Summary
The results obtained with primary retroperitoneal lymph-node dissection (RPLND) in 464 patients with clinical stage A nonseminomatous germ-cell (NSGC) testicular cancer over a period of 25 years (1965–1989) were reviewed. Results were analyzed in clinical terms and subdivided into early (1965–1978) and contemporary (1979–1989) findings so as to be comparable with series using radiotherapy or surveillance. Between 1965 and 1978 (86 clinical stage A patients), the overall relapse rate of 15% (n=13) was similar to that obtained in radiotherapy series but the survival (98.8% after RPLND) was superior to that achieved with irradiation (87%). From 1979 to 1989, 378 clinical stage A cases had primary RPLND, of whom 29% (n=111) had cancerous nodes. The relapse rate for pathological stage A patients (n=267) was 11% and two patients died. The rate of relapse for pathological stage B patients who did not receive adjuvant chemotherapy was 32%. No relapse was seen among 46 pathological stage B patients given postoperative adjuvant chemotherapy. The mortality of 0.7% observed among 378 clinical stage A RPLND cases was lower than the 2% value reported in surveillance series. Although not statistically significant, these consistent results reported for two eras (pre- and postplatinum) spanning a period of 25 years suggest a sound basis for the surgical approach. The anatomic and medical principles in oncology, which have supported this approach, remain cogent today. They are discussed herein. Now that nerve-sparing techniques have been developed, the one long-term morbidity of RPLND (i.e., anejaculation) can be avoided. It would seem appropriate to have nerve-sparing RPLND techniques in any armamentarium dealing with clinical stage A disease.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Donohue JP (1987) Selecting initial therapy, seminoma and nonseminoma. Cancer 60:115–120
Pont J, Holtl W, Kosak D et al. (1990) Risk adapted treatment choice in stage I nonseminomatous testicular germ cell cancer by regarding vascular invasion in the primary tumor: a prospective trial. J Clin Oncol 8:16–20
Peckham MJ, Barrett A, Husband JE et al. (1982) Orchiectomy alone in testicular stage I nonseminomatous germ cell tumours. Lancet II:678–680
Hinman F (1919) The radical operation for teratoma testis. Surg Gynecol Obstet 28:495–508
Boden G, Gibb R (1951) Radiotherapy and testicular neoplasms. Lancet II:1195–1197
Peckham MJ, McElwain TJ (1994) Radiotherapy of testicular tumours. Proc R Soc Med 67:300–303
Peckham MJ (1982) Radiotherapy for clinical stage I and II nonseminomatous germ cell tumours (malignant teratoma) of the testis. In: Williams CJ, Whitehouse JMA (eds) Recent advances in clinical oncology. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh, London, Melbourne, pp 107–181
Donohue JP (1984) Metastatic pathways of nonseminomatous germ cell tumours. Semin Urol 2:217–229
Donohue JP, Thornhill JA, Foster RS et al. (1990) The evolution of surgical templates and nerve-sparing techniques in retroperitoneal lymphadenectomy for low stage testis cancer. J Urol 143:395A
Tyrrell CJ, Peckham MJ (1976) The response of lymph node metastases of testicular teratoma to radiation therapy. Br J Urol 48:363–370
Clements JC, McLeod DG, Weisbaum GS et al. (1981) Radiation therapy for nonseminomatous germ cell tumor of the testis: a reappraisal. J Urol 126:490–492
Williams SD, Stablein DM, Einhorn LH et al. (1987) Immediate adjuvant chemotherapy versus observation with treatment at relapse in pathological stage II testicular cancer. N Engl J Med 317:1433–1438
Sogani PC, Fair WR (1989) Surveillance alone in the treatment of clinical stage I nonseminomatous germ cell tumor of the testis (NSGCT). Semin Urol 6:53–56
Liedke S, Allhoff EP, Jonas U (1990) Wait and see in NSGCT clinical stage I: a critical assessment after eight years. J Urol 143:397A
Raghavan D, Colls B, Levi J et al. (1988) Surveillance for stage I non-seminomatous germ cell tumours of the testis: the optimal protocol has not yet been defined. Br J Urol 61:522–526
Rowland RG, Weisman D, Williams SD et al. (1982) Accuracy of preoperative staging in stages A and B nonseminomatous germ cell testis tumors. J Urol 127:718–720
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Donohue, J.P., Thornhill, J.A., Foster, R.S. et al. Stage I nonseminomatous germ-cell testicular cancer — management options and risk-benefit considerations. World J Urol 12, 170–176 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00185665
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00185665