Abstract
Background
Colon J-pouch (JCP) reconstructions result in a better functional outcome than straight coloanal anastomosis (SCA) in terms of continence and frequency of defecation after rectal resection but might be associated with more evacuation difficulties. In order to evaluate this hypothesis, we systematically reviewed the literature to collect data on evacuation disorders after rectal resection in randomized or otherwise comparative trials.
Materials and methods
Randomized controlled trials and comparative trials evaluating CJP versus SCA, latero-terminal anastomosis (LTA), and transverse coloplasty pouch (TCP) were ascertained by methodical search using Medline, Embase, and PubMed. Pooled estimates of outcomes were calculated for early-, intermediate-, and long-term follow-up. Primary meta-analysis outcomes were sensation of incomplete evacuation, prolonged evacuation, use of laxatives, use of enemas and suppositories, and stool fragmentation.
Results
When compared to SCA, CJP was associated with significantly less “prolongation of evacuation” but more “use of laxatives” in the intermediate-term follow-up, while both less “sensation of incomplete evacuation” and less “fragmentation” was found after CJP in the long-term. When compared to TCP, CJP was associated with significantly less fragmentation in the intermediate-term follow-up.
Conclusions
Evacuation disorders are a unique problem of low anterior resection and are not specifically related to the colon J-pouch.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Parc R, Tiret E, Frileux P, Moszkowski E, Loygue J (1986) Resection and colo-anal anastomosis with colonic reservoir for rectal carcinoma. Br J Surg 73:139–141
Lazorthes F, Fages P, Chiotasso P, Lemozy J, Bloom E (1986) Resection of the rectum with construction of a colonic reservoir and colo-anal anastomosis for carcinoma of the rectum. Br J Surg 73:136–138
Heriot AG, Tekkis PP, Constantinides V, Paraskevas P, Nicholls RJ, Darzi A, Fazio VW (2006) Meta-analysis of colonic reservoirs versus straight coloanal anastomosis after anterior resection. Br J Surg 93:19–32
Koh PK, Tang CL, Eu KW, Samuel M, Chan E (2006) A systematic review of the function and complications of colonic pouches. Int J Colorectal Dis 22:543–548
Berger A, Tiret E, Parc R, Frileux P, Hannoun L, Nordlinger B, Ratelle R, Simon R (1992) Excision of the rectum with colonic J pouch-anal anastomosis for adenocarcinoma of the low and mid rectum. World J Surg 16:470–477
Nicholls RJ, Lubowski DZ, Donaldson DR (1988) Comparison of colonic reservoir and straight colo-anal reconstruction after rectal excision. Br J Surg 75:318–320
Mortensen NJ, Ramirez JM, Takeuchi N, Humphreys MM (1995) Colonic J pouch-anal anastomosis after rectal excision for carcinoma: functional outcome. Br J Surg 82:611–613
Kusunoki M, Yanagi H, Shoji Y, Yamamura T, Utsunomiya J (1997) Anoabdominal rectal resection and colonic J pouch-anal anastomosis: 10 years’ experience. Br J Surg 84:1277–1280
Hida J, Yasutomi M, Fujimoto K, Okuno K, Ieda S, Machidera N, Kubo R, Shindo K, Koh K (1996) Functional outcome after low anterior resection with low anastomosis for rectal cancer using the colonic J-pouch. Prospective randomized study for determination of optimum pouch size. Dis Colon Rectum 39:986–991
Lazorthes F, Gamagami R, Chiotasso P, Istvan G, Muhammad S (1997) Prospective, randomized study comparing clinical results between small and large colonic J-pouch following coloanal anastomosis. Dis Colon Rectum 40:1409–1413
Ho YH, Brown S, Heah SM, Tsang C, Seow-Choen F, Eu KW, Tang CL (2002) Comparison of J-pouch and coloplasty pouch for low rectal cancers: a randomized, controlled trial investigating functional results and comparative anastomotic leak rates. Ann Surg 236:49–55
Lin JK, Wang HS, Yang SH, Jiang JK, Chen WS, Lin TC (2002) Comparison between straight and J-pouch coloanal anastomoses in surgery for rectal cancer. Surg Today 32:487–492
Z’Graggen K, Maurer CA, Birrer S, Giachino D, Kern B, Buchler MW (2001) A new surgical concept for rectal replacement after low anterior resection: the transverse coloplasty pouch. Ann Surg 234:780–785 (discussion 785–787)
Z’Graggen K, Maurer CA, Buchler MW (1999) Transverse coloplasty pouch. A novel neorectal reservoir. Dig Surg 16:363–366
von Flue MO, Degen LP, Beglinger C, Harder FH (1996) The ileocecal reservoir for rectal replacement in complicated radiation proctitis. Am J Surg 172:335–340
Rink AD, Haaf F, Knupper N, Vestweber KH (2007) Prospective randomised trial comparing ileocaecal interposition and colon-J-pouch as rectal replacement after total mesorectal excision. Int J Colorectal Dis 22:153–160
Hamel CT, Metzger J, Curti G, Degen L, Harder F, von Flue MO (2004) Ileocecal reservoir reconstruction after total mesorectal excision: functional results of the long-term follow-up. Int J Colorectal Dis 19:574–579
Schumpelick V, Braun J (1991) Rectumresektion mit coloanaler Anastomose. Ergebnisse der Kontinenz und Radikalitat. Chirurg 62:25–31
Enker WE, Stearns MW Jr., Janov AJ (1985) Peranal coloanal anastomosis following low anterior resection for rectal carcinoma. Dis Colon Rectum 28:576–581
Hallbook O, Pahlman L, Krog M, Wexner SD, Sjodahl R (1996) Randomized comparison of straight and colonic J pouch anastomosis after low anterior resection. Ann Surg 224:58–65
Machado M, Nygren J, Goldman S, Ljungqvist O (2003) Similar outcome after colonic pouch and side-to-end anastomosis in low anterior resection for rectal cancer: a prospective randomized trial. Ann Surg 238:214–220
Ho YH, Tan M, Leong AF, Seow-Choen F (2000) Ambulatory manometry in patients with colonic J-pouch and straight coloanal anastomoses: randomized, controlled trial. Dis Colon Rectum 43:793–799
Oya M, Komatsu J, Takase Y, Nakamura T, Ishikawa H (2002) Comparison of defecatory function after colonic J-pouch anastomosis and straight anastomosis for stapled low anterior resection: results of a prospective randomized trial. Surg Today 32:104–110
Hida J, Yoshifuji T, Okuno K, Matsuzaki T, Uchida T, Ishimaru E, Tokoro T, Yasutomi M, Shiozaki H (2006) Long-term functional outcome of colonic J-pouch reconstruction after low anterior resection for rectal cancer. Surg Today 36:441–449
Hida J, Yoshifuji T, Tokoro T, Inoue K, Matsuzaki T, Okuno K, Shiozaki H, Yasutomi M (2004) Comparison of long-term functional results of colonic J-pouch and straight anastomosis after low anterior resection for rectal cancer: a five-year follow-up. Dis Colon Rectum 47:1578–1585
Seow-Choen F, Goh HS (1995) Prospective randomized trial comparing J colonic pouch-anal anastomosis and straight coloanal reconstruction. Br J Surg 82:608–610
Wang JY, You YT, Chen HH, Chiang JM, Yeh CY, Tang R (1997) Stapled colonic J-pouch-anal anastomosis without a diverting colostomy for rectal carcinoma. Dis Colon Rectum 40:30–34
Pimentel JM, Duarte A, Gregorio C, Souto P, Patricio J (2003) Transverse coloplasty pouch and colonic J-pouch for rectal cancer–a comparative study. Colorectal Dis 5:465–470
Dehni N Tiret E, Singland JD, Cunningham C, Schlegel RD, Guiguet M, Parc R (1998) Long-term functional outcome after low anterior resection: comparison of low colorectal anastomosis and colonic J-pouch-anal anastomosis. Dis Colon Rectum 41:817–822 (discussion 822–823)
Harris GJ, Lavery IC, Fazio VW (2001) Function of a colonic J pouch continues to improve with time. Br J Surg 88:1623–1627
Peeters KC, van de Velde CJ, Leer JW, Martijn H, Junggeburt JM, Kranenbarg EK, Steup WH, Wiggers T, Rutten HJ, Marijnen CA (2005) Late side effects of short-course preoperative radiotherapy combined with total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: increased bowel dysfunction in irradiated patients—a Dutch colorectal cancer group study. J Clin Oncol 23:6199–6206
Lim JF, Tjandra JJ, Hiscock R, Chao MW, Gibbs P (2006) Preoperative chemoradiation for rectal cancer causes prolonged pudendal nerve terminal motor latency. Dis Colon Rectum 49:12–19
Pollack J, Holm T, Cedermark B, Holmstrom B, Mellgren A (2006) Long-term effect of preoperative radiation therapy on anorectal function. Dis Colon Rectum 49:345–352
Ammann K, Kirchmayr W, Klaus A, Muhlmann G, Kafka R, Oberwalder M, De Vries A, Ofner D, Weiss H (2003) Impact of neoadjuvant chemoradiation on anal sphincter function in patients with carcinoma of the midrectum and low rectum. Arch Surg 138:257–261
Kollmorgen CF, Meagher AP, Wolff BG, Pemberton JH, Martenson JA, Illstrup DM (1994) The long-term effect of adjuvant postoperative chemoradiotherapy for rectal carcinoma on bowel function. Ann Surg 220:676–682
Lundby L, Jensen VJ, Overgaard J, Laurberg S (1997) Long-term colorectal function after postoperative radiotherapy for colorectal cancer. Lancet 350:564
Nathanson DR, Espat NJ, Nash GM, D’Alessio M, Thaler H, Minsky BD, Enker W, Wong D, Guillem J, Cohen A, Paty PB (2003) Evaluation of preoperative and postoperative radiotherapy on long-term functional results of straight coloanal anastomosis. Dis Colon Rectum 46:888–894
Kienle P, Abend F, Dueck M, Abel U, Treiber M, Riedl S (2006) Influence of intraoperative and postoperative radiotherapy on functional outcome in patients undergoing standard and deep anterior resection for rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 49:557–567
Rink AD, Vestweber KH (2002) Vulnerability of ileocoecal interposition pouch and colonic J-pouch to postoperative adjuvant radiotherapy. Zentralbl Chir 127:769–774
Moher D, Cook DJ, Eastwood S, Olkin I, Rennie D, Stroup DF (1999) Improving the quality of reports of meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials: the QUOROM statement. Quality of Reporting of Meta-analyses. Lancet 354:1896–1900
Mahid SS, Hornung CA, Minor KS, Turina M, Galandiuk S (2006) Systematic reviews and meta-analysis for the surgeon scientist. Br J Surg 93:1315–1324
Egger MDSG, Altman DG (2001). Systematic reviews in health care: meta-analysis in context. BMJ, London
Gotzinger P, Wamser P, Herbst F (2001) [Colo-anal anastomosis: improvement of early function outcome by reconstruction with the colonic pouch]. Chirurg 72:49–53
Barrier A, Martel P, Gallot D, Dugue L, Sezeur A, Malafosse M (1999) Long-term functional results of colonic J pouch versus straight coloanal anastomosis. Br J Surg 86:1176–1179
Ikeuchi H, Kusunoki M, Shoji Y, Yamamura T, Utsunomiya J (1997) Functional results after “high” coloanal anastomosis and “low” coloanal anastomosis with a colonic J-pouch for rectal carcinoma. Surg Today 27:702–705
Portier G, Platonoff I, Lazorthes F (2005) Long-term functional results after straight or colonic J-pouch coloanal anastomosis. Recent Results Cancer Res 165:191–195
Tonelli F, Garcea A, Batignani G (2005) Different role of the colonic pouch for low anterior resection and coloanal anastomosis. Tech Coloproctol 9:15–20
Huber FT, Herter B, Siewert JR (1999) Colonic pouch vs. side-to-end anastomosis in low anterior resection. Dis Colon Rectum 42:896–902
Liang JT, Lai HS, Lee PH, Huang KC (2007) Comparison of functional and surgical outcomes of laparoscopic-assisted colonic J-pouch versus straight reconstruction after total mesorectal excision for lower rectal cancer. Ann Surg Oncol 14:1972–1979
Fazio VW, Zutshi M, Remzi FH, Parc Y, Ruppert R, Furst A, Celebrezze J Jr., Galanduik S, Orangio G, Hyman N, Bokey L, Tiret E, Kirchdorfer B, Medich D, Tietze M, Hull T, Hammel J (2007) A randomized multicenter trial to compare long-term functional outcome, quality of life, and complications of surgical procedures for low rectal cancers. Ann Surg 246:481–488 (discussion 488–490)
Ho YH, Tan M, Seow-Choen F (1996) Prospective randomized controlled study of clinical function and anorectal physiology after low anterior resection: comparison of straight and colonic J pouch anastomoses. Br J Surg 83:978–980
Jiang JK, Yang SH, Lin JK (2005) Transabdominal anastomosis after low anterior resection: A prospective, randomized, controlled trial comparing long-term results between side-to-end anastomosis and colonic J-pouch. Dis Colon Rectum 48:2100–2108 (discussion 2108–2110)
Kanne V, Kim NH, Ulrich B (2002) Der Transverse Coloplastie Pouch (TCP)–Funktionalität und subjektives Empfinden verglichen mit dem operativ aufwendigeren J-Pouch. Zentralbl Chir 127:781–785
Matsuoka H, Masaki T, Sugiyama M, Atomi Y (2004) Large contractions in the colonic J-pouch as a possible cause of incomplete evacuation. Langenbecks Arch Surg 389:391–395
Willis S, Kasperk R, Braun J, Schumpelick V (2001) Comparison of colonic J-pouch reconstruction and straight coloanal anastomosis after intersphincteric rectal resection. Langenbecks Arch Surg 386:193–199
Bretagnol F, Troubat H, Laurent C, Zerbib F, Saric J, Rullier E (2004) Long-term functional results after sphincter-saving resection for rectal cancer. Gastroenterol Clin Biol 28:155–159
Gamagami R, Istvan G, Cabarrot P, Liagre A, Chiotasso P, Lazorthes F (2000) Fecal continence following partial resection of the anal canal in distal rectal cancer: long-term results after coloanal anastomoses. Surgery 127:291–295
Matzel KE, Stadelmaier U, Muehldorfer S, Hohenberger W (1997) Continence after colorectal reconstruction following resection: impact of level of anastomosis. Int J Colorectal Dis 12:82–87
Montesani C, Pronio A, Santella S, Boschetto A, Aguzzi D, Pirozzi R, D’Amato A, Vestri A (2004) Rectal cancer surgery with sphincter preservation: functional results related to the level of anastomosis. Clinical and instrumental study. Hepatogastroenterology 51:718–721
Hida J, Yasutomi M, Maruyama T, Fujimoto K, Nakajima A, Uchida T, Wakano T, Tokoro T, Kubo R, Shindo K (1998) Indications for colonic J-pouch reconstruction after anterior resection for rectal cancer: determining the optimum level of anastomosis. Dis Colon Rectum 41:558–563
Temple LK, Bacik J, Savatta SG, Gottesman L, Paty PB, Weiser MR, Guillem JG, Minsky BD, Kalman M, Thaler HT, Schrag D, Wong WD (2005) The development of a validated instrument to evaluate bowel function after sphincter-preserving surgery for rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 48:1353–1365
Wilson TR, Alexander DJ, Kind P (2006) Measurement of health-related quality of life in the early follow-up of colon and rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 49:1692–1702
Rauch P, Miny J, Conroy T, Neyton L, Guillemin F (2004) Quality of life among disease-free survivors of rectal cancer. J Clin Oncol 22:354–360
Pelissier EP, Blum D, Bachour A, Bosset JF (1992) Functional results of coloanal anastomosis with reservoir. Dis Colon Rectum 35:843–846
Hallbook O, Sjodahl R (1997) Comparison between the colonic J pouch-anal anastomosis and healthy rectum: clinical and physiological function. Br J Surg 84:1437–1441
Hida J, Yasutomi M, Maruyama T, Tokoro T, Wakano T, Uchida T (1999) Enlargement of colonic pouch after proctectomy and coloanal anastomosis: potential cause for evacuation difficulty. Dis Colon Rectum 42:1181–1188
Hida J, Yasutomi M, Maruyama T, Yoshifuji T, Tokoro T, Wakano T, Uchida T, Ueda K (1999) Detection of a rectocele-like prolapse in the colonic J-pouch using pouchography: cause or effect of evacuation difficulties? Surg Today 29:1237–1242
Hida J, Yasutomi M, Maruyama T, Tokoro T, Uchida T, Wakano T, Kubo R (1999) Horizontal inclination of the longitudinal axis of the colonic J-pouch: defining causes of evacuation difficulty. Dis Colon Rectum 42:1560–1568
Sailer M, Debus ES, Fuchs KH, Fein M, Beyerlein J, Thiede A (1999) Comparison of different J-pouches vs. straight and side-to-end coloanal anastomoses: experimental study in pigs. Dis Colon Rectum 42:590–595
Köninger JS, Butters M, Redecke JD, Z’Graggen K (2005) Evacuation of neorectal reservoirs after TME. Recent Results Cancer Res 165:180–190
Lewis WG, Holdsworth PJ, Sagar PM, Stephenson BM, Finan PJ, Johnston D (1994) Coordinated activity of the new “rectum” and anal sphincter after sphincter-saving resection of the rectum for colitis or carcinoma. Dis Colon Rectum 37:1012–1019
Otto IC, Ito K, Ye C, Hibi K, Kasai Y, Akiyama S, Takagi H (1996) Causes of rectal incontinence after sphincter-preserving operations for rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 39:1423–1427
Kakodkar R, Gupta S, Nundy S (2006) Low anterior resection with total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: functional assessment and factors affecting outcome. Colorectal Dis 8:650–656
Rao GN, Drew PJ, Lee PW, Monson JR, Duthie GS (1996) Anterior resection syndrome is secondary to sympathetic denervation. Int J Colorectal Dis 11:250–258
Lewis WG, Martin IG, Williamson ME, Stephenson BM, Holdsworth PJ, Finan PJ, Johnston D (1995) Why do some patients experience poor functional results after anterior resection of the rectum for carcinoma? Dis Colon Rectum 38:259–263
Shafik A, Mostafa RM, Shafik I, Ei-Sibai O, Shafik AA (2006) Functional activity of the rectum: A conduit organ or a storage organ or both? World J Gastroenterol 12:4549–4552
Shafik A, Shafik AA, El Sibai O, Ahmed I, Mostafa RM (2006) Role of the rectosigmoidal junction in fecal continence: concept of the primary continent mechanism. Arch Surg 141:23–26
Shafik A, Doss S, Asaad S, Ali YA (1999) Rectosigmoid junction: anatomical, histological, and radiological studies with special reference to a sphincteric function. Int J Colorectal Dis 14:237–244
Koda K, Saito N, Seike K, Shimizu K, Kosugi C, Miyazaki M (2005) Denervation of the neorectum as a potential cause of defecatory disorder following low anterior resection for rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 48:210–217
Oya M, Sugamata Y, Komatsu J, Ishikawa H, Nozaki M (2002) Poor neorectal evacuation as a cause of impaired defecatory function after low anterior resection: a study using scintigraphic assessment. Surg Today 32:111–117
Seike K, Koda K, Takiguchi N, Oda K, Miyazaki M (2003) Gas volume analysis and postoperative bowel functional disorders in patients who received anterior resection for rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 46:661–666
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
An erratum to this article can be found at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00423-008-0415-2
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rink, A.D., Sgourakis, G., Sotiropoulos, G.C. et al. The colon J-pouch as a cause of evacuation disorders after rectal resection: myth or fact?. Langenbecks Arch Surg 394, 79–91 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00423-008-0364-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00423-008-0364-9