The Evolution of Virulence in Parasites and Pathogens: Reconciliation Between Two Competing Hypotheses

doi:10.1006/jtbi.1994.1146

Journal of Theoretical Biology

Volume 169, Issue 3, 7 August 1994, Pages 253-265

https://doi.org/10.1006/jtbi.1994.1146 Get rights and content

Abstract

According to conventional wisdom, parasites and pathogens should evolve reduced virulence to their hosts, because more virulent parasites and pathogens are more likely to drive their hosts, and themselves, to extinction. But this view has been criticized for its reliance on group selection. According to an alternative perspective, selection will favor whatever level of virulence maximizes the rate of increase of the parasite or pathogen. This optimum virulence depends on the functional relationship between a parasite or pathogen's transmissibility and its effect on host mortality, with selection often favoring an intermediate degree of virulence. The thesis of this paper is that models in which intermediate levels of virulence are favored lead quite naturally to the further conclusion that parasites and pathogens should—up to a point—become less virulent over time, once the feedbacks between ecological and evolutionary processes are incorporated into the analysis. As a consequence of successive adaptations by the parasite or pathogen, the density of susceptible hosts is reduced, thereby altering the balance between selective forces so as to favor reduced virulence. However, the evolutionarily stable strategy that is achieved is bounded away from complete avirulence. We conclude that models in which intermediate virulence is favored do not necessarily contradict the conventional wisdom in the long run; in fact, these models provide a simple mechanistic explanation for the evolution of reduced virulence.

References (0)

Cited by (288)

Virulence of a virus: How it depends on growth rate, effectors, memory cells, and immune escape
2021, Journal of Theoretical Biology
Citation Excerpt :
A traditional argument of virulence evolution was that the virus that recently became to attack a host species may be very virulent, but they tend to evolve more benign, because killing the host quickly would reduce the chance of transmission to susceptible hosts and is disadvantageous to the virus. However, the virulence may not decrease in evolution if a higher transmission rate is accompanied by a larger virus abundance, which inevitably causes the infected host to have a shorter life (Lenski and May, 1994). In addition, the spatial structure of the host population may produce an evolution toward enhanced virulence (Boots and Sasaki, 1999; Boots et al., 2004).
A viral strain may infect a host, proliferate rapidly, become controlled by immune reactions, and eventually be eliminated from the body. The virulence, or the magnitude of harm to the host due to infection, depends on the abundance and duration of the viral strain in the body, and the importance of the damaged tissue of the host. In this study, we investigated how the cumulative viral load (time-integral of the number of infected cells) depends on various factors, such as the viral growth rate, the effectiveness of immune cells to kill infected cells, speed of immune activation, formation of memory cells, and longevity of immune cells. In addition, viruses may produce a mutant with different antigen types, escape the immune reaction targeting the original type, and inflate virulence. We succeeded in deriving simple and explicit formulas of the virulence in four different parameter regions. We found that, in some parameter region, enhancing memory cells is very effective in suppressing virulence, but direct activation of immune effector cells is not effective; while the opposite is the case in other regions. The result could be important in designing drug suppressing virus effectively. Additionally, we discussed the reported correlation between virulence and molecular evolution rate.
D614G mutation eventuates in all VOI and VOC in SARS-CoV-2: Is it part of the positive selection pioneered by Darwin?
2021, Molecular Therapy Nucleic Acids
Recently, several emerging variants of SARS-CoV-2 have originated from the Wuhan strain and spread throughout the globe within one and a half years. One mutation, D614G, is very prominent in all VOI and VOC in SARS-CoV-2. This mutation might help to increase the viral fitness in all emerging variants where the mutation is present. With the help of this mutation (D614G), the SARS-CoV-2 variants have gained viral fitness to enhance viral replication and increase transmission. This paper attempts to answer the question of whether the mutation (D614G) occurs due to positive selection or not.
The origins and potential future of SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern in the evolving COVID-19 pandemic
2021, Current Biology
One year into the global COVID-19 pandemic, the focus of attention has shifted to the emergence and spread of SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern (VOCs). After nearly a year of the pandemic with little evolutionary change affecting human health, several variants have now been shown to have substantial detrimental effects on transmission and severity of the virus. Public health officials, medical practitioners, scientists, and the broader community have since been scrambling to understand what these variants mean for diagnosis, treatment, and the control of the pandemic through nonpharmaceutical interventions and vaccines. Here we explore the evolutionary processes that are involved in the emergence of new variants, what we can expect in terms of the future emergence of VOCs, and what we can do to minimise their impact.
The two-way relationship between food systems and the COVID19 pandemic: causes and consequences
2021, Agricultural Systems
Citation Excerpt :
Normally, when a new pathogen emerges in a host population, and assuming it is transmitted directly from host to host, it gradually moderates its virulence in order to keep those hosts alive for long enough to spread it far and wide (Rohr et al., 2019). But in industrial farms – where animals are densely packed together and host-to-host transmission is easy – the evolutionary pressure on the pathogen to moderate its virulence is relieved (Lenski and May, 1994). And because those animals tend to be genetically close to each other, a pathogen introduced into that population can race through it without any genetic “firebreak” to slow its progress.
The COVID-19 pandemic has become one of the most pressing challenges for humanity. The pandemic is affecting all aspects of human lives and livelihoods, including food. In this context, new research shows the nexus between agri-food systems and the spread of emergent infectious diseases (EID) such as the coronavirus disease while at the same time, shows how the COVID-19 pandemics has heavily impacted food systems.
The aim of this work is to shed light and draw, through the case of COVID-19, the network of direct and indirect links and feedback loops between the globalised food system and pandemics.
We conducted a literature review.
As with climate change, food systems have a double relation with EID in general, and in particular with the present world health crisis linked to COVID-19. On the one hand, global agri-food systems, as currently organised, are a necessary step in the development of EID, through their impacts in land use changes, habitat fragmentation, biodiversity loss and climate change. On the other hand, COVID-19 has had and is having impacts on all food systems at all scales. The review shows that all activities of the food system (from production to consumption) as well as all pillars of food security (availability, access, use, stability) have been affected. The impacts of COVID-19 pandemic on food systems can be divided between direct impacts of the virus outbreak, and indirect impacts derived from the containment measures (e.g. lockdowns, mobility restrictions, shops closure) adopted at different levels (from local to global). While all food systems across the globe have been affected by the pandemic, it is argued that vulnerability is different for different types of food systems. Long food supply chains have been particularly affected by COVID-19 crisis, however, it is important to avoid universalization of impacts and responses as agri-food systems are characterised by a huge diversity and heterogeneity. The review concludes by pointing out that while the pandemic represents a challenge for the global food systems, this ‘stress test’ can be also seized as an opportunity to highlight vulnerabilities to be urgently addressed during the recovery period and speed up the transformation towards more sustainable and resilient food systems.
A food systems approach is essential to have a broader picture of the relationship of agri-food systems with zoonosis and their centrality in the pandemics and the derived socio-economic consequences.
Resource asynchrony and landscape homogenization as drivers of virulence evolution: The case of a directly transmitted disease in a social host
2024, Ecology and Evolution
Phenotypic and genomic changes during Turnip mosaic virus adaptation to Arabidopsis thaliana mutants lacking epigenetic regulatory factors
2024, Evolution

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Regular ArticleThe Evolution of Virulence in Parasites and Pathogens: Reconciliation Between Two Competing Hypotheses

Abstract

Regular Article
The Evolution of Virulence in Parasites and Pathogens: Reconciliation Between Two Competing Hypotheses