Abstract
In this two-part study, we investigate the usefulness of Sodars as part of a large instrument suite for the study of high mountains in the site selection process of the Thirty Meter Telescope (TMT). In this first part, we describe the reproducibility of the measurements and the comparability of results from different sites for data taken with two complementary Sodar models: the XFAS and SFAS models manufactured by Scintec Inc. To this end, a cross-calibration campaign was conducted on two of the sites comparing both the wind speeds and the optical turbulence measurements of the different units. The specific set-up conditions and the low atmospheric pressure require us to make a compromise between the amount of data available for statistics and the quality of the data. For the comparison of the wind speed, results from the same models show a systematic difference of 12 and 9% for the XFAS and SFAS, respectively. The scatter between individual measurements, which includes instrumental, set-up and statistical fluctuation contributions, was found to be 21 and 23%. For optical turbulence, the respective values are 6 and 3% for the systematic difference and 46 and 67% for the scatter. These results show that Sodars can be useful tools for astronomical site testing for projects such as the TMT.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Crescenti GH (1997) A look back on two decades of Doppler Sodar comparison studies. Bull Am Meteorol Soc 78: 651–673
Danilov SD, Gur’yanov AE, Kallistratova MA, Petenko IV, Singal SP, Pahwa DR, Gera BS (1992) Acoustic calibration of Sodars. Meas Sci Technol 3(10): 1001–1007
Els SG, Travouillon T, Schöck M, Riddle R, Skidmore W, Seguel J, Bustos E, Walker D (2009) Thirty Meter Telescope site testing VI: turbulence profiles. Pub Astron Soc Pac 121(879): 527–543
Gaynor JE, Baker CB, Kaimal JC (1990) The international sodar intercomparison experiment. In: Proceedings of fifth international symposium on Acoustic remote sensing. India International Society of Acoustic Remote Sensing, New Delhi, pp 67–74
Gur’yanov AE, Kallistratova MA, Kutyrev AS, Petenko IV, Shchglov PV, Tokovinin AA (1992) The contribution of the lower atmospheric layers to the seeing at some mountain observatories. Astron Astrophys 262: 373–381
Kornilov V, Tokovinin AA, Vozyakova O, Zaitsev A, Shatsky N, Potanin SF, Sarazin MS (2003) MASS: a monitor of the vertical turbulence distribution. Proc SPIE 4839: 837–845
Moore KE, Bailey BH (2005) Maximizing the accuracy of Sodar measurements for wind resource assessment. In: Proceedings of the American Wind Energy Association, Denver, CO, May 2005
Piringer M (1994) Selected results of a sodar intercomparison experiment. Meteorol Z 3: 132–137
RADIAN (1984) Echosonde calibration. Internal memo, Radian Corporation
Schöck M, Els SG, Riddle RR, Skidmore W, Travouillon T, Blum R, Bustos E, Chanan G, Djorgovski G, Gillett P, Gregory B, Nelson J, Otarola A, Seguel J, Vasquez J, Walker A, Walker D, Wang L (2009) Thirty Meter Telescope site testing I: overview. Pub Astron Soc Pac 121(878): 384–395
Thirty Meter Telescope Construction Proposal (2007) http://www.tmt.org/sites/default/files/TMT-Construction-Proposal-Public.pdf
Travouillon T (2006) Sodar calibration for the turbulence profiling in TMT site testing. Proc SPIE 6267: 626720
Travouillon T, Ashley MCB, Burton MG, Storey JWV, Loewenstein RF (2003) Atmospheric turbulence at the South Pole and its implications for astronomy. Astron Astrophys 400: 1163–1172
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Travouillon, T., Schöck, M., Els, S. et al. Using a Sodar to Measure Optical Turbulence and Wind Speed for the Thirty Meter Telescope Site Testing. Part I: Reproducibility. Boundary-Layer Meteorol 141, 273–288 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10546-011-9642-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10546-011-9642-0