Abstract
Background
Measurement of service content is necessary to understand what services actually provide and explain variation in service outcomes. There is no consensus about how to measure content of care in mental health services.
Method
Content of care measures for use in mental health services were identified through a search of electronic databases, hand searching of references from selected studies and consultation with experts in the field. Measures are presented in an organising methodological framework. Studies which introduced or cited the measures were read and investigations of empirical associations between content of care and outcomes were identified.
Results
Twenty five measures of content of care were identified, which used three different data collection methods and five information sources. Seven of these measures have been used to identify links between content of care and outcomes, most commonly in Assertive Community Treatment settings.
Discussion
Measures have been developed which can provide information about service content. However, there is a need for measures to demonstrate more clearly a theoretical or empirical basis, robust psychometric properties and feasibility in a range of service settings. Further comparison of the feasibility and reliability of different measurement methods is needed. Contradictory findings of associations between service content and outcomes may reflect measures’ uncertain reliability, or that crucial process variables are not being measured.
Conclusion
Measures providing a greater depth of information about the nature of interventions are needed. In the absence of a gold standard content of care measure, a multi-methods approach should be adopted.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abramowitz S, Obten N, Cohen H (1998) Measuring HIV/AIDS Case Management. Soc Work Healthcare 27(3):1–28
Beecham J, Knapp M (1992) Costing psychiatric interventions. In: Thornicroft G, Brewin CWJ (eds) Measuring mental health needs, Gaskell, pp 163–183
Bond G, Salyers M (2004) Prediction of outcome from the Dartmouth Assertive Community Treatment fidelity Scale. CNS-Spectrums 9(12):937–942
Bowers L, Brennan G, Flood C, Lipang M, Oladapo P (2006) Preliminary outcomes of a trial to reduce conflict and containment on acute psychiatric wards: City Nurses. J Psychiatr Mental Health Nursing 13:165–172
Bowie P, Mountain G (1993) Using direct observation to record the behaviour of long-stay patients with dementia. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 8:857–864
Brekke J (1987) The model-guided method for monitoring program implementation. Eval Rev 11(3):281–299
Brekke J, Long J (1997) The impact of service characteristics on functional outcomes from Community Support Programs for persons with schizophrenia: a growth curve analysis. J Consult Clin Psychol 65(3):464–475
Brekke J, Ansel J, Long J, Slade E, Weinstein M (1999) Intensity and continuity of services and functional outcomes in the rehabilitation of persons with schizophrenia. Psychiatr Services 50(2):248–256
Brugha T, Glover G (1998) Process and health outcomes: need for clarity in systematic reviews of case management for severe mental disorders. Health Trends 30(3):76–79
Brugha TS, Lindsay F (1996) Quality of mental health service care: the forgotten pathway from process to outcome. Social Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 31(2):89–98
Bryman A (2004) Social research methods, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press
Burns T, Fiander M, Kent A, Ukoumunne OC, Byford S, Fahy T, Kumar KR (2000) Effects of case-load size on the process of care of patients with severe psychotic illness. Report from the UK700 trial. Br J Psychiatry 177:427–433
Burns T, Priebe S (1996) Mental health care systems and their characteristics: A proposal. Acta Psychiatr Scand 94(6):381–385
Dean R, Proudfoot R (1993) The Quality of Interactions Schedule (QUIS): Development, Reliability and Use in the Evaluation of Two Domus Units. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 8:819–826
De Jong A (2000) Development of the International Classification of Mental Health Care (ICMHC). Acta Psychiatr Scand 102(Suppl 405):8–13
De Jong A, Giel R, Tentlom G (1991) International classification of mental health care: a tool for classifying services providing mental health care Part 1. Dept Social Psychiatry, University of Groningen and World Health organisation Regional office for Europe, Groningen
Dietzen L, Bond G (1993) Relationship between case manager contact and outcome for frequently hospitalised psychiatric clients. Hospital Community Psychiatry 44(9):839–843
Donabedian A (1980) Explorations in Quality Assessment and Monitoring, Volume 1: the Definition of Quality and Approaches to its Assessment Health Administration Press
Falloon I, Fadden G (1995) Integrated mental health care: a comprehensive community-based approach Cambridge University Press
Fiander M, Burns T (2000) A Delphi approach to describing service models of community mental health practice. Psychiatr Serv 51(5):656–658
Fisher G, Landis D, Clark D (1988) Case management service provision and client change. Commun Mental Health J 24(2):134–142
Glick I, Burti L, Suzuki K, Sacks M (1991) Effectiveness in psychiatric care: 1. A cross-national study of the process of treatment and outcomes of major depressive disorder. J Nerv Mental Disease 179(2):55–63
Hansson KS, Allebeck P, Malm U (2001) Event recording in psychiatric care: Developing an instrument and 1-year results. J Nordic Psychiatry 55(1):25–31
Higgins R, Hurst K, Wistow G (1999) Nursing acute psychiatric patients: a quantitative and qualitative study. J Advanced Nursing 29(1):52–63
Johnson S, Salvador-Carulla L (1998) Description and classification of mental health services: a European perspective. European Psychiatry 13:333–341
Johnson S, Kuhlman R (2000) The EPCAT Group, “The European Service Mapping Schedule (ESMS): development of an instrument for the description and classification of mental health services”. Acta Psychiatr Scand 102:14–23
Kitwood T (1997) Evaluating dementia care: the DCM method, 7th edn. Universwity of Bradford
Kovess V, Lafleche M (1988) How do teams practice community psychiatry?”. Canada’s Mental Health 36(2):1–28
McGrew J, Bond G, Dietzen L, Salyers M (1994) Measuring the fidelity of implementation of a mental health program model. J Consult Clin Psychol 62:670–678
McHugo G, Drake R, Teague G, Xie H (1999) Fidelity to assertive community treatment and client outcomes in the new hampshire dual disorders study. Psychiatr Service 50(6):818–824
Mechanic D (1996) Emerging issues in international mental health services research. Psychiatr Services 47(4):371–375
Morley S, Snaith P (1992) Principles of psychological assessment. In: Freeman C, Tyrer P (eds) Research methods in psychiatry, 2nd edn. Gaskell, pp 135–152
Morse G, Calsyn R, Klinkenberg W, Helminiak T, Wolff N, Drake R, Yonker R, Lama G, Lemming M, McCudden S (2006) Treating homeless clients with severe mental illness and substance use disorders: costs and outcomes. Commun Mental Health J 42(4):377–404
Olusina AK, Ohaeri JU, Olatawura MO (2003) The quality of interactions between staff and psychiatric inpatients in a Nigerian general hospital. Psychopathology 36(5):269–275
Patmore C, Weaver T (1989) A measure of care. Health Serv J 99(5142):330–331
Paul G (1987) Rational operations in residential treatment settings through ongoing assessment of staff and client functioning. In: Peterson D, Fishman D (eds) Assessment for decision, Rutgers University Press, pp 145–203
Pawson R, Tilley N (1997) Realistic Evaluation. Sage
Popkin M, Callies A, Lurie N, Harman J, Stoner T, Manning W (1997) An instrument to evaluate the process of care in ambulatory settings. Psychiatr Service 48(4):524–527
Quirk A, Lelliot P (2001) What do we know about life on acute psychiatric wards in the UK? A review of the research evidence. Soc Sci Med 53(12):1565–1574
Resnick S, Neale M, Rosenheck R (2003) Impact of Public Support Payments, intensive pychiatric community care and program fidelity on employment outcomes for people with severe mental illness. J Nerv Mental Disease 191(3):139–144
Rossberg J, Friis S (2004) Patients’ and staff’s perceptions of the psychiatric ward environment. Psychiatr Service 55(7):798–803
Rossi P, Freeman H (1989) Evaluation: a systematic approach, 4th edn. Sage
Rossi P, Freeman H, Lipsey G (1999) Evaluation: a systematic approach, 6th edn. Sage
Salize HJ, Kustner BM, Torres-Gonzalez F, Reinhard I, Estevez JFJ, Rossler W (1999) Needs for care and effectiveness of mental health care provision for schizophrenic patients in two European regions: a comparison between Granada (Spain) and Mannheim (Germany). Acta Psychiatr Scand 100(5):328–334
Shepherd G, Richardson R (1979) Organization and interaction in psychiatric day centers. Psychol Med 9:573–579
Slade M, Phelan M, Thornicroft G (1998) A comparison of needs assessed by staff and by and epidemiologically representative sample of patients with psychosis. Psychol Med 28(3):543–550
Slade M, Thornicroft G, Loftus S, Phelan M, Wykes T (1999) The camberwell assessment of need Gaskell, London
Teague G, Bond G, Drake R (1998) Programme fidelity in ACT: development and use of a measure. Am J Orthopsychiatry 68:216–232
Thornicroft G, Tansella M (1999) The mental health matrix: a Manual to Improve Services Cambridge University Press
Thornton A, Hatton A, Tatham A (2004) Dementia care mapping reconsidered: exploring the reliability and validity of the observational tool. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 19:718–726
Tugwell P (1979) A methodological perspective on process measures of the quality of medical care. Clin Investigat Med 2:113–121
Tyson G, Lambert G, Beattie L (1995) The quality of psychiatric nurses’ interactions with patients: an observational study. Int J Nursing Studies 32(1):49–58
Whitley R, Crawford M (2005) Qualitative research in psychiatry. Can J Psychiatry 50(2):108–114
Wing J, Brown G (1970) Institutionalism and Schizophrenia Cambridge University Press
Wright R, Sklebar T, Heiman J (1987) Patterns of case management activity in an intensive community support programme. Commun Mental Health J 23(1):53–59
Young A, Sullivan G, Burnam A, Brook R (1998) Measuring the quality of outpatient treatment for schizophrenia. Arch Gen Psychiatry 55:611–617
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lloyd-Evans, B., Johnson, S. & Slade, M. Assessing the content of mental health services: a review of measures. Soc Psychiat Epidemiol 42, 673–682 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-007-0216-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-007-0216-x