Nir Becker, Doron Lavee, David Katz
.
DOI: 10.4236/jwarp.2010.212124   PDF    HTML     8,222 Downloads   17,500 Views   Citations

Abstract

Costs for seawater desalination have dropped significantly over the past decade due to technological advances. This has increased the attractiveness of desalination to policy-makers as a means to address water supply shortages. Israel, a country that faces chronic water scarcity, is in the process of developing wide-scale desalination capacity that is projected to supply all of the nation's domestic water use within a few years. Two issues are often neglected, however, by policy-makers pursuing desalination. The first is that seawater desalination is associated with a number of external costs, consideration of which may influence the optimal scale and timing of desalination implementation. The second is that alternative measures for managing water scarcity, including conservation techniques, are often more cost-efficient. This study estimates the full cost of desalination in Israel, including externalities, and then compares this to the costs of several alternative options for addressing water scarcity, including both demand management and supply augmentation measures. We find that desalination, despite being the primary policy option pursued by Israel, is among the least cost-efficient of all the alternatives considered, even without taking into account the externalities involved.

Keywords

Cost-effectiveness Analysis, Desalination, Israel, Water Policy

Share and Cite:

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

[1]	H. Gvirtzman, “Water Resources in Israel,” Yad Ben Tzvi Publishing, Hebrew, 2002.
[2]	A. Hurlimann, S. Dolnicar and P. Meye, “Understanding Behavior to Inform Water Supply Management in Developed Nations - A Review of Literature, Conceptual Model and Research Agenda,” Journal of Environmental Management, Vol. 91, No. 1, October 2009, pp. 47-56.
[3]	N. Becker, “The Stragedy of Water,” Water Engi-neering, Vol. 76, 2001, pp. 15-19.
[4]	Y. Dreizin, “Ashkelon Seawater Desalination Project- Off-Taker’s Self Costs, Supplied Water Costs, Total Costs and Benefits,” Desalination, Vol. 190, No.1-3, 2006, pp. 104-120.
[5]	Y. Dreizin, A. Tenne and D. Hoffman, “Integrating Large Scale Seawater Desalination Plants within Israel’s Water Supply System” Desalination, Vol. 220, No.1-3, pp. 132- 149.
[6]	R. Sanders, “Water Desalting and the Middle East Peace Process,” Technology in Society, Vol. 31, No. 1, February 2009, pp. 94-99.
[7]	A. Tal, “Seeking Sustainability: Israel’s Evolving Water Management Strategy,” Science, Vol. 313, No. 5790, August 2006, pp. 1081-1084.
[8]	S. Dolnicar and A. I. Schafer, “Desalinated versus Recycled Water: Public Perceptions and Profiles of the Accepters,” Journal of Environmental Management, Vol. 90, No. 2, February 2009, pp. 888-900.
[9]	M. El-Fadel and I. Alameddine, “Desalination in Arid Regions: Merits and Concerns,” Journal of Water Supply Research and Technology-Aqua, Vol. 54, No. 7, November 2005, pp. 449-461.
[10]	E. Yuhas and T. Daniels, “The US Freshwater Supply Shortage: Experiences with Desalination as Part of the Solution” Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, Vol. 49, No. 4, July 2009, pp. 571-585.
[11]	I. C. Karagiannis and P. G. Soldatos, “Water Desalination Cost Literature: Review and Assessment,” Desalination, Vol. 223, No.1-3, 2008, pp. 448-456.
[12]	K. Reddy and N. Ghaffour, “Overview of the Cost of Desalinated Water and Costing Methodologies,” Desali-nation, Vol. 207, No. 1-3, 2005, pp. 340-353.
[13]	K. V. Reddy, “Review and Evaluation of Desalination Cost and Costing Methodologies,” International Journal of Nuclear Desalination, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2008, pp. 79-94.
[14]	Y. Zhou and R. S. J. Tol “Evaluating the Costs of Desalination and Water Transport,” Water Resources Research, Vol. 41, No. 1-10, W03003, 2005, pp. 269-287.
[15]	P. Glueckstern and M. Priel, “Advanced Concept of Large Seawater Desalination Systems for Israel,” Desalination, Vol. 119, No.1-3, 1998, pp.33-45.
[16]	G. W. Characklis, R. C. Griffin and P. B. Bedient, “Measuring the Long-Term Regional Benefits of Salinity Reduction,” Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, Vol. 30, No. 1, 2005, pp. 69-93.
[17]	A. M. Altayaran and I. M. Madany, “Impact of a Desalination Plant on the Physical and Chemical-Properties of the Seawater, Bahrain,” Water Research, Vol. 26, No. 4, April 1992, pp. 435-441.
[18]	P. K. Azis, A. I. Al-Tisan, M. Al-Daili, T. N. Green, A. G. I. Dalvi and M. A. Javeed, “Effects of Environment on Source Water for Desalination Plants on the Eastern Coast of Saudi Arabia,” Desalination, Vol. 132, No. 1-3, 2000, pp. 29-40.
[19]	R. Einav, K. Harussi and D. Perry, “The Footprints of Desalination Processes on the Environment,” Irrigation and Water Engineering, Vol. 17, 2002, pp. 19-28.
[20]	N. Becker and D. Lavee, “The Effect and Reform of Water Pricing: The Israeli Experience,” International Journal of Water Resource Development, Vol. 18, No. 2, June 2002, pp. 353-366.
[21]	I. Fischhendler, “Institutional Conditions for IWRM: The Israeli Case,” Ground Water, Vol. 46, No. 1, Jan-uary-February 2008, pp. 91-102.
[22]	Y. Margoninsky, “Ma-croeconomic and Institutional Sou- rces of Environmental Changes - The Case of Israel’s Water Sector,” Water Policy, Vol. 11, No. 3, 2009, pp. 307-319.
[23]	A. Kartin, “Factors Inhibiting Structural Changes in Israel’s Water Policy,” Political Geography, Vol. 19, No. 1, January 2000, pp. 97-115.
[24]	P. Alpert, S. O. Krichak, H. Shafir, D. Haim and I. Osetinsky, “Climatic Trends to Extremes Employing Regional Modeling and Statistical Interpretation over the E. Mediterranean,” Global and Planetary Change, Vol. 63, No. 2-3, September 2008, pp. 163-170.
[25]	R. Hovel, “The Tax did What He was Supposed to do: Water Consumption Decreased by 20% in 2009,” Calcal-ist, Vol. 19, January, 2010.
[26]	Z. Lavi, “In the Knesset, Support for Continuing the Freeze on Drought Tax”, Ynet News Service, Vol. 8, March 2010. (In Hebrew) http://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-3859529,00.html
[27]	State Comptroller Report, “The National Committee of Inquiry Regarding the Management of the Water Economy in Israel”, 2009.
[28]	T. Schorr, Speech Given at Conference on “Reuse of Grey Water: From Theory to Practice,” Ramat Gan, Israel, April 2010.
[29]	T. Rinat, “Minister Erdan Criticizes Water Authority Campaign: Calling for Conservation for Three Years Only”, Haaretz, 22 July 2010. (In Hebrew)
[30]	J. Rothfeder, “Every Drop for Sale,” Tarcher/Penguin, 2004.
[31]	T. Daniels and K. Daniels, “The Environmental Planning Handbook for Sustainable Communities and Regions,” APA/Planners Press, 2003.
[32]	C. Sabol, Testimony to the House Subcommittee on Water and Power, 24 May 2005. http://resourcescommittee.house.gov/archives/109/testimony/2005/colinsabol.pdf (accessed 21 October 2008).
[33]	W. Alley, “Desalination of Ground Water: Earth Science Perspectives,” USGS Fact Sheet 075-03. http://pubs.usgs.gov.
[34]	T. Levin, “Turning Oceans into Tap Water,” On Earth, Vol. 26, Summer 2004, pp. 28-33.
[35]	G. Pitzer, “Tapping the World's Largest Reservoir: Desalination,” Western Water, January-February 2003, pp. 4-13.
[36]	National Research Council, “Desalination: A National Perspective,” Committee on Advancing Desalination Technology, National Research Council, 2008.
[37]	N. H. Afgan, M. Darwish and M. G. Carvalho, “Sustainability As-sessement of Desalination Plants for Water Production,” Desa-lination, Vol. 124, No. 1-3, 1999, pp. 19-31.
[38]	S. R. Downward and R. Taylor, “An Assessment of Spain's Programa AGUA and Its Implications for Sustainable Water Management in the Province of Almeria, Southeast Spain,” Journal of Environmental Management, Vol. 82, No. 2, January 2007, pp. 277-289.
[39]	Y. Tsur and A. Zemel, “R&D Policies for Desalination Technologies,” Agricultural Economics, Vol. 24, No. 1, December 2000, pp. 73-85.
[40]	M. Sadiq, “Metal Contamination in Sediments from a Desalination Plant Effluent Outfall Area,” Science of the Total Environment, Vol. 287, No. 1-2, March 2002, pp. 37-44.
[41]	E. P. Glenn, “Cienega de Santa Clara: Endangered Wetland in the Colorado River Delta, Sonora, Mexico,” Natural Resources Journal, Vol. 32, 1992, pp. 817-824.
[42]	J. R. Stokes and A. Horvath, “Energy and Air Emission Effects of Water Supply,” Environmental Science & Technology, Vol. 43, No. 8, April 2009, pp. 2680-2687.
[43]	S. Nisan and N. Benzarti, “A Comprehen-sive Economic Evaluation of Integrated Desalination Systems Using Fossil Fuelled and Nuclear Energies and Including Their Environmental Costs,” Desalination, Vol. 229, No. 1, Septem-ber 2008, pp. 125-146.
[44]	I. C. Karagiann and P. G. Soldatos, “Estimation of Critical CO2 Values When Planning the Power Source in Water Desalination: The Case of the Small Aegean Islands,” Energy Policy, Vol. 38, No. 8 August 2010, pp. 3891- 3897.
[45]	R. Samit, “The Future of Desalination in Israel,” Irrigation and Water Engineering, Vol. 12, 2001, pp. 45-49.
[46]	Ministry of Environment (Israel), External Costs Of Air Pollution from Energy Production–Final Report, September 2008. (In Hebrew)
[47]	European Commission, Valuing External Costs from Energy Production and Transportation. http://www.ext erne.info
[48]	Israeli Electric Company (IEC), http://www.iec.co.il/
[49]	Kivun LTD, “Guidelines for Shore Taxes Due to Externalities,” Report submitted to the Ministry of Environment, Jerusalem, Israel. 2006. (In Hebrew)
[50]	H. Winters, I. R. Isquith and R. Bakish. “Influence of Desalination Effluents on Marine Ecosystems”, Desalination, Vol. 30, 1979, pp. 403-410.
[51]	R. Einav, K. Harussi, and D. Perry. “The Footprint of the Desalination Processes on the Environment,” Desalination Vol. 152, No. 1, 2003, pp. 141-154.
[52]	S. Lattemann, and T. H?pner, “Environmental Impact and Impact Assessment of Seawater Desalination,” Desalination, Vol. 220, No. 1, 2008, pp. 1-15.
[53]	UNEP, Desalination Resource and Guidance Manual for Environmental Impact Assessments, United Nations Environment Programme, Regional Office for West Asia, Manama, and World Health Organization, Regional Office for the Eastern Mediterranean, Cairo, 2008.
[54]	D. Roberts, A. David, L. Emma, L. Johnston and N. A. Knott, “Impacts of Desalination Plant Discharges on the Marine Environment: A Critical Review of Published studies,” Water Research, Vol. 44, No. 18, 2010, pp. 5117-5128.
[55]	I. Safrai and A. Zask. “Reverse Osmosis Desalination Plants-Marine Environmentalist Regulator Point of View”. Desalination, Vol. 220, No. 1, 2008, pp. 72-84.
[56]	D. Lavee, “Cost-Benefit Analysis of Alternative Wastewater Treatment Standards: A Case Study in Israel,” Water and Environment Journal. (Forthcoming).
[57]	Friends of the Earth-Middle East (FoEME), “An Economic Analysis of Policy Options for Water Conservation in Israel,” July 2010. http://www.foeme.org/
[58]	P. Dar, “The Efficiency of Reduced Water Consumption in the Household Sector,” The Center for Environmental Policy at the Jerusalem Institute, Discussion paper 30, 2002. (In Hebrew)
[59]	Y. Darel, “With Wa-ter-Savers We could have Saved Half of the Sea of Galilee”, Ynet News Service, 9 May, 2010. http://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-3886750,00.html.
[60]	Z. Bar-Shira, I. Finkelshtain and A. Simhon, “Block- Rate versus Uniform Water Pricing in Agriculture: An Empirical Analysis,” American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 88, No. 4, 2006, pp. 986-999.
[61]	A. Fleischer and Y. Tsur, “Measuring the Recreational Value of Agricultural Landscape,” European Review of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 27, No. 3, 2000, pp. 385- 398.
[62]	A. Fleischer and Y. Tsur, “Measuring the Economic Value of Open Space,” Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 54, No. 2, 2003, pp. 269-283.
[63]	A. Fleischer and Y. Tsur, “The Amenity Value of Agricultural Landscape and Rural–Urban Land Allocation,” Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 60, No. 1, 2009, pp. 132-153.
[64]	I. Kan, D. Haim, M. Rapaport-Rom and M. Shechter, “Environmental Amenities and Optimal Agricultural Land Use: The Case of Israel,” Ecological Economics, Vol. 68, No. 6, 2009, pp. 1893-1898.
[65]	O. Ayalon, H. Tzaban, Y. Avnimelech, L. Amdor, and N. Feler, “Sustainable Agriculture: How to Internalize Externalities in the Farming Sector?” Shmuel Neeman Institute at the Technion University, Haifa, Israel, 2004. (In Hebrew).
[66]	Ministry of Environmental Protection (Israel), “Tackling Israel’s Water Crisis,” Israel Environment Bulletin, Vol. 35 (September), 2009, pp. 12-17.
[67]	Pareto Engineering, “A Cost Benefit Analysis of Grey Water Reuse Projects in Israel,” 24 May 2007. http://www.sviva.gov.il/Enviroment/Static/Binaries/index_pirsumim/p0495_1.pdf
[68]	I. Kan, M. Rapaport-Rom and M. Shechter, “Assessing Climate Change Impacts on Water, Land-Use and Economic Return in Agriculture.” http://ssrn.com/abstract=- 1020562