Associations among the Degree of Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease, Metabolic Syndrome, Degree of Obesity in Children, and Parental Obesity

Obesity is newly emerged as a very important health problem in children. The prevalence of obesity was 12.8% in school aged children (including elementary, middle and high school) of Korea in 2014 [1]. Obesity can be defined as body mass index (BMI, kg/m²) more than 95 percentile per sex and age or weight for height exceeding more than 120% of the standard weight for height per sex in children [2].

Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is one of the major complications in obese children and obese adults [3]. NAFLD can progress into liver cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma [4, 5]. NAFLD may be closely associated with metabolic syndrome [6]. However, few report has studied the severity of NAFLD associated with metabolic syndrome [6] and the degree of obesity. Furthermore, there is no report about the association between metabolic syndrome and the severity of NAFLD based on ultrasonography. Although BMI is the gold standard for diagnosing obesity, it cannot figure out the degree of obesity in children [2]. The degree of obesity in this study was based on the percentage over standard weight for height per sex. It was classified into mild, moderate, or severe.

Parental obesity can be closely associated with obesity in children [7]. However, at what degree that parental obesity can affect the degree of obesity in children remains unclear. Therefore, the objective of this study was to analyze the associations among the degree of NAFLD by ultrasonography, metabolic syndrome, degree of obesity in children, and parental obesity (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1
Diagram of study design. The objective of this study was to analyze the associations among the degrees of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) by ultrasonography and metabolic syndrome, degrees of obesity in children, and degrees of parental obesity. ^*The weight for height per sex at more than 120%. ^†Likelihood-ratio χ² test.

• Click for larger image

The study prospectively enrolled 198 obese children who visited the pediatric obesity clinic of Jeju National University Hospital from March 2010 to February 2015 with BMI over 95 percentile per sex and age or weight for height more than 120%. Clinical information, results of laboratory tests, and liver ultrasonography were collected. The questionnaire for the beginning age of obesity in children was obtained from their parents. However, the beginning age of the obesity was only based on the recall of parents because anthropometric parameters could not be collected at that period.

Major clinical information included anthropometric data, the degree of obesity, BMI, blood pressure, and parental obesity. Parental obesity was defined when BMI was more than 25 kg/m². The degree of obesity was defined as the percentage over standard weight for height per sex using the following formula: [(measured weight–standard weight for height per sex)/standard weight for height per sex]×100. The standard weight for height per sex was defined as the weight of 50th percentile according to the patient's actual height per sex based on the weight for height graph per sex provided in the Korean Child Growth Chart 2007. Degree of obesity was further graded into mild obesity (20-30%), moderate obesity (30-50%), and severe obesity (more than 50%).

Laboratory tests included lipid battery, liver functions tests, and serum levels of glucose, HbA1c, and insulin. Blood samples were collected from patients who had fasted for at least 8 hours. To evaluate insulin resistance, homeostatic model assessment-insulin resistance (HOMA-IR) was calculated using the following formula: fasting serum insulin (µU/mL)×fasting plasma glucose (mmoL/L)/22.5. In patients who had elevated aspartate aminotransferase (AST) and alanine aminotransferase (ALT) levels, differential diagnostic work-up was done by checking viral markers of hepatotropic virus and other viruses, serum ceruloplasmin level, muscle enzyme, et cetera.

The severity of NAFLD was classified into no NAFLD, mild, moderate, or severe NAFLD based on liver ultrasonography [8]. One radiologist performed ultrasonography for all patients. Liver biopsy was not performed in all patients. Mild NAFLD was defined as slightly increased liver echogenicity compared to kidney/spleen with prominent portal wall and diaphragm. Moderate NAFLD was defined as medium increase of liver echogenicity compared to kidney/spleen with dimness of portal wall and diaphragm. Severe NAFLD was defined as high increase of liver echogenicity compared to kidney/spleen without showing portal wall and diaphragm due to elevation of echo attenuation.

Metabolic syndrome was diagnosed for patients who had at least 3 factors among the following 6 metabolic risk factors suggested by Lambert et al. [9]: 1) obesity (more than 95th percentile of BMI per sex and age); 2) blood pressure more than 90th percentile per sex and age; 3) fasting serum triglyceride more than 110 mg/dL; 4) fasting high density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol less than 40 mg/dL; 5) fasting plasma glucose more than 110 mg/dL; 6) fasting serum insulin more than 20 µU/mL.

The study was performed after obtaining the approval from Institutional Review Board (IRB no. JNUH 201410013001-HE005). Statistical analyses such as the frequency (%) of variables, mean and standard deviation (SD) for continuous variables, χ² test, and analysis of variance (ANOVA) test were performed using PASW Statistics ver. 18,0 (IBM Co., Armonk, NY, USA). Statistical significance was considered when p-value was less than 0.05.

The mean age of the 198 obese children was 9.6±3.1 years-old (mean±SD). According to the degree of obesity, of the 198 obese children, 14.6% were mild, 52.5% were moderate, and 32.8% were severe (Table 1). Their beginning age of the obesity was 8.0±3.2 years old in the mild group, 6.4±3.2 years old in the moderate group, and 5.5±2.9 years old in the severe group (p=0.006, Table 1).

Table 1
Demographic and Clinical Characteristics of 198 Obese Children according to the Degree of Obesity

• Click for larger image

According to the degree of NAFLD based on ultrasonography, 159 obese children showed several significant findings among the 4 degrees of NAFLD (Table 2). Their age was 8.2±2.5 years old in the no NAFLD group, 10.2±3.0 years in the mild NAFLD group, 11.3±2.2 years in the moderate NAFLD group, and 12.9±1.8 years in the severe NAFLD group (p=0.000). Their age at the beginning of the obesity was 5.4±2.7 years old in the no NAFLD group, 6.5±3.3 years old in the mild NAFLD group, 7.4±2.9 years in the moderate NAFLD group, and 8.1 ±3.5 years old in the severe NAFLD group (p=0.002). Their fasting serum insulin level was 11.50±5.88 µU/mL in the no NAFLD group, 18.04±13.09 µU/mL in the mild NAFLD group, 23.37±17.14 µU/mL in the moderate NAFLD group, and 25.30±14.57 µU/mL in the severe NAFLD group (p=0.000). HOMA-IR value was 2.65±1.45 in the no NAFLD group, 4.23±3.20 in the mild NAFLD group, 5.57±4.38 in the moderate NAFLD group, and 5.96±3.72 in the severe NAFLD group (p=0.000). Their fasting serum triglyceride level was 84.1±39.1 mg/dL in the no NAFLD group, 91.3±38.5 mg/dL in the mild NAFLD group, 117.3±60.6 mg/dL in the moderate NAFLD group, 129.6±32.6 mg/dL in the severe NAFLD group (p=0.000). Their ALT levels showed the trend of higher level according to the severity of NAFLD.

Table 2
Demographic and Clinical Characteristics of 159 Obese Children according to the Degree of Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease

• Click for larger image

The relationships between parental obesity and the degrees of obesity in children are shown in Fig. 2. Father's obesity was found in 9 of 23 (39.1%) children with mild degree of obesity, 46 of 81 (56.8%) children with moderate degree of obesity, and 33 of 49 (67.3%) children with severe degree of obesity (p=0.076). Mother's obesity was found in 3 of 24 (12.5%) children with mild degree of obesity, 25 of 86 (29.1%) children with moderate degree of obesity, and 27 of 49 (55.1%) children with severe degree of obesity (p=0.000). Both parental obesity was found in 9.1% of children with mild degree of obesity, 18.2% of children with moderate degree of obesity, and 40.0% of children with severe degree of obesity (p=0.004).

Fig. 2
The relationship between the degree of obesity in children and parental obesity. Father's obesity percentage according to the degree of obesity in children (A) tended to be higher in the group with more severe degree of obesity. However, it was not significant (p=0.076, likelihood-ratio χ² test). Mother's obesity percentage according to the degree of obesity in children (B) was higher in the group with more severe degree of obesity (p=0.000, likelihood-ratio χ² test). Both parental obesity percentages (C) were higher in the group with more severe degree of obesity (p=0.004, likelihood-ratio χ² test).

• Click for larger image

Regarding the relationship between metabolic syndrome and the degree of obesity or the degree of NAFLD, the comorbidity of metabolic syndrome according to the degree of obesity was not significant (p=0.288, Fig. 3A). The comorbidity of metabolic syndrome according to the degree of NAFLD degree was found in 14 of 68 (20.6%) children with no NAFLD, 12 of 29 (41.4%) children with mild NAFLD, 13 of 23 (56.5%) children with moderate NAFLD, and 6 of 12 (50.0%) children with severe NAFLD (p=0.005, Fig. 3B).

Fig. 3
The percentage of metabolic syndrome combined to the degree of obesity or the degree of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD). The percentage of metabolic syndrome combined to the degree of obesity (A) was not increased according to the increase in the degree of obesity (p=0.288, likelihood-ratio χ² test). The percentage of metabolic syndrome combined to the degree of NAFLD (B) was higher in the group with more severe degree of NAFLD (p=0.005, likelihood-ratio χ² test), even though the percentage between moderate and severe NAFLD was reversed.

• Click for larger image

The comorbidity of NAFLD degree according to the degree of obesity was not significant (p=0.573, Fig. 4). The NAFLD degree did not have significant correlation with the degree of obesity either.

Fig. 4
Relationship between the degree of obesity and the degree of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD). There was no significant change in the degree of NAFLD according to the degree of obesity (p=0.573, likelihood-ratio χ² test).

• Click for larger image

Although the definition of obesity has preferred BMI to the weight for height, BMI is not enough to give an easy explanation for the degree of obesity to obese children and their parents. Yoo et al. [10] have reported that percentage-weight-for-height (PWH) can reflect adiposity with higher sensitivity and specificity than the BMI. Although BMI can define body shape ranging from 'very skinny' to 'obese' [11], it has limitation in grading the degree of obesity. According to our study, the BMI of most children with obesity was more than 97 percentile per sex or age (Table 1). The grading of obesity by BMI was thought to be very difficult. Because obesity's definition by BMI should be based on its percentile instead of an absolute value, standardization of obesity degree in children is very difficult. PWH uses the standard weight for height in a child. Therefore, PWH can be used to standardize obesity degrees with absolute values. In this study, we graded the degree of obesity into mild (20% to 30%), moderate (30% to 50%), and severe (over 50%) based on the percentage over standard weight for height per sex. The grading for degree of obesity in this study was not correlated with clinical or laboratory parameters except for age at the beginning of the obesity (Table 1) and parental obesity (Fig. 2). Therefore, we could conclude that higher grading degree of obesity based on the percentage over standard weight for height does not reflect disease severity of child obesity.

This study revealed that the degree of NAFLD based on ultrasonography was significantly correlated with several clinical and laboratory parameters (Table 2). Among several imaging tests used to estimate the degree of NAFLD, ultrasonography is an inexpensive, noninvasive, and comfortable test to patient [12, 13]. It has been reported that ultrasonography has a sensitivity of 60% to 96% and a specificity of 84% to 100% for the detection of NAFLD when compared to liver biopsy in adults [14, 15]. Its test results could be dependent on the operator. Computed tomography has moderate sensitivity (82%) but high specificity (100%). However, it has radiation hazard [16]. Magnetic resonance image has a high sensitivity (100%) and moderate specificity (90.4%) [17, 18]. However, it is expensive and possibly uncomfortable to patient. In this study, only one expert radiologist performed ultrasonography for all patients.

When the age at the beginning of the obesity was older, the NAFLD degree was higher (p=0.000, Table 2). The severity of NAFLD was highly and significantly correlated with the level of serum insulin, HOMA-IR value, and the level of serum triglyceride (p=0.000). Although the p-value was significant (p=0.000), the severity of NAFLD was only moderately correlated with the levels of HDL-cholesterol, AST, and ALT due to reversed levels between moderate and severe NAFLD. Hyperinsulinemia has a major role in the formation of fatty liver [19]. Increase of insulin in the blood might be able to predict the degree of fatty liver, hepatic inflammation, and fibrosis [20]. Sundaram et al. [21] have reported that NAFLD in youth appears to be tightly correlated with components of the metabolic syndrome, especially visceral fat. Sundaram et al. [21] have insisted that visceral fat can predict fibrosis and liver fat. Park et al. [22] have shown that the risk of abdominal obesity in adults is proportionally increased to the degree of NAFLD. Therefore, central obesity is an important risk factor of NAFLD.

The degree of obesity in children was highly correlated with parental obesity, especially mother's obesity (p=0.000, Fig. 2B). When the grade of mother's obesity was greater, the degree of child obesity was higher, suggesting that mother's obesity can significantly affect the progress and the degree of child obesity. Therefore, to prevent or treat child obesity, we should also focus on mother's obesity. Whitaker et al. [7] have reported that parental obesity may more than double the risk of adult obesity among both obese and non-obese children. Many parents of obese children also might overlook their children's obesity [23]. Parents are the exclusive agent of change in the treatment of childhood obesity [24]. The degree of obesity based on PWH was not correlated with metabolic syndrome (Fig. 3A). Therefore, higher degree of obesity based on PWH does not mean higher rate of metabolic syndrome. However, Chang et al. [25] have reported that there is a trend of higher degree of obesity according to higher rate of metabolic syndrome. The degree of NAFLD was moderately correlated with metabolic syndrome, even though the reversed percentage value of metabolic syndrome was correlated with moderate and severe NAFLD (p=0.005, Fig. 3B). However, the degree of NAFLD was not correlated with the degree of obesity in children (Fig. 4). Patton et al. [6] have reported an association between metabolic syndrome and liver histology among children with NAFLD. They showed that the severity of NAFLD on liver histology was greater among children with metabolic syndrome vs. those without [6].

The limitation of the current study is the absence of normal weight group as control. Therefore, we could not compare each subgroup of obese children to normal weight children for the evaluation of associations among NAFLD degree, the degree of obesity, metabolic syndrome, and parental obesity. The second limitation of this study was that age at the beginning of the obesity was only based on recall of the parents instead of on anthropometric parameters at that period.

In conclusion, prevention and treatment for child obesity should also focus on parental obesity, especially mother's obesity. Severity grading of NAFLD by ultrasonography may be a good alternative method for liver biopsy. Additional and specialized management for metabolic syndrome may be necessary to prevent the progress of NAFLD.