, the expression levels of GH and IGF-1 genes were significantly improved by dietary supplementation of Vit E or Zn, but they did not differ from the LSD group.
Economic efficiency
Table 4 shows the effects of different SDs and the influence of Vit E or Zn supplementation to medium or high stocked birds on the economic parameters and economic efficiency measures during the experimental period. As for the costs of starter (1st and 2nd weeks) and grower (3rd and 4th weeks) diets, there were no significant differences among the LSD and other groups either supplemented or not supplemented with Vit E or Zn. However, the cost of the finisher diet showed a significant (p < 0.05) difference among the different groups. The MSDZn group showed higher finisher diet costs, followed by the HSDVE and MSDVE groups. The broiler sale, TR, and NP differed significantly in the LSD group compared with the other experimental groups.
Higher values were observed for broiler sales and TR in the MSDZn groups, followed by the LSD group. In contrast, lower broiler sales and TR were detected in the MSD and HSD groups. The highest values of NR were observed in the LSD, MSDZn, and MSDVE groups. Economic efficiency measures revealed that TR/TVC, NP/TC, NP/TVC, and BCR were significantly increased in the LSD group followed by the MSDZn, MSD, and HSD groups. At the same time, BW/kg and BWG/kg were found to considerably increase in the MSDZn group, followed by the LSD, MSD, and HSD groups.
Discussion
In modern livestock production systems, the intensification of production is one of the measures applied to meet the increasing demand for animal protein sources. However, stocking animals at a high density is always related to increased health hazards, and it requires good husbandry practices by the farmers. Intensive farming increases the sensitivity of birds to external stressors from their surrounding environment resulting in acute stress responses, reduced productivity, health problems, and low-quality poultry products (Li et al. 2019), thus achieving the balance between intensive farming and animals’ health levels while keeping the production process profitable is problematic.
In this study, we investigated the effects of different SDs to find the density that does not negatively impact the health performance of birds, and we also aimed to find an effective and simple measure to mitigate the adverse effects of HSD. These investigations were underpinned by economic evaluation to achieve a practical and economic recommendation for the breeders who have to breed their birds intensively. This study showed that HSD (13 and 15 birds/m2) negatively impacted the overall BW and BWG. These results are in agreement with those previously reported in several studies in which the ideal SD of broiler birds was between 7 to 10 birds/m2 (Gasparinoa et al. 2014; Mohammed et al. 2021a). In fact, the decreases in FI by birds stocked at high densities can be one of the factors that negatively affect BW and BWG, specifically at grower and finisher phases. Increasing weights/sizes of the birds during fattening may hindrance access to feeders, increasing the competition between birds to get to the feeders (Tong et al. 2012).
Birds stocked at high densities showed homeostasis changes specifically at the finisher phase, indicating the presence of stresses. These birds had high blood plasma glucose, T3, T4, and corticosterone. Biological and/or production stressors such as SD, heat, cold, cooping, restraint, and shackling evoke corticosterone synthesis in birds (Dozier et al. 2006; Alagawany et al., 2018). Furthermore, Antar et al. (2020) reported that stressors can increase the circulating concentrations of T3 and T4. The increase in blood plasma glucose of birds stocked at high densities is a normal result of increased corticosterone concentrations. Increased glucocorticoid concentrations are combined with increased concentrations of circulating glucose in chickens (Wang et al. 2012). The increases in circulating concentrations of glucose are likely to be due to increased rates of hepatic gluconeogenesis stimulated by the action of glucocorticoids and corticosterone. Other reasons for the increases in circulating glucose concentrations are probably due to the reduced utilization of glucose (Scanes 2016). The decreased growth rate by corticosterone was associated with the energy expenditure, proteolysis, and gluconeogenesis, by vital tissues such as muscles (Lin et al. 2004). Furthermore, high concentrations of corticosterone can significantly reduce FI and thus BWG in broiler birds (Luo et al. 2013).
In this study, the expressions of hepatic GH and IGF-l genes were downregulated by overcrowding at a molecular level. This was in harmony with results obtained by Liu et al. (2019), who stated that high SD harmed muscle and bone growth with a lower m-RNA expression of IGF-l. In context, Beccavin et al. (2001) found a positive association between the BW of broiler birds and hepatic IGF-I m-RNA expression levels. In growing broiler birds, IGF-l induces growth of the skeletal muscles by enhancing the protein synthesis rate (Wen et al. 2014). Overall, these metabolic and molecular changes with low FI explain the significant reductions in growth performance attributes of birds stocked at high densities (13 or 15 birds/m2).
Economically, stocking birds at high densities results in huge economic loss and low profitability as indicated by the decreased TR, NR, and other economic efficiency attributes. In fact, these economic losses were mainly due to the sensible decreases in BW and BWG, but not feeding costs, as FI was low in the birds stocked at high densities. This elucidates the decreased TVC values observed in the groups of birds stocked at high densities as feeding costs in poultry farms represent about 70–80% of the TVC (Al-Sagheer et al. 2019).
As an attempt to mitigate the negative impacts of overcrowding in poultry farms, we used either Vit E or Zn as feed additives for birds stocked at high densities. Generally, dietary supplemental vitamins and minerals can either boost the birds’ growth rates or alleviate negative effects of environmental and biological stresses (Shah et al. 2018; Hashem et al. 2017). Vit E can be adopted to enhance the growth performance of different farm animals, including broiler chickens, particularly under harsh environmental conditions and other stresses. In addition, Zn supplementation to broilers’ feed has positive effects on the growth performance of broilers and could increase the average daily gain and the FCR. In fact, we suggest that the requirements of vitamins and minerals under unfavorable environmental conditions are increased as different stressors increase the depletion and elimination of these vital molecules and worsen the animals’ overall health status (Hashem et al. 2017; Bortoluzzi et al. 2020).
In this study, the addition of Vit E or Zn to broiler birds stocked at high densities improved their growth performance as indicated by higher BW, BWG, and FCR. These results are inconsistent with reports of previous studies where Vit E supplementation to the birds stocked at high densities had better growth performance than those that did not receive Vit E supplementation (Elkhatim et al. 2020). Similarly, EL-Gogary et al. (2020) found that adding Zn in the diet for broiler chickens has beneficial effects on broiler birds’ growth performance and economic efficiency. The positive effects of either Vit E or Zn on growth performance can be ascribed to the ability of both supplementations to improve most physiological events impaired by the action of HSD. Birds stocked at high densities and supplemented with either Vit E or Zn showed a pattern of blood glucose concentrations (decreased compared to non-supplemented groups stocked at high densities) similar to those in birds stocked at low density, indicating the lack of negative effects of HSD on glucose metabolism. In fact, the decreases in blood plasma glucose concentrations in supplemented groups and LSD match the decreases in blood plasma corticosterone, as a reverse relationship is known between glucose concentrations and corticosterone. These decreases in blood plasma glucose could presumably result from insulin action that plays an essential role in regulating carbohydrates, glucose uptake, and lipid metabolism and stimulating growth by increasing protein synthesis and affecting the expression of growth-related genes (Taniguchi et al. 2006). However, our finding disagreed with the report that SD did not affect glucose concentrations (Abudabos et al. 2013).
This study observed significant decreases in stress-related hormones, including T3, T4, and corticosterone, in the LSD, MSDZn, HSDZn, MSDVE, and HSDVE groups. Several studies have shown that stress increased circulating concentrations of T3, T4, and corticosterone (Tareen et al. 2017). Actually, these hormones are pivotal for bone and muscle growth in broilers but only under physiological conditions (Li et al. 2019). In our study, Vit E or Zn supplementation upregulated GH, and IGF-1 m-RNA expression restored the negative effect of overcrowding on the broiler chicken’s growth. This is in line with the findings obtained by Hosseini-Mansoub et al. (2011), who stated that higher BW is obtained when birds received Vit E (100 mg/kg diet) or Zn (50 mg/kg diet) compared with control birds. Furthermore, Kirrella et al. (2021) suggested that the relative m-RNA expression of IGF-I and GH receptor genes was upregulated with the addition of corn silk meal in the broiler diet because of its higher Vit E content and other elements like Zn minerals. Additionally, Zn supplementation to male broilers elevated the serum concentrations of IGF-I (Tomaszewska et al. 2017). Also, Zn is required for the normal activity of numerous enzymes, structural proteins, and hormones, and is essential for growth and development, regulation of gene expression, and protein synthesis (Lin et al. 2004).
From an economic point of view, supplementing Zn to MSD birds (MSDZN) resulted in TR, NR, and other economic efficiency comparable to those recorded for MSD and HSD birds. This effect is mainly due to the improvements in all growth performance-related variables, which may compensate for the high costs of Vit E- or Zn-supplemented diets. There is a direct relationship between broiler sales and final BW, reflecting TR and NP (Tomaszewska et al. 2017; Kirrella et al. 2021).
Conclusion
Our results indicate that stocking broiler birds at a level of 10 birds/m2 are considered an ideal stocking density for Cobb-500 broilers. At this SD, birds can express adequate growth performance with no signs of stress and provide sufficient economic profit. However, if a breeder intends to apply an intensive farming system with the same production outputs, it is recommended that the SD should be 15 birds/m2 with Zn supplementation at a level of 100 mg/kg DM diet during the whole fattening cycle. This is an efficient measure to maintain the birds’ welfare and to achieve adequate growth performance and economic profit.
Data availability
Data are available upon request.
Abbreviations
- SD :
-
Stocking density
- LSD :
-
Low stocked denisity
- MSD :
-
Medium stocked density
- HSD :
-
High stocked density
- MSDVE :
-
Medium stocked density birds supplemented with Vit E
- HSDVE :
-
High stocked density birds supplemented with Vit E
- MSDZn :
-
Medium stocked density birds supplemented with Zn
- HSDZn :
-
High stocked density birds supplemented with Zn
- IBW :
-
Initial body weight
- FBW :
-
Final body weight
- BWG :
-
Body weight gain
- FI :
-
Feed intake
- FCR :
-
Feed conversion rate
- TVM :
-
Total veterinary management
- TFC :
-
Total feed cost
- TVC :
-
Total variable cost
- TC :
-
Total costs
- TR :
-
Total return
- NR :
-
Net return
- kg :
-
Kilogram
- BCR :
-
Benefit cost ratio
- GH :
-
Growth hormone
- GHR :
-
Growth hormone receptor
- HSD :
-
High stocking density
- IGF1 :
-
Insulin-like growth factor 1
- RNA :
-
Ribonucleic acid
- IGF-l :
-
Insulin-like growth factor-l
- T 3 :
-
Triiodothyronine
- T 4 :
-
Thyroxin
- cortico :
-
Corticosterone
References
Abudabos AM, Samara EM, Hussein EOS, Al-Ghadi MQ, and Al-Atiyat RM,Abudabos AM, Samara EM, Hussein EOS, Al-Ghadi MQ, and Al-Atiyat RM, (2013) Impacts of stocking density on the performance and welfare of broiler chickens Italian Journal of Animal Science, 12:66–71
Al-khalaifah HS, Shahin SE, Omar AE, Mohammed HA, Mahmoud HI, and Ibrahim D,Al-khalaifah HS, Shahin SE, Omar AE, Mohammed HA, Mahmoud HI, and Ibrahim D, (2020) Effects of graded levels of microbial fermented or enzymatically treated dried brewer ’ s grains on growth , digestive and nutrient transporter genes expression and cost effectiveness in broiler chickens BMC Veterinary Research, 16:424 (BMC Veterinary Research)
Al-Sagheer, A., Abd El-Hack ME, Alagawany M, Naiel MA, Mahgoub SA, Badr MM, Hussein EOS, and Swelum ANA and AA,Al-Sagheer, A., Abd El-Hack ME, Alagawany M, Naiel MA, Mahgoub SA, Badr MM, Hussein EOS, and Swelum ANA and AA, (2019) Paulownia Leaves as A New Feed Resource: Chemical Composition and Effects on Growth, Carcasses, Digestibility, Blood Biochemistry, and Intestinal Bacterial Populations of Growing Rabbits Animals, 9:95
Alagawany M, Abd El-Hack ME, Farag MR, Elnesr SS, El-Kholy MS, Saadeldin IM, and Swelum AA,Alagawany M, Abd El-Hack ME, Farag MR, Elnesr SS, El-Kholy MS, Saadeldin IM, and Swelum AA, (2018) Dietary supplementation of Yucca schidigera extract enhances productive and reproductive performances, blood profile, immune function, and antioxidant status in laying Japanese quails exposed to lead in the diet Poultry Science, 97:3126–3137
Antar RI, Azab ME, Ismail RS, and Shousha SM, (2020) Genetic and hormonal differences between high ( Cobb Broiler ) and low ( Native Fayoumi ) growth rate breeds of chicken Benha veterinary medical Journal, 39:28–33
Beccavin C, Chevalier B, Cogburn LA, Simon J, and Duclos MJ, (2001) Insulin-like growth factors and body growth in chickens divergently selected for high or low growth rate Journal of Endocrinology,
Bortoluzzi C, Vieira BS, and Applegate TJ,Bortoluzzi C, Vieira BS, and Applegate TJ, (2020) Influence of Dietary Zinc, Copper, and Manganese on the Intestinal Health of Broilers Under Eimeria Challenge Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 7:1–7
CO E, and KI E, (2015) A Comparative Analysis of Profitability of Broiler Production Systems in Urban OURNAL OF A PPLIED S A Comparative Analysis of Profitability of Broiler Production Systems in Urban Areas J. Appl. Sci. Environ. Manage, 19 (4):627–631
Dozier WA, Thaxton JP, Purswell JL, Olanrewaju HA, Branton SL, and Roush WB, (2006) Stocking density effects on male broilers grown to 1.8 kilograms of body weight Poultry Science, 85:344–351 (Poultry Science Association, Inc.)
Duclos MJ, (2005) Insulin-like Growth Factor-I (IGF-1) mRNA levels and chicken muscle growth. Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology, 56:25–35
EL-Gogary MR., and EL-Maaty and HMAA,EL-Gogary MR., and EL-Maaty and HMAA, (2020) Impact of Zinc Supplementation and Stocking Density on Performance , Physiological and Immune Responses in Broiler Chickens Journal of Animal and Poultry Production Impact of Zinc Supplementation and Stocking Density on Performance , Physiological and Imm J. of Animal and Poultry Production, Mansoura Univ., 11:95–102
Elkhatim I M, Osman Abda H, Hassan Mha O, Babiker Ma MS, lhadi Hass HE, and A. Abdegad A,Elkhatim I M, Osman Abda H, Hassan Mha O, Babiker Ma MS, lhadi Hass HE, and A. Abdegad A, (2020) Evaluation of Inclusion of Medicinal Plants Seeds and Alpha-tocopherol on Broilers Meat Fatty Acids Content and Blood Parameters Research Journal of Medicinal Plants, 14:174–181
Gasparino E, Del Vesco AP, Voltolini DM, Nascimento CSD, Batista E, Khatlab AS, Grieser DO, Zancanela V, and GuimarÃEs SEF,Gasparino E, Del Vesco AP, Voltolini DM, Nascimento CSD, Batista E, Khatlab AS, Grieser DO, Zancanela V, and GuimarÃEs SEF, (2014) The effect of heat stress on GHR, IGF-I, ANT, UCP and COXIII mRNA expression in the liver and muscle of high and low feed efficiency female quail British Poultry Science, 55:466–473 (Taylor and Francis Ltd.)
Gasparinoa E, Del Vescoa A., Voltolinia DM, Do BNNascimentob CS, Batistaa E, and Khatlaba, A. S., Griesera, D.O., Zancanelaa, V., and Guimarãesb SEF,Gasparinoa E, Del Vescoa A., Voltolinia DM, Do BNNascimentob CS, Batistaa E, and Khatlaba, A. S., Griesera, D.O., Zancanelaa, V., and Guimarãesb SEF, (2014) The effect of heat stress on GHR , IGF-I , ANT , UCP and COXIII mRNA expression in the liver and muscle of high and low feed efficiency female quail British Poultry Science, 1–8
Goo D, Kim JH, Park GH, Reyes JBD, and Kil DY,Goo D, Kim JH, Park GH, Reyes JBD, and Kil DY, (2019) Effect of heat stress and stocking density on growth performance, breast meat quality, and intestinal barrier function in broiler chickens Animals, 9:1–10 (MDPI AG)
Hashem NM, Abd El-Hady AM, and Hassan OA,Hashem NM, Abd El-Hady AM, and Hassan OA, (2017) Inclusion of phytogenic feed additives comparable to vitamin E in diet of growing rabbits: Effects on metabolism and growth Annals of Agricultural Sciences, 62:161–167 (Elsevier B.V.)
Hidayat C, Jayanegara A, and Wina E,Hidayat C, Jayanegara A, and Wina E, (2020) Effect of zinc on the immune response and production performance of broilers: a meta-analysis Asian-Australas J Anim Sci, 33:465–479
Hosseini-Mansoub N, Chekani-Azar S, Tehrani A, Lotfi A, and Manesh M,Hosseini-Mansoub N, Chekani-Azar S, Tehrani A, Lotfi A, and Manesh M, (2011) Influence of dietary vitamin E and zinc on performance, oxidative stability and some blood measures of broiler chickens reared under heat stress (35 °C) Journal of Agrobiology, 27:103–110
Khalifa OA, Al Wakeel RA, Hemeda SA, Abdel-Daim MM, Albadrani GM, El Askary A, Fadl SE, and Elgendey F,Khalifa OA, Al Wakeel RA, Hemeda SA, Abdel-Daim MM, Albadrani GM, El Askary A, Fadl SE, and Elgendey F, (2021) The impact of vitamin E and/or selenium dietary supplementation on growth parameters and expression levels of the growth-related genes in broilers BMC Veterinary Research, 17:1–10 (BMC Veterinary Research)
Kim JW, (2010) The endocrine regulation of chicken growth Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences, 23:1668–1676
Kirrella AA, Abdo SE, El-Naggar K, Soliman MM, Aboelenin SM, Dawood MAO, and Saleh AA, (2021) Use of corn silk meal in broiler diet: Effect on growth performance, blood biochemistry, immunological responses, and growth-related gene expression Animals, 11
Li W, Wei F, Xu B, Sun Q, Deng W, Ma H, Bai J, and Li S,Li W, Wei F, Xu B, Sun Q, Deng W, Ma H, Bai J, and Li S, (2019) Effect of stocking density and alpha-lipoic acid on the growth performance, physiological and oxidative stress and immune response of broilers Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences, 32:1914–1922 (Asian-Australasian Association of Animal Production Societies)
Lin H, Decuypere E, and and Buyse J,Lin H, Decuypere E, and and Buyse J, (2004) Oxidative stress induced by corticosterone administration in broiler chickens (Gallus gallus domesticus): 2. Short-term effect Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology - B Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, 139:745–751
Liu S, Wang X, Zhou Y, Feng J, Li X, Xing S, Zhang M, Ma D, (2019) Effects of stocking density on growth performance, growth regulatory factors, and endocrine hormones in broilers under appropriate environments Poultry Science, 98 (Oxford University Press)
Lohakare JD, Hahn T, Shim YH, Choi JY, and Chae BJ,Lohakare JD, Hahn T, Shim YH, Choi JY, and Chae BJ, (2016) Effects of Feeding Methods ( Feed vs . Water ) of Vitamin E on Growth Performance and Meat Quality of Broilers Effects of Feeding Methods ( Feed vs . Water ) of Vitamin E on Growth Performance and Meat Quality of Broilers. https://doi.org/10.5713/ajas.2004.1260
Luo JW, Zhou ZL, Zhang H, Ma RS, and Hou JF, (2013) Bone response of broiler chickens (Gallus gallus domesticus) induced by corticosterone, Journal of Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology.3: 414-420
Mohammed LS, Sallam EA, Edris SN, Khalifa OA, Soliman MM, and Shehata SF, (2021a) Growth performance, economic efficiency, meat quality, and gene expression in two broiler breeds fed different levels of tomato pomace Veterinary Research Communications.1-17. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11259-021-09819-x (Springer Netherlands)
Mohammed LS, Sallam EA, El Basuni SS, Eldiarby AS, Soliman MM, Aboelenin SM, and Shehata SF, (2021b) Ameliorative effect of neem leaf and pomegranate peel extracts in coccidial infections in new zealand and v-line rabbits: Performance, intestinal health, oocyst shedding, carcass traits and effect on economic measures Animals, 11:1-28
Part H, Food BP, El-demerdash F, Yousef MI, and Baghdadi HH, (2004) Role of alpha-tocopherol and beta-carotene in ameliorating the fenvalerate-induced changes in oxidative stress, hemato-biochemical parameters, and semen quality of male rats JJournal of Environmental Science and Health Part B Pesticides Food Contaminants and Agricultural Wastes. https://doi.org/10.1081/PFC-120035929
Scanes CG, (2009) Perspectives on the endocrinology of poultry growth and metabolism. General and Comparative Endocrinology,163:24–32
Scanes CG, (2016) Biology of stress in poultry with emphasis on glucocorticoids and the heterophil to lymphocyte ratio Poultry Science, 95:2208–2215
Schmittgen TD, Livak KJ, (2008) Analyzing real-time PCR data by the comparative CT method. Nat Protoc, 3:1101–1108
Shah M, Zaneb H, Masood S, Khan I, Sikandar A, Ashraf S, Rehman HF, Usman MM, Khan FA, Amanullah H, and Rehman H,Shah M, Zaneb H, Masood S, Khan I, Sikandar A, Ashraf S, Rehman HF, Usman MM, Khan FA, Amanullah H, and Rehman H, (2018) Effect of zinc and probiotics supplementation on performance and immune organs morphology in heat stressed broilers South African Journal of Animal Sciences, 48:1017–1025
Shehata S, Sallam E, Azam A, Soliman M, and Mohammed L,Shehata S, Sallam E, Azam A, Soliman M, and Mohammed L, (2021) Effect of different dietary inclusion levels of mulberry leaves on productive traits, economic indices, and immunity of white and brown Japanese quail Alexandria Journal of Veterinary Sciences, 70:63
Simitzis PE, Kalogeraki E, Goliomytis M, Charismiadou MA, Triantaphyllopoulos K, Ayoutanti A, Niforou K, Hager-Theodorides AL, and Deligeorgis SG,Simitzis PE, Kalogeraki E, Goliomytis M, Charismiadou MA, Triantaphyllopoulos K, Ayoutanti A, Niforou K, Hager-Theodorides AL, and Deligeorgis SG, (2012) Impact of stocking density on broiler growth performance, meat characteristics, behavioural components and indicators of physiological and oxidative stress British Poultry Science, 53:721–730
Taniguchi CM, Emanuelli B, and and Kahn CR, (2006) Critical nodes in signalling pathways: Insights into insulin action.85-96
Tareen MH, Wagan R, Siyal FA, Babazadeh D, Bhutto ZA, Arain MA, and Saeed M,Tareen MH, Wagan R, Siyal FA, Babazadeh D, Bhutto ZA, Arain MA, and Saeed M, (2017) Effect of various levels of date palm kernel on growth performance of broilers Veterinary World, 10:227–232
Tatiane S dos S, Po-Yun T, Sudhir Y, Lima F, Castro DS, Gould RL, Craig SW, Chen C, Fuller AL, Pazdro R, Sartori JR, and Kim WK,Tatiane S dos S, Po-Yun T, Sudhir Y, Lima F, Castro DS, Gould RL, Craig SW, Chen C, Fuller AL, Pazdro R, Sartori JR, and Kim WK, (2020) Effects of Inorganic Zn and Cu Supplementation on Gut Health in Broiler Chickens Challenged With Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 7:1–8
Tomaszewska E, Muszyński S, Dobrowolski P, Kwiecień M, and Winiarska-Mieczan, AI., Świetlicka , I., and I Wawrzyniak A,Tomaszewska E, Muszyński S, Dobrowolski P, Kwiecień M, and Winiarska-Mieczan, AI., Świetlicka , I., and I Wawrzyniak A, (2017) Parameters , and Histomorphology in Male Ross 308 Brazilian Journal of Poultry Science, 19:159–170
Tong HB, Lu J, Zou JM, Wang Q, and Shi SR,Tong HB, Lu J, Zou JM, Wang Q, and Shi SR, (2012) Effects of stocking density on growth performance, carcass yield, and immune status of a local chicken breed. Poultry science, 91:667–73
Vieira V, Marx FO, Bassi LS, Santos MC, Oba A, de Oliveira SG, and Maiorka A,Vieira V, Marx FO, Bassi LS, Santos MC, Oba A, de Oliveira SG, and Maiorka A, (2021) Effect of age and different doses of dietary vitamin E on breast meat qualitative characteristics of finishing broilers Animal Nutrition, 7:163–167 (Elsevier Ltd)
Wang X juan, Wei D lin, Song Z gang, Jiao H chao, and Lin H, (2012) Effects of fatty acid treatments on the dexamethasone-induced intramuscular lipid accumulation in chickens PLoS ONE, 7
Wen C, Wu P, Chen Y, Wang T, and Zhou Y,Wen C, Wu P, Chen Y, Wang T, and Zhou Y, (2014) Methionine improves the performance and breast muscle growth of broilers with lower hatching weight by altering the expression of genes associated with the insulin-like growth factor-I signalling pathway British Journal of Nutrition, 111:201–206
Acknowledgements
We thank Professor Doctor Nasser Khadr (Professor of Nutrition and Clinical Nutrition, Dept. Faculty of Vet. Med. Benha University, Egypt) for his help and advice during the experiment.
Funding
Open access funding provided by The Science, Technology & Innovation Funding Authority (STDF) in cooperation with The Egyptian Knowledge Bank (EKB). This study was self-funded.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Conceptualization: S. F. S.; methodology: S. F. S., M. M. K., S. H. B., and M. M. E.; investigation: S. F. S., M. M. K., M. M. E., and S. H. B.; data curation: S. F. S., M. M. K., and S. H. B.; writing—original draft preparation: S. F. S., M. M. K., M. M. E., and S. H. B.; review and editing: S. F. S., N. M. H., M. M. E., S. H. B., and M. M. K.; supervision: S. F. S., M. M. E., and N. M. H. All authors have read and agreed to the manuscript’s current published version.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics approval
All the procedures were carried out after obtaining the ethical approval of Animals Care and Use committee Research Ethics Board, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Benha University, under ethical number BUFVTM 08–06-21.
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Shehata, S.F., Baloza, S.H., Elsokary, M.M.M. et al. Effect of stocking density and vitamin E or zinc supplementation on growth, physiology, gene expression, and economic efficiency of growing broiler chicks. Trop Anim Health Prod 54, 403 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11250-022-03382-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11250-022-03382-6