• Chinese Optics Letters
  • Vol. 19, Issue 2, 021901 (2021)
Hui Kong1、2, Jintian Bian1、2、*, Jiyong Yao3, Qing Ye1、2, and Xiaoquan Sun1、2、**
Author Affiliations
  • 1State Key Laboratory of Pulsed Power Laser Technology, National University of Defense Technology, Hefei 230037, China
  • 2Advanced Laser Technology Laboratory of Anhui Province, Hefei 230037, China
  • 3Technical Institute of Physics and Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/COL202119.021901 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Hui Kong, Jintian Bian, Jiyong Yao, Qing Ye, Xiaoquan Sun. Temperature tuning of BaGa4Se7 optical parametric oscillator[J]. Chinese Optics Letters, 2021, 19(2): 021901 Copy Citation Text show less

    Abstract

    The temperature tuning of BaGa4Se7 (BGSe) was demonstrated for the first time, to the best of our knowledge. When the temperature of BGSe (56.3°,0°) was raised from 30°C to 140°C, the idler light under type I raised from 3637 nm to 3989 nm, the tunable range reached 352 nm, and Δλ2/ΔT reached 3.20 nm/°C. We calculated the phase matching curve of BGSe when ? and T took different values. The relationship between θ and Δλ2/ΔT was obtained by fixing ? at 0°. The maximum Δλ2/ΔT and its corresponding (θ, ?) phase matching type were reported under different fixed λ2 (3 μm, 3.2 μm,, 5 μm).

    1. Introduction

    The mid-infrared (IR) coherent sources in the 3–5 µm range have always been intensively desired for a wide range of scientific and technological applications in remote sensing, spectrum analysis, materials diagnostics, aerospace fields, etc.[1]. Optical parametric oscillation is an attractive approach, especially when high energy and average power are demanded simultaneously[2,3]. BaGa4Se7 (BGSe) showed excellent optical quality and performance in a 1.064 µm pumped nanosecond optical parametric oscillator (OPO). Its second harmonic generation (SHG) effect is about 2–3 times that of the benchmark material AgGaS2, and the surface laser damage threshold is about 3.7 times that of AgGaS2. The transparent range of this crystal covers 0.47 to 18 µm, which makes it possible to obtain mid-IR coherent light through parametric down-conversion from 1 µm (Nd and Yb) lasers[4].

    In 2010, the BGSe crystal was synthesized for the first time[4], to the best of our knowledge, and the thermal conductivity coefficients and laser damage threshold were measured in 2012[5]. In 2013, Yang et al. demonstrated a mid-IR optical parametric amplifier with BGSe pumped by a 1064 nm Nd:Y3Al5O12 (Nd:YAG) laser. A maximum idler output of 830 μJ at 3.9 µm was obtained at pump energy of ∼9.1 mJ, and 3–5 µm idler tuning range was demonstrated for the first time, to the best of our knowledge, through angle tuning[6]. In 2016, Kostyukova et al. achieved the unprecedented tuning capability from 2.7 to 17 µm with a single crystal cut by angle tuning[7]. But up to now, we have not seen the report of temperature tuning of a BGSe OPO.

    Angle tuning has many advantages, such as wide tuning range and continuously tunable wavelength. However, it is necessary to use a precise rotating table to control the crystal rotation angle, and the pump efficiency decreases as the tunable angles increase due to the crystal’s reflection. Temperature tuning uses a temperature control furnace to change the wavelength of idler light by adjusting the temperature of the crystal. Generally, the tuning range of temperature tuning is smaller than that of angle tuning. But, the mechanical structure is stable, and the idler energy is stable for its vertical incidence, so it can be used on many occasions such as vehicle, ship, and airborne applications. In 2017, Zhai et al. measured the principal axis refractive index nx, ny, nz of BGSe crystal at different temperatures (25°C–150°C) and gave the relationship between the principal thermal refractive index and temperature dnx/dT, dny/dT, dnz/dT in the wavelength range of 0.254µmλ2.325µm[8]. In 2018, Kato et al. measured the fundamental wavelength of the crystal to achieve the maximum SHG efficiency at different temperatures and gave the dnx/dT, dny/dT, dnz/dT of the crystal in a larger wavelength range (0.901µmλ10.5910µm)[9]. These works provided important theoretical guidance for the temperature tuning of BGSe OPOs. Therefore, based on the Sellmeier equation in Ref. [9], we first calculated the phase matching curves of BGSe under type I and type II at different temperatures. Then, we obtained the relationship between θ and Δλ2/ΔT with fixed =0°. Next, the maximum Δλ2/ΔT and its corresponding (θ,) phase matching type were reported with fixed λ2=3µm,3.2µm,3.4µm,,5µm. In addition, temperature tuning of BGSe (56.3°,0°) was demonstrated. The wavelength tuning of 3637–3989 nm was realized with the temperature tunable from 30°C to 140°C, corresponding to Δλ2/ΔT=3.2nm/°C. In 2020, six periodically poled lithium niobate (PPLN) crystals were used by Niu et al. to achieve a wide range tuning of 2.2–4.8 µm from 25°C to 200°C[10], where the tunable range was approximately 3000–3375 nm when the grating period was 30 µm, corresponding to Δλ2/ΔT2.14nm/°C under λ2 of 3000 nm. The results show that the Δλ2/ΔT of the BGSe crystal is larger than that of the PPLN crystal. In addition, the BGSe crystal also has wide transmission range and angle tuning ability. The combination of temperature tuning and angle tuning has great development potential.

    2. Methods

    2.1 Phase matching curve at room temperature

    Up to now, four articles[1114] have given the Sellmeier equation of BGSe at room temperature. We select the equation in Ref. [14] to calculate the phase matching curve of BGSe at room temperature, with wavelength 0.901 µm ≤ λ ≤ 10.5910 µm, as shown in Eq. (1):{nx2=6.72431+0.26375λ20.04248+602.97λ2749.87ny2=6.86603+0.26816λ20.04259+682.97λ2781.78nz2=7.16709+0.32681λ20.06973+731.86λ2790.16.

    The light incident into the BGSe crystal can be represented by (θ,), where θ is the angle between the light and the Z axis of the crystal, and is the angle between the kOZ plane and X axis of the crystal. Each light has two refractive indices. The larger one is called slow light ne1(θ,), and the smaller one is called fast light ne2(θ,). The ne1(θ,), ne2(θ,) can be derived from ni2(i=x,y,z)[15].

    The pump light λ3, signal light λ1, and idler light λ2 should be in accord with Eqs. (2) and (3):1λ3=1λ1+1λ2,ne2λ3λ3=ne1λ1λ1+ne1λ2λ2(I),orne2λ3λ3=ne2λ1λ1+ne1λ2λ2(IIA),orne2λ3λ3=ne1λ1λ1+ne2λ2λ2(IIB),where ne2λ3 is the refractive index of fast light at λ3; ne1λiandne2λi are the refractive indices of slow light and fast light at λi (i=1,2). The phase matching curves of BGSe at room temperature can be calculated from Eqs. (1)–(3).

    The λ3 was set to 1064 nm, and the sampling accuracy of λ2 was set to 1 nm. Since BGSe is a biaxial crystal, the refractive index is related to (θ,). We investigated the relationship between θ and λ2, λ1 when =0°,10°,20°,,90°. Because BGSe has no suitable matching angles under type II-A phase matching condition, we only give the phase matching curves of type I and type II-B, which are shown in Fig. 1.

    Phase matching curves of BGSe at room temperature under (a) type I and (b) type II-B conditions (λ3=1064 nm).

    Figure 1.Phase matching curves of BGSe at room temperature under (a) type I and (b) type II-B conditions (λ3=1064nm).

    As shown in Fig. 1, when rises from 0° to 90°, the curves of type I move from right to left, and the upper curves of type II-B move from right to left, too. The changes of the phase matching curve are tiny when is 0°–10° and 80°–90°.

    2.2 Phase matching curve at 20°C–140°C

    The refractive index of BGSe at 20°C–140°C can be revised from Eqs. (4) and (5) with wavelength 0.901 µm ≤ λ ≤ 10.5910 µm[9]:{dnxdT=(6.0868λ312.6368λ2+10.5624λ+1.9583)×105(°C1)dnydT=(6.3935λ313.1762λ2+10.8950λ+2.4079)×105(°C1)dnzdT=(6.3141λ313.0790λ2+10.8486λ+2.0758)×105(°C1),ni(T)=ni+dnidT(TT0),where ni(T) and ni(i=x,y,z) are the refractive indices at T and 20°C on the dielectric frame (x,y,z). The phase matching curve at 20°C–140°C can be derived from Eqs. (1)–(5).

    Due to the effective nonlinear coefficient being large when =0° under type I and =20° under type II-B[16], we only give the phase matching curve of BGSe crystal at T=20°C, 80°C, 140°C with =0° and =20°, which is shown in Fig. 2.

    Phase matching curve at 20°C, 80°C, and 140°C under (a) type I and (b) type II-B conditions (λ3=1064 nm, ∅=0°, 20°).

    Figure 2.Phase matching curve at 20°C, 80°C, and 140°C under (a) type I and (b) type II-B conditions (λ3=1064nm, =0°,20°).

    As shown in Fig. 2, when the temperature is raised from 20°C to 140°C, the curves of type I move from left to right, and the upper curves of type II-B move from left to right, too, so the wavelength of idler light increases as the temperature rises.

    2.3 Relationship between Δλ2/ΔT and θ when =0°

    The Δλ2/ΔT varied when (θ,) changed. The relationship between Δλ2/ΔT and θ when =0° is shown in Fig. 3, and the corresponding wavelength of idler light at T=20°C is obtained.

    Wavelength of idler light at T=20°C and Δλ2/ΔT at each θ when ∅=0° under (a) type I and (b) type II-B conditions.

    Figure 3.Wavelength of idler light at T=20°C and Δλ2/ΔT at each θ when =0° under (a) type I and (b) type II-B conditions.

    As shown in Fig. 3, the Δλ2/ΔT are not given when =0°, θ65° under type I because they don't meet the phase matching condition. The maximum value of Δλ2/ΔT is 6.175 nm/°C when θ=45° under the type I condition. Δλ2/ΔT and λ(20°C) decrease monotonically as θ increases. The maximum value of Δλ2/ΔT is 6.60 nm/°C when θ=45° under the type II-B condition. Δλ2/ΔT and λ(20°C) decrease monotonically as θ increases, too. If the unit of λ changes from nanometers (nm) to cm1, Δλ2/ΔT is very close, which is from the minimum 0.76cm1/°C to the maximum 2.52cm1/°C. Δλ2/ΔT of type II-B is larger than that of type I when θ=45°, while Δλ2/ΔT of type I is larger than that of type II-B at other points.

    2.4 Peak of Δλ2/ΔT and corresponding (θ,), matching type when λ2 is fixed

    We also give Δλ2/ΔT at each (θ,) and matching type when the wavelength of the idler light is fixed. The maximum value of Δλ2/ΔT and the corresponding (θ,), matching type are listed in Table 1 when the wavelength of the idler light is from 3 µm to 5 µm at 20°C. In addition, the idler light of the corresponding (θ,) and matching type at 140°C is reported.

    λ2 (20°C) [μm]33.23.43.63.844.24.44.64.85
    Iθ [°]59.558.457.356.455.454.653.652.952.251.550.8
    [°]4.14.55.33.44.31.853.321.93
    λ2 (140°C) [μm]3.283.483.693.904.114.324.534.754.965.185.40
    Δλ2/ΔT [nm/°C]2.362.362.392.472.552.662.772.903.033.183.33
    II-Bθ [°]89.377.672.668.866.163.961.960.258.757.456.2
    [°]8.53.41.95.94.41.32.62.42.511.4
    λ2 (140°C) [μm]3.123.333.553.763.974.194.404.624.845.055.27
    Δλ2/ΔT [nm/°C]0.991.101.211.331.441.571.701.831.972.122.27

    Table 1. Peak of Δλ2/ΔT and Corresponding (θ,), Matching Type When λ2 Is Fixed

    As shown in Table 1, Δλ2/ΔT increases monotonically with the increase of λ2(20°C). The Δλ2/ΔT of type I is larger than that of type II-B at 3–5 µm, and the corresponding to the maximum Δλ2/ΔT is near 0°. For example, when λ2(20°C) is 3.6 µm, the Δλ2/ΔT and corresponding (θ,), matching type are shown in Table 2 when are close to 0°.

    θ [°]56.356.456.5
    [°]5.23.40
    λ2 (140°C) [nm]389538963892
    Δλ2/ΔT [nm/°C]2.4582.4672.433

    Table 2. Δλ2/ΔT When Is Close to 0° and λ2 at 140°C

    As shown in Table 2, Δλ2/ΔT of =0° is slightly lower compared to the maximum when =3.4°. For the convenience of crystal cutting, it is recommended to cut according to =0°. The following is the experimental verification of the peak wavelength of BGSe (56.3°, 0°) at different temperatures under the type I phase matching condition.

    3. Experimental Setup

    The experimental setup is shown in Fig. 4. The BGSe OPO is pumped by an SL800 Series pulsed Nd:YAG along with 13 ns pulse width (FWHM), 8 mm beam diameter, and 1 Hz pulse repetition frequency. A pinhole is placed behind the Nd:YAG for adjusting the light path, and the beam diameter is compressed to 4 mm through a telescope system to improve the energy density of the pump light.

    Schematic diagram of the experimental setup.

    Figure 4.Schematic diagram of the experimental setup.

    Due to M2 being highly reflective of the pump light, in order to prevent feedback to the Nd:YAG laser, a polarizer and a Faraday rotator were placed after the telescope system to form an optical isolator. Since the polarization direction of the laser output was horizontal, the polarization direction of the polarizer was also adjusted to the horizontal direction. The polarization direction of the pump light rotated 45° to the right after passing the isolator. The BGSe crystal was a 6mm×8mm×15mm cuboid with a cutting angle of (56.3°, 0°). Phase matching is satisfied when the pump light is e2. The polarization direction of e2 is perpendicular to the XOZ plane, that is, parallel to the long side of the crystal at 8 mm. In order to make the BGSe crystal horizontally placed on the temperature control furnace and improve the stability of the equipment, it is necessary to use a 45° phase delay plate to rotate the polarization direction 45° to the left again to make the polarization direction return to the horizontal direction.

    M1 is highly transmissive (HT) for the pump (P, T>95%) and highly reflective (HR) for the signal (S, 1.4–1.6 µm, R>99%). M2 is HR for the pump (P, R>99%) and the signal (S, 1.4–1.6 µm, R=90%) and HT for the idler (I, T>95%). The BGSe crystal was polished but not coated. A copper gripper holds the crystals in a temperature control furnace (HCP TC038-PC) that can tune the temperature up to 200°C, and tunable accuracy is 0.1°C.

    A filter and a Ge plate are placed behind M2. The transmittance of the filter is about 1% at 1064 nm and 95%–99% at 3–5 µm. The transmittance of Ge is zero at 1064 nm and about 80% at 3–5 µm.

    The idler light was detected by a grating spectrometer (Omni-300λ, Zolix). The peak wavelength of the blazed grating is 3000 nm, the grating line is 300 g/mm, and the minimum resolution is 1 nm. The computer controls the rotation of the grating to make its transmission wavelength tunable from 2000 nm to 6000 nm, and the adjustment accuracy is 1 nm. The DEC-M204-InSb detector and ZAMP amplifier from Zolix detected and amplified the idler light transmitted from the grating spectrometer. And the idler light energy from ZAMP amplifier was measured by a DSOX3054 oscilloscope. When the maximum energy emerges in the oscilloscope, the wavelength set by the grating spectrometer is the peak wavelength of the idler light.

    4. Results and Discussion

    Before measuring the idler light wavelength of the BGSe OPO, we used the same device that measured the idler light wavelength of KTiOAsO4 (KTA) (90°, 0°) produced from CRYSTECH. The wavelength of the idler light was 3464 nm. In Refs. [17,18], KTA (90°, 0°) comes from the same company. Their measured data were 3467 nm and 3473 nm, respectively, and the deviation was 3 nm and 9 nm, respectively. The results showed the reliability and accuracy of the measuring devices and methods applied in this manuscript.

    Then, we used BGSe to replace the KTA. When the pump energy reached 20.62 mJ, the crystal surface was slightly damaged, and the idler energy was 1.07 mJ. So, the peak wavelengths at different temperatures were measured under the pump energy of 15.74 mJ, corresponding to the idler energy of 0.62 mJ.

    First, we searched and measured the output of the BGSe (56.3°, 0°) OPO in the range of 3600–3700 nm at room temperature. The oscilloscope triggered at 3611–3619 nm and failed to trigger at other wavelengths. In the experiment, the noise of the InSb detector passing through the ZAMP amplifier was slightly less than the signal of the idler light, and the oscilloscope had no data when the wavelength set by the grating spectrometer was far from the peak wavelength. So, the precise idler light output spectrum cannot be obtained, but the peak wavelength can still be measured.

    As shown in Fig. 5, the output energy of BGSe (56.3°, 0°) at 3614 nm is the largest, so the peak wavelength of BGSe (56.3°, 0°) at room temperature is located at 3614 nm, which is 23 nm smaller than the theoretical value of 3637 nm. Then, we used the temperature control furnace to adjust the temperature of the BGSe crystal, recorded the peak wavelength of its idler light output at 30°C–140°C, and compared it with the theoretical value given in Refs. [8,9].

    Output at 3611–3619 nm of BGSe (56.3°, 0°).

    Figure 5.Output at 3611–3619 nm of BGSe (56.3°, 0°).

    Theoretical and experimental values are presented in Fig. 6. When the temperature of BGSe (56.3°, 0°) increased from 30°C to 140°C, the wavelength of idler frequency light under type I phase matching increased from 3637 nm to 3989 nm. The experimental values of the peak wavelength are close to the theoretical value from Ref. [9], while Δλ2/ΔT is close to the theoretical value from Ref. [8]. Δλ2/ΔT is 2.49 nm/°C from Ref. [9], 3.36 nm/°C from Ref. [8], and 3.20 nm/°C from the experiment. It might be due to the experimental wavelength in Ref. [9] being wider than in Ref. [8], so the prediction of the idler wavelength is more precise. While nx,ny,andnz are measured directly in Ref. [8] rather than changed by SHG in Ref. [9], Δλ2/ΔT from Ref. [8] is closer to the experimental value from this manuscript.

    Idler light’s peak wavelength of BGSe (56.3°, 0°) at 30°C–140°C.

    Figure 6.Idler light’s peak wavelength of BGSe (56.3°, 0°) at 30°C–140°C.

    5. Conclusions

    BGSe possesses a wide temperature tuning range. corresponding to the maximum Δλ2/ΔT is close to 0° when λ2=3µm,3.2µm,3.4µm,,5µm, and Δλ2/ΔT of type I is larger than that of type II-B. The Δλ2/ΔT increases as λ2 increases. When λ2=3µm, the maximum Δλ2/ΔT=2.358nm/°C; while λ2=5µm, the maximum Δλ2/ΔT=3.333nm/°C. According to our experimental results, the wavelength of the idler light derived from Ref. [9] is more precise, while Δλ2/ΔT derived from Ref. [8] is more precise. To the best of our knowledge, the temperature tuning of the BGSe OPO was demonstrated for the first time. The peak wavelength of the idler light is 3637 nm at 30°C and 3989 nm at 140°C, corresponding to the Δλ2/ΔT of 3.20 nm/°C. Our results indicate that BGSe possesses advantages for application in wide band temperature tuning.

    References

    [1] M. Q. Kang, Y. Deng, X. W. Yan, X. M. Zeng, Y. W. Guo, J. Y. Yao, F. Zeng, J. G. Zheng, K. N. Zhou, C. B. Qu, J. Q. Su, Q. H. Zhu. A compact and efficient 4.25 μm BaGa4Se7 optical parametric oscillator. Chin. Opt. Lett., 17, 121402(2019).

    [2] H. Y. Liu, Y. J. Yu, D. H. Sun, H. Liu, Y. H. Wang, H. Zheng, D. Li, G. Y. Jin. 1514 nm eye-safe passively Q-switched self-optical parametric oscillator based on Nd3+-doped MgO:PPLN. Chin. Opt. Lett., 17, 111404(2019).

    [3] J. J. Song, X. H. Meng, Z. H. Wang, X. Z. Wang, W. L. Tian, J. F. Zhu, S. B. Fang, H. Teng, Z. Y. Wei. Harmonically pump a femtosecond optical parametric oscillator to 1.13 GHz by a femtosecond 515 nm laser. Chin. Opt. Lett., 18, 033201(2020).

    [4] J. Yao, D. Mei, L. Bai, Z. Lin, W. Yin, P. Fu, Y. Wu. BaGa4Se7: a new congruent-melting IR nonlinear optical material. Inorg. Chem., 49, 9212(2010).

    [5] J. Yao, W. Yin, K. Feng, X. Li, D. Mei, Q. Lu, Y. Ni, Z. Zhang, Z. Hu, Y. Wu. Growth and characterization of BaGa4Se7 crystal. J. Crystal Growth, 346, 1(2012).

    [6] F. Yang, J.-Y. Yao, H.-Y. Xu, K. Feng, W.-L. Yin, F.-Q. Li, J. Yang, S.-F. Du, Q.-J. Peng, J.-Y. Zhang, D.-F. Cui, Y.-C. Wu, C.-T. Chen, Z.-Y. Xu. High efficiency and high peak power picosecond mid-infrared optical parametric amplifier based on BaGa4Se7 crystal. Opt. Lett., 38, 3903(2013).

    [7] N. Y. Kostyukova, A. A. Boyko, V. Badikov, D. Badikov, G. Shevyrdyaeva, V. Panyutin, G. M. Marchev, D. B. Kolker, V. Petrov. Widely tunable in the mid-IR BaGa4Se7 optical parametric oscillator pumped at 1064 nm. Opt. Lett., 41, 3667(2016).

    [8] N. Zhai, C. Li, B. Xu, L. Bai, J. Yao, G. Zhang, Z. Hu, Y. Wu. Temperature-dependent sellmeier equations of IR nonlinear optical crystal BaGa4Se7. Crystals, 7, 62(2017).

    [9] K. Kato, K. Miyata, V. V. Badikov, V. Petrov. Thermo-optic dispersion formula for BaGa4Se7. Appl. Opt., 57, 2935(2018).

    [10] S. J. Niu, P. Aierken, M. Ababaike, S. T. Wang, T. Yusufu. Widely tunable, high-energy, mid-infrared (2.2–4.8 μm) laser based on a multi-grating MgO:PPLN optical parametric oscillator. Inf. Phys. Technol., 104, 103121(2020).

    [11] V. Badikov, D. Badikov, G. Shevyrdyaeva, A. Tyazhev, G. Marchev, V. Panyutin, V. Petrov, A. Kwasniewski. Phase-matching properties of BaGa4S7 and BaGa4Se7: wide-bandgap nonlinear crystals for the mid-infrared. Phys. Status Solidi RRL, 5, 31(2011).

    [12] F. Yang, J. Yao, H. Xu, F. Zhang, N. Zhai, Z. Lin, N. Zong, Q. Peng, J. Zhang, D. Cui, Y. Wu, C. Chen, Z. Xu. Midinfrared optical parametric amplifier with 6.4–11 µm range based on BaGa4Se7. IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., 27, 1100(2015).

    [13] E. Boursier, P. Segonds, B. Ménaert, V. Badikov, V. Panyutin, D. Badikov, V. Petrov, B. Boulanger. Phase-matching directions and refined Sellmeier equations of the monoclinic acentric crystal BaGa4Se7. Opt. Lett., 41, 2731(2016).

    [14] K. Kato, K. Miyata, V. Petrov. Phase-matching properties of BaGa4Se7 for SHG and SFG in the 0.901–10.5910 µm range. Appl. Opt., 56, 2978(2017).

    [15] W.-Q. Zhang. General ray-tracing formulas for crystal. Appl. Opt., 31, 7328(1992).

    [16] H. Kong, J. T. Bian, X. Q. Sun. Calculation of phase-matching angles and effective nonlinear coefficients of BaGa4Se7 crystals. Optik, 193, 163004(2019).

    [17] F. Bai. The studies of novel solid-state lasers based on optical parametric oscillation and stimulated Raman scattering(2013).

    [18] X. Dong. All-solid-state KTA optical parametric oscillation(2009).

    Hui Kong, Jintian Bian, Jiyong Yao, Qing Ye, Xiaoquan Sun. Temperature tuning of BaGa4Se7 optical parametric oscillator[J]. Chinese Optics Letters, 2021, 19(2): 021901
    Download Citation