Abstract
Using a nationally representative survey of farm operators in Ireland, this study examines the effect of non-pecuniary benefits from farm work on labor allocation choices. Results suggest that non-pecuniary benefits affect both the decision to enter the off-farm labor market and also once that decision is made, the amount of time spent working off-farm. We find our derived variable representing non-monetary benefits associated with farm work to have a substantial impact similar to the effect of other more widely reported personal and farm structural variables such as the age of the farm operator, farm size, and farming system. The existence of these non-pecuniary benefits serves to increase the implied wage to farmers for their farm work. This in turn can lead to allocations of labor that would seem suboptimal from a purely financial point of view. Rural development policies aimed at creating off-farm opportunities could fail unless returns to off-farm work are high enough to compensate the farmer for losing the benefits associated with the farming lifestyle. From a methodological perspective, our analysis indicates that failure to model off-farm labor allocation choices as a two-part process may lead to some incorrect conclusions regarding the effect of certain explanatory variables. Outside of explaining farmers’ off-farm labor supply it would be useful to incorporate farmer perceptions regarding the non-pecuniary benefits from farming in economic models of farm behavior across a range of activities as this could lead to much more accurate predictions of farmers’ responses to policy changes.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
The interested reader is referred to Benjamin and Kimhi (2006) for a discussion of the potential interdependency of the labor allocation choices of farm couples.
One factor with an eigenvalue > one explaining 57 % of the variance.
It is likely that stocking rate and to a lesser extent farm size are endogenous with the off-farm labor decision. Dropping these variables did not, however, have a significant effect on the other parameter estimates. As these variables were not the focus of this paper but merely included to support previous research we included these as explanatory variables despite some potential endogeneity problems.
The reader is referred to Wooldridge (2008) for a more detailed discussion of this issue.
References
Ackerman, N., D. Jenson, and D. Bailey. 1989. Major sources of satisfaction for farm families. Utah Science 50: 134–142.
Alasia, A., A. Weersink, R.D. Bolman, and J. Cranfield. 2009. Off-farm labor decisions of Canadian farm operators: Urbanization effects and rural labor market linkages. Journal of Rural Studies 25(1): 12–24.
Basarir, A., and J.M. Gillespie. 2006. Multidimensional goals of beef and dairy producers: An inter-industry comparison. Agricultural Economics 35: 103–114.
Benjamin, C., and A. Kimhi. 2006. Farm work, off-farm work, and hired farm labor: Estimating a discrete-choice model of French farm couples’ labor decisions. European Review of Agricultural Economics 33(2): 149–171.
Blamey, R.K., J.W. Bennett, and M. Morrison. 1999. Yea-saying in contingent valuation surveys. Land Economics 75(1): 126–141.
Colman, D., and D. Harvey. 2004. The future of UK dairy farming. Report commissioned jointly by the MDC, DIAL, and Defra. http://archive.defra.gov.uk/foodfarm/food/industry/sectors/milk/pdf/colman-harveyreport.pdf Accessed 11 July 2013.
Connolly, L., A. Kinsella, G. Quinlan, and B. Moran. 2010. National farm survey. Dublin: Rural Economy Research Centre.
Corsi, A., and J.L. Findeis. 2000. True state dependence and heterogeneity in off-farm labor participation. European Review of Agricultural Economics 27(2): 127–151.
Cragg, J. 1971. Some statistical models for limited dependent variables with application to the demand for durable goods. Econometrica 39(5): 829–844.
Cuddeback, G., E. Wilson, J.G. Orme, and T. Combs-Orme. 2004. Detecting and statistically correcting sample selection bias. Journal of Social Service Research 30(3): 19–33.
Darnhofer, I., W. Schneeberger, and B. Freyer. 2005. Converting or not converting to organic farming in Austria: Farmer types and their rationale. Agriculture and Human Values 22: 39–52.
Edwards-Jones, G. 2006. Modelling farmers’ decision-making: Concepts, progress, and challenges. Animal Science 82: 783–790.
El-Osta, H.S., A.K. Mishra, and M.C. Ahearn. 2004. Labor supply by farm operators under “decoupled” farm program payments. Review of Economics of the Household 2(4): 367–385.
El-Osta, H.S., A.K. Mishra, and M.J. Morehart. 2008. Off-farm labor participation decisions of married farm couples and the role of government payments. Review of Agricultural Economics 30(2): 311–332.
Gillespie, J., and A. Mishra. 2011. Off-farm employment and reasons for entering farming as determinants of production enterprise selection in US agriculture. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 55: 411–428.
Hamilton, B.H. 2000. Does entrepreneurship pay? An empirical analysis of the returns of self-employment. The Journal of Political Economy 108(3): 604–631.
Heckman, J. 1979. Sample selection bias as a specification error. Econometrica 47(1): 153–161.
Hennessy, T., and T. Rehman. 2008. Assessing the impact of the “decoupling” reform of the Common Agricultural Policy on Irish farmers’ off-farm labor market participation decisions. Journal of Agricultural Economics 59(1): 41–56.
Hennessy, T., and F. Thorne. 2005. How decoupled are decoupled payments? The evidence from Ireland. Eurochoices 4(1): 30–35.
Herrmann, V., and P. Uttitz. 1990. If only I didn’t enjoy being a farmer! Attitudes and opinions of monoactive and pluriactive farmers. Sociologica Ruralis 30(1): 62–75.
Howard, W., and M. Swidinsky. 2000. Estimating the of-farm labor supply in Canada. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics 48(1): 1–14.
Howley, P., J. Breen, C.O. Donoghue, and T. Hennessy. 2012. Does the single farm payment affect farmers’ behavior: A macro and micro analysis. International Journal of Agricultural Management 2(1): 57–64.
Howley, P., and E. Dillon. 2012. Modeling the effect of farming attitudes on farm credit use: A case study from Ireland. Agricultural Finance Review 72: 456–470.
Huffman, W. 1980. Farm and off-farm work decisions: The role of human capital. The Review of Economics and Statistics 62(1): 14–23.
Huffman, W.E., and H. El-Osta. 1998. Off-farm work participation, off-farm labor supply, and on-farm labor demand of US farm operators. Paper presented at the 1998 Summer AAEA meeting, Salt Lake City, UT.
Kaiser, H.F. 1974. An index of factorial simplicity. Psychometrika 39: 31–36.
Kantelhardt, J. 2006. Impact of the Common European Agricultural Policy (CAP) reform on future research on rural areas. Outlook on Agriculture 35(2): 143–148.
Keeney, M., and A. Matthews. 2000. Multiple job holding—Explaining participation in off-farm employment, labor demand, and labor supply of Irish farm households. Paper presented at the Agricultural Economics Society Conference, Manchester, UK, April 2000.
Key, N. 2005. How much do farmers value their independence? Agricultural Economics 33: 117–126.
Key, N., and M.J. Roberts. 2009. Non-pecuniary benefits to farming: Implications for supply response to decoupled payments to decoupled payments. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 91(1): 1–18.
Kimhi, A., and N. Nachlieli. 2001. Inter-generational succession on Israeli family farms. Journal of Agricultural Economics 52(2): 42–58.
Koontz, T.M. 2001. Money talks? But to whom? Financial versus nonmonetary motivations in land use decisions. Society and Natural Resources 14: 510–565.
Kuehne, G., H. Bjornland, and B. Cheers. 2007. There’s more than one type of farmer: Acknowledging farmers’ diversity—An Australian perspective. International Journal of Interdisciplinary Social Sciences 2: 179–186.
Lass, D., J. Findeis, and M. Hallberg. 1989. Off-farm labor employment decisions by Massachusetts farm households. Northern Journal of Agricultural Resource Economics: 149–159.
Lass, D., and C.M. Gempesaw. 1992. The supply of off-farm labor: A random coefficient approach. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 74(2): 400–411.
Lim-Applegate, H., G. Rodriguez, and R. Olfert. 2002. Determinants of non-farm labor participation rates among farmers in Australia. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 46(1): 85–98.
Long, J.S., and J. Freese. 2006. Regression models for categorical dependent variables using Stata. College Station, Texas: Stata Press.
Matshe, I., and T. Young. 2004. Off-farm labor allocation decisions in small-scale rural households in Zimbabwe. Agricultural Economics 30(3): 175–186.
Mishra, A.K., and B.K. Goodwin. 1997. Farm income variability and the supply of off-farm labor. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 79(3): 880–887.
Nunnally, J.C. 1967. Psychometric theory, 1st ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Pannell, D.J., G.R. Marshall, N. Barr, A. Curtis, F. Vanclay, and R. Wilkinson. 2006. Understanding and promoting adoption of conservation practices by rural landholders. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 46: 1407–1424.
Weersink, A. 1992. Off-farm labor decisions by Ontario swine producers. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics 40(2): 235–251.
Weiss, C.R. 1997. Do they come back again? The symmetry and reversibility of off-farm employment. European Review of Agricultural Economics 24: 65–84.
Willock, J., I.J. Deary, G. Edwards Jones, G. Gibson, M.J. McGregor, A. Sutherland, J.B. Dent, O. Morgan, and R. Grieve. 1999a. The role of attitudes and objectives in farmer decision making: Business and environmentally oriented behavior in Scotland. Journal of Agricultural Economics 50(2): 286–303.
Willock, J., I.J. Deary, M.J. McGregor, A. Sutherland, J.B. Dent, G. Edwards Jones, R. Grieve, O. Morgan, G. Gibson, and E. Austin. 1999b. Farmers’ attitudes, objectives, behaviors, and personality traits: The Edinburgh study of decision making on farms. Journal of Vocational Behavior 54(1): 5–36.
Wooldridge, J. 2008. Introductory econometrics: A modern approach. Mason, OH: South Western College Publications.
Vanclay, F. 2004. Social principles for agricultural extension to assist in the promotion of natural resource management. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 44: 213–222.
Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful to the editor in chief and three reviewers for helpful comments and suggestions that greatly improved this manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Howley, P., Dillon, E. & Hennessy, T. It’s not all about the money: understanding farmers’ labor allocation choices. Agric Hum Values 31, 261–271 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-013-9474-2
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-013-9474-2