The Unavoidability of Nature - the Struggle of Erich Przywara and Chantal Delsol to Reintroduce the Concept

Maciej Raczyński-Rożek

Catholic Academy in Warsaw , Poland
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4843-4743


Abstract

The history of modern philosophy has been marked by a retreat from traditional metaphysical concepts, including the notion of nature, which is central to theological considerations. It allows us to recognize a direct connection between the ordered world of nature and the existence of God. Still, some theologians paradoxically welcomed the downfall of metaphysics. Acknowledging the irreversibility of changes in the intellectual landscape of contemporary culture, and following Heidegger’s critique of the so-called ontotheology, they stated that one can and should “do” theology without resorting to metaphysical concepts, like the concept of nature. In this paper I am revisiting the work of two thinkers that defended the concept of nature. They represent two generations of 20th and 21st century Christian theologians (Erich Przywara) and philosophers (Chantal Delsol) who assiduously sought to reintroduce the concept of nature to the mainstream of intellectual discourse. Tracing their footsteps, we shall see that intellectual systems inspired by Christianity actually need the concept of nature, or its equivalent. What is common to both scholars is that they try to achieve this goal indirectly, by substituting the concepts of classical metaphysics. As mentioned, modern critique left metaphysical notions with a bad reputation (undeservedly, in our opinion), but Przywara and Delsol replace them with related concepts that latter-day thinkers find easier to accept.

Keywords:

Delsol, nature, in-und-über, analogy, personalism, postmodernism, Przywara

Aquinas, De ente et essentia (Torino: Marietti 1957).

Aquinas, Summa theologiae (Torino: Marietti 1952–1962).

Aristotle, Metaphysics (trans. W.D. Ross) (Whitefish: Kessinger 2010).

Aristotle, Politics (trans. B. Jowett) (New York: Dover 2000). (Crossref)

Baudrillard, J., The Intelligence of Evil or the Lucidity Pact (trans. C. Turner) (Oxford: Berg 2005).

Betz, J.R., “After Barth: A New Introduction to Erich Przywara’s Analogia Entis,” The Analogy of Being. Invention of the Antichrist or the Wisdom of God? (ed. T.J. White) (Grand Rapids, MI – Cambridge, UK: Eerdmans 2011) 35–87.

Brague, R., Europe, la voie romaine (Paris: Gallimard 1999).

Delsol, Ch., Éloge de la singularité. Essai sur la modernité tardive (Paris: La Table Ronde 2007).

Delsol, Ch., Qu'est-ce que l'homme? Cours familier d’anthropologie (Paris: Cerf 2008).

Delsol, Ch., Les pierres d’angle. A quoi tenons-nous? (Paris: Cerf 2014).

Delsol, Ch., La Haine du Monde. Totalitarismes et postmodernité (Paris: Cerf 2019).

Dobrzeniecki, M., “W poszukiwaniu transcendencji [In the Search for Transcendence],” Teologia między Wschodem a Zachodem (eds. M. Dobrzeniecki – M. Raczyński-Rożek) (Kraków: WAM 2019) 9–20.

Godzieba, A.J., “Ontotheology to Excess. Imagining God Without Being,” Theological Studies 56 (1995) 3–20. (Crossref)

Heidegger, M., Identität und Differenz (Stuttgart: Nesk 1999).

Hume, D., A Treatise of Human Nature (Oxford: Clarendon 1896).

Kant, I., Critique of Pure Reason (trans. W. Pluhar) (Indianapolis, IN: Hackett 1996).

Marion, J.-L., God Without Being (trans. T. Carlson) (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press 1991).

Przywara, E., Schriften. III. Analogia Entis. Metaphysik. Ur-Struktur und All-Rhytmus (Einsiedeln: Johannes 1962).

Przywara, E., Deus semper maior. Theologie der Exerzitien (Freiburg im Breisgau: Herder 1938) I–III.

Przywara, E., “Gotteserfahrung und Gottesbeweis,” Schriften. II. Religions-philosophische Schriften. Weg zu Gott (Einsiedeln: Johannes 1962) 3–13.

Przywara, E., “Kant-Newman-Thomas,” Ringen der Gegenwart. Gesammelte Aufsätze 1922–1927 (Augsburg: Filser 1929) II, 729–961.

Przywara, E., “Katholizismus,” Ringen der Gegenwart. Gesammelte Aufsätze 1922–1927 (Augsburg: Filser 1929) II, 543–728.

Raczyński-Rożek, M., „Analogia Entis Ericha Przywary jako model myślenia katolickiego w postmodernistycznej rzeczywistości [Analogia Entis by Erich Przywara as a model of Catholic thinking in postmodern reality],” Teologia w Polsce 12/2 (2018) 215–231.

Raczyński-Rożek, M., „The Church as the Realization of the Nature of Man in ‘Deus Semper Maior’ by Erich Przywara,” Bogoslovni Vestnik 79/3 (2019) 752–785. (Crossref)

Ross, J.F., Portraying analogy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1981). (Crossref)

Taylor, C., Sources of the Self. The Making of the Modern Identity (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1989).

Westphal, M., Overcoming Onto-Theology. Toward a Post-Modern Christian Faith (New York: Fordham University Press 2001).

Download

Published
2020-12-21


Raczyński-Rożek, M. (2020). The Unavoidability of Nature - the Struggle of Erich Przywara and Chantal Delsol to Reintroduce the Concept. Verbum Vitae, 38(2), 613–632. https://doi.org/10.31743/vv.11017

Maciej Raczyński-Rożek  mraczynskirozek@pwtw.pl
Catholic Academy in Warsaw

Maciej Raczyński-Rożek, a priest of the archdiocese of Warsaw (Poland), S.T.D. in dogmatic theology (Pontifical Gregorian University, Rome, Italy), an assistant professor at the Catholic Academy in Warsaw (previous: Pontifical Faculty of Theology in Warsaw) and at the Metropolitan Major Seminary in Warsaw.

https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4843-4743



License

The author(s) grant (s) to the Licensee a non-exclusive and royalty-free license in accordance with the provisions of the Appendix: LICENSE TO USE THE WORK