The Nebular Shock Wave Model for Chondrule Formation: Shock Processing in a Particle–Gas Suspension

doi:10.1006/icar.2002.6895

Icarus

Volume 158, Issue 2, August 2002, Pages 281-293

https://doi.org/10.1006/icar.2002.6895 Get rights and content

Abstract

We present numerical simulations of the thermal and dynamical histories of solid particles (chondrules and their precursors—treated as 1-mm silicate spheres) during passage of an adiabatic shock wave through a particle–gas suspension in a minimum-mass solar nebula. The steady-state equations of energy, momentum, and mass conservation are derived and integrated for both solids and gas under a variety of shock conditions and particle number densities using the free-molecular-flow approximation. These simulations allow us to investigate both the heating and cooling of particles in a shock wave and to compare the time and distance scales associated with their processing to those expected for natural chondrules. The interactions with the particles cause the gas to achieve higher temperatures and pressures both upstream and downstream of the shock than would be reached otherwise. The cooling rates of the particles are found to be nonlinear but agree approximately with the cooling rates inferred for chondrules by laboratory simulations. The initial concentration of solids upstream of the shock controls the cooling rates and the distances over which they are processed: Lower concentrations cool more slowly and over longer distances. These simulations are consistent with the hypothesis that large-scale shocks, e.g., those due to density waves or gravitational instabilities, were the dominant mechanism for chondrule formation in the nebula.

References (44)

L.L. Hood et al.
Gas dynamic heating of chondrule precursor grains in the solar nebula
Icarus
(1991)
L.L. Hood et al.
The nebular shock wave model for chondrule formation: One-dimensional calculations
Icarus
(1993)
S. Huang et al.
Chondrules: Their diversity and the role of open-system processes during their formation
Icarus
(1996)
A. Iida et al.
A shock heating model for chondrule formation in a protoplanetary disk
Icarus
(2001)
D.A. Kring
High temperature rims around chondrules in primitive chondrites: Evidence for fluctuating conditions in the solar nebula
Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.
(1991)
D.S. Lauretta et al.
Opaque minerals in the matrix of the Bishunpur (LL3.1) chondrite: Constraints on the chondrule formation environment
Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta
(2001)
K. Liffman et al.
Chondrule fine-grained mantle formation by hypervelocity impact of chondrules with a dusty gas
Icarus
(2000)
P.M. Radomsky et al.
Formation conditions of pyroxene–olivine and magnesian olivine chondrules
Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta
(1990)
A.E. Rubin
Petrologic, geochemical and experimental constraints on models of chondrule formation
Earth Sci. Rev.
(2000)
T.V. Ruzmaikina et al.
Chondrule formation in radiative shock
Icarus
(1994)

K.K. Tanaka et al.

Shock heating due to accretion of a clumpy cloud onto a protoplanetary disk

Icarus

(1998)

J.T. Wasson et al.

Compound chondrules

Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta

(1995)

S.J. Weidenschilling

Evolution of grains in a turbulent solar nebula

Icarus

(1984)

J.A. Wood

On the formation of meteoritic chondrules by aerodynamic drag heating in the solar nebula

Earth Planet Sci. Lett.

(1984)

Y. Yu et al.

Transient heating and chondrule formation: Evidence from sodium loss in flash heating simulation experiments

Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta

(1998)

Boss, A. P.1996. A concise guide to chondrule formation models. In Chondrules and the Protoplanetary DiskR. H. Hewins,...

A.P. Boss

Possible rapid gas giant planet formation in the solar nebula and other protoplanetary disks

Astrophys. J.

(2000)

F.J. Ciesla et al.

Chondrule formation in nebular shocks: An improved one-dimensional model

Lunar Planet. Sci.

(2000)

A.J. Collison et al.

Axisymmetric models of circumstellar dust shells

Astrophys. J.

(1991)

H.C. Connolly et al.

The formation of chondrules: Petrologic tests of the shock wave model

Science

(1998)

Cuzzi, J. N., A. R. Dobrovolskis, and R. C. Hogan1996. Turbulence, chondrules, and planetesimals. In Chondrules and the...

Cited by (107)

Chondrule formation via impact jetting in the icy outer solar system
2022, Icarus
Impact jetting during planetesimal collisions is a process that ejects small amounts of highly shocked material during the earliest stages of an impact. Jetting can produce melted and vaporized material during relatively low velocity collisions and has previously been presented as a mechanism for producing chondrules in the inner solar system during impacts between rocky planetesimals. However, chondrules are observed in both non‑carbonaceous and carbonaceous chondrites, which are thought to have formed in the inner and outer solar system, respectively. In this work, we use the iSALE2D hydrocode to investigate the viability of jetting for producing chondrules in the outer solar system, where ice-rich bodies begin to be incorporated into the planetesimal population. We create mixed material equations of state for ice mass fractions of 10–50% intimately combined with dunite to emulate the compositions of ice-rich outer solar system planetesimals. We account for collisions between a sphere and flat target at 2–7 km/s. Our results indicate that the presence of ice lowers the total mass of chondrule forming material jetting can produce, but a significant mass of chondrules is likely to form nonetheless even through collisions of bodies with relatively high ice concentrations. For example, for collisions at 4 km/s, pure dunite bodies create ~1% the mass of a 10-km-diameter projectile of chondrules, while bodies that include 50% ice by mass produce ~0.004% the mass of an impactor of chondrules. The presence of ice results in water vapor in the jet plume which may generate an oxidizing environment that favors the production of chondrules relatively enriched in ¹⁷O and ¹⁸O due to ¹⁶O-poor composition of water ice in the outer solar system.
A temporal shift of chondrule generation from the inner to outer Solar System inferred from oxygen isotopes and Al-Mg chronology of chondrules from primitive CM and CO chondrites
2022, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
Deciphering the spatial and temporal evolution of chondrules allows for a better understanding of how asteroidal seeds formed, migrated, and eventually accreted into parent asteroids. Here we report high precision Al-Mg ages and oxygen three-isotope ratios of fifteen FeO-poor chondrules from the least metamorphosed Mighei-like (CM) and Ornans-like (CO) carbonaceous chondrites, Asuka 12236 (CM2.9), Dominion Range 08006 (CO3.01), and Yamato 81020 (CO3.05). This is the first report of Al-Mg ages of chondrules from the CM chondrite group. All but one of the fifteen chondrules exhibit a restricted range of inferred initial ²⁶Al/²⁷Al ratios, and all ratios are ≤ 6.0 × 10⁻⁶, which is systematically lower than those of the majority of ordinary chondrite (OC) chondrules. These observations indicate that the majority of chondrules in the outer Solar System were produced ≥2.2 Ma after the formation of Ca-Al-rich inclusions (CAIs), which postdates OC chondrule formation in the inner Solar System (≤2.2 Ma after CAI formation). We propose that the discrete chondrule-forming events in different disk regions reflect a time difference in growth and orbital evolution of planetesimals within the first 4 Ma of the Solar System.
One chondrule from Asuka 12236 has an age of 1.9 Ma after CAI formation and is therefore significantly older than the other fourteen chondrules, meaning this chondrule formed contemporaneously with the majority of OC chondrules. This old chondrule also exhibits ¹⁶O-depleted oxygen isotope characteristics compared to the other chondrules, suggesting a distinct formation region, probably inside the disk region relative to where the majority of CM and CO chondrules formed. Our results indicate that this old chondrule has migrated from the inner to the outer part of the protoplanetary disk within ∼1 Ma and then accreted into the CM parent asteroid >3 Ma after CAI formation, although its formation exterior to the accretion region of the CM parent asteroid and subsequent inward migration cannot be ruled out completely.
In situ Si isotope and chemical constraints on formation and processing of chondrules in the Allende meteorite
2021, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
Citation Excerpt :
Chondrules, few hundred microns to mm- sized silicate spheres, are one of the major constituents of undifferentiated meteorites, contributing 15–70 vol% to all but CI carbonaceous chondrites (Scott and Krot, 2003). Various models of chondrule formation were proposed such as the X-wind model, gravitational instability driven by shocks, bow shocks from planetesimals or lightning in the solar nebula, and hypervelocity impact (Shu et al., 1997; Iida et al., 2001; Ciesla and Hood, 2002; Desch and Connolly, 2002; Morris and Desch, 2010; Johnson et al., 2015). However, no single model explains all experimental and observational data on textures, chemical compositions, and isotope records of chondrules (Desch et al., 2012).
Chondrules in undifferentiated meteorites are former silicate melt droplets of variable texture and composition. Although widely studied, the chondrule formation mechanisms and conditions that explain all properties of chondrules are yet to be identified. To further constrain the processes that affected chondrules in the solar nebula and on the meteorite parent body, we determined in situ Si isotope ratios and major and trace element compositions of minerals in chondrules of variable types and sizes from the Allende CV3 chondrite.
The δ³⁰Si in chondrule minerals ranges from −1.28 ± 0.19 to 0.55 ± 0.20‰ (2SE). The δ³⁰Si in chondrules shows no direct relationship with chondrule sizes or with distance between core and rim. Barred olivine-rich chondrules record the highest δ³⁰Si, likely because of faster cooling and less interaction with isotopically light nebular gas. Type I non-porphyritic and some porphyritic chondrules show overall higher δ³⁰Si compared to type II porphyritic chondrules. Furthermore, Mg-rich olivine and Mg-rich pyroxene have systematically higher δ³⁰Si compared to Fe-rich olivine and Fe-rich pyroxene.
The variable δ³⁰Si of type I chondrule silicates (Mg-rich) compared to type II chondrule silicates (Fe-rich) may be explained by variable interaction of chondrule silicates with the nebular gas in the solar nebula. We envision a combination of equilibrium and kinetic isotope fractionation of Si between nebular gas and Fe-poor silicates (such as forsterite, anorthite, enstatite and mesostasis) and Fe-rich olivine and orthopyroxene. Petrographic evidence suggests that the enrichment of Fe in some highly altered porphyritic chondrules and at chondrule rims was likely caused by hydrothermal alteration on the parent body. Therefore, the correlation of Fe and δ³⁰Si of the chondrule minerals might serve as an indicator for the extent of further secondary processing of some chondrule minerals. The sum of these observations suggests that the formation and alteration of type II chondrules occurred by oxidation of originally reduced, metal-rich type I chondrules, both in the solar nebula and later on the meteorite parent body. Remaining ³⁰Si depleted gas contributed to the isotopic composition of matrix silicates. The evidence favours the formation of chondrules and matrix of the Allende meteorite in nebular settings rather than by asteroid impacts.
A chondrule formation experiment aboard the ISS: Experimental set-up and test experiments
2020, Icarus
The formation of chondrules in the solar nebula is still an enigmatic process. In order to reconstruct this process, we performed a chondrule formation experiment aboard the International Space Station (ISS), called EXCISS. The purpose of the EXCISS experiment is to acquire new insights in chondrule formation by “nebular lightnings”. During the experiment, forsterite (Mg $_{2}$ SiO₄) particles were repeatedly exposed to arc discharges under long-term micro-gravity conditions. The purpose of this paper is to describe the experimental set-up and establish and benchmark approaches for the analysis of the samples once they are returned from the ISS. We produced aggregates of fused Mg $_{2}$ SiO₄ particles in our Earth-based experiment which we studied by SEM and X-ray microtomography. The results of our preliminary Earth-based experiments indicate that the chosen experimental parameters will likely lead to melting of Mg $_{2}$ SiO₄ particles and the formation of aggregates. The results from the first experiments aboard the ISS revealed that the EXCISS experiment is fully operational.
Constraints on compound chondrule formation from laboratory high-temperature collisions
2019, Icarus
In laboratory experiments, spherical 1 mm-wide glass and basalt particles are heated, and the hot particles collide at about 1 m/s with a flat glass target that is at room temperature. When the particles are heated below 900 K, the collisions are essentially elastic with coefficients of restitution of about 0.9, but above 900 K collisions become increasingly inelastic and the coefficient of restitution decreases with increasing temperature. At 1100 K the glass particles approach sticking but, simultaneously, at the same temperature the particles melt on timescales of minutes. The basalt particles approach sticking at 1200 K. Only above 1400 K do basalt grains in contact with each other fuse together, forming compounds on timescales of hours, and at 1500 K basalt grains completely fuse together. Therefore, cooling basalt grains only have a 100 K window for compound formation, and velocities very likely have to be below 1 m/s for sticking in the first place. We predict that this puts constraints on compound chondrule formation and particle densities in the solar nebula.
Formation of unequilibrated R chondrite chondrules and opaque phases
2017, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
Sulfide assemblages are commonly found in chondritic meteorites as small inclusions in the matrix or in association with chondrules. These assemblages are widely hypothesized to form through pre-accretionary corrosion of metal by H₂S gas or through parent body processes. We report here on two unequilibrated R chondrite samples that contain large, chondrule-sized sulfide nodules in the matrix. Both samples are from Mount Prestrud (PRE) 95404. Chemical maps and spot and broad-beam electron microprobe analyses (EMPA) were used to assess the distribution, stoichiometry, and bulk composition of sulfide nodules and silicate chondrules in the clasts. Oxygen isotope data were collected via secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) to assess the relationship of chondrules to other chondrite groups. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM), focused ion beam (FIB), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analyses were used to assess fine-scale features and identify crystal structures in sulfide assemblages. Thermodynamic models were used to assess the temperature, sulfur fugacity (fS₂), total pressure, dust-to-gas ratio, and oxygen fugacity (fO₂) conditions during sulfide nodule and chondrule formation.
The unequilibrated clasts include a mixture of type I and type II chondrules, as well as non-porphyritic chondrules. Chondrule oxygen isotopes overlap with ordinary-chondrite chondrules. Sulfide nodules average 200 µm in diameter, have rounded shapes, and are primarily composed of pyrrhotite, pentlandite, and magnetite. Some are deformed around chondrules in a petrologic relationship similar in appearance to compound chondrules. Both nodules and sulfides in chondrules include phosphate inclusions and Cu-rich lamellae, which suggests a genetic relationship between sulfides in chondrules and in the matrix. Ni/Co ratios for matrix and chondrule sulfides are solar, while Fe and Ni are non-solar and inversely related.
We hypothesize that sulfide nodules formed via pre-accretionary melt processes. During chondrule formation, precursors composed of a mixture of silicate and sulfide material were heated to form immiscible melt droplets, which separated and cooled to form Si-rich chondrules and S-rich nodules. Sulfide melt was stabilized by a high total pressure (∼1 atm) in a dust- or ice-enriched environment. Heating of this material contributed to a high fS₂ (2 × 10⁻³ atm at 1138 °C), and high fO₂ (IW – 1 to IW – 4), in an environment with peak temperatures between 1539 °C and 1750 °C. Oxygen isotopic compositions in this region were similar to those recorded by the LL-chondrite chondrules.

View all citing articles on Scopus

^f1: [email protected]

View full text

Regular ArticleThe Nebular Shock Wave Model for Chondrule Formation: Shock Processing in a Particle–Gas Suspension

Abstract

Icarus

Icarus

Icarus

Icarus

Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.

Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta

Icarus

Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta

Earth Sci. Rev.

Icarus

Icarus

Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta

Icarus

Earth Planet Sci. Lett.

Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta

Possible rapid gas giant planet formation in the solar nebula and other protoplanetary disks

Astrophys. J.

Chondrule formation in nebular shocks: An improved one-dimensional model

Lunar Planet. Sci.

Axisymmetric models of circumstellar dust shells

Astrophys. J.

The formation of chondrules: Petrologic tests of the shock wave model

Science

Regular Article
The Nebular Shock Wave Model for Chondrule Formation: Shock Processing in a Particle–Gas Suspension