소년범죄사건과 정보공개에 관한 비교법적 소고

@article{ART002350313},
author={ 김연지 },
title={소년범죄사건과 정보공개에 관한 비교법적 소고},
journal={소년보호연구},
issn={1598-8163},
year={2018},
volume={31},
number={2},
pages={1-26},
doi={http://dx.doi.org/10.35930/KJPR.31.2.1},
url={http://dx.doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.35930/KJPR.31.2.1}

TY - JOUR
AU - 김연지
TI - 소년범죄사건과 정보공개에 관한 비교법적 소고
T2 - 소년보호연구
PY - 2018
VL - 31
IS - 2
PB - 한국소년정책학회
SP - 1-26
SN - 1598-8163
AB - In recent cases where the content of the crime is serious, and attracts a lot of attention, the information about the suspect is usually disclosed by the media. This happens because the law stipulates that in cases of certain violent crimes and sexual assault crimes, exceptions can be made to remove the protection from the suspect’s personal information. In addition, Article 68 of the Juvenile Act prohibits the reporting of juvenile offenses and juveniles who are under investigation or in trial, so that if the suspect is a juvenile, their personal information and photos may not be disclosed under any circumstances. Juveniles are still mentally or morally immature, as a result, even if they commit a crime, they are less liable than adults under the concept of protectionism in juvenile law. Furthermore, there is a reasonable aspect to prevent juveniles from reporting crime, even if they commit criminal acts, in order to help them grow healthily for the purpose of juvenile law. However, the crimes by some juveniles can be so inhuman and serious, that this protection of juveniles is questioned. As a result of comparative legal investigation, the U.S., Japan, and Brazil allow the cases of juvenile offenders as well as their information to be officially disclosed in exceptional cases of juvenile crimes. In other words, if the protection of public interest is greater than the protection of the juveniles, even if the aggressor is a juvenile, then the public’s right to know should be guaranteed and the juvenile’s name or photo should be revealed. This way, it is possible to prevent a recidivism from the violent crime. Subsequently, the law needs to be revised for the sake of ensuring social awareness of the violent crime. The public has the right to know personal information of juvenile offenders in extremely exceptional cases in which a serious damage, such as death, has been caused. Of course, even in exceptional cases, judicious judgment based on strict criteria is necessary, despite the fact whether it is possible to disclose personal information or not.
KW - 소년범죄자, 소년범죄사건, 신상공개, 정보공개, 보도금지
DO - http://dx.doi.org/10.35930/KJPR.31.2.1
UR - http://dx.doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.35930/KJPR.31.2.1
ER -

김연지 (2018). 소년범죄사건과 정보공개에 관한 비교법적 소고. 소년보호연구, 31( 2), 1- 26.

김연지 . 2018, “소년범죄사건과 정보공개에 관한 비교법적 소고”, 소년보호연구, vol. 31, no. 2, pp. 1-26. Available from: doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.35930/KJPR.31.2.1

김연지 “소년범죄사건과 정보공개에 관한 비교법적 소고” 소년보호연구 31.2 pp. 1-26 (2018): 1.

김연지 . 소년범죄사건과 정보공개에 관한 비교법적 소고 소년보호연구 [Internet]. 2018; 31( 2), : 1-26. Available from: doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.35930/KJPR.31.2.1

김연지 . “소년범죄사건과 정보공개에 관한 비교법적 소고” 소년보호연구 31, no.2 (2018): 1-26. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.35930/KJPR.31.2.1

홈 권호 목록 논문 목록 논문 상세

소년범죄사건과 정보공개에 관한 비교법적 소고

소년보호연구

약어 : -

2018, vol.31, no.2, pp.1 - 26

DOI : http://dx.doi.org/10.35930/KJPR.31.2.1

발행기관 : 한국소년정책학회

연구분야 : 법학

김연지¹

¹한국외국어대학교 강사

인용한 논문 수 : - 서지 간략 보기

초록

In recent cases where the content of the crime is serious, and attracts a lot of attention, the information about the suspect is usually disclosed by the media. This happens because the law stipulates that in cases of certain violent crimes and sexual assault crimes, exceptions can be made to remove the protection from the suspect’s personal information. In addition, Article 68 of the Juvenile Act prohibits the reporting of juvenile offenses and juveniles who are under investigation or in trial, so that if the suspect is a juvenile, their personal information and photos may not be disclosed under any circumstances. Juveniles are still mentally or morally immature, as a result, even if they commit a crime, they are less liable than adults under the concept of protectionism in juvenile law. Furthermore, there is a reasonable aspect to prevent juveniles from reporting crime, even if they commit criminal acts, in order to help them grow healthily for the purpose of juvenile law. However, the crimes by some juveniles can be so inhuman and serious, that this protection of juveniles is questioned. As a result of comparative legal investigation, the U.S., Japan, and Brazil allow the cases of juvenile offenders as well as their information to be officially disclosed in exceptional cases of juvenile crimes. In other words, if the protection of public interest is greater than the protection of the juveniles, even if the aggressor is a juvenile, then the public’s right to know should be guaranteed and the juvenile’s name or photo should be revealed. This way, it is possible to prevent a recidivism from the violent crime. Subsequently, the law needs to be revised for the sake of ensuring social awareness of the violent crime. The public has the right to know personal information of juvenile offenders in extremely exceptional cases in which a serious damage, such as death, has been caused. Of course, even in exceptional cases, judicious judgment based on strict criteria is necessary, despite the fact whether it is possible to disclose personal information or not.

키워드

소년범죄자, 소년범죄사건, 신상공개, 정보공개, 보도금지

참고문헌(14)

[학술지] 강경래 / 2013 / 소년사건의 보도와 소년법 / 소년보호연구 22 : 1 ~ 31
[학위논문] 김연지 / 2018 / 소년의 형사책임능력과 치료적 사법에 관한 연구
[학술지] 김진 / 2012 / 公的인 人物에 대한 名譽毁損에 관한 고찰 - 새로운 모색을 위한 제언 - / 형사법의 신동향 (36) : 279 ~ 317
[학술지] 김혁 / 2016 / 소년법의 연령과 형사책임 / 형사정책 28 (3) : 35 ~ 72
[학술지] 김혁 / 2017 / 소년사건에서의 신상공개와 보도금지 / 형사정책 29 (2) : 61 ~ 89
[학술지] 민영성 / 2006 / 소년의 중대사건의 보장과 실효적 형사재판절차참가 / 법학연구 47 (1)
[학술지] 박상열 / 2014 / 소년법 제24조 제2항의 소년심판 비공개원칙의 의의 / 소년보호연구 26 : 115 ~ 146
[보고서] 이병희 / 2001 / 프라이버시의 보호와 범죄자 신상공개
[보고서] 이승현 / 2017 / 소년강력범죄에 대한 외국의 대응동향 및 정책 시사점 연구
[학술지] 조희문 / 2010 / 브라질의 법률체계와 입법절차 / 최신외국법제정보 2010 (3)
[단행본] 카와이데 토시히로 / 2016 / 소년법 / 박영사
[단행본] 諸澤英道 / 1996 / 被害者支援を創る / 岩波書店
[기타] 大月晶代 / 2005 / 青少年をめぐる諸問題 - アメリカの少年犯罪事件と情報公開 / 総合調査
[단행본] John Spark / 2015 / A Practical Approach to Criminal Procedure / Oxford University Press