Abstract
Much of the literature shows that a compact city with well-mixed land use tends to produce lower vehicle miles traveled (VMT), and consequently lower energy consumption and less emissions. However, a significant portion of the literature indicates that the built environment only generates some minor—if any—influence on travel behavior. Through the literature review, we identify four major methodological problems that may have resulted in these conflicting conclusions: self-selection, spatial autocorrelation, inter-trip dependency, and geographic scale. Various approaches have been developed to resolve each of these issues separately, but few efforts have been made to reexamine the built environment-travel behavior relationship by considering these methodological issues simultaneously. The objective of this paper is twofold: (1) to better understand the existing methodological gaps, and (2) to reexamine the effects of built-environment factors on transportation by employing a framework that incorporates recently developed methodological approaches. Using the Seattle metropolitan region as our study area, the 2006 Household Activity Survey and the 2005 parcel and building data are used in our analysis. The research employs Bayesian hierarchical models with built-environment factors measured at different geographic scales. Spatial random effects based on a conditional autoregressive specification are incorporated in the hierarchical model framework to account for spatial contiguity among Traffic Analysis Zones. Our findings indicate that land use factors have highly significant effects on VMT even after controlling for travel attitude and spatial autocorrelation. In addition, our analyses suggest that some of these effects may translate into different empirical results depending on geographic scales and tour types.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Antipova, A., Wang, F., Wilmot, C.: Urban land uses, socio-demographic attributes and commuting: a multilevel modeling approach. Appl. Geogr. 31(3), 1010–1018 (2011)
Bhat, C.R.: A multi-level cross-classified model for discrete response variables. Transp. Res. Part B 34(7), 567–582 (2000)
Bhat, C.R., Guo, J.Y.: A comprehensive analysis of built environment characteristics on household residential choice and auto ownership level. Transp. Res. Part B 41(5), 506–526 (2007)
Bhat, C.R., Zhao, H.: The spatial analysis of activity stop generation. Transp. Res. Part B 36(6), 557–575 (2002)
Boarnet, M.G., Crane, R.: The influence of land use on travel behavior: specification and estimation strategies. Transp. Res. Part A 35(9), 823–845 (2001)
Boarnet, M.G., Sarmiento, S.: Can land-use policy really affect travel behavior? A study of the link between non-work travel and land-use characteristics. Urban Stud. 35(7), 1155–1169 (1998)
Bottai, M., Salvati, N., Orsini, N.: Multilevel models for analyzing people’s daily movement behavior. J. Geogr. Syst. 8(1), 97–108 (2006)
Brownstone, D.: Key relationships Between the Built Environment and VMT. Univeristy of California, Irvine (2008)
Brownstone, D., Golob, T.F.: The impact of residential density on vehicle usage and energy consumption. J. Urban Econ. 65, 91–98 (2009)
Cao, X., Mokhtarian, P.L., Handy, S.L.: Neighborhood design and vehicle type choice: evidence from Northern California. Transp. Res. Part D 11(2), 133–145 (2006)
Cao, X., Xu, Z., Fan, Y.: Exploring the connections among residential location, self-selection, and driving: propensity score matching with multiple treatments. Transp. Res. Part A 44(10), 797–805 (2010)
Cervero, R.: Land-use mixing and suburban mobility. Transport. Q. 42(3), 429–446 (1988)
Cervero, R.: Land uses and travel at suburban activity centers. Transp. Q. 45(4), 479–491 (1991)
Cervero, R.: Mixed land-uses and commuting: evidence from the American Housing Survey. Transp. Res. Part A 30(5), 361–377 (1996)
Cervero, R., Kockelman, K.: Travel demand and the three Ds: density, diversity, and design. Transp. Res. Part D 2(3), 199–219 (1997)
Chaix, B., Merlo, J., Subramanian, S.V., Lynch, J., Chauvin, P.: Comparison of a spatial perspective with the multilevel analytical approach in neighborhood studies: the case of mental and behavioral disorders due to psychoactive substance use in Malmo, Sweden, 2001. Am. J. Epidemiol. 162(2), 171–182 (2005)
Chen, C., Gong, H., Paaswell, R.: Role of the built environment on mode choice decisions: additional evidence on the impact of density. Transportation 35(3), 285–299 (2008)
Crane, R.: The influence of urban form on travel: an interpretive review. J. Plan. Lit. 15(1), 3–23 (2000)
de Abreu e Silva, J., Golob, T.F., Goulias, K.G.: Effects of land use characteristics on residence and employment location and travel behavior of urban adult workers. Transp. Res. Rec. 1977, 121–131 (2006)
Duncan, C., Jones, K.: Using multilevel models to model heterogeneity: potential and pitfalls. Geogr. Anal. 32(4), 279–305 (2000)
EPA: Greenhouse gas emissions from the U.S. transportation sector, 1990–2003. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC (2006)
Ewing, R., Cervero, R.: Travel and the built environment: a synthesis. Transp. Res. Rec. 1780, 87–114 (2001)
Ewing, R., Bartholomew, K., Winkelman, S., Walters, J., Chen, D.: Growing Cooler: The Evidence on Urban Development and Climate Change. ULI—The Urban Land Institute, Washington, DC (2008)
Fotheringham, A.S., Wong, D.W.S.: The modifiable areal unit problem in multivariate statistical analysis. Environ Plan A 23(7), 1025–1044 (1991)
Frank, L.D., Stone, B., Bachman, W.: Linking land use with household vehicle emissions in the central Puget Sound: methodological framework and findings. Transp. Res. Part D 5(3), 173–196 (2000)
Frank, L.D., Saelens, B.E., Powell, K.E., Chapman, J.E.: Stepping towards causation: do built environments or neighborhood and travel preferences explain physical activity, driving, and obesity? Soc. Sci. Med. 65, 1898–1914 (2007)
Frank, L.D., Bradley, M., Kavage, S., Chapman, J., Lawton, T.K.: Urban form, travel time, and cost relationships with tour complexity and mode choice. Transportation 35(1), 37–54 (2008)
Frumkin, H.: Urban sprawl and public health. Public Health Rep. 117, 201–217 (2002)
Gelman, A., Hill, J.: Data analysis using regression and multilevel/hierarchical models. Cambridge University Press, New York (2007)
Gelman, A., Pardoe, I.: Bayesian measures of explained variance and pooling in multilevel (hierarchical) models. Technometrics 48(2), 241–251 (2006)
Grazi, F., van den Bergh, J.C., van Ommeren, J.: An empirical analysis of urban form, transport, and global warming. Energy J. 29(4), 97–122 (2008)
Handy, S.: Smart growth and the transportation-land use connection: what does the research tell us? Int. Reg. Sci. Rev. 28(2), 146–167 (2005)
Handy, S.L., Boarnet, M.G., Ewing, R., Killingsworth, R.E.: How the built environment affects physical activity: views from urban Planning. Am. J. Prev. Med. 23(2S), 64–73 (2002)
Handy, S., Cao, X., Mokhtarian, P.: Correlation or causality between the built environment and travel behavior? Evidence from Northern California. Transp. Res. Part D 10, 427–444 (2005)
Hanson, S., Schwab, M.: Accessibility and intraurban travel. Environ. Plan. A 19(6), 735–748 (1987)
Heres-Del-Valle, D., Niemeier, D.: CO2 emissions: are land-use changes enough for California to reduce VMT? Specification of a two-part model with instrumental variables. Transp. Res. Part B 45(1), 150–161 (2011)
Hickman R, Banister D (2007) Transport and reduced energy consumption: what role can urban planning play? Working paper, Oxford University, Oxford
Horner, M.W., Murray, A.T.: Excess commuting and the modifiable areal unit problem. Urban Stud. 39(1), 131–139 (2002)
Jelinski, D.E., Wu, J.: The modifiable areal unit problem and implication for landscape ecology. Landsc. Ecol. 11(3), 129–140 (1996)
Kitamura, R., Mokhtarian, P.L., Laidet, L.: A micro-analysis of land use and travel in five neighborhoods in the San Francisco Bay Area. Transportation 24(2), 125–158 (1997)
Krizek, K.J.: Neighborhood services, trip purpose, and tour-based travel. Transportation 30(4), 387–410 (2003a)
Krizek, K.J.: Residential relocation and changes in urban travel: does neighborhood-scale urban form matter. J. Am. Plan. Assoc. 69(3), 265–281 (2003b)
Kwan, M., Weber, J.: Scale and accessibility: implications for the analysis of land use-travel interaction. Appl. Geogr. 28(2), 110–123 (2008)
Lawson, A.B.: Bayesian Disease Mapping: Hierarchical Modeling in Spatial Epidemiology. CRC Press, Boca Raton (2008)
LeSage, J.P.: Regression analysis of spatial data. J. Reg. Anal. Policy 27(2), 83–94 (1997)
Mokhtarian, P.L., Cao, X.: Examining the impacts of residential self-selection on travel behavior: a focus on methodologies. Transp. Res. Part B 42(3), 204–228 (2008)
Neuman, M.: The compact city fallacy. J. Plan. Educ. Res. 25, 11–26 (2005)
Pas, E.I.: The effect of selected sociodemographic characteristics on daily travel-activity behavior. Environ. Plan. A 16(5), 571–581 (1984)
Reason Foundation: Does bus transit reduce greenhouse gas emissions? http://reason.org/news/show/does-bus-transit-reduce-greenhouse (2010)
Recker, W.W., Schuler, H.J.: An integrated analysis of complex travel behavior and urban form indicators. Urban Geogr. 3(2), 110–120 (1982)
Schwanen, T., Dieleman, F.M., Dijst, M.: Car use in Netherlands daily urban systems: does polycentrism result in lower commute times? Urban Geogr. 24(5), 410–430 (2003)
Shen, Q.: Spatial and social dimensions of commuting. J. Am. Plan. Assoc. 66(1), 68–82 (2000)
Snellen, D., Borgers, A., Timmermans, H.: Urban form, road network type, and mode choice for frequently conducted activities: a multilevel analysis using quasi-experimental design data. Environ. Plan. A 34(7), 1207–1220 (2002)
Van Acker, V.V., Witlox, F.: Commuting trips within tours: how is commuting related to land use? Transportation 38(3), 465–486 (2011)
Vance, C., Hedel, R.: The impact of urban form on automobile travel: disentangling causation from correlation. Transportation 34(5), 575–588 (2007)
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to acknowledge the financial support of this work provided by the Federal Highway Administration through a research grant. We also want to thank Dr. Charlie Han, President of Macrosys Research and Technology, for his helpful comments on an earlier draft of this paper, and three anonymous referees for their constructive criticisms and suggestions.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hong, J., Shen, Q. & Zhang, L. How do built-environment factors affect travel behavior? A spatial analysis at different geographic scales. Transportation 41, 419–440 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11116-013-9462-9
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11116-013-9462-9