Abstract
The effective dose of combined spectrum energy neutrons and high energy spectrum γ-rays in A-bomb survivors in Hiroshima and Nagasaki has long been a matter of discussion. The reason is largely due to the paucity of biological data for high energy photons, particularly for those with an energy of tens of MeV. To circumvent this problem, a mathematical formalism was developed for the photon energy dependency of chromosomal effectiveness by reviewing a large number of data sets published in the literature on dicentric chromosome formation in human lymphocytes. The chromosomal effectiveness was expressed by a simple multiparametric function of photon energy, which made it possible to estimate the effective dose of spectrum energy photons and differential evaluation in the field of mixed neutron and γ-ray exposure with an internal reference radiation. The effective dose of reactor-produced spectrum energy neutrons was insensitive to the fine structure of the energy distribution and was accessible by a generalized formula applicable to the A-bomb neutrons. Energy spectra of all sources of A-bomb γ-rays at different tissue depths were simulated by a Monte Carlo calculation applied on an ICRU sphere. Using kerma-weighted chromosomal effectiveness of A-bomb spectrum energy photons, the effective dose of A-bomb neutrons was determined, where the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of neutrons was expressed by a dose-dependent variable RBE, RBE(γ, D n), against A-bomb γ-rays as an internal reference radiation. When the newly estimated variable RBE(γ, D n) was applied to the chromosome data of A-bomb survivors in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the city difference was completely eliminated. The revised effective dose was about 35% larger in Hiroshima, 19% larger in Nagasaki and 26% larger for the combined cohort compared with that based on a constant RBE of 10. Since the differences are significantly large, the proposed effective dose might have an impact on the magnitude of the risk estimates deduced from the A-bomb survivor cohort.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
ICRP (1991) Publication 60. The 1990 recommendations of the International Commission on Radiological Protection. Annals of ICRP 21. Pergamon Press, New York
Preston DL, McCornney ME, Awa AA (1988) Comparison of the dose–response relationship for chromosome aberration frequencies between the T65D and DS86 dosimetries. Radiation Effects Research Foundation Technical Report TR-88
Preston DL, Shimizu Y, Pierce DA, Suyama A, Mabuchi K (2003) Studies of mortality of atomic bomb survivors. Report 13: solid cancer and noncancer disease mortality: 1950–1997. Radiat Res 160:381–407
Preston DL, Pierce DA, Shimizu Y, Cullings HM, Fujita S, Funamoto S, Kodama K (2004) Effect of recent changes in atomic bomb survivor dosimetry on cancer mortality risk estimates. Radiat Res 162:377–389
RERF (1987) US–Japan joint reassessment of atomic bomb radiation dosimetry in Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Final Report. In: WC Roesch (ed) Vols 1 and 2. Radiation Effects Research Foundation, Hiroshima
RERF (2005) Reassessment of the atomic bomb radiation dosimetry for Hiroshima and Nagasaki: Dosimetry system 2002, DS02. In: RW Young, GD Kerr (eds) Vols 1 and 2. Radiation Effects Research Foundation, Hiroshima
ICRP (2003) Publication 92. Relative biological effectiveness (RBE), quality factor (Q), and radiation weighting factor (w R). International Commission on Radiological Protection. Ann. ICRP 33, Pergamon Press, New York
Straume T (1995) High-energy gamma rays in Hiroshima and Nagasaki: Implications for risk and w R. Health Phys 69:954–956
Sasaki MS, Kobayashi K, Hieda K, Yamada T, Ejima Y, Maezawa H, Furusawa Y, Ito T, Okada S (1989) Induction of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes by monochromatic X-rays of quantum energy between 4.8 and 14.6 keV. Int J Radiat Biol 56:975–988
Sasaki MS (1991) Primary damage and fixation of chromosomal DNA as probed by monochromatic soft X-rays and low-energy neutrons. In: Fielden EM, O‘Neil P (eds) The early effects of radiation on DNA 54:369–384
Schmid E, Krumrey M, Ulm G, Roos H, Regulla D (2003) Maximum low-dose RBE of 17.4 and 40 keV monochromatic X-rays for the induction of dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes. Radiat Res 160:499–504
Krumrey M, Ulm G, Schmid E (2004) Dicentric chromosomes in monolayers of human lymphocytes produced by monochromatized synchrotron radiation with photon energies from 1.83 keV to 17.4 keV. Radiat Environ Biophys 43:1–6
Roos H, Schmid E (1998) Analysis of chromosome aberrations in human peripheral lymphocytes induced by 5.4 keV X-rays. Radiat Environ Biophys 36:251–254
Regulla D, Panzer W, Schmid E, Stepha G, Harder D (2001) Detection of elevated RBE in human lymphocytes exposed to secondary electrons from x-irradiated metal surface. Radiat Res 155:744–747
Schmid E, Regulla D, Kramer H-M, Harder D (2002) The effect of 29 kV X-rays on the dose response of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes. Radiat Res 158:771–777
Endo S, Hoshi M, Takada J, Takatsuji T, Ejima Y, Saigusa S, Tachibana A, Sasaki MS (2006) Development, beam characterization and chromosomal effectiveness of X-rays of RBC characteristic X-ray generator. J Radiat Res (in press)
Schmid E, Bauchinger M, Streng S, Hahrstedt U (1984) The effect of 220 kVp X-rays with different spectra on the dose response of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes. Radiat Environ Biophys 23:303–309
Lloyd DC, Edwards AA, Prosser JS (1986) Chromosome aberrations induced in human lymphocytes by in vitro acute x and gamma radiation. Radiat Prot Dosimetry 15:83–88
Guerrero-Carbajal C, Edwards AA, Lloyd DC (2003) Induction of chromosome aberration in human lymphocytes and its dependence on X-ray energy. Radiat Prot Dosimetry 106:131–135
Lloyd DC, Purrott RJ, Dolphin GW, Bolton D, Edwards AA, Corp MJ (1975) The relationship between chromosome aberrations and low LET dose to human lymphocytes. Int J Radiat Biol 28:75–90
Bauchinger M, Schmid E, Streng S, Dresp J (1983) Quantitative analysis of the chromosome damage at first division of human lymphocytes after 60Co γ-irradiation. Radiat Environ Biophys 22:225–229
Schmid E, Braselmann H, Nahrstedt U (1995) Comparison of γ-ray induced dicentric yields in human lymphocytes measured by conventional analysis and FISH. Mutat Res 348:125–130
Schmid E, Hieber L, Heinzmann U, Roos H, Kellere AM (1996) Analysis of chromosome aberrations in human peripheral lymphocytes induced by in vitro α-particle irradiation. Radiat Environ Biophys 35:179–184
Sasaki MS, Takatsuji T, Ejima Y (1998) The F value cannot be ruled out as a chromosomal fingerprint of radiation quality. Radiat Res 150:253–258
Sasaki MS (2003) Chromosomal biodosimetry by unfolding a mixed Poisson distribution: a generalized model. Int J Radiat Biol 79:83–97
Norman A, Sasaki MS (1966) Chromosome-exchange aberrations in human lymphocytes. Int J Radiat Biol 11:321–328
Norman A (1967) Multi-hit aberrations. In: Evans HJ, Court Brown WM, McLean AS (eds) Human radiation cytogenetics. North Holland Pub. Co., Amsterdam, pp 53–57
Schmid E, Rimpl G, Bauchinger M (1974) Dose–response relation of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes after in vitro irradiation with 3-MeV electrons. Radiat Res 57:228–238
Purrott RJ, Reeder EJ (1977) Chromosome aberration yields induced in human lymphocytes by 15 MeV electrons given at a conventional dose-rate and in microsecond pulses. Int J Radiat Biol 31:251–256
Attix FH (1986) Introduction to radiological physics and radiation dosimetry. Wiley, New York
Sasaki MS, Saigusa S, Kimura I, Kobayashi T, Ikushima T, Kobayashi K, Saito I, Sasuga N, Oka Y, Ito T, Kondo S (1992) Biological effectiveness of fission neutrons: energy dependency and its implication for the risk assessment. In: Proceedings of International Conference on Radiation Effects and Protection. pp 31–35
Vandenbosch R, Huizenga JR (1972) Nuclear fission. Academic, New York
Kerr GD, Pace JV III, Mendelsohn E, Loewe WE, Kaul DC, Dolatshahi F, Egbert SD, Gritzner M, Scott WH Jr, Kosako T, Kanda K (1987) Transport of initial radiations in air over ground. In: US–Japan Joint Reassessment of Atomic Bomb Radiation Dosimetry in Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Final report, Vol. 1., Radiation Effects Research Foundation, Hiroshima, pp 66–142
Hoshi M, Takeoka S, Tsujimura T, Kuroda T, Kawami M, Sawada S (1988) Dosimetric evaluation of 252Cf beam for the use in radiobiology studies at Hiroshima University. Phys Med Biol 33:473–480
IAEA (2001) Cytogenetic analysis for radiation dose assessment: a manual. Internationnal Atomic Energy Agency Technical Reports Series No. 405, Vienna
Stram DO, Sposto R, Preston D, Abrahamson S, Honda T, Awa AA (1993) Stable chromosome aberrations among A-bomb survivors: an update. Radiat Res 136:29–36
Kodama Y, Pawel D, Nakamura N, Preston D, Honda T, Itoh M, Nakano M, Ohtake K, Funamoto S, Awa AA (2001) Stable chromosome aberrations in atomic bomb survivors: results from 25 years of investigation. Radiat Res 156:337–346
Hubbell JH (1982) Photon mass attenuation and energy-absorption coefficients from 1 keV to 20 MeV. Int J Appl Radiat Isot 33:1269–1290
Papworth DG (1970) Testing and fitting frequency distribution. Appendix to “Savage JRK. Sites of radiation induced chromosome exchanges”. In: Ebert M, Howard A (eds) Current topics in radiation research, vol VI. North Holland Pub. Co., Amsterdam, pp 130–194
Kellerer AM, Rossi HH, The theory of dual radiation action. Curr Topics Radiat Res. Quart 8:85–158
Schmid E, Schraube H, Bauchinger M (1998) Chromosome aberration frequencies in human lymphocytes irradiated in a phantom by a mixed beam of fission neutrons and γ-rays. Int J Radiat Biol 73:263–267
Schmid E, Schlegel D, Guldakke S, Kapsch R-P (2003) RBE of nearly monoenergetic neutrons at energies of 36 keV–14.6 MeV for induction of dicentrics in human lymphocytes. Radiat Environ Biophys 42:87–94
Edwards AA (1997) The use of chromosomal aberrations in human lymphocytes for biological dosimetry. Radiat Res Suppl 148:S39–S44
Dobson RL, Straume T, Carrano AV, Minkler JL, Deaven LL, Littlefield LG, Awa AA (1991) Biological effectiveness of neutrons from Hiroshima bomb replica: results of a collaborative cytogenetic study. Radiat Res 128:143–149
Nikjoo H, O’Neill P, Terrissol M, Goodhead DT (1999) Quantitative modeling of DNA damage using Monte Carlo track structure method. Radiat Environ Biophys 38:31–38
Kellerer AM, Nekolla E (1997) Neutron versus γ-ray risk estimates: inferences from the cancer incidence and mortality data in Hiroshima. Radiat Environ Biophys 36:73–83
Kellerer AM (1999) The effects of neutrons in Hiroshima. Implications for the risk estimates. C R Acad Sci Paris 322:229–237
Preston DL, Sposto R (1991) RBE and dose response functions. RERF Update 3:3–4
Little MP (1997) Estimates of neutron relative biological effectiveness derived from the Japanese atomic bomb survivors. Int J Radiat Biol 72:715–726
Rühm W, Walsh L, Chomentowski M (2003) Choice of model and uncertainties of the gamma-ray and neutron dosimetry in relation to the chromosome aberrations data in Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Radiat Environ Biophys 42:119–128
Pierce DA, Shimizu Y, Preston DL, Veath M, Mabuchi K (1996) Studies of the mortality of atomic bomb survivors. Report 12, Part I. Cancer: 1950–1990. Radiat Res 146:1–12
Radford IR (2004) Chromosomal rearrangement as the basis for human tumorigenesis. Int J Radiat Biol 80:543–557
Pierce DA, Stram DO, Vaeth M (1990) Allowing for random errors in radiation exposure estimates for the atomic bomb survivor data. Radiat Res 123:175–284
Dietze G (1995) Problems with radiation weighting factors for neutrons. In. Hargen U, Harder D, Jung H, Streffer C (eds) Radiation research 1985–1995. In: Proceedings of the 10th International Congress on Radiation Research, Würzburg, pp 169–172
Young RW, Egbert SD, Cullings HM, Kerr GD, Imanaka T (2005) Survivor dosimetry. Part B. DS02 free-in-air neutron and gamma tissue kerma relative to DS86. In: Young RW, Kerr GD (eds) Reassessment of the atomic bomb radiation dosimetry for Hiroshima and Nagasaki: dosimetry system 2002, DS02 vol 2. Radiation Effects Research Foundation, Hiroshima, pp 848–857
Kellerer AM, Rühm W, Walsh L (2006) Indications of the neutron effect contribution in the solid cancer data of the A-bomb survivors. Health Phys 90:554–564
Acknowledgments
We are grateful to the Radiation Effects Research Foundation (RERF) for making use of the chromosome aberration database ca1993. RERF is a private foundation founded by the Japanese Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare, and the US Department of Energy through the US National Academy of Sciences. The conclusions in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the scientific judgment of RERF or its funding agencies. We wish to acknowledge Albrecht M. Kellerer for the most helpful critical discussions during preparation of this manuscript. The experiments using the YAYOI nuclear reactor were carried out as a collaborative research project chaired by Itsuro Kimura. This work was supported in part by the Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research from the Ministry of Education, Science, Culture, Sports and Technology of Japan.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sasaki, M.S., Endo, S., Ejima, Y. et al. Effective dose of A-bomb radiation in Hiroshima and Nagasaki as assessed by chromosomal effectiveness of spectrum energy photons and neutrons. Radiat Environ Biophys 45, 79–91 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00411-006-0051-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00411-006-0051-6