Abstract
Sewall Wright first encountered the complex systems characteristic of gene combinations while a graduate student at Harvard’s Bussey Institute from 1912 to 1915. In Mendelian breeding experiments, Wright observed a hierarchical dependence of the organism’s phenotype on dynamic networks of genetic interaction and organization. An animal’s physical traits, and thus its autonomy from surrounding environmental constraints, depended greatly on how genes behaved in certain combinations. Wright recognized that while genes are the material determinants of the animal phenotype, operating with great regularity, the special nature of genetic systems contributes to the animal phenotype a degree of spontaneity and novelty, creating unpredictable trait variations by virtue of gene interactions. As a result of his experimentation, as well as his keen interest in the philosophical literature of his day, Wright was inspired to see genetic systems as conscious, living organisms in their own right. Moreover, he decided that since genetic systems maintain ordered stability and cause unpredictable novelty in their organic wholes (the animal phenotype), it would be necessary for biologists to integrate techniques for studying causally ordered phenomena (experimental method) and chance phenomena (correlation method). From 1914 to 1921 Wright developed his “method of path coefficient” (or “path analysis”), a new procedure drawing from both laboratory experimentation and statistical correlation in order to analyze the relative influence of specific genetic interactions on phenotype variation. In this paper I aim to show how Wright’s philosophy for understanding complex genetic systems (panpsychic organicism) logically motivated his 1914–1921 design of path analysis.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agar, Wilfred E. 1943. A Contribution to the Theory of the Living Organism. Melbourne University Press
Allen, Garland E. 1983. “The Several Faces of Darwin: Materialism in Nineteenth and Twentieth Century Evolutionary Theory.” D.S. Bendall (ed.), Evolution from Molecules to Men. Cambridge University Press, pp. 81–102
Allen, Garland 1984. “Thomas Hunt Morgan: Materialism and Experimentalism in the Development of Modern Genetics.” Social Research 51: 709–738
Armstrong E.F. 1924. Chemistry in the Twentieth Century: An Account of the Achievement and Present State of Knowledge in Chemical Science. London: Benn
Bateson, William 1907. “Facts Limiting the Theory of Heredity.” Science 26: 649–660
Bergson, Henri. 1911. Creative Evolution. A. Mitchell (trans.), Henry Holt & Co
Bergson, Henri. 1920. Mind-Energy: Essays and Lectures. H. W. Carr (trans.), Henry Holt & Co
Bernard, Claude. 1927. An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine. H. C. Greene (trans.), Schuman Press
Canham, Marlene Rayner and Canham, Geoffroy Rayner 2002. “Past Times—Muriel Wheldale Onslow (1880–1932): Pioneer Plant Biochemist.” The Biochemist 24: 49–51
Cannon, Walter B. 1932. The Wisdom of the Body. W. W. Norton & Co
Carr H. Wildon. 1922. A Theory of Monads. Macmillan & Co
Castle, William E. 1909. “Material Basis of the Hereditary Factors.” Studies of Inheritance in Rabbits, Carnegie Institute of Washington No. 114
Clifford, William K. 1879. Lectures and Essays v2. L. Stephen and F. Pollack (eds.), Macmillan & Co
Cock, Alan G. 1973. “William Bateson, Mendelism and Biometry.” Journal of the History of Biology 6: 1–36
Cross, Stephen J. and Albury, William R. 1987. “Walter B. Cannon, L. J. Henderson, and the Organic Analogy.” Osiris 3: 165–192
Crow, James F. 1982. “Sewall Wright, the Scientist and the Man.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 25: 279–294
Crow, James F.1984. “The Founders of Population Genetics.” A. Chakravarti (ed.), Human Population Genetics: The Pittsburgh Symposium. Van Nostrand Reinhold, pp. 177–194
Crow, James F. 1990. “Sewall Wright’s Place in Twentieth-Century Biology.” Journal of the History of Biology 23: 57–89 [republished. 1992. S. Sarkar (ed.), The Founders of Evolutionary Genetics: a Centenary Reappraisal. Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 167–200]
Driesch, Hans. 1929. The Science and Philosophy of the Organism. 2nd ed A.&C. Black Publishing Co
Fisher R.A. 1918. Correlation Between Relatives on the Supposition of Mendelian Inheritance Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 52: 399–433
Fisher R.A. 1922. On The Dominance Ratio Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 42: 321–341
Fleming, Donald 1984. “Walter B. Cannon and Homeostasis.” Social Research 51: 609–640
Gerard, Ralph. 1940. “Organic Freedom.” Ruth Nanda (ed.), Freedom; its Meaning. Harcourt, Brace & Co
Gibbs, J. Willard. 1876–1878. On the Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Connecticut. Academy of Arts and Sciences
Griesemer James R. 1990. Material Models in Biology PSA 2: 79–93
Griesemer James R. 1991. Must Scientific Diagrams Be Eliminable? The Case of Path Analysis Biology and Philosophy 6: 155–180
Haldane J.S. 1884. Life and Mechanism. Mind 9: 27–47
Haldane, J.S.1917. Organism and Environment. Yale University Press
Haraway, Donna J. 1976. Crystals, Fabrics, and Fields: Metaphors of Organicism in Twentieth-Century Developmental Biology. Yale University Press
Heidelberger, M. 2004. Nature From Within: Gustav Theodor Fechner and His Psychophysical Worldview. University of Pittsburgh Press
Henderson, L.J. 1913. Fitness of the Environment. Macmillan & Co
Henderson, L.J.1917. Order of Nature. Cambridge University Press
Henderson, L.J. 1928. Blood: a Study in General Physiology. Yale University Press
Hodge, M.J.S. 1992. “Biology and Philosophy (Including Ideology): A Study of Fisher and Wright.” S. Sarkar (ed.), The Founders of Evolutionary Genetics: a Centenary Reappraisal. Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 231–293
Li C.C. 1956. The Concept of Path Coefficient and Its Impact on Population Genetics Biometrics 12: 190–210
Lillie, Ralph S. 1945. General Biology and the Philosophy of Organism. University of Chicago Press
Mayr, Ernst and Provine, William B. (eds.) 1980. The Evolutionary Synthesis: Perspectives on the Unification of Biology. Harvard University Press
Mayr Ernst 1959. Where Are We? Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology 24: 1–4
Montgomery, Edmund. 1880. “The Unity of the Organism.” Mind 5: 318–336, 465–489
Moore, Benjamin. 1912. The Origin and Nature of Life. Henry Holt & Co
Needham, Joseph. 1943. Time; The Refreshing River. Allen & Unwin
Norton B.J. 1975a. Biology and Philosophy: The Methodological Foundations of Biometry Journal of the History of Biology 8: 85–93
Norton B.J. 1975b. Metaphysics and Population Genetics: Karl Pearson and the Background to Fisher’s Multi-factorial Theory of Inheritance. Annals of Science 32: 537–553
Norton B.J. 1978. Karl Pearson and Statistics: the Social Origin of Scientific Innovation Social Studies of Science 8: 3–34
Pearson, Karl. 1911. The Grammar of Science, 3rd ed. Macmillan & Co
Pitt G.A.J. 2001. Liverpool: the Early Years of Biochemistry Biochemical Society Transactions 31: 16–19
Porter, Theodore M. 1986. The Rise of Statistical Thinking. Princeton University Press
Porter, Theodore M.2004. Karl Pearson: the Scientific Life in a Statistical Age. Princeton University Press
Provine, William B. 1971. The Origin of Theoretical Population Genetics. University of Chicago Press [reprint edition. 2001. University of Chicago Press]
Provine, William B.1978. “The Role of Mathematical Population Geneticists in the Evolutionary Synthesis of the 1930s and 1940s.” Studies in the History of Biology 2: 167–192
Provine, William B.1986. Sewall Wright and Evolutionary Biology. University of Chicago Press
Punnett R.C. 1950. Early Days of Genetics Heredity 4: 1–10
Rader, Karen A. 1998. “‘The Mouse People’: Murine Genetics Work at the Bussey Institution, 1909–1936.” Journal of the History of Biology 31: 327–354
Rader, Karen A. 2004. Making Mice: Standardizing Animals for American Biomedical Research, 1900–1955. Princeton University Press
Reed, Edward S. 1997. From Soul to Mind: The Emergence of Psychology from Erasmus Darwin to William James. Yale University Press
Richards, Robert J. 1987. Darwin and the Emergence of Evolutionary Theories of Mind and Behavior. University of Chicago Press
Ritter, William E. 1919. The Unity of the Organism or the Organismal Conception of Life, 2 vols. Badger Press
Ruse, Michael. 2004. “Adaptive Landscapes and Dynamic Equilibrium: The Spencerian Contribution to Twentieth-Century American Evolutionary Biology.” A. Lusting, R.J. Richards and M. Ruse (eds.), Darwinian Heresies. Cambridge University Press, pp. 131–150
Russett, Cynthia E. 1966. The Concept of Equilibrium in American Social Thought. Yale University Press
Sarkar, Sahotra (ed.) 1992. The Founders of Evolutionary Genetics: A Centenary Reappraisal. Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science v142. Kluwer Academic Publishers
Smocovitis, Vassiliki Betty. 1996. Unifying Biology: The Evolutionary Synthesis and Evolutionary Biology. Princeton University Press
Troland, Leonard T. 1922. “Psychophysics as Related to the Mysteries of Physics and Metaphysics.” Journal of the Washington Academy of Science 12: 141–162
Waddington, C.H. 1939. Introduction to Modern Genetics. Macmillan
Weir J.A. 1994. Harvard, Agriculture, and the Bussey Institution Genetics 136: 1227–1231
Whitehead, Alfred N. 1925. Science and the Modern World. Macmillan
Whitehead, Alfred N. 1929. Process and Reality. Cambridge University Press
Wilson, Margaret D. 1999. Ideas and Mechanism: Essays on Early Modern Philosophy. Princeton University Press
Wright Sewall 1917. The Average Correlation Within Subgroups of a Population Journal of the Washington Academy of Science 7: 532–535
Wright Sewall 1918. On the Nature of Size Factors Genetics 3: 367–374
Wright Sewall 1920. The Relative Importance of Heredity and Environment in Determining the Piebald Pattern of Guinea Pigs Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 6: 320–332
Wright Sewall 1921. Correlation and Causation Journal of Agricultural Research 20: 557–585
Wright Sewall 1931. Evolution in Mendelian Populations Genetics 16: 97–159
Wright Sewall 1932. The Roles of Mutation, Inbreeding, Crossbreeding and Selection in Evolution Proceedings of the Sixth International Congress of Genetics 1: 356–366
Wright Sewall 1934. The Method of Path Coefficients Annals of Mathematical Statistics 5: 161–215
Wright Sewall 1935. The Emergence of Novelty: A Review of Lloyd Morgan’s ‘Emergent’ Theory of Evolution Journal of Heredity 26: 369–373
Wright Sewall 1941. Review of A Philosophy of Science, by W. J. Werkmeister. The American Biology Teacher 3: 276–278
Wright Sewall 1953. “Gene and Organism.” Presidential Address to the American Society of Naturalists (Sept. 9, 1952) American Naturalist 87: 5–18
Wright Sewall 1959. “Genetics and the Hierarchy of Biological Science.” Presidential Address to the 10th International Congress of Genetics (Aug., 20, 1958) Science 130: 959–965
Wright Sewall. 1964. “Biology and the Philosophy of Science.” Monist 48: 265–290 [republished. 1964. W.L. Reese and E. Freeman (eds.), The Hartshorne Festschrift: Process and Divinity. Open Court, pp. 101–125]
republished. 1964. W. L. Reese and E. Freeman (eds.), The Hartshorne Festschrift: Process and Divinity. Open Court, pp. 101–125
Wright Sewall. 1968. Evolution and the Genetics of Populations: Genetics and Biometric Foundations v1. University of Chicago Press
Wright Sewall. 1975. “Panpsychism and Science.” J.E. Cobb, Jr. and D.R. Griffin (eds.), Mind in Nature. University Press of America, pp. 79–88
Wright Sewall 1978a. The Relation of Livestock Breeding to Theories of Evolution Journal of Animal Science 46: 1192–1200
Wright Sewall. 1978b. Evolution and the Genetics of Populations: Variability Within and Among Natural Populations v4. University of Chicago Press
Wright Sewall 1980. Genic and Organismic Selection Evolution 34: 825–843
Yule G. Udny, Filon L.N.G. 1936. Karl Pearson. 1857–1936 Obituary Notice of the Fellows of the Royal Society 2: 71–110
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Steffes, D.M. Panpsychic Organicism: Sewall Wright’s Philosophy for Understanding Complex Genetic Systems. J Hist Biol 40, 327–361 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-006-9105-5
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-006-9105-5