Organic contaminants in municipal biosolids: risk assessment, quantitative pathways analysis, and current research priorities

https://doi.org/10.1016/0048-9697(96)05051-6Get rights and content

Abstract

Basic research and monitoring of the fate and potential effects of PCBs and other xenobiotic organics in biosolids (municipal sewage sludge) used on cropland have identified specific Pathways by which the xenobiotic organics in biosolids can reach and cause exposure to humans, livestock, plants, soil biota, wildlife, etc. In order to provide the scientific basis for the Clean Water Act Regulations (40 CFR 503) on land application of biosolids in the U.S., a Pathway Approach to risk assessment was undertaken. Pathways included general food production; garden food production; soil ingestion by humans, livestock, and wildlife; human exposure through livestock tissues where the livestock were exposed through crop contamination or biosolids/soil ingestion; wildlife exposure through soil organisms; release to surface and groundwater; volatilization into inhaled air, or dust generated by tillage. Two Pathways were found to comprise the greatest risk from persistent lipophilic organic compounds such as PCBs: (1) adherence of biosolids to forage/pasture crops from surface application of fluid biosolids, followed by grazing and ingestion of biosolids by livestock used as human food; and (2) direct ingestion of biosolids by children. Each Pathway considers risk to Highly Exposed Individuals (HEIs) rather than to the general population who seldom have appreciable exposure to biosolids or foods grown on biosolid-amended soils. Because present (1995) biosolids contain very low levels of PCBs in countries which have prohibited manufacture and use of these compounds, the estimated increase in lifetime cancer risk to HEIs from biosolids-borne PCBs applied to cropland or gardens was much less than 10−4. Low biosolids PCBs and low probability of simultaneously meeting all the constraints of the HEI indicate that HEIs have less than 10−7 increase in lifetime cancer risk from biosolids-borne PCBs; this provides even higher protection to the general population. We conclude that quantitative risk assessment for potentially toxic constituents in biosolids can be meaningfully conducted because research has provided transfer coefficients from biosolids and biosolid-amended soils to plants and animals needed to assess risk for many organic compounds.

References (86)

  • P. Moza et al.

    Studies with 2,4′, 5-trichlorobiphenyl-14C and 2,2′, 4,4′, 6-pentachlorobiphenyl-14C in carrots, sugar beets and soil

    J. Agric. Food Chem.

    (1979)
  • K. Rozman et al.

    Use of aliphatic hydrocarbons in feed to decrease body burdens of lipophilic toxicants in livestock

    J. Agric. Food Chem.

    (1982)
  • S.R. Wild et al.

    Organic chemicals entering soils in sewage sludges: screening for their potential to transfer to crop plants and livestock

    Sci. Total Environ.

    (1992)
  • H. Witte et al.

    Investigation of the entry of organic pollutants into soils and plants through the use of sewage sludge in agriculture. Part A. Organic pollutant load in sewage sludge. Part B. Impact of the application of sewage sludge on organic matter contents in soils and plants

    Korrespondenz Abwasser

    (1988)
    H. Witte et al.

    Investigation of the entry of organic pollutants into soils and plants through the use of sewage sludge in agriculture. Part A. Organic pollutant load in sewage sludge. Part B. Impact of the application of sewage sludge on organic matter contents in soils and plants

    Korrespondenz Abwasser

    (1988)
  • B.N. Ames et al.

    Too many rodent carcinogens: mitogenesis increases mutagenesis

    Science

    (1990)
  • E.L. Baker et al.

    Lead poisoning in children of lead workers. Home contamination with industrial dust

    New Engl. J. Med.

    (1977)
  • T. Batey et al.

    The disposal of copper-enriched pig-manure slurry on grassland

    J. Br. Grassland Soc.

    (1972)
  • J.C. Baxter et al.

    Effects on Cattle From Exposure to Sewage Sludge

    (1983)
  • J.E. Bertrand et al.

    Metal residues in tissues, animal performance, and carcass quality with beef steers grazing Pensacola bahiagrass pastures treated with liquid digested sludge

    J. Anim. Sci.

    (1981)
  • W.N. Beyer et al.

    Long-term persistence of dieldrin, DDT, and heptachlor epoxide in earthworms

    Ambio

    (1989)
  • W.N. Beyer et al.

    Survey and evaluation of contaminants in earthworms and in soils derived from dredged material at confined disposal facilities in the Great Lakes region

    Environ. Monit. Assess.

    (1992)
  • S. Binder et al.

    Estimating soil ingestion: the use of tracer elements in estimating the amount of soil ingested by young children

    Arch. Environ. Health.

    (1986)
  • F.C. Boswell

    Municipal sewage sludge and selected element applications to soil: effect on soil and fescue

    J. Environ. Qual.

    (1975)
  • E.J. Calabrese et al.

    A guide to interpreting soil ingestion studies. 2. Qualitative and quantitative evidence of soil ingestion

    Chem. Spec. Bioavail.

    (1991)
  • R.L. Chaney

    Research provides basis for quantitative risk assessment to make appropriate regulations for land application of sewage sludge: (1) Twenty years of land application research

    BioCycle

    (1990)
    R.L. Chaney

    Research provides basis for quantitative risk assessment to make appropriate regulations for land application of sewage sludge: (2) Public health and sludge utilization

    BioCycle

    (1990)
  • R.L. Chaney et al.

    Transfer of sludge-applied trace elements to the food-chain

  • R.L. Chaney et al.

    Heavy metal relationship during land utilization of sewage sludge in the Northeast

  • R.L. Chaney et al.

    Adherence of spray-applied liquid sewage sludge to tall fescue

    J. Environ. Qual.

    (1979)
  • R.L. Chaney et al.

    Speciation, mobility, and bioavailability of soil lead

  • R.L. Chaney et al.

    Risk assessment for organic micropollutants: U.S. point of view

  • S.F. Chou et al.

    Absence of plant uptake and translocation of polybrominated biphenyls (PBBs)

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (1978)
  • P. Clausing et al.

    A method for estimating soil ingestion by children

    Int. Arch. Occup. Environ. Health

    (1987)
  • Comptroller General

    Sewage Sludge: How Do We Cope With It?

    (1978)
  • R.B. Corey et al.

    Effects of sludge properties on accumulation of trace elements by crops

  • R.D. Davis et al.

    Significance of organic contaminants in sewage sludges used on agricultural land

  • S. Davis et al.

    Quantitative estimates of soil ingestion in normal children between the ages of 2 and 7 years: Population-based estimates using aluminum, silicon, and titaniun as soil tracer elements

    Arch. Environ. Health

    (1990)
  • T.S. Davis et al.

    Uptake of polychlorobiphenyls present in trace amounts from dried municipal sewage sludge through an old field ecosystem

    Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.

    (1981)
  • A.M. Decker et al.

    Animal performance on pastures topdressed with liquid sewage sludge and sludge compost

  • P. Diercxsens et al.

    Earthworm contamination by PCBs and heavy metals

    Chemosphere

    (1985)
  • R. Eisler

    Polychlorinated Biphenyl Hazards to Fish, Wildlife, and Invertebrates: A Synoptic Review

    U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv. Biol. Rept.

    (1986)
  • F.C. Fairbanks et al.

    Effect of sewage sludge on the adsorption of polychlorinated biphenyls by three New Mexico soils

    J. Environ. Qual.

    (1984)
  • D.J. Forsyth et al.

    Species and age differences in accumulation of 36CI-DDT by voles and shrews in the field

    Environ. Pollut.

    (1984)
  • G.F. Fries

    Organic contaminants in terrestrial food chains

  • Cited by (46)

    • Trace contaminants in the environmental assessment of organic waste recycling in agriculture: Gaps between methods and knowledge

      2022, Advances in Agronomy
      Citation Excerpt :

      Several parameters were calculated for each scenario, such as the allowed daily ingestion or the reference soil concentration that cannot be exceeded at the selected risk level. It should be underlined that the highly exposed individuals approach is very conservative because it considers that humans (adults or children) are continuously exposed to the same amount of biosolid-bound PCB (Chaney et al., 1996). Chari and Halden (2012) developed an empirical equation to estimate the aqueous-phase concentration of hydrophobic organic contaminants that could leach from biosolids and potentially reach groundwater and/or surface water.

    • Risk assessments for quality-assured, source-segregated composts and anaerobic digestates for a circular bioeconomy in the UK

      2019, Environment International
      Citation Excerpt :

      Given these concerns, key questions arise, as to: (a) how products derived from composting and AD can be made technically safe by adopting engineering controls during waste processing; (b) whether the products that emerge are inherently safe in their new uses, as evaluated by risk assessment; (c) what level of confidence citizens can have in claims for safety made by waste processors and the users of products, such as farmers; and (d) whether these residues can be declassified as wastes so their value can be secured and products marketed. In response, policy-level risk assessments (see for example, USEPA, 1995) have been used to inform these decisions that seek to balance resource efficiency with environmental safety (see Gillett, 1992; Chaney et al., 1996; Gale, 2002; Kinney et al., 2006; Brooks et al., 2012); assessments that deploy generalised scenarios for a range of end uses so to independently evaluate, albeit at a high level (i) the potential for harms to human health and the environment that might materialise from a change to legislation or from products in use; and (ii) the management controls required to maintain a reduction in any residual risk to acceptable levels. There is merit in summarising the chronology of approach to this study.

    • Four decades since the ban, old urban wastewater treatment plant remains a dominant source of PCBs to the environment

      2019, Environmental Pollution
      Citation Excerpt :

      This level exceeds the No Observed Adverse Effects Limit (NOAEL) of 0.36 mg total PCB/kg/day but does not exceed the Lowest Observed Adverse Effects Limit (LOAEL) of 1.8 mg total PBC/kg/day for the American Robin. The mass of biosolids applied to the soil was based on a 5-year application rate, but using a more common screening time for a biosolid application period is a 10-year application (Chaney et al., 1996). Assuming PCBs do not degrade substantially in soils we would estimate the PCB soil concentration to approximately double resulting in a body burden of 0.76 mg total PCB/kg/day.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text