Abstract
Metaphors are essential devices for fostering collective understanding and forging political commitment across diverse constituencies. Due to the ineffectualness of prevailing linguistic representations of climate change, discursive entrepreneurs have begun to invoke over the last few years new imagery that frames the challenge as tantamount to a protracted state of armed hostility. This process of rhetorical militarization has been most prominent in the UK and it is subsequently creating opportunities for policy makers to propose greenhouse gas-reduction strategies that are reminiscent of wartime austerity programs. A particular approach that has attracted considerable interest is consumer regulation involving the imposition of annual quotas on personal carbon emissions. This idea is best understood as a variant of the comprehensive civilian rationing programs that were deployed during and after World War II. Because any eventual scheme to reduce greenhouse gas production at the individual level will require consummate public legitimacy, this historical experience can serve as a useful reference point for the design of contemporary interventions. To this end, the discussion highlights the methods that the British government used to sustain compliance with the war and postwar consumption control regimes. Of special interest is the role that black market trading and other illicit forms of commerce played during these periods. The conclusion reflects on the status of consumerism in contemporary lifestyles, considers the risks of political interference with consumer prerogatives, and draws some insights from this earlier experience with rationing
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aaltola M (1999) International relations and epidemics: a short expedition to places inhabited by states and mad cows. Med, Confl, Surviv 15(3):235–254
Adam D (2007) Carbon credits: rationing project tests government plans to make pollution personal. The Guardian, London, pp 15 (10 September)
Addison P (1995) Now the war is over: a social history of Britain, 1945–1951, rev. ed. Pimlico, London
Allenby B (2007) Earth systems engineering management. Environ Sci Technol 41(23):7960–7965
Al-Zahrani A (2008) Darwin’s metaphors revisited: conceptual metaphors, conceptual blends, and idealized cognitive models in the theory of evolution. Metaphor Symb 23(1):50–82
Anderson S, Newell R (2004) Prospects for carbon capture and storage technologies. Annu Rev Environ Resour 29:109–142
Antilla L (2005) Climate of skepticism: US newspaper coverage of the science of climate change. Glob Environ Change 15(4):338–352
Arrigo B (1999) Martial metaphors and medical justice: implications for law, crime, and deviance. J Polit Mil Soc 27(2):307–322
Associated Press (2007) Nuclear scientists move “Doomsday Clock” toward midnight. USA Today (17 January)
Barrett K (1995) Personal pollution allowance proposal: an open letter to Massachusetts Gov. William Weld. Available at http://pages.csam.montclair.edu/~barrettki/personal-pollution-allowances
Berdanier C (2006) Food shortages during World War II: can we learn from the experience? Nutr Today 41(4):160–163
Bezdek R, Taylor W (1981) Allocating petroleum products during oil supply disruptions. Science 212(4501):1357–1363
Blendon R, Young J (1998) The public and the war on illicit drugs. J Am Med Assoc 279(11):827–832
Bocking S (1997) Ecologists and environmental politics: a history of contemporary ecology. Yale University Press, New Haven
Bone J (1989) Britain takes lead in war on greenhouse effect. The Times, London (9 May)
Bostrom A (2008) Lead is like mercury: risk comparisons, analogies and mental models. J Risk Res 11(1–2):99–117
Boykoff M (2007a) From convergence to contention: United States mass media representations of anthropogenic climate change science. Trans Inst Br Geogr 32(4):477–489
Boykoff M (2007b) Flogging a dead norm? Newspaper coverage of anthropogenic climate change in the United States and the United Kingdom from 2003 to 2006. Area 39(4):470–481
Boykoff M (2008a) Lost in translation? United States television news coverage of anthropogenic climate change, 1995–2004. Clim Change 86(1–2):1–11
Boykoff M (2008b) The cultural politics of climate change discourse in UK tabloids. Polit Geogr 27(5):549–569
Boykoff M, Mansfield M (2008) “Ye olde hot aire”: reporting on human contributions to climate change in the UK tabloid press. Environ Res Lett 3(2):024002
Bradley M (2007) Air travel, the sky’s the limit: should I really give up flying? The Observer, London, pp 14 (21 January)
Breakley W (1997) It’s time for the public health community to declare war on homelessness. Am J Public Health 87(2):153–155
Brooke S (1995) Reform and reconstruction: Britain after the war, 1945–1951. Manchester University Press, Manchester
Brüning R, Lohmann G (1999) Charles S. Peirce on creative metaphor: a case study on the conveyor belt metaphor in oceanography. Found Sci 4(4):389–403
Calder A (1995) The myth of the blitz. Pimlico, London
Carey F, Arndt M (2007) Hugging the tree-huggers: why so many companies are suddenly linking up with eco groups. Business Week, pp 66 (12 March)
Carolan M (2006) The values and vulnerabilities of metaphors within the environmental sciences. Soc Nat Resour 19(10):921–930
Carter J (1979) Speech on energy and national goals, delivered 15 July. Available at http://www.americanrhetoric.com/speeches/jimmycartercrisisofconfidence.htm
Carvalho A (2007) Ideological cultures and media discourses on scientific knowledge: re-reading news on climate change. Public Underst Sci 16(2):223–243
Carvalho A, Burgess J (2005) Cultural circuits of climate change in the UK broadsheet newspapers, 1985–2003. Risk Anal 25(6):1457–1469
Chatterton T, Coulter A, Musselwhite C, Lyons G, Clegg S (2009) Understanding how transport choices are affected by the environment and health: views expressed in a study on the use of carbon calculators. Public Health 123(1):E45–E49
Chiang W-Y, Duann R (2007) Conceptual metaphors for SARS: “war” between whom? Discourse Soc 18(5):579–602
Churcher J (2007) Blair insists Britain will lead world towards combating climate change. Belfast Telegraph, pp 6 (13 March)
Clark A (2007) Planes, a train, and many automobiles as Charles picks up US green award. The Guardian, London, pp 13 (29 January)
Clover C (2007) Too little, too late to reverse climate change. The Daily Telegraph, pp 25 (20 November)
Cohen L (2003) A consumer’s republic: the politics of mass consumption in postwar America. Vintage, New York
Cojanu V (2008) The “market” metaphor and climate change: an epistemological application in the study of green economics. Int J Green Econ 2(3):284–294
Connelly M (2004) We can take it! Britain and the memory of the Second World War. Pearson Longman, New York
Costello J (1985) Virtue under fire: how World War II changed our social and sexual attitudes. Little, Brown, Boston
Department of Food, Environment, and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) (2008) Synthesis report on the findings from DEFRA’s pre-feasibility study into personal carbon trading. DEFRA, London
Dessler A, Parson E (2006) The science and politics of global climate change: a guide to the debate. Cambridge University Press, New York
Doulton H, Brown K (2009) Ten years to prevent catastrophe? Discourses of climate change and international development in the UK press. Glob Environ Change 19(2):191–202
Doward J, English S, Townsend M (2007) Focus: aftermath of the hurricane. The Observer, London, pp 15 (4 September)
Druckman A, Jackson T (2008) Household energy consumption in the UK: a highly geographically and socio-economically disaggregated model. Energy Policy 36(8):3167–3182
Dryzek J (2005) The politics of the earth: environmental discourses, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press, New York
Duggan E (2003) We can no longer ignore poverty in our midst. In: Cowger T, Markman S (eds) Lyndon Johnson remembered: an intimate portrait of a presidency. Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham
Egger G (2007) Personal carbon trading: a potential “stealth” intervention for obesity reduction? Med J Aust 187(3):185–187
Egger G (2008) Dousing our inflammatory environment(s): is personal carbon trading an option for reducing obesity—and climate change? Obes Rev 9(5):456–463
Environmental Audit Committee of the House of Commons (2008) Personal carbon trading. London: HMSO. Available at http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200708/cmselect/cmenvaud/565/565.pdf
Faguet G (2005) The war on cancer: an anatomy of failure, a blueprint for the future. Springer, Dordrecht
Fawcett T, Battrill C, Boardman B, Lye G (2007) Trialling personal carbon allowances. Oxford University, Environmental Change Institute, Oxford. Available at http://www.eci.ox.ac.uk/research/energy/downloads/fawcett-pca07.pdf
Fleming D (1996) Stopping the traffic. Ctry Life 140(19):62–65
Fleming D (2007) Energy and the common purpose: descending the energy staircase with tradable emission quotas. The Lean Economy Connection, London. Available at http://www.theleaneconomyconnection.net/downloads.html
Friedman J (2003) A war on obesity, not the obese. Science 299(5608):856–858
Gelbspan R (1998) The heat is on, rev. ed. Perseus, New York
Geppert D (2003) The postwar challenge: cultural, social and political change in Western Europe, 1945–1958. Oxford University Press, New York
Golley F (1993) A history of the ecosystem concept in ecology: more than the sum of its parts. Yale University Press, New Haven
Gough C, Taylor I, Shackley S (2002) Burying carbon under the sea: an initial exploration of public opinions. Energy Environ 13(6):883–900
Gowdy J, Walton M (2003) Consumer sovereignty, economic efficiency, and the trade liberalisation debate. Int J Glob Environ Issues 3(1):1–13
Greenberg D (1995) US tobacco war rumbles on. Nature 356(8978):831–832
Griffiths O (2002) Need, greed, and protest in Japan’s black market, 1938–1949. J Soc Hist 35(4):825–858
Grubb M (2002) Britannia waives the rules: the UK, the EU, and climate change. New Econ 9(3):139–142
Hajer M (1995) The politics of environmental discourse: ecological modernization and the policy process. Oxford University Press, New York
Halperin S (2004) War and social change in modern Europe: the great transformation revisited. Cambridge University Press, New York
Hamblyn R (2009) The whistleblower and the canary: rhetorical constructions of climate change. J Hist Geogr 35(2):223–236
Harris J (1997) William Beveridge: a biography, rev. ed. Clarendon, Oxford
Heineman B, Heimann F (2006) The long war against corruption. Foreign Aff 85(3):75–86
Hennessy P (2006) Never again: Britain 1945–1951, 2nd edn. Penguin, London
Hennessy P (2007) Having it so good: Britain in the fifties. Penguin, London
Hillman M (2005) Your planet: the case for rationing. The Independent, London (19 September)
Hillman M (2006) Commentary: personal carbon allowances. Br Med J 332(7554):1387–1388
Hillman M, Fawcett T, Rajan S (2008) How we can save the planet. Penguin, London
Hinsliff G (2008) The young pretender: Miliband—has he got what it takes to be PM? The Observer, London, pp 26 (2 August)
Hinsliff G, Helm T (2008) Labour in turmoil: Miliband woos the left as Labour’s rebels back off. The Observer, London, pp 8 (21 September)
Hodgkin P (1985) Medicine is war, and other medical metaphors. Br Med J 291(6511):1820–1821
Hollingsworth D (1983) Rationing and economic constraints on food consumption in Britain since the Second World War. World Rev Nutr Diet 42:191–218
Holzscheiter A (2004) Discourse as capability: non-state actors’ capital in global governance. Millenn: J Int Stud 33(3):723–746
Hopkins H (1963) The new look: a social history of the forties and fifties in Britain. Secker and Warburg, London
Horowitz D (2005) Jimmy Carter and the energy crisis of the 1970s. St. Martin’s, New York
Howard M (2005) And what if the sceptics are wrong. The Guardian, London, pp 22 (7 June)
Howell R (2009) The experience of carbon rationing action groups: implications for a personal carbon allowances policy. Oxford University, Environmental Change Institute, Oxford. Available at http://www.eci.ox.ac.uk/publications/downloads/howell09crags.pdf
Hume M (2008) We will fight them in the recycle bins. The Times, London, pp 15 (27 May)
Huxley R, Lloyd B, Goldacre M, Neil H (2000) Nutritional research in World War 2: the Oxford Nutrition Survey and its research potential 50 years later. Br J Nutr 84(2):247–251
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) (2007) Climate change 2007: synthesis report. World Meteorological Association and United Nations Environment Program, Geneva. Available at http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/ar4-syr.htm
Jackson D (2007) Warming up to Arnold. The Boston Globe, pp A13 (20 January)
Jacoby J (2006) Censoring ideas. The Boston Globe, pp A9 (18 October)
Jaeger C, Schellnhuber J, Brovkin V (2008) Stern’s review and Adam’s fallacy. Clim Change 89(3–4):207–218
Judge A (2007) Misuse of the potential of the conveyor metaphor: recognition of the circular dynamic essential to its operation. J Futures Stud 12(1):109–130
Kenix L (2008) Framing science: climate change in the mainstream and alternative news in New Zealand. Polit Sci 60(1):117–132
Kennedy F (1996) Clinton’s trip takes toll on birdlife. The Australian, Sydney, pp 3 (29 November)
King D (2004) Climate change science: adapt, mitigate, or ignore? Science 303(5655):176–177
Kynaston D (2007) Austerity Britain, 1945–1951. Bloomsbury, London
Lakoff G, Johnson M (2003) Metaphors we live by, rev. ed. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Langenohl A (2008) How to change other people’s institutions: discursive entrepreneurship and the boundary object of competition/competitiveness in the German banking sector. Econ Soc 37(1):68–93
Larson B (2005) The war of the roses: demilitarizing invasion biology. Front Ecol Environ 3(9):495–500
Larson B, Nerlich B, Wallis P (2005) Metaphors and biorisks: the war on infectious diseases and invasive species. Sci Commun 26(3):243–268
Lawson D (2008) David Miliband. Prospect Magazine 151. Available at http://www.prospect-magazine.co.uk/vis_index.php?select_issue=630
Leggett J (2001) The carbon war: global warming and the end of the oil era. Routledge, New York
Lindenbaum S (2001) Kuru, prions, and human affairs: thinking about epidemics. Annu Rev Anthropol 30:363–385
Lindseth G (2005) Local level adaptation to climate change: discursive strategies in the Norwegian context. J Environ Policy Plan 7(1):61–83
Litfin K (1994) Ozone discourses: science and politics in global environmental cooperation. Columbia University Press, New York
Longmate N (2002) How we lived then: a history of everyday life during the Second World War, rev. ed. Pimlico, London
Lorenzoni I, Pidgeon N (2006) Public views on climate change: European and USA perspectives. Clim Change 77(1-2):73–95
Marwick A (1974) War and social change in the twentieth century: a comparative study of Britain, France, Germany, Russia, and the United States. St. Martin’s, New York
Mazur A (2009) American generation of environmental warnings: avian influenza and global warming. Hum Ecol Rev 16(1):17–26
McLean I (2008) Climate change and UK politics: from Brynle Williams to Sir Nicholas Stern. Polit Q 79(2):184–193
Meacham J (2007) The editor’s desk. Newsweek, pp 4 (16 April)
Meacher M (2007a) Comment and debate: why we have to challenge the New Labour succession. The Guardian, London, pp 40 (23 February)
Meacher M (2007b) I would turn the lights out. The Ecologist 37(1):22–23
Meierhenrich J (2006) Analogies at war. J Confl Secur Law 11(1):1–40
Meyer A (2000) Contraction and convergence: the global solution to climate change. Green Books, Dartington
Meyer A (2004) Briefing: contraction and convergence. Proc Inst Civ Eng (Eng Sustain) 157:189–192
Miliband D (2006) The great stink: towards an environmental contract, Audit Commission annual lecture. Available at: http://www.defra.gov.uk/corporate/ministers/speeches/david-miliband/dm060719.htm (19 July)
Mills G, Rockoff H (1992) Compliance with price controls in the United States and the United Kingdom during World War II. In: Rockoff H (ed) Price Controls. Ashgate, Brookfield, pp 78–94
Monbiot G (2006) Drastic action on climate change is needed now. The Guardian, London, pp 31 (31 October)
Musial J, Stearns J (1973) Gasoline rationing as a solution to resource, environmental, and urban problems. Int J Environ Stud 5(3):173–181
Nerlich B (2006) War on foot and mouth disease in the UK, 2001: towards a cultural understanding of agriculture. Agric Human Values 21(1):15–25
Nerlich B, Halliday C (2007) Avian flu: the creation of expectations in the interplay between science and the media. Soc Health and Illn 29(1):46–65
Newman R (2006) It’s capitalism or a habitable planet—you can’t have both. The Guardian, London, pp 33 (2 February)
Nixson M (2004) America must join war against global warming, says the green Queen. Mail on Sunday, London, pp 7 (31 October)
Noakes L (1998) War and the British: gender, memory, and national identity. Tauris, London
Ohl A, Wolf S, Anderson W (2008) A modest proposal: global rationalization of ecological footprint to eliminate ecological debt. Sustain Sci Pract Policy 4(1). Available at http://ejournal.nbii.org/archives/vol4iss1/0707-016.ohl.pdf
Oppenheimer M (2003) Declare war on global warming. The International Herald Tribune, Paris, pp 6 (8 April)
Pascoe-Watson G (2007) Misson X-possible. The Sun, London, pp 1 (4 October)
Penning-Rowsell E, Johnson C, Turnstall S (2006) “Signals” from pre-crisis discourse: lessons from UK flooding for global environmental policy change? Glob Environ Change 16(4):323–339
Penson R, Schapira L, Daniels K, Chabner B, Lynch T (2004) Cancer as metaphor. Oncologist 9(6):708–716
Pisarski A, de Terra N (1975) American and European transportation responses to the 1973–74 oil embargo. Transportation 4(3):291–312
Prescott M (2008) A persuasive climate: personal trading and changing lifestyles. Royal Society for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufactures, and Commerce, London. Available at http://www.rsacarbonlimited.org/default.aspa
Ramírez A, Hoogwijk M, Hendriks C, Faaij A (2008) Using a participatory approach to develop a sustainability framework for carbon capture and storage systems in The Netherlands. Int J Greenhouse Gas Control 2(1):136–154
Redmond W (2000) Consumer rationality and consumer sovereignty. Rev Soc Econ 58(2):192–196
Reisfield G, Wilson G (2004) Use of metaphor in the discourse on cancer. J Clin Oncol 22(19):4024–4027
Roff R (2007) Shopping for change? Neoliberalizing activism and the limits to eating non-GMO. Agric Human Values 24(4):511–522
Roodhouse M (2007a) Enlist the blitz spirit, get out the carbon ration book. Financial Times, London (13 March)
Roodhouse M (2007b) Rationing returns: a solution to global warming? Available at http://www.historyandpolicy.org/papers/policy-paper-54.html
Rovner J (1997) President Clinton wages public war against AIDS. Lancet 349(9044):39
Sanders P (2008) Economic draining: German black market operations in France 1940–1944. Glob Crime 9(1–2):136–168
Sandvik H (2008) Public concern over global warming correlates negatively with national wealth. Clim Change 90(3):333–314
Sarbin T (2003) The metaphor-to-myth transformation with special reference to the “war on terrorism.” Peace and Confl 9(2):149–157
Schlosser E (2003) Reefer madness: sex, drugs, and cheap labor in the American black market. Houghton Mifflin, Boston
Schneider S (1989) The greenhouse effect: science and policy. Science 243(4892):771–781
Schneider S (2008) Geoengineering: could we or should we make it work? Philos Trans R Soc A (Math, Phys Eng Sci) 366(1882):3843–3862
Schneider S (2010) Science as a contact sport: inside the battle to save earth’s climate. National Geographic, Washington, DC
Schor J (2007) In defense of consumer critique: revisiting the consumption debates of the twentieth century. Annals Am Acad Polit Soc Sci 611(1):16–30
Schrag D (2007) Preparing to capture carbon. Science 315(5813):812–813
Seyfang G, Paavola J (2008) Inequality and sustainable consumption: bridging the gaps. Local Environ 13(8):669–684
Sissions M, French P (eds.) (1986). Age of austerity. Oxford University Press, New York
Skirrow J (1986) Waging the war against alcohol abuse. Can Med Assoc J 135(5):434
Smith H (1996) Britain in the Second World War: a social history. Manchester University Press, Manchester
Smith M (2000) Britain and 1940: history, myth, and popular memory. Routledge, New York
Smith J (2005) Dangerous news: media decision making about climate change risk. Risk Anal 25(6):1471–1482
Smithies E (1984) The black economy in England since 1914. Humanities, Atlantic Highlands
Somerville R (2006) Medical metaphors for climate issues: an editorial essay. Clim Change 76(1–2):1–6
Starkey R, Anderson K (2005) Domestic tradable quotas: a policy instrument for reducing greenhouse gas emissions from energy use. Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, Manchester University, Manchester. Available at http://www.tyndall.ac.uk/research/theme2/final_reports/t3_22.pdf
Steege P (2007) Black market, cold war: everyday life in Berlin, 1946–1949. Cambridge University Press, New York
Stern N (2007) The economics of climate change. Cambridge University Press, New York
Stratton A (2008) Cabinet reshuffle: debutant Miliband brings clout to new department. The Guardian, London, pp 7 (4 October)
Sunday Mail (London) (1989) Declare war, plant a tree. London (11 June)
Tainter J (2008) Introduction. In: Polimeni J, Mayumi K, Giampietro M, Alcott B (eds) The Jevons Paradox and the myth of resource efficiency improvements, pp ix–xvi. Earthscan, London
Taylor N, Nathan S (2002) How science contributes to environmental reporting in British newspapers: a case study of the reporting of global warming and climate change. Environmentalist 22(4):325–331
The Boston Globe (1989) Empty words on global warming. pp 18 (8 November)
The Economist (2006) Where to start (9 September)
Thorpe K (2007) The forgotten shortage: Britain’s handling of the 1967 oil embargo. Contemp Br Hist 21(2):201–222
Törnqvist T (2007) A Dutch geoscience perspective on the Katrina disaster. Neth J Geosci 86(3):307–315
Toynbee P (2008) Carbon credits tick all the boxes: what’s the delay? The Guardian, London, pp 35 (16 August)
Turner D (2005) Are we at war with nature? Environ Values 14(1):21–36
Ungar S (2000) Knowledge, ignorance, and the popular culture: climate change versus the ozone hole. Public Underst Sci 9(3):297–312
Ungar S (2003) Global warming versus ozone depletion: failure and success in North America. Clim Res 213(3):263–274
Van Alphen K, van Voorst tot Voorst Q, Hekkert M, Smits R (2007) Societal acceptance of carbon capture and storage technologies. Energy Policy 35(8):4368–4380
Vincent J (2007) Science and imagery in the “war on old age.” Ageing Soc 27(6):941–961
Virgoe J (2008) International governance of a possible geoengineering intervention to combat climate change. Clim Change 95(1–2):103–119
Walker K (2007) Meacher mounts the old labour challenge to Brown. Daily Mail, London, pp 10 (23 February)
Watson R (2008) Charles urges war on climate change. The Times, London, pp 4 (15 February)
Wiman B (1995) Metaphors, analogies, and models in communicating climate-change uncertainties and economics to policy : a note on a pre-UNCED U.S. case. Ecol Econ 15(1):21–28
Wintour P (2007) Labour to set legal limit on UK carbon emissions. The Guardian, London, pp 1 (13 March)
Wintour P, Stratton A (2008) Target to cut carbon emissions may be increased as Miliband insists climate change is priority. The Guardian, London, pp 12 (16 October)
Worster D (1992) Nature’s economy: a history of ecological ideas, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press, New York
Zweiniger-Bargielowska I (2000) Austerity in Britain: rationing, controls, and consumption, 1939–1955. Oxford University Press, New York
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cohen, M.J. Is the UK preparing for “war”? Military metaphors, personal carbon allowances, and consumption rationing in historical perspective. Climatic Change 104, 199–222 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-009-9785-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-009-9785-x